[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Random_Walk_Down_Wall_Street
When allocating capital to funds you are being adversely selected against: those who can generate returns probably aren't interested in your money (there's a lot more money in the world than profitable trading/investment opportunities).
As such, I normally recommend to people that unless they are professionals and know that they are doing or HNW (say >50mil), they stick to ETFs for the bulk of their portfolio. To be clear this isn't the optimal strategy, but it's easy and it mostly works.
Is there any proof of that? Some traders of course will get very rich, just like some lottery-players.
If we're talking about short-term traders, yes. There's firms and traders that make money almost every day of the year.
If we're talking about investors with 4 week+ holding periods, then I agree the evidence is much more flimsy and the luck explanation (or risk premium explanation) can apply very often (or all the time).
https://www.gerd-kommer-invest.de/der-beste-fonds-aller-zeit...
In investing, the first thing you have an influence on is avoiding fees (go passive).
The second thing you have an influence on is time (remain invested).
For me, I decided to follow Steve Clark's advice of "Do More of What Works and Less of What Doesn't". I invested in a bunch of different things including ETFs, managed funds, futures, individual stock picks, IPOs, etc. and I found managed funds that seemed to work better than ETFs (though 5 years is not really enough time to know for sure), so I pumped more into the managed funds that were working.
Investing only in IPOs seems to work well as well but the hardest part for me was knowing when to sell (which in my case I almost never sell and I often miss the best opportunity to cash out my IPO investments).
I am sure there are some bad managed funds, probably more bad ones than good ones. I'm certainly not saying managed funds are a better choice overall than just going "all-in" on Vanguard, but picking out a few managed funds to try out after doing a couple of hours research is also not a strategy that should be completely written off either, at least in my experience.
How have they done against the S&P?
https://news.yahoo.com/mark-spitznagel-univesa-cio-on-risk-m...
https://www.institutionalinvestor.com/article/b1nhg4w9k5hjp0...
They made 4000% on the premium paid in, not on capital. No practitioner uses such concept because it's not useful.
Imagine you insure your car worth $20000 and pay $1000 a year in premium. Your car gets totaled and the insurance pays out $10000. You are not going to say "woah my insurance paid out 1000%", as it's a meaningless number. You are going to say: "my insurance paid out 50% of the original car value".
This is the same case, but of course Mr Spitznagel doesn't mind that silly numbers are flying around his fund.
Since they were able to invest only the premium paid in, I don't see why this isn't a useful metric. If they return 4000% on every dollar I give them but I only choose to give them 1% of my wealth, then the lower aggregate returns are on me.
Dividing by a higher notional amount would be justified if the Universea funds could cause investors to lose more than their initial investment, in the same way that futures contracts have a notional value far in excess of their face value. However, I do not think the Universea funds work in this way.
I feel there's a misunderstanding of what Universa is and this keeps confusing people.
Universa is not an alpha fund. You don't give money to Universa with the aim that they'll generate steady income, or even any income. They are basically an insurance product. If nothing happens for 10 years, they'll just steadily lose money (this is expected) in the form of the premium. In fact, in absence of market crashes, the expected value of Universa is negative.
>Dividing by a higher notional amount would be justified if the Universea funds could cause investors to lose more than their initial investment, in the same way that futures contracts have a notional value far in excess of their face value. However, I do not think the Universea funds work in this way.
That's not at all how you think of a tail protection fund like Universa.
The premium is just a constraint, not a risk metric. Say your portfolio makes 10% a year and you are willing to invest 1% of that in protection. That 1% premium spending is your constraint, nothing more. But your risk metric is the capital that you wish to insure, not the premium. It then follows that you should calculate the Universa return as a % of the capital you want to protect, not the premium you spend to protect it.
Exmaple: you have assets worth $100 and you want to spend $1 on protection (Universa). You determine that in a 2020 style market stress event you'd be expected to suffer a 20% drawdown. Beyond protection efficiency analyses, you really don't care what your return on premium is, you care that for the 1% premium spent, your protection is expected to earn enough as a % of your assets that your total drawdowns become manageable. The premium just puts a ceiling on the overall insurance level you can afford for your portfolio, but again for this you need to think in terms of % return of your portfolio value.
Just like other managed funds don’t make promises but market themselves along a certain strategy. They market themselves along a different strategy.
Universa is a fund. They returned 100%+ on every dollar invested. End of story. You can think of them ‘like insurance’ or ‘like a casino’ but it’s ridiculous to pretend they are.
Though it almost seems like luck. If you had asked me 2 years ago, my contrarian funds were in the red.
I think the pandemic has really created both good contrarian opportunities as well as good value investment opportunities; both strategies seem to be working well at the moment.
Also, on average, my "punter" picks do about the same as the contrarian funds although with more wild swings up and down, so for less hair pulling I am tending to move more and more towards managed funds or industry-based ETFs with the occasional punter picks.
I certainly think that having some investments in the contrarian space makes sense as a diversification strategy, but I tend to leave those stock picks up to someone who has made it their day job.