I have direct experience with this problem. I was labeled as a gifted student in elementary school but offered no opportunity to take enriched or accelerated classes. Out of boredom I quit trying and my grades collapsed. I dropped out of high school at age 16. Now I am an undergraduate student in mathematics, age 37, trying to put the pieces of my life back together. I have been forced to make friends with classmates half my age. All but 2 of my friends from elementary school have moved on.
True. However the state can not provide this "regardless whether we have special programs for them or not". You migh not have intended to but
>>> Gifted will do well regardless whether we have special programs for them or not.
is a claim which has policy implications orthogonal to any discussion about the innateness of talent. It is in this component that i disagree with you. I couldn't care less whether people being good at something is being caused by something innate or taught as far as that is not relevant for pushing the being good at further.
The state can provide this without believing you have a naturally innate ability in mathematics. They can still construct programs for people who are performing better in math.
The discussion is about innate talent, not whether we treat people who do well in math differently.