Must all of the cards in the deck be played at each turn? Things cannot simply be bad/user hostile/privacy invading, etc.
Again, I wouldn't chalk any of this up to deliberate bias against any of these groups, but it's all bias anonetheless.
Racist systems that have encoded societies biases are generally not white supremacist. The 'justification' for those systems is often things like "this is just the way it is" or "this was easier to do like this" or "I went with my own experience".
These days a lot of racism does not come from white supremacy. It either comes from something like familiarity bias of people in power, or from following the status quo mindlessly. Calling those acts white supremacist can be dangerous. It allows the real white supremacists to hide among the unknowing. It also pushes people who unintentionally did something racist way into the defensive if you tell them they are white supremacist. And pushing people who unintentionally did racist things into defending their actions is not going to make things better.
That's a common dictionary or encyclopedia definition of the white supremacy. More broadly, white supremacy also refers to the systems and structures of power that are built into most of "western" (a better term might be post-colonial) societies that favor both white people, and people who support or uphold the balance of power in those post-colonial societies.
> Racist systems that have encoded societies biases are generally not white supremacist
I agree, however I think that those racist systems that are not inherently white supremacist in nature are largely rooted in non-colonial countries (basically countries other than the European colonial powers, and the countries that grew out of those colonies).
> It also pushes people who unintentionally did something racist way into the defensive if you tell them they are white supremacist. And pushing people who unintentionally did racist things into defending their actions is not going to make things better.
That is just not true. If someone does or says something racist, they can and should be challenged on it. If they become defensive, there are multiple reasons that could happen, but if the reason is that they simply didn't know better, it's just the way their society is, or if the reason is that they are opposed to "wokeness" (which is a catch-all for intersectionality, critical race theory, and many other modern perspectives and ideologies that are largely centered on dismantling power structures and reducing bias and discrimination), then it's likely that they are supporting white supremacy out of ignorance (whether that ignorance is from being uninformed or uneducated, or the more malicious willful ignorance of people who choose to use or engage in racist norms because they are opposed to "wokeness" from an ideological or other perspective).
Pushing people who do things that could be cast as unintentionally racist is the only way to a) educate them, so they can do better, or b) determine if it was an intentional act. I know this from practical experience, and it was only from going through the hard and painful experience of being called out on harmful "unintentionally" racist jokes and behaviour that I learned to do better after being raised by a family that had (and for the most part, still has) some pretty racist and discriminatory views.
I still think we should not tell people who do racist things "you are being a white supremacist". Instead we should say "that thing you did was a bit racist" or even "that thing you did could be seen as racist". We should _definitely_ challenge those people. But if you are trying to get someone to change their mind or behavior, you gotta be real careful about their feelings.
Calling someone a white supremacist is going to hurt their feelings quite a bit. And that isn't going to make them more likely to consider if they should change or did something wrong. That doesn't mean don't challenge people on their actions. That means challenge people on their actions very gently.
If we don't treat these people gently, then we lose the less introspective part of the population. They start getting reactionary, start 'banding together' against these annoying people. They start 'fighting back in the culture war'. Basically, getting this wrong is how you create republicans.
All of the above means I think we should be considerate in how we challenge racists. And I think part of that involves being really careful about the term white-supremacy.
what a vague concept lumping together unrelated things
the systems of power in one place are different from another place, they are unrelated, can't be reified like this
Id like to suggest that what you are calling "familiarity bias" might have a component of the quote in it too. Not salary in this case, but social position. That is in the racist system, one race of folks get better treatment, and if they want to maintain better treatment, the status quo must be maintained. The group of people at top of a racial hierarchy (that is in the supreme position), are incentivized to keep the racist system. When race is considered a bad reason to judge a person, they still are incentivized to maintain the system, just find different words to justify the status quo.
I guess a different way of saying this is - white supremacy describes a race based social hierarchy where white people are at the highest level. It has also been used to describe the lowlife Nazi or KKK wannabes that advocate for it in the baldest terms, but they are bigots who advocate for white supremacy using racist terms like "inferior genetics" or worse.
Compare the term racist itself - there are folks who would have you believe that the term is limited to personal bigotry against people of a different race, and has nothing to do with the rules and actions of systems (a position I think you don't hold due to your description of racist systems).
White supremacy, to me, implies explicit, militant, proactive racism. People who might very well be proud of the fact they're racists.
This story is about a software system that (among many other issues) doesn't work well with darker skin tones in low light. Especially in light of all the other failure modes, I'd ascribe that to carelessness or indiference, mixed with pressure to reduce false negatives at the expense of more false positives. I wouldn't be surprised if training data and/or testing were filmed in an office setting with the amount of light you expect there, and they never ran across the issues with dark skin interacting poorly with the amount of lighting a student would have a home.
That is only half of the story of white supremacy though. The other half is the entrenched systems and biases baked into those systems that largely benefit white people, and that train people, through experience, to prioritize preserving the existing systems and status quo.
Not considering the fact that there is a well documented history over the last 20 years of tech companies and business in general prioritizing the experiences of the white majority, at the expense of people of colour, is largely the reason why you can "wouldn't be surprised if training data and/or testing were filmed in an office setting with the amount of light you expect there, and they never ran across the issues with dark skin interacting poorly with the amount of lighting a student would have a home.", and not consider that being the norm, or even acceptable as being indicative of white supremacy.
Those biases may not always, and only impact people of colour, but they do overwhelmingly benefit white people. That's the entire point of the article that OP shared, and the references the author of that post uses to back their claims.
But something I always wonder when accusations like "white supremacy" are thrown around: is it falsifiable? What evidence would dissuade you from that?
- What if both ends of the spectrum do poorly and extremely pale people have problems, too?
- What if the threshold is dark black and lighter-skinned black people, Asians, Middle Easterners and other non-white people are able to use it successfully?
- What if only a narrow band of light levels work, making it clear their testing range was generally too narrow, not just in skin color?
- What if they took care to incorporate black models in testing, but the photo quality (and their own in-house cameras and lighting) overestimated the quality of most home users'?
And what of the myriad other things that were done poorly in the software: limited OS support, bugs, excessive memory usage, overall intrusiveness, browser limitations, disallowed mobile devices, lack of multi-monitor support? Do they likewise arise from systematic oppression of some group? What if we dig in and find that white people are more likely to use iPads, Linux, and multiple displays?
Most often these accusations flow in only one direction, and that all other flaws or problems are taken to be simply happenstance and noise. Certainly anything that impacts white people negatively will not be automatically seen as anti-white, although in a world with activist devs, such a result isn't incomprehensible.
Claims of white supremacy (among other accusations of character) are thus, to my mind, wildly speculative and carry a very heavy burden of proof.
Your way of grouping people by race is kind of arbitrary. It puts together rich and poor when they only share a skin color. How is white supremacy working in Bulgaria, for example?
I would especially consider that in the United States we do not have a broad legal right to privacy but there are potentially much stronger tools available if that software skews negative outcomes towards protected categories like sex, disability, or race. From the perspective of a student, job applicant, etc. being asked to use this, if the legal risks cause an organization to stop using it they'll enjoy that as a win even if the outcome isn't a blanket ban.
Not at the expense of grounded reasoning. When I see poorly substantiated claims, it shouldn't, but it really drags the whole rest of the argument down. The argument presented about lawsuits is actually a great example of why I think that's a broken system. They resolve that issue of lost credibility by considering each issue with total, clear, and mandated separation. Outside of that legal world with very well-defined rules, using such tactics reduces credibility.
I should note, that in this particular case, the claim of racial biases is at least substantiated by a believable anecdote.
EDIT: To clarify why I think the legal methodology is broken, its only because the same principles apply to criminal trials. IMO, prosecutors should NOT be throwing poorly substantiated charges at a defendant just to increase their winning probability and make the required defense more expensive.
It should. If someone is willing to make wild, unsubstantiated, claims, it should detract from their credibility.
If the parent comment had said something to the effect of "I should give the benefit of the doubt to a sitting US senator" then you'd have a point, but that context wasn't part of their statement.
Edit: Also, frankly, I wouldn't give the benefit of the doubt to a US senator. If anything, it makes the identity politics feel even more irrelevant.
I wasn't reacting to a summary, I was reacting to an independent premise. The sentence I reacted to, at least the way I read it, was broad to the point of being more of an axiom with which the commenter interpreted the post. As I see it, disagreeing with an axiom is an intellectual engagement. Feel free to counter my disagreement.
> It’s kind of hard to see any definition of “identity politics” which includes the reports but not your emotional reaction to accurate words.
Not entirely sure what you're saying here, but none of what I said was emotional. Simply pointing out that pattern matching is a viable way of filtering other people's thoughts and ideas. If someone makes wild claim, it should change the way you view other claims which may have seemed more rational in their absence. Not really an emotional statement in my mind, but again, feel free to point out which part of this you disagree with and I'd be happy to engage.
As it stands now you aren't really responding to anything I've said, but rather disagreeing that what I'm responding to warrants responding, which is rather tangential.
Case in point, here's someone saying, 'How can you even handwave away systemic racism?' in reply to a comment agreeing that bias exists but is not deliberate: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29164295
Also, the identity politics argument seems to hinder a simple, moral argument against surveillance software as a violation of privacy. The logical implication of the IP argument is that this surveillance software would be okay to use if we manage to work out all the kinks.
It's not the same with general discourse - when you raise a bunch of issues that aren't especially relevant and seem designed to be inflammatory, you damage the credibility of your other arguments. Arguing that test proctoring software is transphobic is such a stretch that it makes you question whether they author has such strong biases against the software that their evaluation of it is just generally too biased to be trustworthy.
It seems like the software is matching people against existing images, based on the issue with the black student, and trans people are I would assume more likely to change their appearance, including as a result of taking hormones and having facial feminization/masculinization surgeries.
Yes, but with some evidence. Otherwise, as a society, this is a bad direction to head in.
You could read the research and refute it, or you could just bluster about things. I know you tried to expand on it in your comment below, but minimizing the specific concerns raised to "isms" and ignoring that at least two of the references in the articles linked and their references for the actual research addressed at least the socioeconomic portion of it, illustrates that you only applied your surface level perspective and criticism.
That being said, there's a rotating list of "badnesses" that are in the zeitgeist and I agree that it's annoying to see them flogged at every opportunity (often w/o much insight).
The statement is at best extremely misleading, and at worse, mostly false. It also represents a juvenile, immature, and myopic perspective on reality.
I would suggest reading "Wealth, Poverty, and Politics" or "Discrimination and Disparities" by Thomas Sowell. He has been debunking the "inequality of outcome therefore racism" logical fallacy for decades.
It seems like you're reading a specific thing I said about a specific scenario and universalizing it in a way you imagine I might universalize it. I'd love to hear a critique of what I actually said, or we could talk about our views of society in a wider way, but I can't respond to this combination of generally dismissing what I said and attacking what you imagine I might think.
I wanna pull this apart a bit because I think it's a good opportunity to talk about how systemic bias gets started. Digital sensor evolution is path-dependent. Technologists developed photo-sites that have "enough" dynamic range for most uses before moving on to increase the resolution on a sensor. What exactly is "enough" depends on your test data.
The sensor on a webcam is only "so big" as you say - but how that sensor balances resolution and photo-site count depends on what conditions they consider acceptable. We could build web cams that would see more pigmented faces better - there is no fundamental limitation in the technology itself. It's that a series of decisions have been made over years of development, generally without people thinking specifically about race at all, and we've arrived at a status quo that has adverse outcomes for people with different skin tones.
There was a similar process that happened with film photography[1]. Not that film, as a technology, is unable to capture dark skin - but that the development standards that were tested and distributed were designed for lighter skin.
Like, I agree that the webcams we have aren't intentionally 'racist.' But I do think that the status quo that has led everyone to accept this balance of dynamic range and resolution is reflective of valuing people with lighter skin more.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/25/lens/sarah-lewis-racial-b...
https://www.newyorker.com/culture/cultural-comment/a-century...
B) Even if it were simply physics at play, requiring the use of a system known to have physical constraints against darker skin causing failing grades purely on that metric is still pretty racist.
I sense you’re tired of discussions that mention the “cards in the deck”, likely because you aren’t affected by them and therefore care little for them. That’s honestly fair, but there’s value in writing that way to channel outrage into action.
White supremacy: darker skin tones tend to photograph worse than lighter skin tones. Laptop webcams are notoriously crappy and can make this effect worse. Is this white supremacy or physics? Can the test instructions be modified to ask all users to have an appropriate lighting setup (ie lit from above and from the side to ensure that your face is foregrounded properly)
Ableism: for users who require assistive technologies, is it better to take a test in their own space with their own equipment or to travel to a test center and use shared lab equipment? For users with mobility challenges, is it better to be in their own space or travel to a potentially non-accessible testing center?
Sexism: for working mothers, better to take a test in your own home or travel to a testing center and arrange for child care?
Two "isms" seem more relevant but weren’t mentioned: ageism - because fuck boomers, right? Socioeconomics - not everyone has access to a PC that meets the specifications or can acquire one on short notice.
Lots of context is discarded when one engages in polarizing categorical rhetoric. I’m not here shilling for proctoring software but rather for nuanced discourse.
I’m not a photography expert, but it seems to me that cameras are physically equally capable of overexposing an image and underexposing an image. If a particular camera which is used in a facial monitoring system tends to do one rather than the other, I would ask why that is the case.
The choice to use typically terrible cameras in a proctoring system disregarding that it might work ever worse than normally for a subset of people is suspect, yes.
White supremacy is not just bad faith things done by bad people, it is also the assumption that whiteness is the default experience and the failure to account for that not being the case. Similarly with ableism and sexism.
That being said, complaining about the accessibility & inclusiveness of our required surveillance technology does have a dystopian feel to it, lol.
This only works with "new" definitions of racism. It is in fact plainly racist on it's face to demonize a group based on immutable characteristics. It is even worse when actual diversity of though is ignored and people of color are demonized because they don't agree with a race-marxist ideology.
It is in fact plainly racist on it's face to demonize a group based on immutable characteristics.
Yes. Where have I, or the study's author, done this? It is even worse when actual diversity of though is ignored and people of color are demonized because they don't agree with a race-marxist ideology.
Yes. Where have I, or the study's author, done this?I think you just reflexively dismissed this because you saw a basket of words that normally go along with things you disagree with, but the argument is pretty solid.
Really? On the male part? I'd have expected it to do best with women, because I'd have figured facial hair is more difficult to deal with than a wider varieties of hair styles.
In this case, the algorithm is actually bad for all ethnicities [0]. It's just that it's extremely bad for black students (fails half the time) and just regular bad for everyone else (fails a quarter of the time).
[0] https://www.theverge.com/2021/4/8/22374386/proctorio-racial-...
>At the beginning of a test, these products ask students to verify their identity by matching their appearance with a photo ID. As Os Keyes has demonstrated, facial recognition has a terrible history with gender[x]. This means that a software asking students to verify their identity is compromising for students who identify as trans, non-binary, or express their gender in ways counter to cis/heteronormativity. If a student’s gender expression or name on their ID are different from their current gender expression or name, the algorithm may flag them as suspicious. When this happens, they may have to undergo another level of scrutiny to authenticate their identity, an already common and traumatic experience for trans and gender non-conforming students. If these students are not alerted of this possibility before the test begins, it may force them to either discontinue the test and risk their grade, or out themselves to their course owner when they may not want to, risking more trauma and discrimination including being denied financial aid, being forced to leave their institution, or have their lives put in physical danger.
>The Eugenic Gaze is a combination of white supremacy, sexism, ableism, cis/heteronormativity, and xenophobia. When we apply the Eugenic Gaze using technology, the way we do with algorithmic test proctoring, we’re able to codify and reinforce all of those oppressive systems while avoiding equity-based critiques because of our belief in the neutrality of data and technology.
Their recommendations are quite reasonable:
>Don’t use algorithmic test proctoring. Instead, focus on pedagogical techniques that you can use to design assessments, online or in person, that draw from personal experience or require students to apply concepts in unique contexts. If you have to use algorithmic test proctoring, make sure students know about the test settings and ID requirement well before they take a test, and assure them that you will not take any behavior flagged as “suspicious” into consideration that isn’t described explicitly in the syllabus.
The GP link[1] instead calls out "Facial Recognition Tech", and "Algorithmic Proctoring" as being too biased and follows up with a petition[2] to ban these entirely.
[0]: https://hybridpedagogy.org/our-bodies-encoded-algorithmic-te...
[1]: https://library.auraria.edu/news/2021/why-online-test-procto...
[2]: https://www.sheaswauger.com/post/petition-to-ban-facial-reco...
[x]: https://ironholds.org/resources/papers/agr_paper.pdf "The Misgendering Machines: Trans/HCI Implications of Automatic Gender Recognition"
> It’s not clear to me that algorithmic proctoring is a modern surveillance technology that reinforces white supremacy, sexism, ableism, and transphobia. The use of these tools is an invasion of students’ privacy and, often, a civil rights violation."
It does require you to engage with people directly.
"This" clearly means the original accusation in the OP.
The total time spent in creating a few good, easy to discuss questions, the answering of which would demonstrate understanding, and then reading them, thinking about them, and coming up with a grade, was probably actually less than the amount of time it took to create meaningful multiple choice questions that didn't have any ambiguity, and which weren't easy to intuit the answer even without understanding. Doubly so when we did away with "partial credit" answers, but instead made it so each question was 1 point (or otherwise all or nothing), you had, say, 5 of them, and what we really were looking for was a paragraph that showed understanding (rather than checking off boxes in a rubric of "mentioned A, B, and C"; short essay questions, if you will), an expectation we communicated to the students.
And that's aside from the actual project based grades, which were better still.
By the way, where I work, management pushes for stuff like proctoring, and more students, and "measurable" results, and so on. As a teacher, I don't care much about the whole grading show.
Then the students are not getting what they pay for.
Article proceeds to use a lot of words to not show any of these being true.
I am against it for the general dystopian surveillance normalization it encourages. We don’t need to throw a word salad of made up progressive insults against it to resist its implementation.
Still, ProctorU it's a major deterrence to cheating, I'm just not sure it's worth the cost.
I opted out of using spyware in the university physics courses I taught last year, and caught my cheating students the old fashioned way. Proctor-spyware, like airport security, is more about theater than effectiveness. You aren't giving the USMLE or a Bar Exam, so you can take the time to write a good exam and evaluate it correctly.