It seems like tabula rasa idealism has made a serious resurgence in leftist and liberal circles and the scary thing is that nobody (other than extremists saying nonsense) is really talking about this explicitly. Somehow we went from a bunch of stuff being cultural constructs to literally everything is a cultural construct and then this somehow became extremely widespread in no time at all. We need to have this conversation out-loud.
I have not met a single parent who didn't want to try and give their own children an advantage over the others. It is one thing to support "equity in education", but when parents sense that these activists are trying to dumb-down the curriculum, I expect significant pushback. Especially because this is quite literally a "won't somebody please think of the children" issue.
As for the competitive advantage, I think that only works for the children who are already in the private school system.
So the "social disease" of virtue signaling will follow the higher socioeconomic crowd where ever they go.
Even mathematics education is now being twisted by this -- it's now seen as more important for math classes to pursue equality/equity than it is to teach math.
One outcome of this is a levelling effect -- an equal outcome for all students, in which they all possess average mathematical skills, is preferred to a situation in which some students perform above average.
The people who were critical of the first moves in this direction and explicitly said it would be a slippery slope were dismissed at the time. We're still moving in that direction. Hopefully the pendulum will swing back to something more reasonbale.
Maybe from liberals, but from what I've seen not the left. Marx's mantra is literally "From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs", it has nothing to do with liberal conceptions of tabula rasa idealism. I've never seen a leftist who asserts that people start from a blank state and can be "anyone" depending on the circumstances, that statement will get you accused of having bourgeois sensibilities who ignore the material forces of the world.
https://www.currentaffairs.org/2020/09/we-dont-know-our-pote...
I wholeheartedly agree with your point, but there is no "somewhat" about it. The differences can be and often are stark, and we shouldn't shy away from saying that if we want an honest and productive conversation. It does not exclude the also-true fact that good education, practice, and other controllable environmental factors play an important role.
What makes you think anybody wants an honest and productive conversation? One half is just trying to get the other half to slip up and say something - anything - they can cancel them for saying. The other half is just keeping their heads down and trying not to lose their job for heresy.
> Research is also clear that all students are capable of becoming powerful mathematics learners and users (Boaler, 2019a, c). This notion runs counter to many students’ ideas about school mathematics. Most adults can recall times when they received messages during their school or college years that they were not cut out for mathematics-based fields. The race-, class-, and gender-based differences in those who pursue more advanced mathematics make it clear that messages students receive about who belongs in mathematics are biased along racial, socioeconomic status, language, and gender lines, a fact that has led to considerable inequities in mathematics.
>In 2015, Sarah-Jane Leslie, Andrei Cimpian, and colleagues interviewed university professors in different subject areas to gauge student perceptions of educational “gifts”—the concept that people need a special ability to be successful in a particular field. The results were staggering; the more prevalent the idea, in any academic field, the fewer women and people of color participating in that field. This outcome held across all thirty subjects in the study. More mathematics professors believed that students needed a gift than any other professor of STEAM content. The study highlights the subtle ways that students are dissuaded from continuing in mathematics and underscores the important role mathematics teachers play in communicating messages that mathematics success is only achievable for select students. This pervasive belief more often influences women and people of color to conclude they will not find success in classes or studies that rely on knowledge of mathematics.
>Negative messages, either explicit (“I think you’d be happier if you didn’t take that hard mathematics class”) or implicit (“I’m just not a math person”), both imply that only some people can succeed. Perceptions can also be personal (“Math just doesn’t seem to be your strength”) or general (“This test isn’t showing me that these students have what it takes in math.” My other class aced this test.”). And they can also be linked to labels (“low kids,” “bubble kids,” “slow kids”) that lead to a differentiated and unjust mathematics education for students.
That leads to the principals:
> ● All students deserve powerful mathematics; we reject ideas of natural gifts and talents (Cimpian et al, 2015; Boaler, 2019) and the “cult of the genius” (Ellenberg, 2015).
> ● The belief that “I treat everyone the same” is insufficient: Active efforts in mathematics teaching are required in order to counter the cultural forces that have led to and continue to perpetuate current inequities (Langer-Osuna, 2011).
Based on coverage I've read, the CMF does not cite, acknowledge, or discuss any of the critiques of Boaler's work. If they had good responses to these critiques, they probably would have spent some of their 800 pages addressing these serious challenges.
1: http://www.danielwillingham.com/daniel-willingham-science-an...
2: https://gregashman.wordpress.com/2019/03/03/jo-boaler-cites-...
Wait, the finest minds and educators in their respective fields are providing observational data that gifts are a real phenomenon, literally contradicting "reject ideas of natural gifts and talents". This is tremendous news that should have been a clarion call to seek out and elevate the gifted and invest every possible effort to nurture their gifts.
Yet the conclusion is somehow the exact opposite: that "gifts" are a falsehood used to malignly, even if unconsciously and unintentionally, dissuade people. How is this possible?
This is not evidence that natural talent is not needed, it is at best some evidence that minorities and women maybe don't think they have the requisite natural talent.
> Negative messages, either explicit (“I think you’d be happier if you didn’t take that hard mathematics class”) or implicit (“I’m just not a math person”), both imply that only some people can succeed.
To say the evidence for stereotype threat is "weak" is charitable at best [1], and multiple replication attempts have failed entirely.
Overall, the evidence that was cited is simply not sufficient to justify the principles you list.
[1] https://replicationindex.com/2017/04/07/hidden-figures-repli...
Math is not scalar is skill! When I am working with Boolean value function i almost always need to draw a table of all options while in Linear Algebra or numerics of differential equations I have a quiet good intuition.
That is not surprising to hear as it was written by people that have invested a large part of their careers in the educational system.
"Those who can't, teach. Those who can't teach, teach Gym."
"It must be nice to think about a world in which every boy and girl is an equally-capable blank slate. But we do not live in that world. We live in a world where some people are tall, and somewhat more likely to be successful basketball players. And boys find math easy, and are somewhat more likely to succeed in math.
When you start out with flawed assumptions, it's not surprising when your prescriptions (no advanced math for anyone!) are foolish and counterproductive."
This is what society used to believe. How was that productive and wise?
This is not a flawed assumption with respect to baseline high school learning.
People can be taught much more mathematics and science than they normally learn.
This is not limited to STEM--people can be taught to write much better than they normally learn, as well.
The trick with the students is getting to the students before the "I'm not a <X> person/<X> isn't for me" kicks in. That means you have to get them in the 5th-8th grades--5th is a bit early/8th is a bit late.
I don't disagree. But holding back advanced students is no way to accomplish this.
My father (a high school teacher for almost 4 decades) used to say: "I can't stop an advanced student even if I wanted to--sheer boredom will propel them to do something." For him, dealing with an advanced student was the easiest thing in the world and took practically no effort--a little extra work with a slight bit of focus and they're off and running. At that point, he could practically forget about them until they raised an interrupt.
My own personal experiences in school also reflect this. Most of my teachers forced me to turn in "normal" homework, pointed me at something more advanced, and let me at it while occasionally checking in on me or offering advice. Sure, they did this so that they could get me off their plate to focus on someone else. But, to be fair, what they had me doing is also the essence of learning--self-directed engagement with an unfamiliar knowledge base via intrinsic motivation.
And, to be fair, if your "advanced" student can't operate in that regime, are they really that "advanced" after all? Far too many parents think their children are "advanced" when they are merely a touch above average and really do fit inside the "standard" curriculum.
The real problem in high school is motivating average to below-average students who want to be anywhere but in class. Video games, hanging with friends/dates, vaping/CBD, etc. is way more compelling than anything having to do with school. Getting through to those students is difficult and has very little to do with the curriculum.
The biggest irony is that the same people who preach that there are intrinsic differences always seem to forget that concept when it comes time to hire and pay teachers. Funny that.
Every student, no matter how capable, benefits dramatically from instruction tuned to their level and ability. Claiming advanced students will take care of themselves is an absolute failure in an instructor’s duty of care towards them, an excuse to make the teacher feel better about not having the time, interest, or knowledge to provide proper instruction. There is no merit to the notion.
Sorry. That's not even close to being a valid argument.
> Every student, no matter how capable, benefits dramatically from instruction tuned to their level and ability.
Oh, I agree. And the research supports it. However, when you tally up the bill for 2 teachers per every 10 or fewer students to make that happen, suddenly everybody starts screaming and objecting.
And curriculum has no bearing on any of that.
If you want to hear screaming and objecting, try to suggest that teachers need to be competent and tested in the areas in which they teach. Yes, if we had an entirely different educational system with an intelligent, competent teacher for every 5 students instead of a semi-literate, incompetent teacher with 30 kids in every classroom, some of these "reforms" might make more sense. But that isn't what we are seeing. Advanced math and gifted programs are being eliminated with the same semi-literate, incompetent teacher still responsible for 30 kids. Only now the few bright kids and the few kids who work very hard to excel will have no opportunity to do so. They will sit at the back of the class and scroll on their phones while the barely competent teacher struggles to crawl through a remedial lesson that the dumbest 10 kids in class cannot master. But we'll have equity when all of them are handed the same worthless diploma after 12 years.
And that is the real problem for parents looking for an "accelerated" track at school.
All they really want is a program that will challenge their kids and surround them with an equally motivated peer group that has a goal of getting into a selective university.
That is what drives private school enrollment, selecting public schools in areas with high property tax revenues, and accelerated tracks within public schools with lower socio-economic status.
You have part of that right. What most parents want is a magic piece of paper that says "Good for one admission to Prestigious University." The achievement of their child and whether it brings down other students is irrelevant to them. The credential is everything.
We see this with AP (Advanced Placement) programs. Parents will sue the district to get their child put into the AP class (who almost always also has an ADHD exemption for extra time on all tests due to "anxiety")--who is completely unequipped for the class and then doesn't succeed in the class and scores a 1 on the AP exam afterward. This is practically a tautology because if the parents were actually engaged in their child's education, the child would already be in the AP class by credential.
This, of course, brings down the children who do belong in the AP class. But the parents don't care because now their child is punching above their weight in terms of credential.
This is the standard "Something ceases to be a good metric once it becomes known to be a metric."
What does that say about the district?
Learning Mathematics: for All
Introduction
Students learn best when they are actively engaged in questioning, struggling, problem solving, reasoning, communicating, making connections, and explaining. The research is overwhelmingly clear that powerful mathematics classrooms thrive when students feel a sense of agency (a willingness to engage in the discipline, based in a belief in progress through engagement) and an understanding that the intellectual authority in mathematics rests in mathematical reasoning itself (in other words, that mathematics makes sense) (Boaler, 2019 a, b; Boaler, Cordero & Dieckmann, 2019; Anderson, Boaler & Dieckmann, 2018; Schoenfeld, 2014). These factors support students as they develop their own identities as powerful mathematics learners and users. Further, active-learning experiences enable students to engage in a full range of mathematical activities—exploring, noticing, questioning, solving, justifying, explaining, representing and analyzing—making clear that mathematics represents far more than calculating.
Research is also clear that all students are capable of becoming powerful mathematics learners and users (Boaler, 2019a, c). This notion runs counter to many students’ ideas about school mathematics. Most adults can recall times when they received messages during their school or college years that they were not cut out for mathematics-based fields. The race-, class-, and gender-based differences in those who pursue more advanced mathematics make it clear that messages students receive about who belongs in mathematics are biased along racial, socioeconomic status, language, and gender lines, a fact that has led to considerable inequities in mathematics.
In 2015, Sarah-Jane Leslie, Andrei Cimpian, and colleagues interviewed university professors in different subject areas to gauge student perceptions of educational “gifts”—the concept that people need a special ability to be successful in a particular field. The results were staggering; the more prevalent the idea, in any academic field, the fewer women and people of color participating in that field. This outcome held across all thirty subjects in the study. More mathematics professors believed that students needed a gift than any other professor of STEAM content. The study highlights the subtle ways that students are dissuaded from continuing in mathematics and underscores the important role mathematics teachers play in communicating messages that mathematics success is only achievable for select students. This pervasive belief more often influences women and people of color to conclude they will not find success in classes or studies that rely on knowledge of mathematics.
Negative messages, either explicit (“I think you’d be happier if you didn’t take that hard mathematics class”) or implicit (“I’m just not a math person”), both imply that only some people can succeed. Perceptions can also be personal (“Math just doesn’t seem to be your strength”) or general (“This test isn’t showing me that these students have what it takes in math.” My other class aced this test.”). And they can also be linked to labels (“low kids,” “bubble kids,” “slow kids”) that lead to a differentiated and unjust mathematics education for students. A fundamental aim of this framework is to respond issues of inequity in mathematics learning; equity influences all aspects of this document. Some overarching principles that guide work towards equity in mathematics include the following:
⦁ Access to an engaging and humanizing education—a socio-cultural, human endeavor—is a universal right, central among civil rights.
⦁ All students deserve powerful mathematics; we reject ideas of natural gifts and talents (Cimpian et al, 2015; Boaler, 2019) and the “cult of the genius” (Ellenberg, 2015).
⦁ The belief that “I treat everyone the same” is insufficient: Active efforts in mathematics teaching are required in order to counter the cultural forces that have led to and continue to perpetuate current inequities (Langer-Osuna, 2011).
⦁ Student engagement must be a design goal of mathematics curriculum design, co-equal with content goals.
⦁ Mathematics pathways must open mathematics to all students, eliminating option-limiting tracking.
⦁ Students’ cultural backgrounds, experiences, and language are resources for learning mathematics (González, Moll, & Amanti, 2006; Turner & Celedón-Pattichis, 2011; Moschkovich, 2013).
⦁ All students, regardless of background, language of origin, differences, or foundational knowledge are capable and deserving of depth of understanding and engagement in rich mathematics tasks.
[1] https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/ma/cf/documents/mathfwchapter1.doc...
could be replaced with:
> All students deserve powerful mathematics.
and still make the same pedagogical point, that all students should be taught with the expectation they will succeed at learning mathematical concepts.
Putting the emphasis on believing people do not differ in natural ability, is obviously false and therefor detracts from the overall goal.
The rejection of "ideas of natural gifts" is rejecting that success in math is tied to natural gifts (as opposed to say hard work or careful study.)
It is not rejecting the idea that some students will have an easier or harder time learning!
Perhaps ability to consistently do hard work is also a natural gift.
> “gifts”—the concept that people need a special ability to be successful in a particular field
It's not whether gifted students exist - it's the extent they should be catered to. Society benefits more when you raise the average than when you foster the top 0.1%. Even Soviet mathematicians who moved to and taught in the US after the fall of the Soviet Union said something to the effect of "sucks for talented folks, but better for society" when they compared it to Soviet education.
With that context, whether they exist or not is really a rounding error. Most gifted students will do well eventually whether we have special programs for them or not. And it's challenging to show strong net positives for society if you did have those programs. As in, actual data that supports having them, vs mere anecdotes.
> Gifted will do well regardless whether we have special programs for them or not.
This is very much not true. Only gifted with rich or caring parents will do well. Others might suffer a lot. Being in a program for gifted for me made the difference between being thrown out of a school because I never did the homework and being invited and having my flights paid to a conference in Japan where I gave a presentation while in the last grade of school.
The state can provide this without believing you have a naturally innate ability in mathematics. They can still construct programs for people who are performing better in math.
The discussion is about innate talent, not whether we treat people who do well in math differently.
I have direct experience with this problem. I was labeled as a gifted student in elementary school but offered no opportunity to take enriched or accelerated classes. Out of boredom I quit trying and my grades collapsed. I dropped out of high school at age 16. Now I am an undergraduate student in mathematics, age 37, trying to put the pieces of my life back together. I have been forced to make friends with classmates half my age. All but 2 of my friends from elementary school have moved on.
True. However the state can not provide this "regardless whether we have special programs for them or not". You migh not have intended to but
>>> Gifted will do well regardless whether we have special programs for them or not.
is a claim which has policy implications orthogonal to any discussion about the innateness of talent. It is in this component that i disagree with you. I couldn't care less whether people being good at something is being caused by something innate or taught as far as that is not relevant for pushing the being good at further.
If it turns out that "natural talents and gifts" are really just due to a better critical period for the child, then the liberals here are really shooting themselves in the foot with this argument.
That said, twin studies do provide substantial evidence that giftedness is highly heritable and probably significantly genetic.
I am well aware of how twin studies but any claim about the genetic component kinda falls apart for me based on them as the children were in the same pregnant mother at the same time.
> any claim about the genetic component kinda falls apart for me based on them as the children were in the same pregnant mother at the same time.
They do somewhat control for pregnancy by comparing identical vs fraternal twins, and finding a higher correlation in intelligence between the former, as well as a far more similar brain structure in regions known to be related to intelligence (frontal cortex).
Anyway, it's impossible to get rid of all confounds via twin studies. But this doesn't mean that twin studies provide zero evidence. It just means the evidence can't be fully conclusive. It just strongly points in the direction of genetics.
Predicting IQ from genetic information alone should remove all the of compounding factors (except those introduced by IQ measurement itself) but can only serve as a lower bound unless predictor overfitted the study data.
> The truth is most likely somewhere between those two.
> but can only serve as a lower bound unless predictor overfitted the study data.
Yes, but the truth is likely somewhere much closer to the upper bound (twin studies) than the lower bound (genome studies).Genome studies are only good for lower bounds. They're a new methodology that isn't good with complex traits. For example, they can only explain 20-30% of the variability in hair color even though we know that hair color is almost 100% genetic due to the observation that identical twins always have the same hair color. Intelligence is much more complex than hair color, so it's no surprise that this method has failed to explain more than 5%. Further, these studies often rely on weak proxies like educational attainment because of the difficulty of IQ testing at scale, and the studies that do try to IQ test at scale suffer from small sample sizes which impacts the ability to find results due to being underpowered.
Also, IQ becomes more correlated with parents as you age, suggesting childhood environment plays a less important role.
In addition, the jump in correlation from fraternal to identical suggests more role for genetics than merely a few %.
But I remember they found a surprising amount of similarities in twins brought up in different environments.
To me, it seems these changes are oriented towards helping everyone succeed in STEM, even those who don’t think they’re math people. Which, again, is less to do with their actual abilities and much more to do with their mental dialogue.
This makes a ton of sense. Basically any skill or habit you might want to develop can be easily thwarted if you’re struggling mentally with discipline, focus, self-image, etc. In my opinion, the “mental game” is crucial to nearly everything and doesn’t get enough focus. (Think of how in sports, a bad mental game can easily loose you the physical game even if you’re an incredible athlete.)
I doubt these educational changes would ever have much of an impact on bonafide geniuses, because they are operating in an entirely different context.
It should be both.
Of all the things to evaluate the policy on, this is a real poor proxy as whether there are gifted people or not usually has little bearing on the overall health of math education across a very highly populated state.
I never disagreed with whether they exist or not. I just don't see why this is such a sore point for people. I can virtually guarantee that the existing education system in CA didn't really benefit the gifted folks either. If I were setting up the program for a whole state, whether it will be good for a Jacobi/Euler/Gauss is totally irrelevant. We're not going to make people who show up once every 50-100 years be a major factor in educating millions of people.
Your reply is that we shouldn't design a state-wide math program for extreme outliers. But no one said we should! We only said that we should design a math program that acknowledges a diversity in innate math ability (as proven by the existence of extreme outliers, and the many, many less extreme outliers).
> we reject ideas of natural gifts and talents
It must be nice to think about a world in which every child is an equally-capable blank slate. But we do not live in that world. We live in a world where some people are tall, and somewhat more likely to be successful basketball players. And some people find math easy, and are somewhat more likely to succeed in math.
When you start out with flawed assumptions, it's not surprising when your prescriptions (no advanced math for anyone!) are foolish and counterproductive.