News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by ajkdhcb2 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @12:16AM (#29009487)
Users, miners and developers all have different powers and hold each other to account in an interesting way that few people understand so far, affecting what 'control' really means. It needs to be put in context with alternatives. Compared to the alternative of corrupt governments that have complete control to print money at will, I have no doubt that it is a extremely promising experiment. ASICs do seem to pervert some incentives so people should be more interested in modified Proof-of-Work algorithms like Monero has been doing successfully
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by jayd16 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @12:33AM (#29009574)
In what way do users have control over miners or developers? If the assumption is that corruption can overcome a democratic state, I never understood why its so crazy to suggest it can overcome developers or a mining cartel.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by Geee on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:47AM (#29009964)
Bitcoin is open-source software. Users decide which version they want to run. Developers and miners can't force users to switch to another version. Some miners tried to force an upgrade on users in 2017 which was averted with a threat of user activated soft fork.[0]

[0] https://bitcoinmagazine.com/culture/bitcoin-independence-day...

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by runeks on Saturday October 30, 2021 @12:16PM (#29049917)
> Developers and miners can't force users to switch to another version.

Miners can, but it’s costly. By a majority mining empty blocks on the chain they wish users to switch away from they make that chain useless. However, they need to sacrifice profit on some other chain (by not mining on that) to do so.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by wmf on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:02AM (#29009726)
Users have the money. If there's a fork, users can value one side higher than the other and then developers and miners will follow the money.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by nuerow on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:38AM (#29009911)
> Users have the money. If there's a fork, users can value one side higher than the other and then developers and miners will follow the money.

As the article shows, BTC's user side of the equation is actually controlled by a small group of investors. Thus, users like you and me have absolutely zero control or influence over the value of BTC, and are vulnerable to the manipulation done by this small group of investors.

We already saw BTC's value tank to half in a matter of days. How do you explain that as being something that meets the users' best interests?

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by keymone on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @02:08AM (#29010040)
Investors invest to increase wealth. If users stop thinking of any particular version of bitcoin as bitcoin - investors will start pulling out of it.

This is not about money invested but about social consensus over which version of software is the bitcoin.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by sleavey on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @02:37AM (#29010206)
Bitcoin aligns incentives. It's in the interest of those with lots of bitcoin to have everyone else use the same fork, so their coins have value. This discourages bad behaviour from whales.

Let's not forget that bitcoin's monetary policy is fixed. Everyone earns coins the same way as everyone else: by mining or buying. No printing of new money for example. Central banks are far bigger whales than bitcoin's given their ability to print new money on a whim.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by nuerow on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @02:47AM (#29010259)
> Bitcoin aligns incentives. It's in the interest of those with lots of bitcoin to have everyone else use the same fork, so their coins have value. This discourages bad behaviour from whales.

No, not really. It is in the interests of those with lots of bitcoins to sell high and buy low. This means whales stand to profit by pumping BTC's value to leave everyone else holding the bag when it's value tanks. Rinse and repeat, and fat whales get fatter. But for this scheme to work, first you need unwitting users to fall for the promise of quick and easy fortunes at arm's reach. A tale as old as time.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by haimez on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:15AM (#29009802)
Right. The pyramid needs a base to stand on.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by PEJOE on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:21AM (#29009826)
I thought Bitcoin was the money?
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by victor106 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:16AM (#29009804)
How many forks of Bitcoin have been as successful as Bitcoin?
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by ajkdhcb2 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:26AM (#29009848)
Some would argue that Bitcoin Cash is the real Bitcoin. People have to fight for the name when there is a fork. Miners were fighting for a different chain and actually lost
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by jimmydorry on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @12:57AM (#29009701)
Corrupt states have a monopoly on violence. There is no such similar force ensuring people have to use the crypto made available to them. The Bitcoin network operates by balancing the economic incentives of each party, and at any point, any party is free to walk away.

__Developers:__

* Profit motive: Paid salaries / bounties / donations by users, business that build off the Blockchain, miners, and appreciation from their BTC holdings

* The consequence of all the core developers going rogue would be the price of BTC collapsing, salaries or donations no longer getting paid by either or all of the above groups

__Miners:__

* Profit motive: Appreciation of BTC holdings, income derrived from doing their job by validating transactions and appending them to the blockchain for the block reward and transaction fees

* Rogue miners can't exert much force on the system until they get close to 50% of the hashing power.

* A collective of miners (e.g. a mining pool) can negatively impact the ecosystem by buying developers, or messing with transactions. This would result in a large cost by way of their holdings losing value and no longer being able to derrive as much income from mining.

__Users:__

* Profit motive: Transacting and speculating with BTC gives it value. If a significant group of users dislike a developer's proposed changes or feels they are corrupt, they can make their voice heard which can force the miners and other developers to weigh in resolve the issue. If this does not happen, then the loss of confidence in Bitcoin can result in a fork (the troublemakers leaving the chain, or the majority / active users moving to a new coin and leaving the troublemakers behind).

No one party in the above can force any issue on the other two stakeholders, and doing so against all economic incentives will typically cause enough damage that none of the other actors would likely go along with such an act.

For example, the main active developers could get bought off and push out a client with 10GB transaction blocks. Assuming the miners also get bought off, the users can choose not to use such cyrpto and sell their coins while they can still get a decent value for them. The miners and developers would be king of their fiefdom, which means very little. This is only possible though if you treat the miners and developers each as a single entity. This is far from the case though.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by EdwardDiego on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @03:47AM (#29010588)
> Corrupt states have a monopoly on violence

Do you believe all states to be corrupt?

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by jimmydorry on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @04:56AM (#29010917)
No? Using the same terms as GP.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by postalrat on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @02:10PM (#29016861)
Three groups all seeking profits, but where do the profits come from? Tether?
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by jimmydorry on Friday October 29, 2021 @12:29PM (#29040427)
Users: Profit through deflationary design (demand higher than supply). Most currencies are inflationary by nature, while Bitcoin is designed to be the opposite (the first phase aimed for growth is inflationary, but this pressure decreases substantially every halving).

Developers: Profit from being a user, as well as from the power to drive additional demand by improving the ecosystem (make it easier to use, more powerful or more efficient), and lastly by way of bounty/salary/donation based on how well they are achieving #2.

Miners: Arbitrage between cost of electricity and price of crypto, transaction fees mined, block reward, and finally from being a user.

The funny money some exchanges offer to make moving fiat easier or faster between other exchanges is pretty irrelevant. As long as tether is not committing massive fraud by minting billions to buy crypto on a fraudulent basis, it doesn’t matter what token people use to move their fiat. Tether could explode tomorrow or in decades from now, but I don’t see them bringing down crypto longterm, just like I don’t see an Elon tweet having the potential for long term impact.

I would certainly never touch Tether, and anyone who does is taking a not insignificant risk of getting burnt if there is no-one willing to buy their tether when they want to sell (Tethers are not and have not been redeemable for dollars from Tether corp for a long time).

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by ajkdhcb2 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @12:44AM (#29009626)
Developers are wasting their time if nobody wants to use what they develop. Miners lose their income if they are mining blocks on a chain that nobody wants to use.

Users running software nodes validates the blocks, limiting what miners can do. Miners can be pushed to change the rules with methods like a 'User Activated Soft Fork'. The proof of work algorithm can even be changed, rendering all the ASIC hardware of the mining industry worthless.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by matteotom on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @12:57AM (#29009700)
Corrupt governments and central banks can be pushed to change the rules with methods like "voting" or "mass protests".
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by sunshinerag on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:01AM (#29009714)
Except corrupt governments and central banks do not care for either. Central bank policies are not subject to voting by people. Did any of us vote for bailouts, QE?. corrupt governments also know how to suppress "mass protests". If these are the only ways to hold them to account how would that work.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by lkrubner on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:19AM (#29009816)
Most of us did vote for quantitative easing. Certainly after 2008, for many years, in the USA and in Europe, people were voting any kind of stimulus they could get, and when it was impossible to get enough fiscal stimulus, most of us were willing to support any effort for monetary stimulus as a second-best alternative. It is, of course, an interesting point of discussion why it was so difficult to get sufficient fiscal stimulus, but that topic is too complex to get into in a comment on Hacker News.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by nuerow on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:27AM (#29009858)
> Central bank policies are not subject to voting by people. Did any of us vote for bailouts, QE?.

Isn't the role of a central bank to enact monetary policy and to contribute to financial stability? I mean, actively working to stabilize the value of money and to ensure inflation meets the government's policy goals, which are motivated by the need to ensure the economy stays healthy, don't sound like something that creates controversy. I mean, do we really need a vote do check if we want Zimbabwean hyperinflation?

Given the alternative is the perpetual risk of seeing the value of your currency halve in less than a week, like BTC experienced a few months ago, how exactly is the service provided by a central bank bad or undesirable?

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by matteotom on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:34AM (#29009891)
The Fed has a pretty straightforward mission to balance inflation and employment. If they're doing a bad job of that, then the president or congress (acting on behalf of the people) can act to hold them accountable. If congress decides that's no longer the right mission, they can pass a law changing it.

And there are countless historical examples (even recent) of peaceful or violent protests causing change to corrupt governments.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by tenuousemphasis on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @03:01AM (#29010338)
Users choose which software to run, so they can fire one set of developers by running software by different developers. The software they run determines which blocks they consider valid, and if enough people agree that miners' blocks are invalid, miners will have to accept their blocks have less value or change the way they produce blocks.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by stkdump on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:38AM (#29009916)
By users you mean investors? The article argues that only a small group of investors have power. So replacing one man one vote by one dollar (or bitcoin) one vote is a loss of democracy. I don't see how corruption can be prevented by restricting the voting rights to the rich.
Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by wolverine876 on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @10:50PM (#29021821)
> Compared to the alternative of corrupt governments that have complete control to print money at will

Major governments in wealthy countries have done an excellent job of managing currency. It's far more stable than cryptocurrencies, and the stability has improved as knowledge of economics has improved. They went through two massive economic calamities in 13 years (the Great Recession and the Coronavirus Pandemic) with almost no economic instability.

Cryptocurrency seems to me to be a far greater threat to economic stability and for corruption and undemocratic seizure of power.

Re:Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investo... by EdwardDiego on Wednesday October 27, 2021 @01:40AM (#29009924)
> the alternative of corrupt governments

Are all governments inherently corrupt in your mind?