News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by WastingMyTime89 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @06:42PM (#29325078)
Not going to lie, I thought and still think that the whole Web 2.0 thing was clever marketing and window dressing on top of fairly pedestrian but useful technologies. It was actually less of seismic shock than mobile first which despite being a bigger shift didn't actually get a number.

As far as I'm concerned, Web3 is beyond this. It's what happen when you let Ponzi schemers write the marketing material. I can't for the life of me discern what's of actual value from what is a fabrication in the pile of technologies put forward. It doesn't help that I personally have yet to see a use for a blockchain which isn't replicating an existing financial instrument while trying to avoid the eyes of the state.

I’m sure there is some good things in the middle of it all but I respect the authors of this article for having the courage to delve into the whole steaming pile. I certainly do not have it.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by practice9 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:27PM (#29325497)
Blockchain isn't even central in Web3, but it surely helps.

Web3 = decentralized identity, full data and connection graph ownership by user, reputation transfer, verification via zero knowledge proofs, support for VR/AR and 3D objects.

All of this stuff is either in prototype or draft phase, but it's ok. These things need to be built to stop horror stories on HN about "algorithm justice" and "data kingdoms”:

- Google accidentaly bans your 10+ year old Gmail account that is a huge part of your online identity, oops. You can't access your important data or reach support if you can't make this situation a huge deal on HN, Reddit or Twitter

- Facebook or Twitter locks your account because you added a new sentence to your About you section

- LinkedIn reads your messages and makes sure you can't automate responses to recruiters, locks your account if you reply in a generic way

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by KallDrexx on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:30PM (#29325982)
Can you explain how web3 solves any of your bullets?

If you are trying to say that web3 will prevent platform holders from banning you from their platform, then good luck with that. Any platform can and will ban you and have complete control over their platform. Thinking web3 is going to prevent that is naive for many many reasons. If Facebook bans me then web3 isn't going to allow me to post on Facebook still. Same with Twitter and Linked In.

If you are saying that web3 solves these by making it so that these platforms aren't in charge of my identity, well they aren't today so I'm not sure what the deal is. If gmail bans my account it's not a huge issue because I use a custom domain for my email, so I can route it to another provider or host my own. If Facebook bans me then I lose contact with family on there but I don't lost my identity because FB isn't in charge of my identity. same with twitter or linked in or whatever.

All these problems you list are solvable today with the decentralized web we've had for decades. There's a reason centralization has happened on these platforms, and it seems like all the web3 talk I see is naive to that.

Edit: Also Keybase is a great example using cryptography to solve the identity problem without a blockchain and with some level of decentralization (keybase's servers are centralized but the actual identity is all based on PGP and GPG that's been around for a long time).

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by wpietri on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:27PM (#29326346)
This is always my issue with things in this space. There's a list of bad things to be fixed or good things to achieve. And then there's a technology like [jazz hands] blockchain. But when you ask how they relate, it gets very handwavey.

When I was at Code for America in 2015, somebody dropped by one of our events to buttonhole me about [jazz hands] blockchain for governments. I listened politely for a while and then asked, "Why would something that is definitionally a central authority need a trustless, distributed system?" They blathered and huffed for a while, but could never answer the question. They walked away thinking I was clearly not bright enough to see how it was all going to change.

A couple years later a friend asked me to set down with somebody who wanted to launch a startup. Their customers were companies who wanted employees to be able to safely report sexual harassment and other misbehavior. They had a few existing competitors, so I asked what made this new company different. The would-be founder explained that they would use [jazz hands] blockchain. I asked further, and it turned out that they would use [jazz hands] blockchain internally. So basically a database with extra steps. I pointed out that assault reporters wouldn't be able to see any difference; from the user perspective, all the companies in the market were just saying, "trust us, we definitely won't tell the people paying us anything". The entrepreneur was convinced that it really was different, but if so they couldn't make it clear to me.

So now we've had, what, 6 or 7 years where [jazz hands] blockchain was going to revolutionize things and it hasn't made a practical dent in any real industry. Originally I too was willing to call that naive, but it seems an awfully long time to accidentally maintain such perfect innocence.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by the_snooze on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:29PM (#29326660)
At its heart, the strongest claim blockchain technology offers is pretty good data consistency assurances between nodes that don't trust one another. I guess that's kind of interesting as a technical demonstration, but it's hard to see what's actually the practical benefit of that. This has been around and under continuous development since 2008, and still no actual use case.

It seems like the space is full of hype-bro crooks and hype-bro dupes who feed off one another, warping a niche technical toy into whatever get-rich-quick revolutionary fantasy they want.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by s3tz on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @01:32AM (#29327430)
That's because everyone fell for the systems fallacy. Blockchain was designed for bitcoin to function, for that purpose alone. Then because it worked for that one use case of a decentralized storage/transfer of value, people assumed they could make it work for everything else. Not how technology works.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by Vetch on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @06:43AM (#29329015)
> it's hard to see what's actually the practical benefit of that

Its utility is much easier to see if you're stuck in a system rife with corruption and have a general lack of trust in central institutions. A key aspect of corruption is that central authorities are not accountable to anyone.

With blockchains, you can design systems where game theory via what's encoded into system design, can limit what concentrations of power can do. The centralized powers in bitcoin for example, can't rationally act in way that destroys the value of the system they're participating in. This is totally not true for many developing economies; just that property is already an encouraging one.

Working on scaling these systems, making them less resource intensive and proving stronger more formal bounds for open peer to peer friendly non-discriminatory systems that are harder to corrupt and more robust to bad actors is a not a solution in search of a problem.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by gls2ro on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @02:30PM (#29334108)
This sounds good. But I think technology cannot solve political issues or corruption of central authorities.

The reason in my mind is simple: a corrupt central system will never choose such technology.

In our human history we kept inventing technology but it (the technology) never fixed corruption. Of course maybe web3 is truly something special but I doubt this. Why: because I dont see how this techology changes fundamental human nature.

Here is an example: people were saying that internet (web1 or web2 not sure how to name this) will offer free access to knowledge thus making everybody smarter. But we see this not happening. It is true that more people are smarter or better but many many more are influenced by internet in bad (corrupted) ways.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by the_snooze on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @10:52AM (#29331189)
Can you elaborate more? It's unclear to me how a data storage technology has any bearing on trust and power relationships, especially in interactions that are largely in meatspace.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by bawolff on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @01:44AM (#29327496)
I think its important to add, with open group membership to that definition.

If there is a known fixed list of nodes participating in the system, blockchain again becomes a bad choice.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by dehrmann on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @11:50PM (#29327020)
The expression you're looking for to describe blockchain is a solution in search of a problem.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by outside1234 on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @12:40AM (#29327227)
To be fair - it probably has revolutionized money laundering and government bribes.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by Vetch on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @07:00AM (#29329125)
> government bribes

Governments mired in corruption, embezzlement of public funds, dumping toxic waste and ignoring infrastructure and human development are not banning crypto out of the goodness of their heart. They're banning it because it erodes and threatens control of their mismanaged currencies.

If we required governments and large corporations to use identifiable addresses then the traceability and immutability of public blockchains makes bribes and corruption much harder to hide. Government spending, which is not used to being held accountable would of course not take kindly to this.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by wpietri on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @06:51PM (#29336641)
This seems very whataboutist. Is your serious claim that Bitcoin, et al, aren't increasing bribery? They're helping out other sorts of financial crime quite handily, so this is a claim that would require a lot of evidence.

And as to your second paragraph, [citation needed]. As long as we're imagining central authorities mandating the sort of transparency that would make it harder for corruption, we could just use the existing financial system, which is already reasonably well tied to real-world identity. Cryptocurrency in no way helps here.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by nberkman on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @02:01AM (#29327578)
I remember when the massive early growth of Napster led to a similar hype cycle around P2P, with overblown articles in Wired proclaiming it to be the answer to everything. Around 2004 I was CTO of a company building a streaming music service and I got a call from the CEO of a P2P-based CDN. I asked him some basic questions trying to find any reason I might consider them. It became clear that it would make no sense for us - their pricing was above the quotes I had received from other CDNs and I had no confidence in their reliability. The only selling point was whatever residual buzz P2P had at that point. He quickly became agitated and began yelling at me about how I "didn't get it". The company was called Red Swoosh and the angry CEO was Travis Kalanick. A few years later he somehow managed to sell it to Akamai, and as I recall it was shut down within a year.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by wpietri on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @10:20AM (#29330778)
Wow, excellent story. If only he had gone out of business before the sale, we might never have heard from that guy again, and the world would have been much better for it.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by shsbdncudx on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @05:49AM (#29328743)
This [jazz hands] _thing_ works once but then drop it, it ruins your [jazz hands] _story_
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by wpietri on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @10:16AM (#29330746)
Oh, is today the day on HN where we give unwanted writing advice? In that case, I'll just tell you that I don't really listen to people who universalize their individual reactions and act as if they're their only audience member in the world. So next time you want to give feedback, please do it in a fashion where your individual feelings are clearly marked as such, not hyperbolized into the total ruination of the writing in question.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by kwertyoowiyop on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @09:59AM (#29330584)
[sarcastic finger quotes]?
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by practice9 on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @05:27AM (#29328615)
Sure, I'll try to explain the Gmail point:

- Setting up a separate domain for mail is a good idea, but access to previous emails and/or photos, docs, Drive files will be not recovered. Also non-technical person would probably skip this step.

The issue of not really being in control of your data can be solved by:

- regulating Google to let you access your data irrespectively if you are banned from their frontend or not. You can choose to export it in a standardized way to your own server, IPFS or another cloud provider. All data and metadata is exported and then parsed depending on capabilities of the receiving server.

- putting all of your data, encrypted, on IPFS or similar and creating multiple frontends for it (not unlike email clients, right? Similar idea). Then assigning your unique DID to this data, so it's part of your online belongings

- Next step would be regulating Google to allow you to use the complete user data stored on their servers with any client. Like an S3 bucket? Yes, something like that. Google can choose to charge some price for the access, that's OK.

GDPR tried to solve some of the high level issues related to user data, but it's not enough

Edit:

Google already has semi-closed APIs for some of their products, but only for partner businesses.

You're required to jump through multiple hoops to gain access (not guaranteed): https://developers.google.com/photos/partner-program/overvie...

On Twitter: Jack does seem to have plans to make Twitter more decentralized, i.e. Bluesky https://blueskyweb.org/

Seem like they started off with brainstorming identity verification solutions and DIDs.

But I haven't followed them closely

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by denton-scratch on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @07:21AM (#29329261)
> Setting up a separate domain for mail is a good idea, but access to previous emails [...]

Fetchmail?

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by strogonoff on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:49PM (#29325665)
Lack of human support in the old Web 2.0 is bad, but going full zero-trust in response seems more like throwing a fit instead of improving things (e.g., banning the exploitative ‘free’ ad-supported business models).

A world in which you lose some magic alphanumeric combination (or a thief pinches your hardware key, etc.) and you are literally locked out of your identity (together with access to your eternal blockchain-backed social rating or whatever is the logical next move) seems simultaneously horrifying and ridiculous.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by paul_f on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:40PM (#29326057)
It does not even require hacker, a thief could show up at your house and demand your keys.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by DanHulton on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:50PM (#29326757)
Ah, the ol' "rubber hose cryptanalysis". I was literally just talking about this an hour ago.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by mannanj on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @02:26AM (#29327670)
How would this be any different from a thief breaking in anyways and taking your valuables at gunpoint?
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by strogonoff on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @10:17AM (#29393008)
Because your money are in a bank (which is generally a bit more difficult to break into), and if the thief takes some of the shiny toys you are still left with your identity at least.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by practice9 on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @04:49AM (#29328427)
It's just that by relying so much on centralized corporations we give them powers of a country/dictatorship:

- issue an ID

- create a policy

- ban if you break the ambiguous rules or trip some fraud algorithm

- not ban some people or orgs even if they break the rules, because they bring too much value to platform (= almost a bribe in some sense)

- and you can't really emigrate and take your belongings with you. Can you export your social graph from FB? Not sure if that's possible, at least not in a straightforward way, you need to recreate it on another platform again.

- Google and Apple become a little better with this last few years, there is data export (in a .zip, lol)

I agree with your second point. For non-technical users, taking care of their private key will be a huge issue. There are some models like multisig, or social recovery (you add a guardian or a set of trusted persons that can vouch for you).

AFAIK even FB has been trying out social recovery features.

This is a good post about social recovery wallets:

https://vitalik.ca/general/2021/01/11/recovery.html

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by strogonoff on Thursday November 25, 2021 @09:17AM (#29341531)
This won’t solve the problem with maliciuos actors in positions of power, and if we take care of malicious intent (which is really the only way forward) there is no need for technology that essentially exists to avoid having people to trust each other.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by chrisfrantz on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:41PM (#29325609)
Sure, but that’s replaced with user’s being in control of their identity (permanently).

Lose your keys, you’re out of luck and locked out of who knows how many applications permanently.

It might be fine for us, but just think of the less technically inclined folks in your life. Are they going to remember a 32 word phrase or use a password manager for a key?

And what happens if they’re hacked? If google detects your account is hacked, you may be able to salvage it.

If someone nabs your wallet, they get access to however many apps you have set up along with whatever funds you have in there.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by robbiep on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @02:00AM (#29327572)
I think the idea of fully decentralising all the things as per web3 or the move to crypto is really interesting.

But if the last couple years has told us anything it’s that it’s being immediately met with a wave of recentralisation where some ungodly percentage of crypto wallets are all sitting with centralised providers and services, which still require email/password entry.

I fail to see how a non-tecnhical user is going to migrate from where we are now to keeping all their keys by themselves (Sorry I recognise you’re agreeing with these points as well basically but started replying here so might as well finish)

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by kaetemi on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:51PM (#29326132)
Then they can still use a middleman. The idea is that any data ownership can be transferred. No middleman monopoly or lock-in.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by chrisfrantz on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @11:08PM (#29326838)
If people need a middleman, there will be a few winners and the monopoly or duopoly will continue.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by necubi on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:54PM (#29325707)
And that's an improvement how? At least with Google there's a chance you'll be able to get your account back. If it's "decentralized" (which in crypto land is apparently synonymous with "run by a cabal of miners in China") and you lose your private key, you're completely out of luck.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by drdeca on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:11PM (#29326263)
If it isn't relying on a blockchain thing, and it's based on you setting up a private key, there's no "run by a cabal of miners in China" issue.

And how is "google accidentally bans your account" and "you lose your private key" comparable anyway? In the first case, it isn't under your control, but under the control of some large organization, and in the second case it is because you messed up.

In addition, there are mechanisms being worked on (often in the context of on-blockchain stuff, but I don't see this as fundamentally necessary to it) for facilitating like, "I trust these people to authenticate whether someone is me, in the case that I lose my private key", in order to establish that a new key still corresponds to the same person.

Like, I'm less enthusiastic about this kind of thing than I have been in the past (and I've never spent money on it), but your criticism doesn't seem to be engaging in the ideas really.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by aaronax on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @11:49PM (#29327011)
If you lose some cash you are also out of luck, yet cash is still useful and even had some valuable properties.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by onion2k on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @12:06AM (#29327083)
You may have a different experience, but most people tend to only keep small amounts of cash that they're able to accept the loss of around. They put the rest of their assets in banks and securities because then they're protected from loss by several mechanisms like bank security, legal security, and insurance.

The way people handle money is literally the opposite of keeping your identity on a blockchain.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by notafraudster on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @10:47AM (#29331121)
I'm actually not sure this is true. I lived in the US 2014-early 2021 and don't think I used cash after about 2017; I've lived in Europe since and just got touched cash for the first time today because my Christmas tree delivery guy doesn't take Revolut. A few months ago I had lunch at a restaurant whose terminal went down and I asked what they wanted me to do and they said "sure, don't worry about it, come back later today and pay, or whenever you can" (so I did, obviously.)

No doubt there are people for whom cash has valuable properties, but I'm just saying I don't think I'm one of them and my use case seems pretty normal as far as people go.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by mamma_luvs_rust on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @11:13PM (#29326858)
Even if you're logging in with the 'blockchain' they can still ban your account, all of the good usages of 'Web3' I've seen look like WebAuthn but with most possibilities for scams
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by swiftcoder on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @02:50AM (#29327775)
Indeed. Blockchain identities have the unfortunate property of being immutable and easily traceable. No longer can you just create a new email account to evade a service ban...
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by richardw on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @03:02AM (#29327834)
People can self publish and now we have a total shitshow of misinformation. It’s not guaranteed that decentralised finance and web solves world peace. There is always a tradeoff.

Maybe it’s awesome. Maybe it’s the web version of string theory. Can someone tell us why it’s more of the former than the latter?

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by nyanpasu64 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:56PM (#29325724)
It's a noble goal. And I don't think that's what NFTs and blockchains and their promoters are setting out to do.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by DantesKite on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:07PM (#29325318)
Riding off a wave of addicts and their enthusiasm for gambling.

Meanwhile, Cash App, Apple Pay, and Stripe have done more for fintech in the past month than all other cryptocurrency technologies combined in the last decade.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by Vetch on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:11PM (#29326258)
Where I live none of those services are available but cryptocurrency tech is.

Connecting to services like patreon or getting small amounts for games on itch.io are headache inducing high friction activities involving several extra third party services that are barely worth the effort. The attached risk is hard to state as better given all the fly by night operations in the local finance industry.

Even if very few people use crypto, it's orders of magnitude less stress to put up a link to a wallet for donations on say a page with a visual demo on how linear acceleration and light bending motivate gravity.

It's instrumental in financing sci-hub, which is also vital here.

You probably live in a country where central institutions are trusted. Probably without overwhelming levels of corruption actively antagonistic to citizens, or double digit inflation, or very high unemployment rates and a general lack of opportunity.

I don't think cryptocurrencies are some magical cure and can't say they will be part of a solution concept. Neither do I care for gambling and scummy activity on it. For some of us it isn't about inflation hedging (although it has a useful role if you can anticipate impending economic collapse) or anti-fiat or overthrowing governments.

It's about imagining a network of transactions where anyone can participate regardless of their country of birth, without a central synchronizing consensus mechanism and a strongly tamper resistant storage useful in coordinating economic activity. Blockchain free decentralized tech are preferable where possible but there are some things only blockchain structures (or even worse scaling massive communication overhead systems) can do.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by supernovae on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @11:39PM (#29326968)
For some reason, i just can’t fathom that it would be wise for a stable economic system to connect to such an unstable system - the only reason to champion such would be to create instability at larger scale.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by Vetch on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @06:08AM (#29328828)
Unsure about what you mean but the current instability of this type of economy is already very high.

What with double digit inflation being hard to tackle due to the feedback loop of corruption fueling too few employment opportunities, being import dependent amid rising costs everywhere and then noting the large divergence between black market and official rates, it cannot be said with certainty which is more stable and less risky in the long run. Things are bad enough that putting some money in crypto as a makeshift uncorrelated hedging instrument makes sense.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by supernovae on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @11:57AM (#29332108)
Crypto isn't an exception to any of your concerns. Easily manipulated by foriegn governments, no assurance in import/exports, no assurance on value for employment opportunities, ripe for fraud and as for inflation - until Crypto actually behaves like a currency all your doing is betting against the dollar and if the dollar collapses then all you're doing is ensuring instability and perptetuating exactly what you say you solve
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by wpietri on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:30PM (#29326359)
Your poetic invocation of the theoretical glorious potential of crypto aside, what country do you live in?
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by askonomm on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @11:27PM (#29326919)
Not sure about OP, but I live in Argentina, and there is no Apple Pay, Stripe, or Cash App here either. Not in most of the Latin American countries, actually. I had to make a U.S Wyoming company in order to be able to use Stripe. And Latin America is a pretty big chunk of land, with a ton of people.

And with the ever-increasing inflation of 40% YoY and government restrictions on the ability to convert foreign currency to local currency, crypto P2P is a saving grace here.

I do think most crypto stuff is probably still a scam, but the ability to buy stable coins and sell them to someone local here for peso's by getting 2x more than I would with the official central bank rate is a godsend.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by wpietri on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @10:13AM (#29330724)
Is there actual data on cryptocurrency use in Argentina?

Last I lived in an unstable Latin America country with inflation issues, the common solution was just to buy dollars. So much so that the country, Ecuador, eventually just switched over to using dollars entirely. So I can believe it's possible that people are trying to do similar things digitally when they don't trust the local currency. But given the user-hostile nature of a lot of the cryptocurrency systems, I suspect they aren't doing all that much of it. As an example, look at El Salvador's clown-shoes attempt to switch over to using Bitcoin.

So as much as I grant the theoretical potential of an imagined version of cryptocurrencies to be useful, I'm still pretty skeptical of the actual use of actual cryptocurrencies, even under those conditions.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by askonomm on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @10:26AM (#29330866)
I don't have any data points, but my own social circle, of which the majority uses Binance to buy crypto and uses Binance P2P to sell it to ARS (Peso). And since the transfer will be reflected on your bank balance as some regular person sending you money locally, it's not taxed either. The whole process of buying stablecoins USDC or Tether to it being sold to ARS and actually landing on my local bank account takes about 5 min maybe, which is really nice as well - Western Union and Xoom take up to 3 days or so on average.

Most people have used Western Union / Xoom here to get local money, but those have quick limits here, and the government is making it harder and harder to do that, by often prompting to explain your income, then pay taxes on that income, often resulting in double taxation for people.

Most of the things in Argentina are still in Pesos (pubs, restaurants, grocery stores, etc), except for the real estate market of which about half the rental listings ask payment in USD, and if you want to buy a car then half the listings of those are also in USD. Lots of local jobs also pay in USD, so I can definitely see how ARS might at some point be devalued and everything going over to USD, but for now for most day-to-day things you still need ARS.

I'm by no means saying that crypto is the future or even a great solution, but for the current situation here it is quite convenient and better than any alternative.

Edit: To add, if there is one indication of crypto use there, it's that the local Apple Pay equivalent "Mercado Pago", which is available in most shops and restaurants here, has announced that they will add the ability to pay with crypto balance to their app, so I guess there are enough people to warrant that, at the very least.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by wpietri on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @10:47AM (#29331120)
Thanks for the details. But I'm not quite following this bit: "The whole process of buying stablecoins USDC or Tether to it being sold to ARS and actually landing on my local bank account takes about 5 min maybe"

This sounds like you are going from pesos to pesos in 5 minutes, but I assume that isn't the case. What are you buying the stablecoins with?

Also, if I understand the use case directly, there's nothing here that requires a blockchain at all. The same thing could happen with dollars and another centralized company like Binance, yes? It seems like the novel technical part is the person-to-person transactions used to hide that it's a centralized company. Did I get tha right?

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by askonomm on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @11:29AM (#29331719)
I'm buying the crypto with foreign currency, e.g USD or EUR. For example, since I have a U.S company, I effectively make dollars with my work, but to be able to live here I need pesos. And the same would be the case if you work for one of the local companies that pay you in USD, since you still need pesos for day to day stuff.

Now, I can of course convert my foreign currency to ARS via a central bank, or a regular bank transfer. But here's the thing: official central bank rate for 1 USD is around 100 ARS. The unofficial rate (Western Union, Xoom, Crypto P2P) gives me 200 ARS for 1 USD. Quite literally double the money. That's a very big deal.

And yes, you're right that there is no inherent need for the blockchain or crypto at all, but the lack of oversight is probably the only reason why it is so convenient, and the lack of alternatives, because Western Union and Xoom serve the same purpose, but are much slower (days instead of minutes) and are bombarded with government restrictions.

I could, of course, try to find people here directly who want to buy my USD for ARS, and it would function the same way, but Binance P2P offers a marketplace website for that without me needing to find any of the people myself, equipped with escrow functionality so I won't get scammed.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by wpietri on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @01:00PM (#29332958)
Got it. Thanks, that's helpful.

I definitely agree that evading governmental controls on currency exchange can be beneficial, especially if one's income isn't local. And reasonable when the controls are used to cover up other problems. I also agree that in the short term using centralized digital services can help there, especially ones that don't worry much about fraud prevention or remediation, as they can be very quick. Doubly so if they're tuned for financial crime.

But by the same token, the centrality and convenience are major points of weakness if they are going to last. Binance is under regulatory threat the world over, and keeps withdrawing from markets one step ahead of regulators. I'd be very surprised if they are able to do that for you a decade from now. Especially as digital forensics and AML tooling will be a decade better.

Instead, I'd guess people in your situation will be doing what they've always done: building informal networks of collaborators so that the regulatory evasion happens offline in ways that are hard to track or limit. Perhaps it will be more like what I saw in Ecuador: friends of friends swapping envelopes of cash when it suits them both.

So to me this story isn't about the power of crypto, which is incidental here, or the magic of decentralization, which isn't much in play either. Instead it's about another temporary window where technology has gotten ahead of regulation.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by echelon on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:47PM (#29325653)
Bingo.

They can't even get their numbering scheme right. This would be "web4"

Disregarding the semantic web throws out the history of the tech that sought to build p2p knowledge graphs before the social giants pushed it aside. They care little for these concepts given their blatant disregard.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by tata71 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:15PM (#29325867)
Nah, jamming shitty responsive sites into phone screens was Web 2.5.

Convergence, meaning plug your phone or tablet into fullsize keyboard and display, will be the new normal.

Crossplatform web app EVERYTHING, PWA if you please, with web3 hooks where relevant, is Web 3.0.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by bawolff on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @01:47AM (#29327512)
Honestly i think its perfect.

Both are big ideas that sound very impressive to an outsider but problematic once you get into the details.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by echelon on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @10:37AM (#29330993)
In a world without the concentration of development to venture capital-backed tech firms, semantic models of data create a web of rich APIs and data that are interlinked and that can grow and evolve.

You have schemas for representing people that you can download as contacts. Schemas for representing articles that can be linked to people. Schemas for comments and upvotes... Fully distributed Facebook / Reddit / Twitter that anyone could extend.

Venture-backed startups grew faster than the Semantic Web. That's the reason it didn't materialize.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by danjac on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @02:43AM (#29327756)
When upward mobility has been stymied for generations (the US has the lowest upword mobility among Western nations, outdoing even the class-ridden Brits) and insane house prices, student loans and cost of living increases have cut all the bootstraps, people are looking for anything - anything - that offers the slimmest of opportunities, because education and hard work don't cut it any more. Hence the crypto nonsense among the younger generation and MLM cults for the older Facebook crowd.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by dgb23 on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @06:32AM (#29328948)
The people who put their hope into blockchain and crypto currency technology are missing a fundamental point that would have _catastrophic_ consequences on social mobility, exploitation and oppression in the long term: You don't actually want a decentralized, persistent log of all transactions, especially if that also includes credit and debt.

The financial market is going out of hand because since the 70's/80's it isn't serving it's purpose anymore, which is regulating and allocating resources and credit. Instead it is disjoint from actual value and productivity, so it has started a life of its own.

People and entire nations are being held down by financial obligations while not benefiting from the increase in productivity and profit because the connection between finance and value production is almost completely severed.

The only non-violent way out of this is forgiveness. Which acknowledges that exact monetary value and debt in any form and especially in it's current form is just a highly volatile figment. And that's only possible if we can actually _forget_ transactions.

An eternal, cryptographic, decentralized transaction log might just be the perfect tool for long term financial oppression and exploitation. And the more convenient it gets the more exchange will flow through it. Well at least until the people start magnetizing and burning down data centers and PCs. But I think there are less destructive ways forward.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by blatchcorn on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @06:59AM (#29329114)
You make a large assumption that people don't want a permanent log. If the system works then you do want it to be permanent. The only reason why you propose forgetting the transactions of the current system is that it is distorted by politicians. Politicians cannot distorted crypto markets in the same way they can with the USD, therefore is no need to ever forget crypto transactions
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by beepbooptheory on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @07:42AM (#29329409)
I think you give politicians too much credit, they have influence, but at the end of the day we all have one master in this world. There is something importantly impersonal and algorithmic about the circulation and allotment of capital and currency, and that is the ultimate reason we live in the unjust and unforgiving world we do. A persistent totalizing ledger would only reify these systems more. It would absolve the system of any traces of humanity it might incidentally have, leaving nothing but transactions.

There is not a more egalitarian capitalism hidden under the machinations of corrupt politicians, it is itself a dark, destructive thing. I am confident that money will save no one at the end. Money is not the salvation you are looking for.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by dgb23 on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @08:05AM (#29329593)
I'm saying "the system" doesn't work because it doesn't serve its purpose and on a deeper level it is inherently based on imagination.

Politicians and the financial system are not entities that can isolated from each other. The financial system is in of itself a form of trade regulation: to make rules about what costs what, who owes who, what can be traded how and so on. Finance is the bureaucracy of trade. It is failing because it shifted its purpose from regulation and quantification of value to a life of its own and has become in large parts speculative and non-proportional. Even some of the most libertarian thinkers like Adam Smith have warned us about this.

A crypto market is one such thing, but not only is it already disjoint from its purpose, which is enumerating value, credit and regulating trade. The speculative and volatile nature of crypto markets show that. But it also doesn't enable the use of a safety break - that has been used time and time again in larger history but also in smaller interactions - to repair the economy from becoming fantastical to real again. Crypto has also no alternative solution of doing that.

What happens when you don't do that for long enough is that the people will do it for you. They will at some point burn it all down. Debt and profits that are disjoint from actual value and become more so through financial mechanisms erode trust. And currently that is exactly what you can see happening since a few years. People are quitting their jobs, joining protests, unions and so on because they intuitively understand that they are being screwed.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by tim333 on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @09:53AM (#29330513)
The way to deal with excess debt is not to have a cranky database that loses the records. Also forgiveness seldom happens.

What does happen in reality often is inflation - government gives money to the needy (or similar) and the money being given out inflates away the debts.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by kwertyoowiyop on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @09:57AM (#29330556)
Governments also “inflate” their way out of debts through population increases.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by austincheney on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @03:53AM (#29328118)
So much wrong with that.

Education and hard work drive labor. These aren’t qualities respected by any kind of wealth generators or management. If anything they are unrewarded implicit requirements except for labor where there aren’t other more substantial qualities to rate individual contributions.

In most of the country house prices remained low and stable until very recently. Only a few coastal areas have seen decades of out of control pricing.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by Xeronate on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @04:13AM (#29328230)
I agree with you, but I am interested in hearing what qualities you feel are respected by wealth generators and management.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by austincheney on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @04:48AM (#29328426)
Initiative and accountability are two broadly rewarded qualities.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by vletal on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @04:02AM (#29328175)
I can clearly see a strong correlation between both education and hard work vs. social status and income. I come from Europe though. Is it really not the case in the US? Is it because of student loan barrier?
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by rbanffy on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @07:17AM (#29329231)
How hard did Boris Johnson work again? Or Priti Patel? Or Don Jr? Or Jair Bolsonaro?

I'm Brazilian, but I live in Europe, and everyday I see that I was privileged to be able to focus on studying hard (and didn't, most of the time) and still managed to be quite successful when compared to the average European. In Brazil, my skin and eye color was a ticket to some very restricted spaces I simply wouldn't have access to with the wrong colors.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by vletal on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @10:35AM (#29330977)
You are cherry picking outliers to argue against a claim about a general trend.

It really does not matter how hard this or that particular individual worked. What matters is statistics which describes the opportunity of an anonymous Joe in the society.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by rbanffy on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @10:44AM (#29331084)
It really depends on what kind of mobility we are talking about. The wealth and influence of the individuals I mentioned is pretty much impossible to reach unless you have optimal initial conditions. As the saying goes, the easiest way to become a millionaire is to be born a billionaire. Even if you are born a mere millionaire, you can make many more attempts at becoming a billionaire than a person who needs to work in order to have dinner.

There is a lot of statistics that point that current levels of social mobility are on par with feudal England and, while a modest improvement in conditions is very achievable for those who aren’t born in the most unforgiving situations, the remaining possible paths are very much closed.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by vletal on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @11:05AM (#29331354)
I kind of expected that we are talking about the basic mobility, such as my wife coming from a low income blue collar family becoming an upper-middle class architect. Not the chance of becoming a super-rich or super-powerful.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by rbanffy on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @11:36AM (#29331811)
It's kind of a caste society where you can have some mobility, but you can't really move out of your place in society.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by koboll on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:29PM (#29325516)
>It doesn't help that I personally have yet to see a use for a blockchain which isn't replicating an existing financial instrument while trying to avoid the eyes of the state.

I mean, there's a domain name system. There are various games. There was recently a high-profile crowdfunded attempt to buy an artifact at auction. Feel free to be skeptical of all of these, but what's the point of posting that you "haven't seen" anything legitimate if you're unwilling to exert a bare minimum level of effort to research other use cases?

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by luhn on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:51PM (#29326128)
> I mean, there's a domain name system.

You mean ENS, the .eth domain registrar incorporated in the Cayman Islands? It doesn't matter what the blockchain says, my .eth domain is only good as long as the registrar agrees to honor it. Sounds like GoDaddy with more steps.

> There are various games.

What's the point of a distribute ledger that can only be used within a game controlled by a centralized company?

> There was recently a high-profile crowdfunded attempt to buy an artifact at auction.

You mean ConstitutionDOA, which imploded quite spectacularly? People are still wondering if that was a scam or just sheer incompetence.

Honestly it's hilarious that you would bring that up as a flagship example.

> you're unwilling to exert a bare minimum level of effort to research other use cases

I have exerted that effort and more, and still come up short.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by koboll on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @10:46AM (#29331112)
So when I point out that there are other use cases beyond "replicating an existing financial instrument while trying to avoid the eyes of the state", instead of walking back your claim that no other use cases exist, you simply move the goalposts and attack these use cases in other ways.

They're all perfectly legitimate complaints. But the fact that you have to resort to them, rather than defending your original claim, shows how weak that claim was.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by luhn on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @01:42PM (#29333529)
When someone says "use case" they mean something... useful. I think it's pretty obvious that the OP didn't mean "no one has tried anything with blockchain."

I wasn't the one who made that claim anyways, so let me make one: Beyond cryptocurrency, there is no problem that blockchain solves better (simpler, cheaper, more efficient, more practical, etc.) than "traditional" organizations and technology.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by lui8906 on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @10:56AM (#29331246)
> What's the point of a distribute ledger that can only be used within a game controlled by a centralized company?

The game is made by a centralized company. The items and economy in the game are on chain. Gamers can sell their items to other gamers. Or items can be interwoven into multiple games because the items / economy share the same "backend".

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by fastball on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @06:59AM (#29329121)
Regarding ENS, it actually does matter what the blockchain says, because everyone that has integrated ENS (like IPFS or MetaMask) are using the records in the blockchain to resolve which name.eth is connected to which wallet.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by afavour on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:43PM (#29325621)
The crowdfunding to bust the constitution is surely a replication of an existing financial instrument? Crowdfunding is not new.

That particular episode also laid bare the problems no web3 proponent seems to want to address: a whole load of people are going to lose all the money they gave to the fund because transaction fees will swallow their investment whole if they ever try for a refund.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by stefan_ on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:19PM (#29325893)
Not to mention that all the transaction fees meant their final fund was just barely too small to actually buy the item they had crowdfunded for. Cryptocurrency: it just ain't good for anything.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by wpietri on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:08PM (#29326237)
Please consider that they have seen those things. Is there any of those that couldn't be done without a blockchain? Indeed, wouldn't have been done better without a blockchain?

The "buy an artifact" thing ended up a total mess. To the extent any true distributed blockchain was used, it didn't help anything: https://www.vice.com/en/article/qjb8av/constitutiondao-after...

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by zepto on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:08PM (#29325814)
How is that crowdfunding thing anything other than a failed publicity stunt? There is nothing new that was demonstrated.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by 7307d55853ee6b9 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:52PM (#29326481)
> unwilling to exert a bare minimum level of effort to research other use cases?

What I'm unwilling to do is wade through the mountains of scams and get-rich-quick schemes to find novel applications of a distributed ledger. Games? Seriously? Show me a game that isn't just a vehicle for boosting the trade volume of some shitcoin.

It's all dystopian tech bro capitalism to me.

> There was recently a high-profile crowdfunded attempt to buy an artifact at auction. Feel free to be skeptical of all of these, but

Yeah, that one where half the people who want a refund will lose a significant chunk, if not all, of their donation in fees. I find it absolutely laughable that with all of the fancy "smart contract" tech out there someone couldn't figure how to hold these donations in cryptographic escrow and return them without a huge penalty if the transaction were to fall through. It's hard to feel bad for those who put money in. It should all be automated and foolproof, and I thought that was the point.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by djohnston on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @05:17AM (#29328557)
Go to a web3 site and use your wallet as your identity without any signin flow, don't click on any asinine cookie prompts, and you'll see it's already bringing improvements. Or you can just write comments like this.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by Uehreka on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @05:42AM (#29328705)
OK, NOW WE’RE TALKIN. In years of talking to blockchain people about this stuff, no one has ever given me a use case description that succinct and concrete. A decentralized SSO is the kind of thing that would seem useful on it’s own, even without the other stuff.

So let’s say I want to try this out this weekend. Do I just download MetaMask and make a wallet? Do I have to go somewhere or pay someone to inscribe my username in the blockchain or does this basically work immediately? And what are some sites that support this?

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by eric_cc on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @12:17PM (#29332392)
Setup a MetaMask wallet. That's it! You don't even have to fund it in order to authenticate on web3 applications. MetaMask will allow you to authenticate on all the different chains that have EVM-based dapps including Ethereum, Fantom, Avalanche, & Moonriver

Polkadot.js for Kusama and Polkadot apps. You can also check out Fearless wallet on mobile for Polkadot & Kusama where you can participate in the ongoing parachain auctiona. Use the Phantom extension to authenticate on Solana dapps.

Hope you have fun!

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by meheleventyone on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @07:16AM (#29329222)
You can also do this with other decentralized tech like PGP for example: https://webauthn.guide/
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by Uehreka on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @12:11PM (#29332323)
My understanding is that you could use that to auth with a site where you already have an account or where you’re signing up. But if blockchain enables me to go to a site I’ve never been to and be already signed in with a unique name I reserved on the blockchain, I’m pretty sure that would be a novel thing.

Maybe not enough to swing me over to being a crypto-booster, but this is the first time that someone has shown me anything at all that makes sense.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by meheleventyone on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @12:50PM (#29332819)
With WebAuthn you could signup with just the auth as well. It's basically the same thing as a wallet private/public key-pair so can do all the same things as a proxy for a universal ID.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by fastball on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @06:57AM (#29329101)
Decentralized SSO is a great use case for blockchain tech and there are so many ways you can do it. There has been a lot of hype around NFTs due to the crazy prices we've been seeing for "digital artwork NFTs", but you can also use them for auth and it's actually pretty slick.

Here is a project[1] that a friend of mine is building that does exactly that. It's basically a collection of TailwindCSS components that he originally built in the "web 2.0" way, as in: buy a subscription (via Stripe) and now you have access to his collection of pre-built components. But then he realized this is actually a great use-case for web3. So instead of signing up for an account with an email + password then using your credit card to buy a lifetime deal, you can connect your MetaMask wallet to his website and "mint" a pass for 0.08 ETH (approx ~$350 atm) which is just an NFT on the Ethereum blockchain. Then as long as that NFT is owned by your wallet you can use it to login to his website. The benefits are: it's actually faster for the user (your wallet is your identity and you access pass is attached directly to that wallet on the blockchain) and also pretty simple for him to integrate on his end. The other benefit is you can trade these passes at will without his oversight – so if he adds more and more Tailwind components to the collection the value of this lifetime access to them hypothetically goes up. But let's say you no longer are interested in building anything with Tailwind components – well you can just sell the NFT that gives you access to someone else via any of the 3rd party decentralized marketplaces.

Anyway there are a lot of cool ideas and use-cases that aren't just decentralized lending (which I'm still pretty skeptical of) or generic gambling (still most of crypto). The main problem right now is that a lot of the coolest stuff has been built on Ethereum (due to the flexibility of its smart contracts) but the transaction fees and throughput are pretty terrible at the moment.

Finally, it gets a lot of hate here on HN, but Brave Browser actually has a MetaMask-equivalent (I think it might actually just be a fork of MetaMask) that is built right into the browser, alongside best-in-class ad-blocking so I'd consider using that too. Though installing MetaMask is super easy as well.

[1] https://rareblocks.xyz/

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by markelliot on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @10:01AM (#29330604)
Thanks for sharing the NFT-as-access-token example, it's far and away the strongest example of a relatable use for NFTs that I've heard, and is compelling both in its value to the issuer (as a verifiable access token) and to the buyer (for both immediate use and due to its resale of residual value after having been used).

I imagine that your friend's NFT contract stipulates he gets a cut of resales, but I'm also curious if/how your friend deals with potentially bad actors that, say, scrape the entire content then resell the token for most of what they paid for it having extracted the content it unlocks. Obviously the contract could help offset a part of that trade, but seems tricky nonetheless?

Edit: I suppose part of the premise is that there are only 500 passes and content continues to be produced, so if you want access to the current library after all passes have been used trading the pass is actually a key attribute of others gaining access to the content.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by bko on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:18PM (#29325439)
> which isn't replicating an existing financial instrument [available to the developed world] while trying to avoid the eyes of the [benevolent] state

Not everyone has access to Venmo or free checking accounts. And not every behavior the state is trying to restrict is nefarious.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by afavour on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @07:25PM (#29325482)
Sure, and if “web3” was sold as “banking for those who cannot use normal banking” and “worthy transactions you want to hide from the state” then I think a lot fewer people would have a negative perception of it. But it isn’t.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by MarkPNeyer on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @07:47AM (#29329452)
Who is doing the selling?

Since nobody is in charge you should expect most sellers to be full of nonsense and misinformed. That’s the nature of any decentralized movement - especially one as directly antagonistic to the status quo.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by zepto on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @08:09PM (#29325824)
Even fewer people have access to cryptocurrency wallets and exchanges than have access to Venmo and it’s international equivalents.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by olalonde on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @01:47AM (#29327511)
> It doesn't help that I personally have yet to see a use for a blockchain which isn't replicating an existing financial instrument while trying to avoid the eyes of the state.

That's kind of the whole point. Money without a state and without permission. If you don't believe in that then of course you won't see the value in decentralized finance.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by mrfinn on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @03:36AM (#29328017)
Blockchain wasn't at first about avoiding eyes of the state, but tyranic control of the state, or any other authority. Then projects allowing secrecy appeared.

Coins like Ethereum pushed way forward, via smart contracts, the possibilities available in cryptocurrencies. Then others like Chainlink added again a whole new level of possibilities connecting the smart contracts to trusted real world data. That goes way beyond the scope of financial instruments, a whole world of automated business can be built on top of that. BTW blockchain is outdated technology, is doesn't scale enough for being able to handle a massive use of cryptocurrencies.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by babyshake on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @01:24AM (#29327397)
Let's say you live in a country where the government carefully monitors all printing presses that publish newspapers and books. And once you see the world wide web, you might just see "trying to avoid the eyes of the state" but that's just a part of what makes it such an important revolution. In both cases, one person with an idea and a keyboard can create something new, or something new that interacts with other existing things. It's a paradigm shift.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by Tom4hawk on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @06:28AM (#29328918)
Just look at China and their access to WORLD wide web. If crypto gains any traction it will also be treated that way.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by ahmedfromtunis on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:02PM (#29326192)
I totally agree with you. The only Blockchain-first technology I got excited about was a system where people can put their free disk space for rent. They get paid in some coin, and that is how the coin gets generated. Sure, you can do it without the Blockchain, but the tech has some real added value.

Alas, for whatever reason, it never got deployed.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by phire on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @12:29AM (#29327176)
The biggest problem with this idea is proving data replication and guaranteed retrievability to the users in a trustless manner.

With a traditional cloud provider, you trust them, upload your data and they deal with the rest, backing it up internally and guaranteeing retrievability with their reputation.

But with blockchain p2p storage, it's really hard to provide the same guarantees. If you only upload the file once and let the blockchain replicate it, then a malicious (or greedy) entity can manipulate the blockchain and control all replicas (backed by a single disk copy). So your software must encrypt multiple copies of your data and upload seperate replicas with different encryption keys.

But that still leaves you open to a very malicious entity going out of it's way to track all uploads from a node, and monopolising control over them, then deleting them when you try to download them. To actually provide the same guarantees that a cloud provider does in a trustless way, your local software will also have to continually download chunks to make sure they are still retrievable, and you might also need to use the tor network for all accesses.

With all that extra complexity, there is a lot to go wrong, and a traditional cloud provider might end up being the cheapest option. I used to agree with you, but after trying to design such a system with these trustless guarantees myself, I've come to the conclusion that there is no good use case for blockchain, outside of exchanging value.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by aspenmayer on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:25PM (#29326332)
It’s possible you’re thinking of Chia, IPFS, or FileCoin, all of which are “live” and “deployed” currently.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by uncomputation on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @09:47PM (#29326450)
Filecoin is “live” only technically. There is no way for individuals to contribute, which seems to be intentional as the leadership is looking for corporate support first. It currently has no real use cases. I say this as someone who is also excited by the idea.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by aspenmayer on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:12PM (#29326580)
Perhaps you can clarify the relations between IPFS and FileCoin? I was under the impression that they were related projects of Protocol Labs, with IPFS being a dependency of FileCoin.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by shepardrtc on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:27PM (#29326649)
If you want something similar to Filecoin that is live and in use, check out http://siasky.net/

Siacoin has been around for a while and approaches things differently. Plus its already being used by people.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by phire on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @12:16AM (#29327126)
IPFS isn't blockchain. and Chia doesn't allow people to rent out storage space, it just lets them mine with HDDs instead of GPUs.

The other one I'm aware of is Sia.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by pcthrowaway on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @07:51AM (#29329488)
Arweave is the big one I know of
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by philwelch on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @03:39AM (#29328044)
> It doesn't help that I personally have yet to see a use for a blockchain which isn't replicating an existing financial instrument while trying to avoid the eyes of the state.

Is that not enough for you? Just because you think you live in a time and place where the eyes of the state are kind and benevolent?

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by nemo44x on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:30PM (#29326669)
Why wouldn’t this primitive thing we call the web have massive and frequent revolutions? You can’t discern the value but creators and their consumers will and will again.

Web 2 is distinct from Web (AJAX, SaaS. Cloud, Mobile). I’m sort of shocked it’s even brought up as a fuzzy distinction.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by matheusmoreira on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @07:06AM (#29329162)
> trying to avoid the eyes of the state

Nothing wrong with that. Everyone agrees cryptography is a good thing, worldwide warrantless surveillance is bad, privacy is good. So why is it acceptable for the government to pry into people's finances? Total surveillance is already the norm there. If a blockchain is what it takes to defeat that, then so be it.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by FridgeSeal on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @08:02AM (#29329565)
It’d be a lot cooler (ha) if we didn’t have to burn the energy of a small country for questionable-to-zero actual gains in privacy though.
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by matheusmoreira on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @08:28AM (#29329759)
I partially agree. Bitcoin is a failure and it's pretty sad that so much energy is being spent mining it. I wouldn't mind that same amount of energy being spent on Monero though.

It would also be nice if we could use the heat generated by computers for something instead of dissipating it all into the air. That way the energy wouldn't actually be wasted.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by thefounder on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @03:45AM (#29328077)
Getting rid of the banks and paypal/visa like services should be enough .
Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by cblconfederate on Wednesday November 24, 2021 @01:18AM (#29327368)
> which isn't replicating an existing financial instrument while trying to avoid the eyes of the state.

Similar to how software ate the world while the state wasn't looking?

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by shp0ngle on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @10:24PM (#29326635)
web3 is whatever you want it to be

They call it "web3" when it's not web, as in, world wide web... so it really means nothing.

There is nothing there. It's all just random imagination an ponzi schemes. Good luck getting anything useful out of this.

Re:An engineer's observations on Web3 and its possibilities by pyuser583 on Tuesday November 23, 2021 @11:35PM (#29326955)
Web 2.0 was definitely a thing … the introduction of social media and targeted advertising as a revenue source changed things a lot. Not to mention cloud computing … but that’s really Web 2.5.

Web 3.0 should probably have something to do with the increasing centralization of web services, and the increasingly common subscription fees everyone is paying.

Instead it’s about blockchains … which are pretty much the only way the web is becoming less centralized.