News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by swman on Saturday November 06, 2021 @04:56AM (#29128561)
Honestly do we really need cryptocurrency? I don’t want my transactions public. I like exchanging cash for weed (legal in California) and nobody needs to know regardless. I also don’t understand what’s wrong with USD. I grew up in a third world country so maybe it could help people there but in USA? I’m happy with the dollar fluctuations vs four digit fluctuations daily.

Can someone give me a good explain?

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by ninepoints on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:02AM (#29128588)
The explanation is simply that there are people that have bought in that want others to buy in also so they can liquidate for a profit. Meanwhile, others are susceptible to what amounts to FOMO-driven investment. The same sentiment that drove the beanie-baby craze, the dot-com boom, the subprime mortgage crisis, the current metaverse craze, and so on. Nothing new under the sun.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:14AM (#29128672)
>there are people that have bought in that want others to buy in also so they can liquidate for a profit.

Is that any different than a ponzi/pyramid scheme?

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by TomSwirly on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:42AM (#29128823)
Consider this.

Crypo cannot create or destroy fiat currency. So if you sell your crypto and make a profit in dollars, it's exactly because someone else bought it at a higher price than you did.

And they expect someone else will buy it from them, in just the same way...

So every dollar that comes out of cryptocurrency is because a later investor put a dollar in.

Doesn't that sound like the definition of a Ponzi scheme?

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by scoopertrooper on Saturday November 06, 2021 @06:15AM (#29128993)
Actually it can create fiat currency... in a roundabout way...

The core of the coin ecosystem are the stable coins, which are generally pegged to fiat, but are only backed by fractional reserves of cash. So the same USD can be recycled many times to buy Bitcoin.

Not only that, but the stable coin operators are under no obligation to exchange their coins back to you for the pegged currency at face value.

Tether is essentially an unregulated bank with nominal deposits totaling 73 billion USD, no obligation to pay depositors, a huge amount of minimally disclosed liabilities, and unaudited financial reserves.

Ponzi was but an amateur.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by oarabbus_ on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:15AM (#29157993)
>Not only that, but the stable coin operators are under no obligation to exchange their coins back to you for the pegged currency at face value.

>but are only backed by fractional reserves of cash.

Maybe tether, but that isn't true of all, or even most stablecoins. Some stablecoins are overcollateralized rather than fractionally lent. As for the obligation, USDC for example is a fully audited system (by firm Grant Horton, who performs weekly audits), backed 1:1 by cash/cash equivalents and redeemable for $1 USD.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by scoopertrooper on Tuesday November 09, 2021 @12:50AM (#29158193)
USDC only has half the market cap of Tether. In fact, Tether has a higher market cap than all the other stable coins combined! So everything I've said is still true even if some operators are not as shady as the market leader.

https://coinmarketcap.com/view/stablecoin/

However, even USDC is still doing fractional reserve banking because an unspecified amount of its reserves are tied up in securities that have maturities up to 90 days, so they are still susceptible to a bank run. Though, granted they seem to be running a much more respectable operation than Tether.

The third biggest stable coin BUSD, looks pretty shady as well. They release monthly audited accounts (good), but they're terse as hell. What liabilities do they have? Have these reserves been used as collateral in loans? Which banks are they in? What steps have the firm taken to audit these funds? No way to know, we're just get a terse list of aggregate numbers.

https://paxos.com/attestations

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:48AM (#29128852)
That means the ones at the bottom, whenever that bottom is gonna be reached, will be left holding the bags for those who got in and got out early.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by GaylordTuring on Saturday November 06, 2021 @08:14AM (#29129555)
This exact reasoning can be applied to the buying and selling of gold, can it not? I’m not saying that therefore it’s moot, but is there a difference? Would you call gold a ponzu scheme as well or do you see a difference between the two? It can also be applied to, for example, the buying and selling of old watches or art.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by kthejoker2 on Saturday November 06, 2021 @11:52AM (#29131237)
The key difference between just pure bubble assets (where extrinsic demand outstrips intrinsic demand) and Ponzi schemes are the representation of the real thing being bought underneath.

In the gold market, you are buying a contract to deliver you physical gold at a point in time.

Similarly with tulips, Beanie babies, fine art, and old watches the underlying asset is what it is.

MLMs and other traditional pyramid schemes also do typically hand you real assets, and so are not inherently Ponzi schemes.

But when that extrinsic demand is driven by fraudulent claims (like Madoff's "beat the market every year" returns), then it can be considered a Ponzi scheme, because they don't even get the tulips or Picassos or whatever, they get nothing.

The gray area, especially with MLMs, is what kind of support and service benefits you get - these are often fraudulent or misleading (Ponzi scheme) but they don't inherently have to be.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by DonHopkins on Saturday November 06, 2021 @02:50PM (#29132790)
Most ponzi/pyramid schemes don't burn as much coal and cause as much cancer and lung disease.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by 3r8Oltr0ziouVDM on Saturday November 06, 2021 @06:08AM (#29128956)
You don't need to invest if you just want to use it.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by DonHopkins on Saturday November 06, 2021 @02:53PM (#29132818)
But you still need to burn coal and cause cancer and lung disease to use it.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by lordlimecat on Saturday November 06, 2021 @09:30AM (#29130034)
The utility of crypto comes from two factors: its decentralization, and its pseudonymity.

The decentralization is only useful in a world where the central authority (e.g. banking system, governments) are not trustworthy, and this excludes legal activities where a legal remedy is enormously valuable. I've heard that international transactions are a use case, but realistically if a country reneged on a financial transaction the remedy is and always would be soft- or hard-power based (diplomacy, sanctions, military).

The pseudonymity is only useful to the extent that you don't want the government to track you. But our societies have generally decided that the government should have oversight into how we spend our money to stop criminal activity. Agree or not, this is the consensus: so it makes no sense to argue that the government should then tolerate a system that undermines its rules.

If we wanted to allow anonymous transactions, we could do so much more efficiently by simply removing KYC regulations on the banks. We aren't going to do that, and in fact KYC is broadly being implemented at crypto exchanges so for the overwhelming majority of crypto users there is no real benefit: you're already centralized and everyone already knows what you're doing.

Even for the speculative investors there is limited utility: they could simply invest in derivative securities on traditional markets without incurring the incredible cost of performing crypto transactions.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by roenxi on Saturday November 06, 2021 @08:05AM (#29129503)
> Honestly do we really need cryptocurrency?

This is a fundamentally unfair question. People waste lots of resources on things I don't think we need. There is a powerful principle in modern economies that if people have money then they don't need to justify what they think is a good idea to you, me, the government or anyone else unless there are compelling reasons to.

"Do you need this?" isn't a question that is asked anywhere except when there is measurable harm. Mining bitcoins doesn't cause measurable harm. If it does, then that is an argument that we shut down the electricity grid - a different debate.

We may as well ban half the technology we have. People don't need any of it.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by Retric on Saturday November 06, 2021 @08:43AM (#29129749)
We also ban quite a few things like CFC’s. Cryptocurrency might not be inherently significantly harmful to the environment but proof of work coins are, so it just comes down to a question of benefit vs harm.

That doesn’t mean we need to ban Bitcoin as a country mandating all computation bound proof of work coins on date X would allow for a transition. However existing miners already have significant investments and are going to keep trying to profit from them which makes such transitions problematic.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by alkonaut on Saturday November 06, 2021 @11:08AM (#29130831)
But we do have good reasons to ban it. It does cause measurable harm.

It’s exactly the same argument that led to the ban of CFCs, incandescent light bulbs, direct electric space heating, and cars without catalytic converters the list goes on and on.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by louloulou on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:17AM (#29128693)
Who's "we"? Maybe you don't need it. Personally, I don't need golf courses, professional football or a new phone every year.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by alkonaut on Saturday November 06, 2021 @11:00AM (#29130760)
Those do have negative externalities too. They are extremely regulated in how those externalities are handled though (how many golf courses are built, where, what their environmental impact is and so on).

I don’t see a problem allowing e.g one Bitcoin to be mined but that doesn’t mean it should be any easier to set up a mining shop than to establish a new golf course.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by louloulou on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:09PM (#29133821)
Sure, all businesses are regulated within the jurisdictions in which they operate. But if I want to set up a mining machine in my house, I don't see how a government can say that running my heater is fine but running the miner is not.. are they monitoring my electricity usage down to the device level? How?
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by alkonaut on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:36PM (#29134020)
Can you grow a ficus but not cannabis? Are they monitoring your gardening to the plant level?

The answer I suppose is that a) what’s legal isn’t necessarily what can be enforced and b) just like no one would find your single cannabis plant, this is probably about industrial level mining where authorities have insight through permits for construction, permits for yearly emissions, use of cooling water and so on.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by louloulou on Saturday November 06, 2021 @06:11PM (#29134286)
Well if it only applies practically to industrial level mining, I guess that's a good thing. Since it would decentralise mining and makes it more profitable for individuals who can freely ignore the law à la file sharing, cannabis, etc. Hopefully it will make the network more robust.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by ur-whale on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:01AM (#29128584)
> I don’t want my transactions public.

First, not all cryptos share Bitcoin's open ledger characteristics.

Look up Monero, ZCash, Grin, Beam : they all implement untraceable transactions, not just pseudo-anonymous ones like Bitcoin.

Second, pseudonymous transactions is far from being the only interesting property of Bitcoin. Among others, no centralized control is a key aspect.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by ninepoints on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:03AM (#29128596)
Complete transaction anonymity is not a feature. There are no protections against wash trading, and you have no way to gauge true market demand or pricing from transaction volume data alone.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by TomSwirly on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:50AM (#29128859)
> they all implement untraceable transactions

As a non-criminal, what use would I have for untraceable transactions?

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by lawn on Saturday November 06, 2021 @07:20AM (#29129263)
Imagine if you have a business and someone uses their tainted coins (from a hack or extortion or whatever) and buys something from you. You then deposit this on an exchange... And get your account locked.

Or worse, imagine using your Bitcoin wallet in a store, and the business owner sees that you have $100k in the wallet you just paid with (because it's public knowledge). He then calls his friends who will follow you and try to kidnap and torture you to hand them over.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by ur-whale on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:53AM (#29128881)
> As a non-criminal, what use would I have for untraceable transactions?

As a non-criminal, what you would you have a need for privacy?

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by swalsh on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:18AM (#29128705)
Not all crypto is money. ETH for example (which will soon be proof of stake... and more energy efficient) could be considered more accurately as a really large (but relatively slow) computer that never turns off. This plus infrastructure like ipfs enables a brand new internet. Completely decentralized and free of the strangle hold of large tech companies.

To me, money and profit is less important than freedom. Web 3.0 to me is a chance to build a better future.

(For the record, I have no investments in btc, eth, or any proof of work chains. I am invested in AVAX, which has a more energy efficient consensus protocol)

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by DonHopkins on Saturday November 06, 2021 @06:15AM (#29128994)
Don't you realize that HBO made a whole TV show series that made fun of people who say stuff like that?

Erlich Bachman Vs Psilocybin. (Making The World a Better Place.):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4tLvzyb3_Uc

Silicon Valley: Making the World a Better Place | SXSW Convergence 2016:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eE9Dvd_NEBg

OH GOD this is hilarious! Zach Woods is so perfectly in character that I'm afraid he may actually be as deeply disturbed as the character he plays on the show. His impression of the Little Lord Fauntleroy of the Grindr empire was perfect! The setup starts at 3:40.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zach_Woods

I won't transcribe his NFSW joke, but later there's some excellent clean discussion too (starting at 13:18):

Steven Leckart (Moderator, Writer and Filmmaker)> You guys need to understand, these guys get pitched all the time by Silicon Valley. Like, we were in the back room, and there were guys from a -- can I say who it is? Should I say who it is?

(Off Camera)> Naaaaaw!

Leckart> But like this tech company that we've all read about in the news is coming up and like handing business cards, and cornering them, and telling them all about their, like, business strategies. And there is no hint -- it's like a deer in the headlights, right, like? Like you are just going to take this conversation and find a way to weave it into the show. And I sort of wondered, like, does Silicon Valley, are they just completely out to lunch about what you're doing? Like, why does anyone talk to you about this stuff?

Martin Star (Bertram Glfoyle)> They want to be a part of the show.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by onedognight on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:24AM (#29128742)
> ETH for example (which will soon be proof of stake... and more energy efficient) could be considered more accurately as a really large (but relatively slow) computer that never turns off.

Run by babies who will manually change the output of the computer when it calculates something they don’t like.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by 3r8Oltr0ziouVDM on Saturday November 06, 2021 @06:03AM (#29128927)
Not possible unless majority of the nodes accepts the change.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by TomSwirly on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:45AM (#29128836)
It's funny and sad that when people talk about their "freedom" in 2021, it's almost always some sort of madness: freedom not to get vaccinated; freedom not to wear a mask; freedom to use cryptocurrencies.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by oytis on Saturday November 06, 2021 @06:12AM (#29128979)
Isn't freedom always a freedom to do something the majority won't like and/or find absurd. Most of it is really absurd, but some things pave way for the future, and it justifies tolerating the rest of it.

I personally don't believe in cryptocurrency and blockchain in general, but also I must say if I believed in it 10 years ago I would be financially much better off :)

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by swalsh on Saturday November 06, 2021 @08:01AM (#29129478)
I'm vaccinated, I wear an N95 mask when I go out. I try to be reasonable. But this comment is exactly why I think crypto is important. There are too many people now questioning the basic tenets of our liberal democracy. When I watched the president of the United States get thrown out of of the most popular forums to discuss politics at the same time, and then destroy the only place people with a different opinion could go to talk, it became clear to me that these companies have too much power.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by azth on Saturday November 06, 2021 @08:38AM (#29129708)
In addition to what was mentioned, the hope is that once cryptocurrencies stabilize (especially the bigger ones like bitcoin, eth), they will be a hedge against government induced inflation.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by lawn on Saturday November 06, 2021 @08:10AM (#29129529)
Using cash is fine, but what if you need to use digital payments? Then you need to rely on third parties (VISA, PayPal, Stripe etc) who will of course charge fees from your business, or completely block you.

For instance, there are tons of stories of PayPal randomly pulling the rug under legitimate businesses, and destroying them in the process.

Or how the US government blocked payments to WikiLeaks when they presented proof of war crimes US committed.

Crypto is like digital cash in this sense, as nobody can prevent you from paying with it.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by f6v on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:01AM (#29128581)
When you have a hammer everything looks like a nail.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by riffraff on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:00AM (#29128575)
I'm not fond of cryptocurrency, but there are both traceable and untraceable ones. You could buy weed with untraceable crypto.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by ikt on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:04AM (#29128612)
you don't use crypto do you? playing with money is honestly just a fun thing to do, putting it into coins you think will do well or staking it to earn more or lending it via defi, or putting it into a yearn vault etc

the other thing is that (for the 9 billionth time) people are clueless and associating all of crypto with bitcoin.

There are tons of chains that aren't proof of work and there's also nothing suggesting proof of work can't run on renewable energy either, something like 60% of chinese mining was.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by efrecon on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:14AM (#29128668)
But the problem isn't that it can use renewable, but rather "steels" renewable that could be used for other purposes
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by TomSwirly on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:52AM (#29128870)
> there's also nothing suggesting proof of work can't run on renewable energy

You act like we have infinite energy of all types. But we don't - it's close to a zero-sum game.

80% of US energy comes from fossil fuels. If your blockchain uses a huge amount of renewable energy, then some other application is forced to use fossil fuels.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by themihai on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:03AM (#29128597)
Crypto doesn't try to replace cash. It tries to replace digital payments (i.e. bank transfer, paypal, credit card etc) and I'm totally fine with that. Some people like paypal, visa and mastercard, some people don't.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by swarnie on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:07AM (#29128632)
Do digital payments need replacing?

I haven't seen physical cash in almost two years (one exception, a contractor wanted to dodge some tax) and the system just works effortlessly.

Tapping a card is easier and faster then counting change.

I don't see how paying a $20 gas fee and waiting 15 minutes would improve the situation.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by VMG on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:39AM (#29128800)
This is because you don't live in a sanctioned country and you have a good social credit score.

This is like saying "why do I need encryption, I don't have anything to hide".

Many people do not have this privilege.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by swarnie on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:59AM (#29128913)
Sorry, i thought the fact we were discussing a move by Sweden, in English on a website dominated by Americans kind of gave the game away.

We should reopen the thread with a different premise.

"Crypto currencies have no place or value in the western world"

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by ur-whale on Saturday November 06, 2021 @06:18AM (#29129004)
> "Crypto currencies have no place or value in the western world"

If the current demand for it, as measured by the market price is any kind of indicator, you have your work cut out for you trying to convince people.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by VMG on Saturday November 06, 2021 @06:19AM (#29129013)
It hat the same place as encryption for the same reason. And it is being fought like encryption was, for the same reasons.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by DonHopkins on Saturday November 06, 2021 @03:00PM (#29132873)
Wrong.

Nobody ever fought encryption because of its environmental impact and contribution to global warming and wasted energy, or because it burns lots of coal and causes cancer and lung disease.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by VMG on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:04PM (#29133787)
Correct, they picked other excuses.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by DonHopkins on Saturday November 06, 2021 @06:38PM (#29134485)
You're picking other excuses for shilling cryptocurrency to detract from the hard cold sociopathic fact that you don't give a flying fuck about the environment or public health.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by Fragoel2 on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:13AM (#29128660)
First, physical cash is still the norm in most of the world.

Second, higher competition in the payments ecosystem would force providers to reduce their fees. The glaring example is what is happening in San Salvador, where by using Bitcoin they are likekly to save 450 USD millions/year in fees.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by morelisp on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:25AM (#29128744)
> by using Bitcoin they are likekly to save 450 USD millions/year in fees.

More like shift 450mm/year into the pockets of the people running Chivo while creating a media circus to distract from the president's takeover of the judiciary.

Freedom!

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by VMG on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:36AM (#29128784)
This is incorrect. The transaction costs are very low and you are free to choose whatever wallet you want.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by morelisp on Saturday November 06, 2021 @07:13AM (#29129228)
> The transaction costs are very low

That's why the government even preemptively allocated $150mm for them, I guess?

> you are free to choose whatever wallet you want.

Unless you want assistance at one of the official facilities, or the promised stimulus. Half the population is supposedly on Chivo. Defaults matter, especially if your goal is graft and not a sustainable and beneficial economic policy.

I also notice you only tried to contradict the parts critical to dear bitcoin, not about growing autocracy.

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by VMG on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:05PM (#29133797)
why should I defend an autocrat?
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by DonHopkins on Saturday November 06, 2021 @06:42PM (#29134513)
Better question: Why should you shill a get-rich-quick pyramid scheme that destroys the environment, causes climate change, wastes energy, burns coal, and causes cancer and lung disease?
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by morelisp on Saturday November 06, 2021 @08:09PM (#29135100)
... and despite all its rhetoric about freedom, seems to be associated primarily with oligarchs, autocrats, and the biggest winners of traditional capitalism.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by gefhfff on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:06AM (#29128623)
No, it isn't a payment system.

Check out GNU Taler (and alternatives), which really are payment systems instead of currency alternatives

Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by lvs on Saturday November 06, 2021 @05:12AM (#29128659)
It's more of a haven asset. It doesn't make sense as a payment system, and it hasn't in a decade really succeded in that role. It has accumulated a lot of capital, however, that might otherwise have gone into other haven assets.
Re:Swedish government agencies say energy-intensive crypto m... by 3r8Oltr0ziouVDM on Saturday November 06, 2021 @06:02AM (#29128919)
It's great for doing cross-border transfers without restrictions as an example. For privacy there are Monero and mixers. The solution for volatility is stablecoins. DeFi can be useful for traders, you can trade without trusting any platform to hold your assets. The most important thing: it's an open source alternative to the traditional financial system, anyone can use it for anything without asking anyone else, and it evolves very fast because there is a lot of competition and no restrictions.