The moment that drove it home for me was flying up into the sky, striking out in a random direction, flying to the roof of a building and zooming right up to a cluster of pipes and seeing individual rivets accurately modelled. All of this, for a 10 minute demo.
This is a staggering achievement, by all accounts made possible by some pretty amazing new tooling. Genuinely baffled that anyone could fail to be impressed by this.
Edit: don’t forget to open up the menu and play around with the lighting, crowd, AI settings, etc.
You can still do stuff like that in UE4. Have a look at what's possible with Quixel Mixer, you can create detail like that surprisingly quickly. I'd tentatively argue that modelling tools are the real MVP when it comes to increased geometric LOD in modern engines. They allow you to add that kind of detail quickly enough that it becomes economical to actually detail rivets.
Either way, it's very cool. The crowd simulation stuff is going to be useful, current tooling there absolutely sucks outside of a few very expensive dedicated products.
Nanite really blurs the line between geometry and texture - in a sense it’s a shader that uses triangle mesh data as if it were a texture source.
This siggraph session will expand your mind: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=eviSykqSUUw
Watch the SIGGRAPH video to get the feelings of: that's impossible - oh, I kind of see how that works - one pixel triangles? - how do they get that mesh representation set up right? - oh, graph theory - that data format has to be a pain to generate with all those constraints - they're rendering mostly in the CPU? - that's all that needs to be done at render time? - GPUs need to be redesigned to be a better match to this - how to stream this stuff? - that compression scheme is clever.
After reading your comment I went back in to the demo to have another look at the rivets up close. In the options menu, you can switch the viewport so that it shows you the triangles that make up object geometry under the "Nanite" system. Would be interested to hear from anyone with access to the demo and the right background what they make of this.
Edit: I took a couple of screenshots of default view vs Nanite triangles view but not sure what the convention is on HN for where to host them. Happy to put them up if someone can clue me in.
Edit: I've just put the screenshots up [here](https://imgur.com/a/2FMpLJa) and a ~30 sec vid [here](https://youtu.be/s1PUCadh1TU), showing cycling through the viewport modes.
I hear tweet threads are really appreciated /s
Some downsides, the "metahuman" face modeling isn't great, it seems very uncanny valley compared to titles like The Last of Us II. There's some obvious framerate issues during the car chase scene where I wouldn't be surprised if it dipped into the 20s.
I think each character in last of us 2 is a custom scan and artist creation. Metahumans is made from an amalgam of scans and lets you parameterize the face (adjust everything with sliders) so it is a much harder problem.
I was much more impressed by Battlefield 2042 graphics when I first saw it. So while this looks "good", may be I was expecting much more. But then again we are limited by Hardware so I guess I have too high of an expectation.
It's always been like that for demos and promo videos. Sometime they straight up run the demo on a PC with crazy specs while pretending it's running a console.
If you have a compatible console I'd really recommend checking it out!
I think it is pretty clear there is a level of detail difference between the 'white room' scenes with Neo and the 'city'.
I would be shocked if the 'white room' scenes where not fully motion captured and then transposed into 3D models to run in engine. A bit unfair as while it may be real time rendered it is fully scripted. The player has no control. It is essentially a movie converted into a 3D environment then optimised to hell and back with pixel corrections where needed.
However the 'city' environment is quite stunning with incredible level of detail and you can free roam either walking/driving around the street or fly by. Really quite something to play about with the real time rendering pipeline to see the triangle make up, etc of every object or adjust the position of the sun in the sky, etc.
A lot of fun. Reminded me a lot of when I first got to play Spider-man on the PS4 and just swing around the city. Will be great to see where this leads in a year or two once devs have really had time to get a feel for how everything works.
The animations don't look that good to me, nowhere near mocap. The weird arms movements alone scream "video game"
Marketing people are at it again
I wasn't aware that was common practice. I assume this is for ease of playtesting a game before any optimisation phases have happened? I wonder whether it has a setting to convert down to actual PS5 power levels.
> And you can get away calling it 'runs on ps5'.
Of course. Sigh...
...
here i googled it for you
https://www.fortressofsolitude.co.za/ps5-dev-kit-vs-playstat...
The textures looked super flat to me in this, the world looked decent, but all together i hoped the PS5 was holding their tech down.. because i expected more. Nanite (codename for high model density rendering) examples previously were _much_ better in my view. Eg: https://youtu.be/U-dRBjqAGgI
Going to be funny listening to elitist PC gamers talk about how inferior everything still looks by then, even though they just play nostalgic pixel art games on Steam all day.
https://www.hinnavaatlus.ee/1891263/sony-playstation-5-digit...
Unfortunately if you watch it on something other than the rendering device you are very likely to be seeing through a video compression/decompression cycle. Providers like YouTube are notorious for rescaling the compression to match the current qualities of the channel. Just a big caveat when looking for rendering artifacts because they may be indistinguishable from compression artifacts.
Note that "playing it on a PS5" is meaningless unless you had demo software. The PS5 has a YouTube player and it's not representative of your in-game experience.
I do not think they were talking about watching the video on their PS5…
It's impressive, but I'm skeptical this video is real-time on a PS5, certainly I doubt this is at 4K - the jaggies when I ran this were everywhere.
It was worse in the city demo after the action sequence. Certainly a lot going on, but in terms of the trade-off, it was visually quite obvious where the costs are side-by-side with Miles Morales on it's PRT mode and for a real game the later would almost certainly be better overall.
Hopeful people will get more out of it in future, but wanted to temper expectations here from the video.
EDIT: Just found the signpost to enable real-time night mode with Lumen. Wow. It's clearly still struggling to run on a PS5 but it's not that far away from where it would need to be. And when it's not struggling with jaggies/framerate it's pretty jaw-dropping.