Of all the things to evaluate the policy on, this is a real poor proxy as whether there are gifted people or not usually has little bearing on the overall health of math education across a very highly populated state.
I never disagreed with whether they exist or not. I just don't see why this is such a sore point for people. I can virtually guarantee that the existing education system in CA didn't really benefit the gifted folks either. If I were setting up the program for a whole state, whether it will be good for a Jacobi/Euler/Gauss is totally irrelevant. We're not going to make people who show up once every 50-100 years be a major factor in educating millions of people.
Your reply is that we shouldn't design a state-wide math program for extreme outliers. But no one said we should! We only said that we should design a math program that acknowledges a diversity in innate math ability (as proven by the existence of extreme outliers, and the many, many less extreme outliers).