News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by olalonde on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:25AM (#28953743)
It's a bit controversial but there's a lot of evidence that actively managed funds underperform passive ones. "A Random Walk Down Wall Street"[0] is a good read on the topic.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Random_Walk_Down_Wall_Street

Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by smabie on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:06AM (#28953909)
The real takeaway from this is not that it's impossible to beat the market consistently (it's not) or that the price movement of securities are random and normally distributed (they're not), but that as an average retail investor (or sometimes as a sophisticated institutional allocator), it is very difficult to find funds that can outperform (which isn't a linear/one dimensional thing btw, more sophisticated analysis is required) that also you can invest in.

When allocating capital to funds you are being adversely selected against: those who can generate returns probably aren't interested in your money (there's a lot more money in the world than profitable trading/investment opportunities).

As such, I normally recommend to people that unless they are professionals and know that they are doing or HNW (say >50mil), they stick to ETFs for the bulk of their portfolio. To be clear this isn't the optimal strategy, but it's easy and it mostly works.

Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by galaxyLogic on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:40AM (#28954024)
> it's impossible to beat the market consistently (it's not)

Is there any proof of that? Some traders of course will get very rich, just like some lottery-players.

Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by vasco on Friday October 22, 2021 @03:15AM (#28954457)
Read this piece from 1984 addressing this topic. The core point being if you find a group of people with some proximity and they're all lotto winners, as you put it, maybe there's something else to explain it: https://www8.gsb.columbia.edu/articles/columbia-business/sup...
Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by carnitine on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:35AM (#28954273)
Try actually modelling it. People like to hand-wave the outperformers as luck, but the chance of just one of the top firms existing by chance alone is basically impossible.
Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by csee on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:56AM (#28955046)
> Is there any proof of that? Some traders of course will get very rich, just like some lottery-players.

If we're talking about short-term traders, yes. There's firms and traders that make money almost every day of the year.

If we're talking about investors with 4 week+ holding periods, then I agree the evidence is much more flimsy and the luck explanation (or risk premium explanation) can apply very often (or all the time).

Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by Panzer04 on Friday October 22, 2021 @01:44AM (#28954039)
Look up renaissance technologies. More quant than typical investing, but it proves that beating the market is possible
Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by mmmrk on Friday October 22, 2021 @09:17AM (#28956834)
I recently read an interesting German article on them (use Google Translate if necessary) and they paint a more nuanced picture of Renaissance.

https://www.gerd-kommer-invest.de/der-beste-fonds-aller-zeit...

Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by throwaway-hnw on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:01AM (#28954112)
What do you recommend that HNW (well, UHNW if you're talking > 50m) do? Why not also ETFs?
Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by m101 on Friday October 22, 2021 @02:18AM (#28954199)
All funds, on average, get the market return. The certain difference with actively managed ones is that they charge a fee, and may pay more in liquidity costs. It's not surprising therefore most underperform.

In investing, the first thing you have an influence on is avoiding fees (go passive).

The second thing you have an influence on is time (remain invested).

Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by riffraff on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:29AM (#28953759)
An interesting read is also the well known SPIVA report. It's not flawless, but it's quite obvious many hedge funds are not working for you as much as they work for themselves. Which is also what the guy in the article says, incidentally.

https://www.spglobal.com/spdji/en/research-insights/spiva/

Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by 22c on Friday October 22, 2021 @12:35AM (#28953786)
Yes, I've read similar stories and of course Buffet is famous for saying things along similar lines.

For me, I decided to follow Steve Clark's advice of "Do More of What Works and Less of What Doesn't". I invested in a bunch of different things including ETFs, managed funds, futures, individual stock picks, IPOs, etc. and I found managed funds that seemed to work better than ETFs (though 5 years is not really enough time to know for sure), so I pumped more into the managed funds that were working.

Investing only in IPOs seems to work well as well but the hardest part for me was knowing when to sell (which in my case I almost never sell and I often miss the best opportunity to cash out my IPO investments).

I am sure there are some bad managed funds, probably more bad ones than good ones. I'm certainly not saying managed funds are a better choice overall than just going "all-in" on Vanguard, but picking out a few managed funds to try out after doing a couple of hours research is also not a strategy that should be completely written off either, at least in my experience.

Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by didibus on Friday October 22, 2021 @04:55AM (#28955034)
One issue with managed funds is that the people in charge of managing can rotate, so a managed fund doing well now in 10 years could be like a whole different fund, since the employees in charge of managing it could have all changed.
Re:Against the herd: trader Mark Spitznagel on contrarian in... by 22c on Friday October 22, 2021 @05:11PM (#28962780)
Agreed. I know the names of the fund managers I'm invested in and would pay close attention if they ever changed.