News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by patio11 on Saturday August 20, 2011 @07:14PM (#2908004)
I live in central Japan's manufacturing hub. If you ever come visit me, and really want to return depressed, I'll arrange for us to take a tour of the company which produces most of the world's cell phone camera gaskets. (A little ring of rubber around the cell phone lens.) You very well might have one in the Japanese cellphone which came in the Chinese paper box and got stamped "Made in China" that you have in your pocket.

Every day, a couple hundred workers report to the factory. The most labor-intensive step in the process is taking a sheet of approximately 1,000 gaskets, manually removing them with a tweezer, inspecting them under a jeweler's loupe, and depositing the passes into the waiting outgoing package. When you fill it, it gets wheeled away for shipping. Your quota is 1,000 passed gaskets per hour, for which you are paid approximately 1,000 yen (at least, that was the pre-crash wage), or about $13 at today's prices.

When you say "We want our manufacturing jobs back", this is the kind of job you really want. It is easily the worst legal job I've heard of in a first-world nation. There's also practically a clock on the wall saying Time Until Robotic Arms Are Sensitive Enough To Do This Without Damaging An Unacceptable Portion Of Gaskets.

One reason that (pre-crash, anyhow) this neighborhood had a lot of immigrants is that the typical worker at this sort of factory 30~50 years ago was a Japanese woman in her twenties and that these days the job is a job Japanese women mostly won't do.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by Klinky on Saturday August 20, 2011 @07:58PM (#2908095)
"When you say "We want our manufacturing jobs back", this is the kind of job you really want. It is easily the worst legal job I've heard of in a first-world nation."

How about cleaning up after old people when they mess themselves? How about any of the DVD sorting facilities at Netflix, which is practically the exact job you described? How about the massive amount of call centers we have in the US? How about almost any low level job in agriculture? I don't think your imagination is deep enough to fathom how bad a job can really be, even in a first world nation.

There are plenty of people who are willing to work or already work a monotonous or difficult job for low pay here in the US.

More investment should go into automation, but given that the world labor market makes humans so cheap(mainly due to not having the care about the workers health or safety), human labor usually wins out.

Once all these jobs go to automation, what do you do with the workers? That is then societies problem really, we'll need to figure out if there should be a social net that guides people into higher education so we have people building/repairing robots instead of doing what the robots are actually doing. Given the vested interests in the status quo, this is probably not too likely to happen in the near future.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by sp4rki on Sunday August 21, 2011 @12:12AM (#2908492)
All the jobs you mention make substantially more money and I can assure you have better work conditions than a gasket manufacturing plant located in Japan's manufacturing hub. I'd rather be earning a living by means of a nursing job that pays at least 5 times (more like 10 times in the US) what a Japanese gasket plucker makes. And I get the bonus that I can feel great because even though I have to clean shit, I make someone's life more bearable and get to take care of human beings that appreciate that I'm contributing to humanity instead of rotting away any chance of developing my intellect by spending 12 hours plucking gaskets.

Also, the solution to the automation problem is not higher education, the solution is the return of the skilled laborer. You can't automate a robot to drive to a customer's house, cut open some drywall, fix a plumbing leak, restructure some electric piping to a new section of the wall, install a socket, make a report and get it signed by the customer, get payed, drive back to the company hub, and finally give you the money. Hell you can't automate a robot to make custom dragon blood forged steel swords, which we'll probably need for the zombie apocalypse. Bachelor and masters degrees are currently too easy to get to the point even a monkey could get a bachelors these days, specially if it's a wealthy monkey. The result is that GOOD plumbers, electricians, or dragon blood forged steel sword making blacksmiths are so hard to get this days because all the offspring of skilled laborers want to go to a fancy school to be doctors, lawyers, or architects, because it's all the rage to get a university degree this days.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by stevenbedrick on Sunday August 21, 2011 @01:39AM (#2908599)
> I'd rather be earning a living by means of a nursing job that pays at least 5 times (more like 10 times in the US) what a Japanese gasket plucker makes.

For what it's worth, most people actually doing the "cleaning up after the elderly" job are certified nursing assistants, who often earn basically a notch or two above minimum wage.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by 0x0x0x on Sunday August 21, 2011 @04:08PM (#2910143)
And coming from a medical family, I don't think most CNAs are thinking of the greater good when they're wiping those asses.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by pessimizer on Sunday August 21, 2011 @05:33AM (#2908838)
Agricultural workers do not get paid substantially more than $13.00/hr gasket inspectors, they get paid substantially less and they work in the sun. A nursing job is a very high skilled job that is very well paid that you go to college for. Shit cleaners are not nurses, they are people who also make less than gasket inspectors. Don't assure people of things you're not sure about.

The pay might be shit, but we'll make it up in overtime:)

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by DanBealeC on Sunday August 21, 2011 @06:52AM (#2908942)
In the UK: agricultural workers either get minimum wage or are exploited migrant workers getting illegally low wages and illegal working conditions. People who look after the elderly are "care assistants" not nurses they are unskilled workers at minimum wage. The amount of abuse in the care industry (as well as the high churn rate) suggests that a substantial number of those workers do not get much satisfaction from 'contributing to humanity'.

1000 yen per hour is about £7.90; the UK minimum wage is £5.93 ((if you're over 21) but there are some tax breaks and benefits available to some low paid workers). There are plenty of jobs at that minimum wage, and many of those jobs will be as dull as checking gaskets.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by latch on Saturday August 20, 2011 @08:39PM (#2908166)
I don't think you are 100% wrong, but I can't let this one slide:

How about cleaning up after old people when they mess themselves?

You know, some people actually appreciate what their parents have done and take pride (or at least sympathy) paying back that debt when the time comes.

I'm not sure that you grasp the working conditions in some parts of Asia (i live in Hong Kong). People would be willing to take the job, but they'd ask for benefits that wouldn't even compare. I don't think there are, as you say, plenty of people willing to take on these types of jobs in their present state. In fact, there are already sectors in the US that are having a hard time finding people because people have generally become too prideful. Just look at the skilled trade problem, which is way better work than what patio11 is talking about.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by joe_the_user on Saturday August 20, 2011 @10:10PM (#2908312)
In fact, there are already sectors in the US that are having a hard time finding people because people have generally become too prideful. Just look at the skilled trade problem, which is way better work than what patio11 is talking about.

Any company in the US that pays significantly more than minimum wage and which claims "we can't find workers" is basically lying.

When they say "we can't find workers to do X" what they meaning is "we can't worker to do X [low-voice-over]between the ages of 23 and 27 who graduated in the top 15% of their class, with six+ year of experience in X and who have strong willingness to work 100 hours/week and able to start yesterday[/low-voice-over]"

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by crag on Sunday August 21, 2011 @01:56AM (#2908617)
That is utter nonsense. Maybe in the Bay Area that's true, but not in Florida.

We've been looking for technical employees (cable'ers, phone techs, etc, etc) for a while (in Florida) and usually come up with crap. We start at $20hr, with full benefits, and a strict 40 hour work week (we like to avoid overtime). That is a very high starting salary in Florida. And we've hired and fired 6 different people for the same position over the last 2 years.

And I can't even tell you how hard it is to find a decent programmer here. Sure there are tons of guys who (barely) write Java or VB. None are remotely qualified to write code for my sister let alone the company. Either I end up writing it or I outsource to NYC. And when you do find someone good, there's a bidding war. I lost a programmer I wanted to hire to one of my customers (a hospital). They offered us a fee if we'd send him over. I sent him him over. They're a good customer so we turned down the fee. :)

These are common complaints down here in Florida; the 4th biggest state in the country by the way. It's not helping that our school system down here is a fucking mess. And that many parents are more concerned about their kids learning evolution than math.

There is one ray of hope for us: the military. I just hired our 3rd vet (I'm a vet by the way too) from a job fair held at the Palm Beach VA.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by pessimizer on Sunday August 21, 2011 @05:42AM (#2908849)
If you're paying $20 an hour and you can't find a decent Java programmer, I'm not sure if it's a failure of the market. I wouldn't program for $20 an hour no matter where I lived, unless life sucked or I wasn't very good. And if pushed by desperation to take that job, I would be constantly trying to find another one.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by idiopathic on Sunday August 21, 2011 @10:17AM (#2909228)
The $20 he mentioned is for cablers and phone techs, not for programmers, if I understood correctly.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by pessimizer on Sunday August 21, 2011 @10:30AM (#2909250)
@idiopathic: You're right, I read it badly. Sorry, crag.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by rmc on Sunday August 21, 2011 @07:08AM (#2908971)
If you are having trouble finding staff than you are by definition not paying market rates. If $20/hr gets you crap, then you need to raise your rates. This is capitalism, people don't owe you their labour for what you consider good money.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by T-hawk on Sunday August 21, 2011 @10:45AM (#2909275)
Indeed. There was a post a month or two ago on HN that captured this fallacy beautifully and I wish I could find it again and/or credit its author:

Q: "We pay salaries competitive with the market average, why can't we find good experienced programmers or engineers?"

A: "So you want top talent for average wages? See the discrepancy here?"

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by rbanffy on Sunday August 21, 2011 @11:58AM (#2909433)
Sometimes you can't find what you need, no matter how much you want to pay. I have enormous difficulty to find good programmers here in São Paulo. Even bad programmers are hard to hire.

I can hire PHP and Java programmers rather easily, but both groups would have a lot to unlearn.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by rmc on Monday August 22, 2011 @03:56AM (#2911753)
You can always hire people for anywhere, it all depends on your requirements and your compensation. If you can't find them, then you need to change either requirements or compensation.

Have you considered trying to hire from abroad? You may need a high salary by USA standards to hire USA workers to work in São Paulo, but tis doable. You have now found the market rate for programmers in São Paulo

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by rbanffy on Monday August 22, 2011 @06:55AM (#2912052)
You are right, of course. I guess I'll have to help people unlearn.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by joe_the_user on Sunday August 21, 2011 @02:15AM (#2908638)
Wow,

I was writing from the Bay Area. I suppose I should realize how different the rest of the country is.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by CamperBob on Sunday August 21, 2011 @04:05AM (#2908757)
And that many parents are more concerned about their kids learning evolution than math.

Can you elaborate on that?

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by felipemnoa on Sunday August 21, 2011 @06:41AM (#2908934)
First time I read it I got that many parents do not like it that their kids are learning evolution (they probably want them to learn creationism instead) when instead they should be worrying that their kids are not learning enough math. I re-read it again and I still think that's what he meant.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by crag on Monday August 22, 2011 @10:14AM (#2912501)
That's right.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by NoPiece on Sunday August 21, 2011 @12:40AM (#2908536)
How about nursing? The starting pay averages three to four times minimum wage, but there is still a shortage. It is easy to underestimate the mismatch between the skills required today, and the typical skills of the unemployed. However, your example does ring true to me in the engineering world.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by pessimizer on Sunday August 21, 2011 @05:51AM (#2908868)
Nursing is a highly skilled job that requires college education, like programming, except that it requires college education.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by NoPiece on Sunday August 21, 2011 @01:17PM (#2909629)
The entry level positions I am talking (Licensed Practical Nurse) about don't require a college degree, just a 6 month certification. There are also tiers of nursing available via an AA program. Regardless, they are decent paying jobs, and they are hard to fill.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by pessimizer on Monday August 22, 2011 @08:10AM (#2912186)
There isn't a shortage of LPNs. In a lot of places there are an excess of LPNs.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by Tichy on Sunday August 21, 2011 @06:31AM (#2908922)
That doesn't make sense. Either they need workers, or they don't. If they need them, why should they refuse to take them on if they don't fulfill some outlandish specification? Unless the job REALLY is that complicated.

But otherwise if a worker makes the more money, why not go for it?

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by Klinky on Saturday August 20, 2011 @09:40PM (#2908266)
"You know, some people actually appreciate what their parents have done and take pride (or at least sympathy) paying back that debt when the time comes."

I was speaking more about people who work in assisted living facilities or nursing homes who do not know the people they clean up after personally. Often these people are probably lucky to be making $13/hr an a hour. Just like there are those who don't mind such a job, I am sure there are those who don't mind sorting gaskets either.

"I'm not sure that you grasp the working conditions in some parts of Asia (i live in Hong Kong)."

Are you suggesting they're good or bad? There are some decent places to work in Asia if you're on top. Job conditions are slowly improving, but often you'll still hear about workers living in boarding houses provided by the company so they can work 12 - 16 hours days 6 days a week. Additionally patio11 was talking about first world countries...

"I don't think there are, as you say, plenty of people willing to take on these types of jobs in their present state. In fact, there are already sectors in the US that are having a hard time finding people because people have generally become too prideful."

You probably aren't looking too hard then. In the current economy you have people with masters & PhDs applying at McDonalds or other low wage/low skill jobs. Often these employers do not hire these people because of "over-qualifications". I also don't think that a lack of skilled tradesmen is due to pride, but perhaps due to a refocusing towards service sector jobs & the deterioration of our education system. The US does not have a standardized vocational education path & often many "vocational colleges" here are scammy for profit colleges that offer little benefit & a lot of debt to their students.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by pessimizer on Sunday August 21, 2011 @05:23AM (#2908829)
I'm totally flying past you here. That's not a bad job, that's a good job. I worked a Xerox Cheshire (for addressing junk mail) for $10.50/hr around the turn of the millenium for between 40 and 76 hours a week. It financed a really comfortable lifestyle at the time (I didn't have kids.) My quota was around 10,000 per hour IIRC, and my hands got a bit chewed up, but I almost always hit quota (if the machine was on my side.)

My hands are keyboard-smooth these days, but I'm always suprised when people are suprised that people make things with their hands, when they spend all day surrounded with things made with someone's hands.

About automation: That robot clock has been running since Henry Ford. Most manufacturing jobs (if not all) are a human loading a machine with material, monitoring the machine so it doesn't jam, tear itself apart on, or shred the material, then pulling the finished product which is being ejected as quickly as a humn can keep up, wrapping it, and getting it to the next machine. Every hour the machine breaks down, and the operator figures out how to bring it back up quickly, or a mechanic has to come and do a medium to full scale repair depending on the damage.

I'm not sure how magic robot arms can change that, until they can figure out how to load themselves with rubber from the truck, and how to fix themselves really quickly.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by shabble on Sunday August 21, 2011 @08:57AM (#2909100)
Back when my insomnia was really bad, I'd be up most of the night watching generally dull television. One of the most interesting shows was "How It's Made", which is an entirely narrated view following a camera through various production facilities for common(ish) products.

http://science.discovery.com/tv/how-its-made/ and https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/How_It%27s_Ma...

Most of the production is heavily automated, but there are always a few humans in the loop somewhere. In a lot of cases, it is exclusively loading the machine with some odd-shaped component, again and again as fast as they can.

Sometimes there's a bit of excitement (poorly designed safety guards or practices), just waiting to trip someone up after they zone out midway through their 12-hour shift.

I don't know what the failure figures would be like, but it's quite possible you do need that engineer on call, with his lateral-thinking brain and dexterous monkey-fingers, but otherwise, robots can do the lot, it's just a question of cost.

See https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Lights_out_%2... for examples.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by pessimizer on Sunday August 21, 2011 @10:13AM (#2909216)
That's exactly what I did - loaded the machine with some odd shaped component, again and again, as fast as I could. And somebody looked at what came out for quality control, then that was packed onto a pallet, and forklifted to somebody who loaded that stuff into another machine, or to a truck. Otherwise, robots (or dumb machines) have always done the lot.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by chopsueyar on Sunday August 21, 2011 @10:13AM (#2909219)
Mattresses and incandescent light bulbs seemed to require a bit of human intervention for manufacturing, according to How It's Made.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by shabble on Sunday August 21, 2011 @01:00PM (#2909586)
Mattresses especially fall into the 'dangerous' category from what I recall; the sewing machines would be extremely easy to run a hand or finger into if you make a mistake.

Lightbulbs are probably similar to Pato11's original story; robots which can handle the glass and construct the filament supports require extremely delicate and precise control, so it's cheaper to use people. For now.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by pessimizer on Sunday August 21, 2011 @08:14AM (#2909048)
Related to nothing, I worked one of these bastards too: http://www.mailmarketplace.com/inserters/5250_001IN.htm. It shoves mail into envelopes so I can swamp you with useless credit card offers, retirement fund statements, and solicitations from nonprofits. Notorious hand mangler. At the time, this was the best job I had ever had.

P.S. Looking for a picture of the Cheshire brought back memories: http://i.ebayimg.com/00/$%28KGrHqF,!g0E1fPtSCr7BNeqtoSh0w~~_...

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by stonemetal on Saturday August 20, 2011 @07:48PM (#2908076)
It is easily the worst legal job I've heard of in a first-world nation. That doesn't sound so bad. You should see the hell that is a tire factory in the US. Minimal automation, lots of poor work environment.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by rhygar on Saturday August 20, 2011 @07:48PM (#2908078)
There are a ton of people in the US that would love to be making $13 an hour like that - if the job also came with free health insurance.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by sp4rki on Sunday August 21, 2011 @12:16AM (#2908498)
I'm pretty sure the patio11 did not mean that they where paid 13 dollars an hour to pluck and approve one thousand gaskets. He probably meant 13 bucks a day. A half inch gasket costs around 8 to 10 cents a piece (retail), around 5 or 6 cents in bulk by the hundred thousand or millions, which are the quantities phone manufacturers buy. At 5 cents a piece you would be making 50 bucks for each 1,000 gaskets, which you need to manufacture, box/package, and ship. You also need to pay utilities, management, equipment, marketing, and probably a whole bunch of other jobs not directly linked to actually plucking and approving gaskets. If you're paying more than one fifth of your earnings before taxes in people that pluck and approve your gaskets you're probably making no money, and most likely are loosing a crapton of dough on each shipment. Not only that, but if you're earning 13 bucks an hour, that's 2080/2496 bucks a month if you go by 8 hour days and 5 or 6 day workweeks. That's 24 to 30 THOUSAND dollars a year, which I'm pretty sure is FAR from being a poor persons salary. In some countries, that's a middle class working person's salary. Hell if they where working 16 hours a day for 6 days a week, they would be making close to 5K a month. That is so far from the reality of the actual japanese worker in a gasket manufacturing manufacturing plant, that it's no close to even being remotely amusing. In truth, it's extremely depressing.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by delackner on Sunday August 21, 2011 @01:02AM (#2908556)
That's an awful lot of thinking going on there, but are you saying you think they are paying 13 dollars a day? No, a bare minimum wage in Japan is (depending on the exchange rate) pretty close to $10 an hour.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by ahi on Sunday August 21, 2011 @01:44AM (#2908605)
According to Wikipedia, "As of 2010, regional minimum wages range from ¥642 (~US$7.75) to ¥821 (~US$9.90) per hour for all workers."
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by anamax on Saturday August 20, 2011 @08:52PM (#2908188)
> It is easily the worst legal job I've heard of in a first-world nation.

I've had worse, and I've had it pretty good.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by sp4rki on Sunday August 21, 2011 @12:34AM (#2908529)
My first legal job was in a callcenter doing inbound collection calls for 450 bucks (I live in Central America, so that's was about 200 bucks more then minimum wage at the time). It sucked. But I wasn't reprimanded or fired at the first minuscule mistake, I was being payed more money (86 bucks actually), than what the gasket person would make IF he/she worked all days of the week, and I could at least use my head to fix some of the customers problems in comparison to mindlessly shoving gaskets into a box.

I'd say my first job was shit, but it's a thousand times better than being a drone in a Japanese gasket factory. I'm not trying to be antagonistic, I'm just curious... What jobs have you had that where so bad?

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by anamax on Sunday August 21, 2011 @02:09AM (#2908631)
The one that comes to mind was feeding trays to a conveyor belt in a food processing plant. The trays came on a stack that was from 8 inches off the ground to 6 feet, so each tray came from a different height.

The wood was so rough that I went through a pair of leather gloves in less than a day. (I eventually figured out to wrap them in duct tape while still new, and keep wrapping them whenever I got a chance.)

At least the weather was reasonable. There are comparable jobs in much hotter and much colder weather.

And then there are jobs where it's easy to lose limbs or lives.

That's not counting the gross jobs, like picking up road kill, or the emotionally draining jobs, like putting abandoned pets to sleep.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by Cushman on Saturday August 20, 2011 @07:45PM (#2908071)
So... that's a job that could be done by robots. Some day soon it will be.

The robots will be paid the same thing whether they run in Japan, Vietnam, Toledo, or downtown Manhattan.

Call me crazy, but why are we arguing about "manufacturing jobs" instead of building robots?

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by patio11 on Saturday August 20, 2011 @07:52PM (#2908087)
why are we arguing about "manufacturing jobs" instead of building robots?

If I recall my stats correctly, the US is #2 in robots, which isn't exactly bad. (Lagging Japan, as a result of 30 years of policy decisions. Japanese government/industry put their chips down on "robots win the future" many years ago and this was not a disastrously stupid decision.)

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by bane on Saturday August 20, 2011 @08:21PM (#2908135)
Interestingly, Japan has spent loads of time on manufacturing robots and personal service robots of dubious utility (see Asimo, Toyotashi and others), while the U.S. has dumped military money at robots and ended up with drones, bomb disposal robots, exoskeletons, etc. etc.

While I agree that the level of technology and packaging in Japanese robots in generally higher than U.S. counterparts, to take a rather cheap shot, it was U.S. drones and robots that were first on the scene.

Due to the pedigree of mobile robotics, the U.S. needed systems that worked now and not the future...resulting in a variety of heavy duty operable robots capable of working in difficult environments.

Here's arguably the most advanced robot in the world handling perfectly normal stairs

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ASoCJTYgYB0

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ASoCJTYgYB0

Conclusion? Make the robot more like a crappy old American robot. http://www.autoguide.com/auto-news/2011/08/hondas-asimo-to-a...

It's critically important PR for the Japanese robotics industry to respond to Fukushima with something of utility. Otherwise these decades of work and millions of Yen in R&D haven't amounted to much more than an interesting series of public demonstrations.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3wwB43D0FG8

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by patio11 on Saturday August 20, 2011 @08:27PM (#2908146)
Human-form robots : robots :: Space Shuttle: ICBMs. It's just a media-friendly way of demonstrating that you have the capability to produce something of use. Most robots look nothing like a human. The overwhelming majority are in industry.

Interesting you mentioned exoskeletons. The US is 5 to 10 years away of getting them on a battlefield. They're commercially available in Japan for medical use. (I'm not making a value judgement on that, except to the extent that "You could actually buy this" is superior to not being able to buy it.)

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by bane on Saturday August 20, 2011 @10:47PM (#2908367)
Interesting you mentioned exoskeletons. The US is 5 to 10 years away of getting them on a battlefield.

Actually that's a very good point, and a fascinating demonstration of the differences in commercial funding for a technology vs military funding and the similar but completely different kind of tech that comes out of that.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by Cushman on Sunday August 21, 2011 @12:10AM (#2908489)
It's more of a technical issue, isn't it? They need to figure out how to power it— that's a lot easier in a hospital than in a war zone.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by redcap on Saturday August 20, 2011 @11:50PM (#2908470)
For reference, when Japan's Fukushima number 1 NPP reactors started going pear-shaped, there was no robot in Japan that they could use to enter the facility.

They had to turn to either a US or French robot to enter the reactor.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by varjag on Sunday August 21, 2011 @08:28AM (#2909066)
The bulk of the work was done by low-wage laborers wandering polluted water in sneakers. Asimo was out busy playing football.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by joe_the_user on Sunday August 21, 2011 @02:37AM (#2908662)
I'm not whether this serves as a proof of problems with Japanese robotics.

If Japan builds robots for the factory and the US builds robots for the battle field, it seem logical that US robots would be more useful in nuclear disaster. An power plant leaking hard radiation after a hydrogen explosion does resemble a battle field more than a factory floor, after all.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by Cushman on Saturday August 20, 2011 @07:59PM (#2908099)
Where are we at with robots per human?

That aside, it's a fair point— lots of people are working on robots. But we should be building more robots. We shouldn't be talking about "how can we create American jobs," we should be talking about "how can we replace every American job with a robot."

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by joe_the_user on Sunday August 21, 2011 @02:30AM (#2908653)
If we are going to talk about "how can we replace every American job with a robot", we'll have to talk about how replace humans can live ennobling lives of leisures rather than either pushing shopping carts or experiencing empty hedonism.

It would be a good conversation. I don't hear it starting. In fact, there was discussion of these issues in the 1960's and 1970's. By now, with the various crises on our heals, no one wants to consider the problems in this fashion.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by Cushman on Sunday August 21, 2011 @03:11PM (#2909945)
I think it's way late to start talking about that. In America, we have this puritanical ideal that working leads to happiness— or that working is, itself, happiness. Scientifically speaking, that's bollocks. To take the classic case study, people who win the lottery aren't any happier or unhappier than their workaday peers. They are exactly as happy.

Real happiness seems to come from something like the Buddhist ideas of mindfulness and acceptance, and that's true whether you're a poverty-sworn monk, a janitor, a CEO, or a pot-smoking layabout.

The idea of "rewarding work" vs. "empty hedonism" is an arbitrary Western construct with little basis in reality.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by foxit on Monday August 22, 2011 @12:01AM (#2911245)
Forgive me if I've misread, but I think what you're putting forth as acknowledged fact here is in fact controversial. You seem to be referencing the 1978 study "Lottery Winners and Accident Victims: Is Happiness Relative?" as well as, perhaps, the idea of the Hedonic Treadmill. Brickman's ideas are considered outdated.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/690806 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hedonic_treadmill

That's not to say that working, alone, producing happiness is a correct idea, but it might make sense that accomplishment does. And these levels of accomplishment - cleaning the floor well for a janitor, for instance - can differ. Most people desire to "make a difference," another way of saying the same thing. If you're talking about deathbed wishes when looking back on a life, the more positive impact your life visited on others, the better.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by felipemnoa on Sunday August 21, 2011 @06:52AM (#2908943)
My guess is that people with low skills will still find work but not as much (part-time) and consequently their pay will be lower. However, if robots are doing all the work then production becomes cheaper which means products become cheaper which again means that people can buy more with less money. So in reality people will not become poorer. The economic level will stay the same or probably increase. The purchase power will probably increase. Question is, what do you do with all that extra time?

Well, this is only one scenario of the things that can happen.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by mgkimsal on Sunday August 21, 2011 @12:31PM (#2909508)
However, if robots are doing all the work then production becomes cheaper which means products become cheaper which again means that people can buy more with less money.

That's a big assumption there. More likely, companies will experience higher profit margins rather than pass along the entirety of the cost savings.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by felipemnoa on Monday August 22, 2011 @06:39PM (#2914448)
True,but it only takes a startup with nothing to lose to enter the market and undercut everybody.
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by asdkl234890 on Saturday August 20, 2011 @08:16PM (#2908121)
Where are we at with robots per human?

What exactly is that a measure of?

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by Cushman on Saturday August 20, 2011 @08:39PM (#2908165)
It's a measure of the ability of automation to replace human labor.

Let's say that, as a middle-class American, I consume enough to employ ten manual laborers full-time. If we have ten robots for every person, then everyone can live like me and no one has to do the physical labor.

Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by quizbiz on Sunday August 21, 2011 @04:51AM (#2908796)
I wonder how many of us will be building platforms that build robots one hundred years from now?
Re:Why Amazon Can't Make A Kindle In the USA by rbanffy on Sunday August 21, 2011 @12:04PM (#2909450)
A hundred years from now, I only hope the robots will feed me on time and keep my cage clean.