Because trust is not a binary value and I don't have the time to do literally everything myself
we ran our own XMPP server for over 10 years using the "off the record" plugin for end to end encryption. Development seem to basically stop on open chat clients a few years ago and everything started getting crufty. (I see Pidgin dev has apparently picked back up again to some extent, as has Adium, to a much lesser extent).
"off the record" mostly worked ok, between Pidgin users, but failed with other clients.
A couple of OMEMO plugins came along but making them work (and keeping them working) was a continual drain - and we're only a small team with only 2 operating systems (Linux and OSX)!
My hunch is that enough people just moved to things like Whatsapp and Slack etc that developers were no longer using chat clients they could hack on. People stopped being able to scratch their itches.
Not to mention lack of any/decent XMPP client support for syncing histories between multiple clients, or handling inline images and things. All that modern stuff people expect.
Things like Mattersmost tried to fit in here but we just didn't get along with them.
Eventually Element/Matrix matured enough and while it was far from perfect, it worked and we sadly finally gave up on XMPP.
All of these work fine with OMEMO (the iOS ones gained better OMEMO and push support in the past few months) and message history retrieval between clients. Gajim doesn't do inline images, but the rest do.
I occasionally use profanity as a console client and that recently had message archive support land in Git.
So, yeah, no idea what you mean by developers giving up - if anything, the ecosystem has greatly improved (minus group OMEMO on iOS).
Oh, and Dino got support for doing encrypted calls to Conversations a few months ago: https://fosstodon.org/@dino/106228549009869402
Even just for OMEMO support, we all had to compile a plugin for libpurple/Pidgin, and it didn't even have full UI support so was very difficult to use when things didn't work automatically.
We used a gajim but iirc, to get OMEMO support we had to compile that too.
But I'm truly glad to hear the ecosystem has improved - I would have much preferred to have stuck with XMPP. But in 2019/2020, Matrix offered all this and more and worked very well. It was impossible to make the case for us to stay on XMPP.
There are a few options yet for XMPP clients, I have some hope for the ecosystem...!
siskin.im has support for OMEMO encrypted group chat
What's the difference between Element offering these bridges, people deploying their own bridges or others having 3rd party clients that you can't trust with your E2E encryption?
Obviously still a long way off actual secure communication though.
yeahh. thats not exactly a meme but i am personally facing these same state sponsored actions read here https://thekashmirwalla.com/not-pegasus-kashmiris-are-worrie...
The sad reality is that things are complex and you probably get suboptimal results trying to do everything yourself, what other spend their lives trying to accomplish the same.
WhatsApp scaled to 1B users with only 50 engineers, but there were 50 people working full time to provide what people think they can provide in their spare time?
Also as the other end of any communication is quite scaring thinking I am communicating securely with someone, but then finding out that their server is compromised because of an out of date library or service.
Server getting compromised - that's largely unimportant with end-to-end encryption through OMEMO. Distros also apply security patches (just keep things up to date).
You do not require 50 engineers to run a chat server for <200 of your friends. In my experience, once you have the software configured and running - it pretty much runs itself.
Here's a guide on how to install everything needed onto a raspberry pi: https://samhobbs.co.uk/2016/09/installing-prosody-instant-me...
As with anything else, it's a fun learning experience and something new to try.
https://www.reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/nkyzdw/what_is_the...
Everyone else, if they don't migrate to a secure and preferred method, I just use email (with pgp if possible) and call it good.
> forced onto FB’s WhatsApp
Just don't install it. I've never used it. People ask why, I answer that I do not accept the spying in their terms of service. Far more people are sympathetic to that line than you might expect.The annoying thing is is that WA became the standard for communications when they were not owned by FB and had a privacy focus. This is why I have no qualms abut trying to cheat out of their horrible system.
As someone who used trillian, you should recognize that you're likely to need to follow someone to a new trendy messaging service within a few years, regardless of an aggregator taking off.
Because end to end encryption means you don't have to trust a third party? The channel goes out of the equation, at least with reference to the content of your messages. Metadata is definitely handled differently by different services but that's a question of threat model.
> These bridges are actually just an intermediate step. Since Matrix itself is an amazing chat network, eventually as more people start using bridges on Matrix, they’ll notice that their friends are already on Matrix, eliminating the need for bridges gradually over time.
> I really believe that the world will be a better place when everyone is in the Matrix. Matrix is the non-proliferation treaty of chat.
https://medium.com/@ericmigi/the-universal-communication-bus...
OMEMO nor XMPP provide trusted transport.
Perhaps the point you are reaching for is that encryption and transport should be different parties. The message should be encrypted before you hand it to the Western Union agent. After that, the decision between Western Union, Union Pacific, or Pony Express hinges on other concerns.
If you use a 3rd party, it can be compromised and you only find out when it is too late.
The disadvantage of having your server at your home is that you don't know if it's compromised from day one. I may never even find out and just fool myself the entire time.
there is a news by arstechnica that updates by cisco who deny the same but these curbs were imposed and i personally suffered so i am not sure if "have their computers taken without it causing a huge problem for everyone from your mom to heads of state is a bit naive"... even a big company like cisco must bow down and bend rules to a dictatorial country like india.
Then don't. I have none of those things save for IRC. I get all my work done and live a full life.
Pidgin is good (I also miss the ancient Trillian, even though it was closed source), but limited to a local device.
There are XMPP Transports as well for these (see https://git.eta.st/eta/whatsxmpp , https://gitlab.com/nicocool84/spectrum2_signald , but sadly https://spectrum.im/ is surprisingly finicky to set up.)
EDIT: for encryption fans, I've been wondering for a long time now: why would you trust ANY 3rd party with your so sensitive data instead of running your own service? Are you not aware of OMEMO for XMPP? (See https://omemo.top/ )