News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by paulcole on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:35PM (#29222994)
I think people who parrot this line try to ignore the total cost of their mortgage being quite different from the purchase price of their home, property taxes, repairs, etc.

As a lifelong renter, I’ve done quite well by keeping my rent low (my preference is studio/1-bedrooms in relatively dense urban areas) and putting extra money into the market.

30 years from when I started renting, I’ll have quite a lot to show for it!

Housing is an expense to me, not an investment.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by willis936 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:02PM (#29223155)
Screw the apartment. You could save so much money living out of a van.

I honestly don't understand this line of thinking. "Why do people even want [tangible good]?"

If an explanation is really needed: it's nice to have a large, private space. People like cars in garages, a room for their work, a room to cook, a room to relax, a room to sleep, a room to store stuff, etc. Why do people bother with any of these things? Why isn't everyone a minimalist? Why do people even bother living?

It's bizarre and alien to me. It also misses the point that people are supposedly free to pursue happiness.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by bumby on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:26PM (#29223316)
I think this argument gets confused because some people refer to it as an investment/asset while others refer to it in emotional terms as a means to pursue happiness. They aren’t always the same thing.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by willis936 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:32PM (#29223358)
For most people it's both. There's a reason home ownership is often a component of "the American Dream".

Owning land and a house is a huge step in status and financial security. Owning a house is also a huge luxury. It's strange to deny either of these realities. Some people don't want luxuries, okay, but it should be clear that nearly everyone does.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by bumby on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:40PM (#29223413)
Recognizing it is one thing, but thinking it’s a good “investment” is another. Often funding/chasing status is a fools errand IMO.

Part of the problem is that homes being the largest asset that a person owns because they’re chasing the status of that American Dream. Can you think of any other illiquid asset that people would suggest piling a majority of your net worth into?

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by willis936 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:43PM (#29223425)
There is no other asset I can own that alleviates the financial burden of burning nearly half of my take-home pay in perpetuity to fund some rich landlord's beach vacations.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by xur17 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:59PM (#29223524)
But it doesn't remove that financial burden entirely (or even close to entirely). You're still paying:

* opportunity cost

* property taxes

* interest

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by jurassic on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:34AM (#29224439)
You're paying many of these things in a rental as well. But at the end of 30 years the landlord keeps the asset.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by bumby on Monday November 15, 2021 @09:27AM (#29227751)
If someone is well-off enough to be in a position to choose, renting is essentially paying a premium for freedom of movement. Used smartly, this can be an avenue to dramatically increase earnings over time because in today’s economy switching jobs is one of the faster ways to increase wages. While previous generations may not have had that problem, I think it changes the own/rent calculus for younger people.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by refurb on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:58AM (#29224920)
I was living in a place in SF that would have cost me 3x to purchase versus my rent. I could take the leftover and invest in other assets. I'm actually ahead of where I would be had I owned since condos have dropped in SF with Covid.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by bumby on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:01PM (#29223533)
If you’re spending that large of a percentage on housing you’re already running against most prudent financial advice and probably shouldn’t be thinking of housing as an investment asset
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by willis936 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:08PM (#29223578)
I live in the real world, not the fantasy one they haves think exist.

I understand where you're coming from though. You wouldn't want social mobility to become the norm.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by bumby on Monday November 15, 2021 @08:15AM (#29226953)
You may want to revisit the HN guidelines.

With that aside, I absolutely do want to foster social mobility. I actually think it’s still possible but probably not in the dream-world way many people think where it comes completely on their own terms. In most cases, it involves avoiding a few basic things like substance abuse, onerous debt, living outside ones means, and having kids before one is financially stable.

But that often flies in the face of what people emotionally want or are told to pursue, so sometimes people want to go into massive debt for depreciating assets or to go to college because that’s what “everyone” does, or to live in an expensive, trendy area because it’s cool or they think that’s where they need to be to chase status. Barring those types of mistakes, social mobility (towards the upper middle class level at least) is generally available. I’m willing to bet many people on HN are already close to that status even if it doesn’t feel like it because they’re comparing themselves to economic outliers rather than the average citizen.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by paulcole on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:59PM (#29231140)
> Owning a house is also a huge luxury. It's strange to deny either of these realities.

I'll happily deny this reality. Owning a home is a huge luxury to some, but it is also a huge burden to some.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by eloisant on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:06AM (#29225697)
It is kinda wrong to see your primary residence as an investment. You can't sell it unless you find a different place to live.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by bumby on Monday November 15, 2021 @09:28AM (#29227769)
I don’t disagree, but that’s the reality of many Americans. Their home is their largest asset by type. This is also why home ownership is one of the largest drivers of wealth.

Maybe it shouldn’t be.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by eloisant on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:34PM (#29233799)
It's an asset but not an investment.

It's factored in your net worth (i.e. your wealth) but it's not something you can leverage like the rest of your wealth.

Note that if you're a homeowner, and the overall market goes up, you don't benefit from it at all. Your wealth goes up on paper, but it doesn't change anything in your life except it will be more expensive if you want to move.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by bumby on Monday November 15, 2021 @08:03PM (#29235262)
I completely understand the distinction, but it’s not entirely different from other assets for the typical American. The two largest wealth assets are their homes and 401k/pensions. Both those groups have a lot of friction before their gains can be realized.

And many people do downsize as they get older, meaning it’s less expensive to move events if their home value increased. Unfortunately, many people (just skim this thread) assume home values always go up so they consider them an investment.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by paulcole on Monday November 15, 2021 @01:44PM (#29230933)
You're doing the same thing though. The whole argument against apartment living is that nobody can imagine that anyone would want to live this way, "Why do people not want [tangible good]?"
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by willis936 on Monday November 15, 2021 @02:00PM (#29231158)
The argument against apartment living is the lack of choice in the matter. More people are living in apartments now than before and it isn't because of preference.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by the__alchemist on Monday November 15, 2021 @09:15PM (#29235888)
This is conflating ownership with single families homes etc. The core issue here is renting vs owning, not flat vs SFH.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by danhak on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:04PM (#29223171)
This is a reasonable take but the government really does everything in its power to put its finger on the scale toward homeownership:

- up to $500,000 in tax-free capital gains for couples

- cheap leverage via low interest rates courtesy of the Fed and further subsidized by renters via mortgage interest deduction

- SALT deduction (albeit reduced as of 2017)

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by hogFeast on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:36PM (#29223386)
You also have government guaranteed mortgages. This is probably the most unusual aspect of the American home market in comparison to other markets...it is essentially publicly owned (the only place that has a similar structure is Denmark, and even then there is no Freddie Mac/Fannie Mac...just a large secondary market for resi mortgages) and makes mortgages very cheap with little rate risk (I am in UK, 30yr fixed mortgages are unheard of, the most you can get is 5yr fixed and it costs 200bps more than a 30yr fixed in the US).

Just a broader comment: the main financial argument against home ownership is really the size of the deposit. If you are paying 25% down (this is now standard where I am in the UK, we went from 120% mortgages to 75% mortgages in the last ten years...and house prices kept rising, so the upfront cost of housing is way way way up) then it may be close for some people. But you add in the security, the potential for capital growth...it is attractive financially (and I wouldn't say this is true in the UK, downpayments are too high, mortgage rates are too expensive and come with massive interest rate risk...it isn't worth it on a pure financial basis).

I can't see myself every buying a house because I just don't like having a lot of stuff, it tends to worry/distract me. But I think it is unfortunate that housing has become associated with this "I got mine" mentality. Germany is a nation of renters, it has led to levels of wealth inequality higher than the US because all that value from rising property prices has gone into the pockets of a few large corporations (the median net financial wealth of a German citizen is EUR20k, about the same as Greece...and they have one of the highest per capita rates of billionaires). Maybe we can tax rising property values more efficiently but the US model (essentially, publicly guaranteed mortgages) works quite well too.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by nly on Monday November 15, 2021 @04:57AM (#29225644)
Habito One do longer fixed rates here in the UK.

For 20% down:

21–25 years: 3.84%

26–30 years: 3.94%

But yes, I agree that at current house prices (8-10x median local income) both the deposit size and the rates at prohibitive

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by vlunkr on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:39PM (#29223012)
Well studio/1-bedroom isn't really an option for families, and rates go up quickly after that point.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Sunday November 14, 2021 @09:40PM (#29223019)
It can be both, but in US real estate historically was seen as a good way to park money. I will venture to say that you are an outlier. I remember renting with my SO. The jumps in rent were getting onerous to the point, when it became cheaper for us to actually buy a place.

But again, each situation varies. Before living with my now wife just like you I lived in a small apartment, because that was all I really needed at the time ( and it was very budget friendly ).

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by throwawayboise on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:03PM (#29223163)
Yes, as long as you start with a modest home that you can actually afford, it can work. The mortgage payment, including taxes and insurance, on my first home (a small 2-br bungalow) was hundreds of dollars less (monthly) than the 1-br shithole apartment I was renting (shithole because I was trying to save for a down payment). At that point, as long as home values do what they normally do, you can upsize every 5 years or so if needed until you are in a home that really fits, rolling the equity gain in the former house into a larger down payment on the newer house.

Mistakes people make: starting with too big a house where they are in trouble immediately if they miss a paycheck. Refinancing and taking equity out to spend on other "things" that depreciate or are consumables like boats, new cars, extravagant vacations, expensive furniture, etc.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by wayoutthere on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:25PM (#29223310)
Yeah this entirely. I had a 600 sq ft shoe box in a high-rise in a major city center for $1800/mo. My mortgage a mile and a half away on a 3000 sq ft house is $2000/mo.

I don’t even use half the rooms in my house and it’s still a way better deal. And no less convenient as I still have everything I really need within a 3-4 block radius. And my mortgage will only get cheaper over time — especially if we get a ton of inflation.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by djanogo on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:42PM (#29223417)
Ya, you saved because you are living single, and _assuming_ you have no kids as you live in 1 BR.

Rest of the population have family's, and have to care where and how their children grow up.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by refurb on Sunday November 14, 2021 @11:59PM (#29223889)
Precisely. People really underestimate the costs of home ownership.

You need to include everything like: 1) mortgage interest, 2) property taxes, 3) insurance, 4) maintenance, 5) opportunity cost of down payment, 6) transaction costs buying and selling.

Clearly if you see major appreciation in the value of your house you'll clearly come out ahead of renting, but I've been in two situations (one while renting, one while owning) where I would have come out ahead renting. In one case the home values went up 20%, but the stock market went up 50% and adjusting for transaction costs, I made more money continuing to rent than buy.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by jjav on Monday November 15, 2021 @04:01PM (#29232687)
> You need to include everything like: 1) mortgage interest, 2) property taxes, 3) insurance, 4) maintenance, 5) opportunity cost of down payment, 6) transaction costs buying and selling.

Factor 1 to 4 are all included (with additional profit margin on top) in rent so you're always paying for those regardless. As an owner at least you don't pay the extra profit margin on it to the landlord.

On #6, if you're moving very frequently then yes, you're better off renting. If you want to settle down, buy.

So realistically that only leaves #5 as a consideration. In the short haul it favors the renter but over a lifetime, not so much.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by refurb on Monday November 15, 2021 @07:06PM (#29234754)
No, #1-4 isn’t factored into rent. Plenty of condos for rent in Toronto that are cash flow negative each month.

Buying and renting are separate markets. Just because housing prices go up doesn’t mean rent does as well.

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by sokoloff on Monday November 15, 2021 @05:19AM (#29225764)
Most homes are bought with 5x or more leverage. In a year where the stock market is up 50% and houses up 20%, recent homeowners probably did better than renters, not worse.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by nly on Monday November 15, 2021 @07:48AM (#29226695)
Of course that leverage works against you if the market tanks.

People just believe that this is impossible in the property market

Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by refurb on Monday November 15, 2021 @06:58AM (#29226375)
You just proved my point. Yes, the return is higher, but subtract all the costs and the stock market is ahead.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by sokoloff on Monday November 15, 2021 @07:33AM (#29226595)
If you buy and sell the house every year, perhaps. Most renters don’t even move every year.
Re:Will real estate ever be normal again? by kelnos on Sunday November 14, 2021 @10:35PM (#29223378)
> Housing is an expense to me, not an investment.

I wish more people (in the US, especially) would think of housing in this way. I think we'd have much more sane housing markets just with that change, even without fixing a lot of the other structural problems we have around housing.