News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by bee_rider on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @03:55PM (#29409020)
Interesting how different his device is, from historical trebuchets. In particular, they seem to maximize arm length, while he seemed to go for the shortest arm he could. I wonder if it is entirely the materials difference, or if his optimization was also much better than theirs. It would be cool to see his design built in period materials.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by masklinn on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @04:32PM (#29409393)
> Interesting how different his device is, from historical trebuchets.

It's more of an onager really: it's a torsion engine, whereas the trebuchet you'd think of is a gravity (counterweight) engine.

> It would be cool to see his design built in period materials.

"Period material" would be limited to sinew and / or hair, wood, and relatively small pieces of metal (mostly fasteners).

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by toolslive on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:49AM (#29414997)
Onagers do not have slings.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by NikolaeVarius on Thursday December 02, 2021 @09:36AM (#29416625)
You are wrong.

> It is commonly depicted as a catapult with a bowl, bucket, or sling at the end of its throwing arm.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Onager_(weapon)

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by toolslive on Thursday December 02, 2021 @12:02PM (#29418855)
I stand corrected!
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by salmonellaeater on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @04:11PM (#29409193)
It might have to do with the fact that he's using rubber bands to turn the arm, while historical trebuchets used weights. A weight is limited in how fast it can accelerate so you need to use a lever (the arm) to increase the speed.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by krasin on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @04:28PM (#29409349)
Springs could be used instead of rubber bands. While "coil spring" is a relatively modern invention, other kinds of springs are known from the Bronze Age, accoding to https://www.designingbuildings.co.uk/wiki/History_of_the_Spr...
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by Retric on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @06:09PM (#29410331)
Springs are much older than that, the bow is perhaps the most famous example from antiquity.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by jacquesm on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @06:59PM (#29410759)
And they can be quite formidable, a full size wooden (yew, maple, ash) bow takes a lot of arm strength to properly pull. Just a few shots and you'll be wishing for stronger muscles.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by pbhjpbhj on Thursday December 02, 2021 @02:38AM (#29413511)
You can double the muscle power available by using a foot-bow.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by krasin on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @06:35PM (#29410537)
Good point. I somehow was thinking about metal springs (Romans used springs from lead, for instance), but there's no reason to restrict it to metal.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by throwanem on Thursday December 02, 2021 @12:56AM (#29413011)
Lead springs? They'd have to be absurdly oversized by modern standards to hold up to any kind of force without deforming, I'd imagine. I'd love to read more about them, if you happen to have a cite handy.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by TheSpiceIsLife on Thursday December 02, 2021 @02:44AM (#29413545)
I don’t reckon.

Surely the above comment is confused, misremembering leaf spring as lead spring.

Leaf springs appeared as early as the Roman empire as a form of primitive suspension for chariots and other two-wheelers. Instead of steel, savvy Romans used flexible wooden sticks.

https://connect2local.com/l/112910/c/478618/examining-the-fa...

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by krasin on Thursday December 02, 2021 @01:44PM (#29420493)
Thank you. This is exactly the mistake I made.

It raised some flags in my head when I read it, but then again - Romans did so many things out of lead that I did not challenge it.

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by throwanem on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:16AM (#29413700)
Ah, yeah, that makes a lot more sense.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by mcguire on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @11:10PM (#29412482)
Torsion springs are another option.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torsion_siege_engine

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by eeperson on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @06:12PM (#29410360)
You could use a weight combined with pulleys or gears to get a faster acceleration.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by the__alchemist on Thursday December 02, 2021 @12:37AM (#29412899)
The book Structures describes how trebuchets are quite inefficient compared to the Roman Ballista, which the author alleges the medieval folks forget how to make. Much of the energy is wasted in the counterweight swinging. By contrast, he alleges bows, including hand-drawn, crossbows, and ballistas (or scorpions, or springalds for you AoE fans)are close to 100% efficient.

This is relevant, since as the original com mentor pointed out what the video-maker built is arguably closer to one of those torsion weapons than a counterweight trebuchet.

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by TylerE on Thursday December 02, 2021 @01:08AM (#29413053)
Seems like efficiency is relatively less important (peasant labor is essentially free) and weight of fire more relevant. Trebuchets were usually siege weapons.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by fabianhjr on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @04:16PM (#29409234)
Well, this might be supersonic but doubt it would throw heavy boulders at fortresses anytime soon to be useful as a siege weapon.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by 0_____0 on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @04:50PM (#29409583)
wouldn't need to be a boulder at those speeds. energy goes up with the square of velocity

50g @ 460m/s = 5290J

25kg @ 50m/s = 31250J

that is to say, the small but fast projectile is 1/6th the energy but only 1/500th the mass

edit: formatting

edit2: a 300g projectile at 460m/s would have approx the same energy as a the 25kg boulder at 50 m/s. at point blank range anyway.

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by rich_sasha on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:06PM (#29409747)
Smaller projectiles lose more energy to air drag.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by dragontamer on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:24PM (#29409944)
Doubly so when you consider the supersonic barrier.

Air drag is proportional to the drag-coefficient * velocity^2. So doubling your speed quadruples the drag.

Except... the drag-coefficient itself is a complex curve over velocity. It barely changes from 0mph through 300mph, but once you reach transonic and supersonic speeds, the drag-coefficient skyrockets.

As a result: 250mph is more than 4x more efficient than 500mph from a drag perspective (4x predicted from Drag equation, but in practice might be 8x or more). This is mostly a problem for airplane efficiency and fuel consumption, but I'm sure it applies to war-machines and projectiles too.

--------

But modern airplanes fly at very high heights, so the air is thinner, reducing drag, but requiring a pressurized cabin lest everyone gets hypoxia.

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by fho on Thursday December 02, 2021 @02:59AM (#29413631)
> It barely changes from 0mph through 300mph

Tell that to cyclists :-) You can barely go above 25 km/h (~15 mph) without feeling like you are just pedaling to overcome the drag.

Reducing the Cd on a bike, ie going recumbent and putting a aerodynamic shell on it, ie switching to a velomobile allows you to go 40 km/h (~25 mph) with relative ease.

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by Toutouxc on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:16AM (#29413701)
Just in case you misunderstood the parent post -- your Cd as a cyclist is pretty much constant around your normal cycling speeds. Your total air drag goes up with the square of velocity, that's for sure, but if you went transsonic on your bike, your Cd would ALSO increase dramatically on top of the already brutal velocity-squared multiplier.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by rich_sasha on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:32AM (#29413797)
It’s almost worse, because you’re working against this quadratic force, at a rate proportional to speed. So power output, the usual limiting factor for a cyclist, scales like 3rd power of speed.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by fho on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:15AM (#29415172)
Fair enough ... I really did not get that :-)
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by ambicapter on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:20PM (#29409906)
You mean objects with lower surface area to mass ratio, AKA objects with lower density. If he wants some high-density objects to throw I think there are stores in the US that sell small, dense metal objects he could use.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by dragontamer on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:34PM (#29410041)
Mass is not a factor in drag equations.

https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/VirtualAero/BottleRocket/a...

Velocity-squared is the factor in drag.

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by bernulli on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:56PM (#29410232)
But very much in inertia, which is acting against the drag, trying to sustain its initial velocity.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ballistic_coefficient

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by jpollock on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:58PM (#29410253)
Density is important when comparing two spheres of the same mass.

https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/VirtualAero/BottleRocket/a...

Where frontal volume is determined by mass and density for a sphere.

So, two speheres with the same mass, but different densities will have different drag forces.

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by dragontamer on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @07:47PM (#29411165)
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by cinquemb on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:22AM (#29414457)
I wonder if you could do something like this[0] on the projectile to reduce drag:

"It is reported that femtosecond-duration laser pulse can be deployed to reduce drag for blunt-body vehicle in high-Mach flow field of air by generating laser plasma and shockwave. The interaction of plasma shockwave induced by femtosecond-duration laser pulse and bow shock over the head of the blunt-body vehicle is investigated numerically in the flow field of 30 km apart from the surface of the earth at Mach number of 5 and the mechanism of deploying the femtosecond laser plasma to reduce the drag of the vehicle is analyzed. The Navier-Stokes equations are exploited to compute the drag reduction for different femtosecond laser energies. The present numerical experiment proves that the femtosecond laser pulse has a better drag reduction effect than the nanosecond laser pulse under the same condition. When the femtosecond laser energy is 0.06 mJ, the femtosecond laser plasma can reduce the drag by 98%. And the higher the energy of femtosecond laser pulse, the higher the drag reduction ratio and the longer the time of low drag. Deploying three femtosecond laser energy point to reduce the drag of hypersonic vehicle is much more obviously. This energy-deposition mode can improve the optimum drag reduction ratio and save the laser energy."

Probably out of the scope for a $200 build, but maybe in the scope of a $2000, $20000, or $200000 build?

I also wonder if iterating on the above, combined with a concentrated solar power plant of arbitrary sized solar field that could provide enough energy for a railgun to launch payload with femtosecond laser plasma capabilities out of earths gravity well?

Maybe, we could escape from the Goddard age eventually lol

[0] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/282709902_Exploring...

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by bernulli on Friday December 03, 2021 @09:00AM (#29430082)
The laser in the study is moving with the projectile, so I guess even for $2000 you won’t be able to have a 30 km altitude, Mach 6 flying object with perfectly controlled laser launched from a trebuchet.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by cinquemb on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:03AM (#29431478)
I'm talking about a projectile that has the laser capabilities in itself (i.e the electromagnetic slug is emitting the femtosecond laser pulses after it is launched), not launched via a laser (it could be launched however, but I was assuming later on the comment that both the rail gun and the slug itself will need to be charged up).
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by bernulli on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:10AM (#29431554)
Yes, it's 'moving with the projectile'. How does that make it easier?
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by cinquemb on Friday December 03, 2021 @11:29AM (#29431807)
I never said how easy it would be only that there is a difference between a payload that is launched via a laser and a payload that has laser capabilities in it (yes, 'moving with the projectile', like i was talking about from the beginning where you assumed otherwise).

But for one, the energy source would have to be on board the payload to power the laser (localized around the payload), and for the other (that I was not talking about) the laser is not on the payload and as the payload travels further away from the launch site, you would use an non linear increasing amount of energy and follow the path of the payload (ionizing air not only around the payload continuously but along the path where the payload no longer is, which would require more energy than needed).

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by bernulli on Friday December 03, 2021 @04:39PM (#29435937)
Try to read my comment, I never 'assumed otherwise', the difficulty of having the laser as payload is exactly my point.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by cinquemb on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:52PM (#29437559)
> so I guess even for $2000 you won’t be able to have a 30 km altitude,

Does seem like it references some difficultly-ness

> flying object with perfectly controlled laser launched from a trebuchet

Does seem like it 'assumes otherwise' to (or its at least ambiguous to me and would be less so if there was a perhaps some separation between the laser and launched, but maybe that's a bit nit picky)

> The laser in the study is moving with the projectile,

And would be even more difficult than such (at least going by how much energy would be required).

But regardless, I'm not sure that 30 km altitude and first achieving mach 5 is a major constraint beyond that is probably not achievable at the $2000 price point (or its not clear to me that it is from the paper) and would be something that could be worked around with more iterations of what level of ionization of surrounding air around a projectile with a given density would give the desired amount of drag reduction (perhaps zeptosecond[0] pulses would work even better than femtosecond ones that were compared against nanosecond, or achieve similar results with lower mach number and higher density of air being ionized around the payload).

[0] https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.11...

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by bernulli on Friday December 03, 2021 @09:09PM (#29438001)
Also try to read my other comment, the difficulty is precisely my point.

I don't see how 'laser in the study is moving with the projectile' is in any way, form, or shape ambiguous.

And the $2000 price point is not from the paper but from your own post.

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by cinquemb on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:02PM (#29438287)
> flying object with perfectly controlled laser launched from a trebuchet

Is what I considered to be ambiguous because it wasn't clear to me that you were assuming the system would be either 'laser launched' or 'launched by a from a trebuchet' with the laser part only applying to the object, regardless of your mention of:

> The laser in the study is moving with the projectile,

Your comments after that made it clear that we are both on the same page regarding the laser part is referring to the payload.

The difficulty being your point is not that interesting to me when i made the post, but the possibility of being able to send something into LEO while minimizing drag effects on the payload to something negligible along the flight path of the payload.

The $2000 came from the cost of the trebuchet system, I'm more interested in at what price point would a system be possible (Ideally below the cost of hypersonic missiles [0] now that I assume use something like this) with a rail gun kind of system.

[0] https://www.scmp.com/news/china/science/article/3142581/chin...

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by jpollock on Thursday December 02, 2021 @01:58PM (#29420751)
The frontal area of two spheres of the same mass will be determined by the sphere's density, and that drives the air resistance.

If frontal area didn't matter to drag, wouldn't all spheres would have the same drag coefficient?

From that page:

Cd = D/(rAV^2/2) where A is frontal area.

What am I missing?

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by dragontamer on Thursday December 02, 2021 @03:43PM (#29422246)
> Cd = D/(rAV^2/2) where A is frontal area.

You're citing a page that uses the word "density" differently than you do.

"D" is density-of-the-air. The density you're talking about appears to be the density-of-the-sphere.

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by bernulli on Friday December 03, 2021 @08:56AM (#29430034)
It absolutely is, and will then drive differences in reference area, thus affecting the drag of the object.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by CRConrad on Thursday December 02, 2021 @07:26PM (#29425033)
"Appears to be"?

They explicitly said so.

Twice.

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by bernulli on Friday December 03, 2021 @08:54AM (#29430023)
You’re missing nothing, you’re correct.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by OneTimePetes on Thursday December 02, 2021 @06:23AM (#29414814)
Only when they are flying to normal atmosphere..

One can use a laser + charge to pre-boil the flight-path into a plasma channel. Sort of like cavitation, but with gasses.

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by technobabbler on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @04:56PM (#29409643)
At a certain point, wouldn't the tiny fast pebble just drill through the fort and leave a small, hot hole in its wake? Like a big neutrino?
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by 0_____0 on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:31PM (#29410017)
You fire the weapon. The tiny pebble breaks up on impact, creating a little crater in the rock. To you, the medieval siege engineer, this is annoying. The frenchmen taunt you from their parapet, yelling maternal insults and farting in your direction. Your supersonic trebuchet is a failure, tactically speaking.

You can't take their mockery anymore, so you set about fixing your projectile.

The pebble lost much of its energy in flight - drag is a huge issue with any distance to target. You make a projectile in the shape of a rod. This has the effect of decreasing the cross-sectional area of the projectile relative to its mass, minimizing drag losses. There's a limit to the length:width ratio, however- go too skinny and it'll deform under firing forces.

The projectile's length also allows it to burrow deeper into the rock -- when material at the tip breaks off on impact, it's got the rest of the shaft behind it, just as mad.

To pack the most punch into your projectile, you craft it from tungsten (then known as Wolfram). In order to keep it from yawing in flight, you add some rigid vanes at the back. It looks like a small, superheavy arrow.

Now you have the issue wherein it doesn't fit well into your cannon anymore. No mind -- you set it in a cup of sorts that seals the barrel. Wait, where did you get a cannon? This is the year 1217 AD...???

Congratulations: you have constructed an armor-piercing fin-stabilized discarding sabot munition (APFSDS). You load it into your M256A1 120mm smoothbore cannon. You peer through the sights.... now where were those sac à merde?

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by jacquesm on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @06:18PM (#29410399)
This would be a highly unexpected turn of events in 'The Holy Grail', at the same time there were already some temporal discontinuities so in a way it fits right in.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by wyldfire on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @10:53PM (#29412383)
They are not knights of the round table, they're very naughty boys!
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by adflux on Thursday December 02, 2021 @01:39AM (#29413207)
Great writing
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by gotts on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @10:10PM (#29412079)
when SHTF I would like to be in your team
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by throwanem on Thursday December 02, 2021 @12:58AM (#29413017)
Well, the recruiter'll tell you you can be a tanker if you want, but as with any salesman you'd be a fool to believe him.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by mcguire on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @11:21PM (#29412534)
Weirdly, that's the idea behind naval guns from the age of sail.

Solid shot goes through the ship, perhaps injuring anyone in the way. Solid shot hitting the structure of the ship on its way through creates massive, dangerous splinters.

https://youtu.be/lIDu7NPLbwc

https://youtu.be/6jRhEiibhCc

https://youtu.be/dGd5HLl3GwE

https://youtu.be/EpNS0JpnUNY

https://youtu.be/9XMOrbOW9DM

https://kurage.files.wordpress.com/2018/03/hocker-isbsa-14-p...

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by lutorm on Thursday December 02, 2021 @01:41AM (#29413219)
This happens with armor piercing shells hitting tanks or other armored vehicles, too. And even if they don't penetrate, they can still generate spall from the inside of the armor that's still deadly. (This was at least true with ~WW2 tanks, modern armor is more advanced.)
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by aasasd on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @06:39PM (#29410577)
Afaik that's exactly what happened with railguns: they were tested at something like mach 11, but it turned out that they just made nice holes in the targets, instead of delivering the energy to the targets themselves. So the speed had to be dialed back.

(Frankly I don't know if this makes much sense from the physics standpoint, but it's what I read in passing.)

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by dredmorbius on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @08:12PM (#29411345)
This is something that's hard to appreciate with any energy-transfer mechanism: If you reach energies that exceed the capacity to transfer energy, you're just wasting effort.

For kinetic systems, the projectile-target interaction is critical. A flimsier target actually needs an impact to be spread over a larger area. Think of a pellet shot through tissue as opposed to, say, a blast of sand or salt.

There are some analogues with subatomic particles and fast/slow neutrons (slow neutrons are far more effective at sustaining nuclear reactions, as they effectively "stick around" where they're more likely to interact with other nuclei for a longer period of time, and the apparent cross-section of the target nuclei appear larger).

https://www.radioactivity.eu.com/site/pages/Slow_Fast_Neutro...

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by KennyBlanken on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @07:54PM (#29411234)
The railgun test videos I've seen were a lot more than "just make nice holes."

At that energy level you have significant damage from spalling from anything the projectile passes through, the superheated metal the projectile actually passes through is launched everywhere, there's the shockwave of the projectile, etc.

That's easily enough to be anti-personnel, incendiary, and obliterate electronics and cables and pipes and hoses. And have lots and lots of penetration, which on a ballistic arc could mean exiting below the waterline, and I imagine something traveling at supersonic speeds hitting water probably does some pretty impressive things.

If you send one of those projectiles through a magazine, missile battery, or fuel bunker - a lot of people are going to have a very, very bad day.

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by curryst on Friday December 03, 2021 @10:26AM (#29431062)
I'm a little doubtful. I think your standard pebble would vaporize from the friction with the air. A pebble certainly wouldn't survive re-entry into the atmosphere, so there's an upper bound on the speed before it disintegrates. If you made a vacuum between you and the wall, it might work?

One reason to use larger projectiles is to deliver similar amounts of energy without having to fight things like that.

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by blacksmith_tb on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:11PM (#29409801)
A small projectile like a pebble would be vaporized pretty quickly by friction with the air at those speeds (and of course a bigger projectile would take more energy to launch).
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by deegles on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @04:19PM (#29409264)
A scaled up version of this would be terrifying... I'm sure with the right materials (and budget) it could launch a cannonball at those speeds.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by ThrustVectoring on Thursday December 02, 2021 @04:00AM (#29413963)
There's some square-cube issues in scaling this up. Specifically, material strength is proportional to cross-sectional area, while the masses of the structures (and projectiles) involved is proportional to volume. The video hints at this with the mention of the difficulty being proportional to the length of the arm to the 1.6th power, slightly more than 3/2.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by kingcharles on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:21PM (#29409914)
I was thinking it would be more fun with a rotten cow.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by Someone on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:34PM (#29410043)
A rotten cow might disintegrate before it leaves the launch site. I wouldn’t classify that as fun.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by jacquesm on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @06:18PM (#29410407)
That strongly depends on your vantage point. Definitely not from the point of view of the cow.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by dredmorbius on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @08:13PM (#29411354)
Rotten cows have limited perceptions.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by IntrepidWorm on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @09:36PM (#29411851)
Sourcing?
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by kingcharles on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @09:54PM (#29411964)
[citation required]
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by dredmorbius on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @10:27PM (#29412193)
Rotten cows ... write no research papers.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by jacquesm on Thursday December 02, 2021 @12:14AM (#29412780)
Assume a spherical, rotten cow...

nm

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by dredmorbius on Thursday December 02, 2021 @05:30AM (#29414500)
A sphere is a perfect form, and hence, immune from corruption.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by robbedpeter on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @08:09PM (#29411325)
Pink mist with subsonic bone shrapnel would still be a terrifying siege weapon.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by klondike_klive on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @06:03PM (#29410288)
"Fetchez la vache?"
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by Robotbeat on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @04:10PM (#29409185)
He built his arm first out of plywood and I’m pretty sure you could easily build the same design out of a high quality single piece of wood. It really comes down to an extremely well-optimized design.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by ggcdn on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:07PM (#29409758)
Right, but I think its the high quality elastic bands that would be difficult to replace.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by Robotbeat on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:29PM (#29410002)
They could be replaced with either a weight, steel springs, or perhaps rope or sinew cords like the Romans used. Rubber is more effective and compact, but watch the video and you see there’s nothing particularly special about using rubber & he could’ve picked something else. The rubber puller itself does not exceed 10 m/s.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by mypalmike on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @06:38PM (#29410574)
I think there is something particularly special about rubber in the design. He stretches it extremely tight. Even with the leverage of a crank, he strains to compress it to the length required, and the rubber holds up. It might be possible to achieve the same result with older materials, but the design would likely be much less compact.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by CrankyCanuck on Saturday December 04, 2021 @11:16AM (#29441771)
No, I don't think so. His design respects the inherent latency to accelerate a looooog set of elastics. Instead of stretching a set of elastics over a long distance, he uses a heavy bundle and stretches them over a short distance. It still takes a lot of effort to get that stretch, but all that energy is released extremely fast..as the elastics don't have to travel very far to do so.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by creato on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:42PM (#29410119)
I agree he could have used some other spring, but I don't think he could have used a weight. The acceleration of springs/rubber is potentially much greater than a weight (at least one starting at rest).
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by Robotbeat on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @06:29PM (#29410495)
You can use mechanical advantage to get the same result.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by ButtSpark69 on Thursday December 02, 2021 @02:13AM (#29413393)
Which means a giant physical structure to support that giant lever arm. When you scale up to things that can knock down castle walls I suspect the difference is incredible.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by mcguire on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @11:23PM (#29412541)
Didn't that break?
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by Aunche on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @04:21PM (#29409285)
His trebuchet is quite high off the ground, so the arm and sling has room to accelerate. This wouldn't really be practical in a medieval trebuchet, especially if you wanted to move it to a siege.
Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by dragontamer on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @04:48PM (#29409572)
Medieval Trebuchets didn't move. You hired engineers to cut down trees and build Trebuchets for a particular siege.

Honestly, "Castle Drops" in AOE2 are more akin to how Trebuchets were used. You build an army, the army gains control of an area, and then you use your engineers to build a long-range siege device at that location.

------

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trebuchet#/media/File:Ms.Thott...

See? No wheels. Those things couldn't move at all.

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by Aunche on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @05:11PM (#29409806)
My impression was that they were assembled on site, but they were pre-made and could be dissembled. From this thread, it looks like both methods could have been used:

https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/3z597l/in_me...

Re:Supersonic Trebuchet by lmilcin on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @07:50PM (#29411194)
He actually explained this in the video.

You missed the best part.