News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by retrac on Friday October 29, 2021 @01:35PM (#29041278)
I dislike the term "gender" in linguistics. Many languages have grammatical gender that has nothing to do with masculine/feminine. "Noun class" gives the idea better. Noun classes in Indo-European and a couple other major language families happen to somewhat align with grammatical markers indicating animal/human sex. But it doesn't have to. Many languages make an animate/inanimate distinction.

It is one of those mysteries that several major language families all do it in a similar way. From Ancient Egyptian to Latin to small languages spoken in New Guinea, there is a common pattern of grammatical markings associated with indicating a person or animal's sex, ending up used to indicate noun classes and govern alignment/agreement patterns.

But why? Well, in languages like Latin with fairly free word order, noun classes and the associated agreement help indicate what goes with what. My take is that it's almost like a form of forwards error correction or type annotation. The way it arises like that doesn't seem too far-fetched.

The persistence is tricky though. Normally a feature in a language that isn't productive is going to get worn down by sound changes, etc. and eventually lost. But grammatical gender rarely gets lost. (English is a major exception as an Indo-European language here.) Even as Latin transformed over thousands of years into French, with grammar and phonology that are basically unrecognizable, a basic gender system persists in the language. I can only assume its error correcting/type annotating properties are still useful even in modern French?

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by chewxy on Friday October 29, 2021 @03:07PM (#29042384)
"Gender" as a concept came in linguistics first[0]. Social sciences co-opted the word later in the 1950s (Simone de Beauvoir comes to mind as one of the first people to use "gender" in its modern sense). The linguistics notion of gender is not tied to masculine or feminine (though they are taught thus). We now associate the word "gender" with its modern political meaning but in the past, the word "gender" was treated the way you'd use "noun class"

[0]: https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=gender&year_st...

[dead]
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by doublepg23 on Saturday October 30, 2021 @12:34AM (#29046007)
I'm surprised you'd reference John Money and not expect politics. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Money#Controversies
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by monopoledance on Saturday October 30, 2021 @04:24AM (#29047061)
Oh, are you? So the fact he is an asshole makes everything he did and thought “politics”? Is everything, any scientist does, which supports a world view you don’t like, “politics”?

Does this somehow invalidate the correction about the origins of ‘gender’’s popular meaning?

Have you read the article I linked? Do you still agree the distinction between sex and gender is all “politics”?

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by telotortium on Friday October 29, 2021 @03:07PM (#29042385)
> I dislike the term "gender" in linguistics. Many languages have grammatical gender that has nothing to do with masculine/feminine.

You realize that the use of gender for grammatical noun class is the original meaning of the word, correct? Gender comes from the Latin genus, generis (via Old French), which means type, kind, sort. The genders in Latin were called masculine, feminine, and neuter because one of the noun classes contained most, but not all of the nouns that refer to males, one of them contain the nouns that refer to females, and the last one, neuter, literally means neither.

If anything, it's English that is to blame here for taking the original meaning and corrupting it. I believe most non-english languages, when they want to use the modern English sense of gender, either borrow the word directly from English or just use a translation of sex role.

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by brazzy on Friday October 29, 2021 @04:25PM (#29043167)
Um... From TFA:

When the Romans started to get interested in grammar, genus came to mean “kind” of noun or “gender”, but because genus could also refer to biological sex, male and female, these concepts were occasionally conflated.

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by FreakLegion on Friday October 29, 2021 @11:25PM (#29045732)
This is overstated. They used genus contextually, in an abstract sense, for biological sex, in the same way we might use kind for a brand of soda ("what kind of soda do you want?"), but genus didn't have the concrete meaning of biological sex for them any more than kind has the concrete meaning of soda brand for us.

It's the same for Greek γένος, e.g. in Plato's Symposium:

> πρῶτον μὲν γὰρ τρία ἦν τὰ γένη τὰ τῶν ἀνθρώπων, οὐχ ὥσπερ νῦν δύο, ἄρρεν καὶ θῆλυ --189d

It's fair to translate that into modern English as "Originally there were three genders [or sexes] of human being, not two like now, male and female", but the specific meaning of sex or gender isn't there, just kind. It's a general word being used in a general way (literally, in fact: genus -> general).

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by telotortium on Friday October 29, 2021 @04:34PM (#29043246)
Thanks for that - I didn't see that.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by peoplefromibiza on Saturday October 30, 2021 @09:33AM (#29048618)
that's a bit of a stretch.

Genere in Italian comes from the Latin word genus and means biological sex for people and animals but also kind.

  Translate genere to English

  noun
  1. gender
  2. kind
They ate not conflated, they depend on the context

What kind of beast is that? -> Che genere di bestia è?

What's that book genre? -> Di che genere è quel libro?

How to write gender questions -> come scrivere domande sul genere

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by dwmbt on Friday October 29, 2021 @04:18PM (#29043094)
great rebuttal, i learned something new! i wonder, do you happen to know how this might impact the conversation between gender and sex being two different descriptors? i'm unsure of how to go about looking at the etymological origins of both words, so help in that regard could prove just as useful. thanks.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by goto11 on Saturday October 30, 2021 @05:54AM (#29047452)
I don't think the etymological origins of the words really impact the current conversation. The meaning of words depends on how they are used, and "gender" today have quite a different meaning when talking about human gender identity than when talking about grammar.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by leephillips on Friday October 29, 2021 @06:18PM (#29044166)
Two different descriptors of what?
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by dwmbt on Friday October 29, 2021 @08:20PM (#29044946)
i've found that there are arguments being had between people my age that sex is a biological descriptor (M/F) and that gender is a looser, more amorphous descriptor. for instance, you can be born a man (your biological sex) and identify as non-binary (your gender). i'm interested to see how the origin of the words could contribute to that discussion.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by leephillips on Friday October 29, 2021 @11:28PM (#29045751)
Various philosophers, such as Wittgenstein, have pointed out that much of what sounds like discussion only exists because one can arrange words into grammatically sensible sentences. That doesn't mean the discussion is actually about anything. People who know the words “Earth” and “flat” can theorize about whether the Earth is flat, but it’s a waste of time to pay any attention to them. A “non-binary” “gender” is just a noise with no idea attached to it.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by goto11 on Saturday October 30, 2021 @05:58AM (#29047465)
> A “non-binary” “gender” is just a noise with no idea attached to it.

Are you talking about grammar here? Because in many (most?) languages gender is not binary.

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by leephillips on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:14AM (#29048930)
I was replying to something. Just read the comment I was replying to. Also, yes, many languages have more than two genders. That’s a non-binary gender system. But no particular word in those languages is “non-binary”.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by goto11 on Sunday October 31, 2021 @05:26AM (#29055695)
Words can certainly change gender over time or be non-gendered if that is what you mean. But it doesn't make any sense to say that a word is non-binary in a trinary gender system like in Latin.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by culi on Friday October 29, 2021 @01:53PM (#29041526)
It's worth pointing out that, in linguistics, grammatical gender can be seen as a specific type of noun class system. The term is mostly useful when talking about Indo-European languages where the feminine-masculine distinction is most prevalent

It's also worth noting that grammatical gender evolves over time. Originally, most Indo-European languages had the three classes of feminine, masculine, and neuter. But, for example, French's loss of the neuter class is pretty recent. We're also seeing modern efforts to drive these processes with, for example, the usage of the gender-neutral term "Latine" instead of "Latino" or "Latina".

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by asveikau on Friday October 29, 2021 @02:50PM (#29042191)
One of my favorite stories about a neutral gender being preserved is in words like Spanish esto.

Typically in comparing Latin with modern Romance, the merger of neuter into masculine is one of the loss of distinguishing suffices. You can't distinguish between bonus and bonum if the final constant is lost and they are both bonu (or bueno in Spanish).

But some words didn't distinguish masculine from neuter by just a consonant. Take iste (m) and istud (n). Remove final consonants and you have iste and istu. So in Spanish there's este and esto. The different vowel gets preserved, so you can distinguish between masculine and neuter still, where with most words you cannot.

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by kgeist on Friday October 29, 2021 @02:10PM (#29041715)
>Originally, most Indo-European languages had the three classes of feminine, masculine, and neuter.

Early Proto-Indoeuropean is theorized to have 2 genders - animate/inanimate, but by the late PIE period it evolved to the classic three.

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by fourtrees on Friday October 29, 2021 @04:41PM (#29043297)
Having missed your comment, I was about to post about this. One interesting fact I can add is that Hittite, the oldest written IE language, has the animate/inanimate gender system rather than the 3-way system. You can also see remnants of the old system here and there in Latin, Greek, Sanskrit, Russian, ect.

Of course, this is largely theoretical like you said, and I'm sure you could dig up some dissenting papers if you wanted to.

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by kgeist on Friday October 29, 2021 @04:59PM (#29043473)
>You can also see remnants of the old system here and there in Latin, Greek, Sanskrit, Russian, ect.

For example, there are some adjectives in Latin and Ancient Greek, which only have two declensions instead of three: one common declension for masculine/feminine, and one for neuter.

For example: naturalis (masc), naturalis (fem), naturale (neut), as opposed to novus (masc), nova (fem), novum (neut).

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by monopoledance on Friday October 29, 2021 @07:52PM (#29044784)
I want that! If we ever get our shit together, let’s use that for a common language. For us, for our home - earth.

Edit: Oh, I translated this as alive/not alive. Guess, this was originally down to soul. Not advocating to go down that path again…

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by superflit2 on Friday October 29, 2021 @02:58PM (#29042274)
On Romantic languages "latinE" a noun ending in "e" or "ne" would express a word from French/Galic.

"Champagne", "Vitrine" as exemple.

The ""new"" gender neutral a woke fashion that has disregard for people with dyslexia or people who needs software to read (blind).

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by asveikau on Friday October 29, 2021 @06:40PM (#29044328)
In both your examples (cf. Campania, vitrina), the pattern is that French makes an -a suffix in Latin into a silent -e. I believe there were earlier parts of the history of french phonetics where it was pronounced as a schwa, so you can kind of imagine it as "softening" over time, starting out as a proper A sound and eventually disappearing over the centuries.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by tasogare on Saturday October 30, 2021 @03:21AM (#29046756)
It's not even their worst attempt. In France, those fringe "woke" people are advocating a forked version of French which is written with a lot of dots everywhere to display genders simultaneously. For example: "Bonjour à tou.s.tes les étudiant.e.s." which is very hard to read even for non-dyslexic people. The normal people are fighting it but they succeeded to promote that crap via a ministry and lot of universities are writing their emails like that.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by b3orn on Saturday October 30, 2021 @03:45AM (#29046871)
Shouldn't that be "Bonjour à tou.te.s les étudiant.e.s."? Also as far as I know it's banned from schools for now.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by umanwizard on Saturday October 30, 2021 @10:39AM (#29049106)
Similar systems are now widespread in Germany and as far as I can tell they don’t impede comprehension.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by umanwizard on Friday October 29, 2021 @03:01PM (#29042308)
> I dislike the term "gender" in linguistics.

I think you have it backwards. The term “gender” meant grammatical gender, i.e. noun classes, before being extended by analogy to the current meaning.

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by olau on Friday October 29, 2021 @05:49PM (#29043929)
Persistence: I'm not sure that line of reasoning is actually valid. I think you need to be able to rule out other reasons for persistence before you can make that conclusion. The article mentions that the genders are learned at an early age and seem to be very resistent to change.

I just looked up Danish - it used to have masculine, feminine and neuter, but masculine disappeared into feminine. The theory given here is that it was a consequence of bilinguals simplifying things:

https://dialekt.ku.dk/dialekter/dialekttraek/navneordenes_ko...

It wouldn't surprise me if modern English is a result of the same kind of multilingual simplification.

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by masswerk on Friday October 29, 2021 @03:53PM (#29042829)
Yet another aspect: In Latin, after the Republic, there's an increasing loss of punctuations and word separators in the written language, and with varying writing directions, as in verses, a distinctive word ending becomes really important. (Which may be a cause for the simplification mentioned in the article.) Now also take the rather free word order into account and it may become quite clear, why forming a relational web using types and repeating the respective word endings is really helpful.

The other way round, that this loss of word separators and punctuations had been possible at all illustrates rather well the amount of redundancy and robustness this system introduces in a language.

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by Kye on Friday October 29, 2021 @01:40PM (#29041350)
I wonder if there are any examples of this in languages from the many cultures past and present that always recognized more than two sex-derived genders.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by bregma on Friday October 29, 2021 @01:51PM (#29041500)
English, for example, has two pronoun genders: animate and inanimate. The animate gender is further subdivided into two subgenders: masculine and feminine. Of course, none of this has anything to do with sex, unless you prefer to attempt reproduction with inanimate objects as many have instructed me to do using the imperative mood (literally "fuck it").
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by kgeist on Friday October 29, 2021 @02:05PM (#29041672)
Slavic languages have both 3 classic genders and grammatical animacy for masculine. I.e. if you view an object as an inanimate object, it will have a slightly different declension in accusative compared to animate objects. But it only works for words of masculine gender.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by tazjin on Friday October 29, 2021 @03:54PM (#29042839)
Russian also has this for feminine plural accusative.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by tsimionescu on Friday October 29, 2021 @02:17PM (#29041797)
Doesn't 'it' refer to both inanimate objects and animate objects (animals)? Or is 'inanimate' a kind of term of art here refering to humans and human-like beings (instead of the more common meaning of 'non-living')?
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by retrac on Friday October 29, 2021 @02:52PM (#29042214)
Yes, it's a linguistics term. Animate things are perceived as having human-like agency. Many languages have a grammatical category clustering things like large non-human animals, the weather, or fire, or trees, together with humans. Animate. Everything else is inanimate and presumably less alive.

In English, many animals are referred to with "he" or "she". Being a mammal, large, being domesticated, being familiar, are all more likely to be animate rather than inanimate. A pet mare is going to be "she". Insects are always "it". Livestock or a reptile might get either. Babies sometimes get treated as inanimate. ("Is it a boy or girl?")

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by occamrazor on Friday October 29, 2021 @04:29PM (#29043208)
When I first learned English in school (almost 40 years ago) I was told that very young babies were grammatically neuter. Now I never hear anyone using “it” for a baby. Has English changed in the last decades, or was my teacher wrong?
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by omegaham on Friday October 29, 2021 @04:48PM (#29043350)
I was loudly corrected on this subject (that is, I had used "it," and he asserted that I was wrong) by a drill instructor in Marine Corps basic training a little more than a decade ago.

I'm not quite sure how much credence to give his opinion considering that his expertise was in pain, misery, and shooting guns rather than linguistics and grammar, but he certainly had strong beliefs on the subject, and I wasn't going to try to convince him otherwise.

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by bregma on Saturday October 30, 2021 @08:40AM (#29048317)
It can be considered an insult to get the sex of a baby wrong because males are generally considered more valuable than females. It's socially better the refer to an infant as inanimate than to mistakenly refer to a male child using the female gender. That said, as soon as one knows the correct sex (often indicated by the colour of cloth used in swaddling or clothing, or other markers like design patterns of trucks or ponies, as appropriate) it's important to start using the corresponding grammatical gender otherwise the early indoctrination lacks the enforcement required for a lifetime of identity with arbitrary social constructs like masculinity and femininity.

It's not a grammar rule, it's a social rule.

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by culi on Friday October 29, 2021 @01:58PM (#29041590)
Most languages with grammatical gender have a distinct third class which linguists usually call "neuter". Languages like French are somewhat unique in having lost that third gender

It's important to note that neuter is distinct from "gender"-less nouns

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by umanwizard on Friday October 29, 2021 @03:03PM (#29042328)
> Most languages with grammatical gender have a distinct third class

There are thousands of languages. They have all kinds of different noun class systems including none at all. By “most languages” you probably mean “most of the widely-known Indo-European languages”.

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by culi on Friday October 29, 2021 @04:51PM (#29043382)
No I said and I meant "most languages with grammatical gender". Other languages have different noun class systems, but these are not generally called "grammatical gender" if they're not tied to feminine, masculine, etc.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by kgeist on Friday October 29, 2021 @02:13PM (#29041750)
I like the fact that in most languages with 3 genders, the word kid is neuter: German "das Kind", Slavic "ditia", Greek "teknon".

I guess that's because a child is not a fully developed man/woman, so it's assumed genderless.

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by apocolyps6 on Friday October 29, 2021 @03:37PM (#29042663)
This feels like cherry-picking. There are non-neuter ways to refer to kids, including in those languages. Also, the diminutive (at least in German) is neuter, and is often used with children. Some of these terms are specifically neutral (i.e. not "boy" or "girl"). So the reasons are much more likely linguistic than ..sociological.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by kgeist on Friday October 29, 2021 @04:21PM (#29043125)
It's not cherry-picking, it's a well-known fact in Indoeuropean studies, and this interpretation is supported by some linguists.

For example (Luraghi 2018): "More than simply indicating referential sex, Luraghi (2009b: 127 and 2011) makes the argument, with which Melchert (2014: 264) agrees, that an involvement in procreation may have played a role in gender assignment in PIE. It may have been a key factor motivating the split between masculine and feminine. Nouns that referred to male or female humans/animals were, for the most part, assigned to masculine and feminine, respectively (Lundquist and Yates 2018: 2095). For example, there was the masculine noun ph2tḗr ‘father’ beside feminine méh2tēr ‘mother’ and wĺ̥kwos ‘(he-)wolf’ beside wl̥kwíhxs ‘she-wolf’ (Lundquist and Yates 2018: 2095). However, words that indicated children and young animals were often neuter in the IE languages (Melchert 2014: 264), e.g. Gk. téknon, OHG kind, and OCS dětę (Lundquist and Yates 2018: 2095). The humans/animals to which those nouns refer are too young to procreate, so, despite being physically animate, they are grammatically neuter.

A questionnaire experiment determined that feminine anaphors were used more if Mädchen referred to, for example, an eighteen-year-old girl “as opposed to a two- or [twelve]-year-old one, where neuter pronouns were more frequent. These results show that speakers perceive biological sex as more important for adults than for children” (Corbett and Fedden 2016: 522). This supports Luraghi’s theory that involvement in procreation was a factor—alongside individuation—in gender assignment in PIE"

Words that refer to children and which aren't of neuter gender today may simply be of later origin, when the system stopped being productive. For example, the Russian word for "child" is rebenok, which today has masculine gender, but stems from earlier "rebia" which was neuter (a synonym of another word, "ditia", also neuter).

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by apocolyps6 on Friday October 29, 2021 @05:33PM (#29043805)
Thanks for the citations. I'm always wary of this sort of reasoning since people often arrive at it via folk etymology, but this was very informative
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by cge on Friday October 29, 2021 @06:27PM (#29044240)
Kgeist gives citations to the more general trend here, but in Modern Greek, terms for children of particular genders often also don't have matching grammatical genders. Thus, το παιδί and το τέκνο (child, nonspecific) are both neuter. But το κορίτσι (girl) and το αγόρι (boy) are also neuter.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by podviaznikov on Friday October 29, 2021 @09:06PM (#29045150)
If I'm not wrong it's feminine in Ukrainian (dytyna). Not sure what it is for all Slavic languages (I think it's neutral in Croatian). Also not sure what is the history for the Ukrainian version.

Just adding some info maybe others can comment.

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by kgeist on Saturday October 30, 2021 @01:00AM (#29046113)
The declension of "ditia" is not very productive (gen "ditiati" etc.) Usually a noun with a rare declension is moved to a different, more conmon declension by assigning a certain productive suffix which uses a common declension. Such suffixes have their own assigned gender.

Same for Russian "rebia" (rare declension) which became rebenok (common declension) by assigning -ok suffix which happens to be masculine. Or in Greek, masculine "pais" had unproductive declension (gen. paidos) so it was assigned diminutive suffux -ion which happens to be neuter, hence modern Greek "paidi" is neuter.

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by goto11 on Saturday October 30, 2021 @06:14AM (#29047557)
Danish have two grammatical genders, "neuter" and "common". Male and female have same grammatical gender. So conflating gender and sexual identity becomes really confusing!
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by Dma54rhs on Saturday October 30, 2021 @04:09AM (#29046992)
There are languages like German or Estonians where gender and sex have the same meaning, or rather term gender and the idea of it simply don't exist.
Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by Kye on Saturday October 30, 2021 @02:57PM (#29051367)
That's interesting considering Germany had (more or less) one of the first queer centers in roughly the form we think of them now. I wonder what could have led to that and a diversifying concept of gender being wiped out of the language and culture...

I kid. Of course it was the purges leading up to WW2. I think they would have eventually developed as robust a concept of gender as we have today. It wasn't that long ago that we only had a concept in English of two binary sexes with gender being bound to secondary sexual characteristics.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Institut_f%C3%BCr_Sexualwissen...

Re:Gender in Latin and Beyond: A Philologist’s Take by peoplefromibiza on Saturday October 30, 2021 @09:37AM (#29048639)
German