Owning land and a house is a huge step in status and financial security. Owning a house is also a huge luxury. It's strange to deny either of these realities. Some people don't want luxuries, okay, but it should be clear that nearly everyone does.
Part of the problem is that homes being the largest asset that a person owns because they’re chasing the status of that American Dream. Can you think of any other illiquid asset that people would suggest piling a majority of your net worth into?
* opportunity cost
* property taxes
* interest
I understand where you're coming from though. You wouldn't want social mobility to become the norm.
With that aside, I absolutely do want to foster social mobility. I actually think it’s still possible but probably not in the dream-world way many people think where it comes completely on their own terms. In most cases, it involves avoiding a few basic things like substance abuse, onerous debt, living outside ones means, and having kids before one is financially stable.
But that often flies in the face of what people emotionally want or are told to pursue, so sometimes people want to go into massive debt for depreciating assets or to go to college because that’s what “everyone” does, or to live in an expensive, trendy area because it’s cool or they think that’s where they need to be to chase status. Barring those types of mistakes, social mobility (towards the upper middle class level at least) is generally available. I’m willing to bet many people on HN are already close to that status even if it doesn’t feel like it because they’re comparing themselves to economic outliers rather than the average citizen.
I'll happily deny this reality. Owning a home is a huge luxury to some, but it is also a huge burden to some.
Maybe it shouldn’t be.
It's factored in your net worth (i.e. your wealth) but it's not something you can leverage like the rest of your wealth.
Note that if you're a homeowner, and the overall market goes up, you don't benefit from it at all. Your wealth goes up on paper, but it doesn't change anything in your life except it will be more expensive if you want to move.
And many people do downsize as they get older, meaning it’s less expensive to move events if their home value increased. Unfortunately, many people (just skim this thread) assume home values always go up so they consider them an investment.