Former enlisted here. Unfortunately death by power point doesn't solve the problem of overworked sailors.
(This happened to us on Ustafish)
It really depends on who dies. Luckily, there are far better ways to solve the problem than by killing someone.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Fitzgerald_and_MV_ACX_Crys...
There's no substitute for looking around (which of course is impossible in a submarine below periscope depth). As a JOOD* underway aboard an aircraft carrier, I had a tendency to spend a lot of time looking at the radar scope. But as soon as I qualified and started standing OOD* watches, I realized that I had switched to constantly scanning the horizon and the flight deck and only occasionally glancing at the radar.
* OOD = Officer of the Deck, the person on watch who's responsible for the safe navigation of the ship for that "watch" (generally, a four-hour period), reporting to the commanding officer. JOOD = Junior Officer of the Deck, in training to be an OOD.
Move to a moving platform.
A lot of our muscle memory and sense help us.
God bless.
this all goes back centuries, back to when navy crews were often kidnapped and made virtual slaves...the navy has always been operated for the benefit of the officer class...
and nowadays we have the issue of lowered standards as well.
This was called "Shanghaiing"[0] or "Impressment"[1] (ala a "press gang") and has an interesting history:
https://www.amusingplanet.com/2018/04/shanghaiing-how-tricke... (also see [3])
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghaiing
I don't think those details have been released on this incident though.
But in the case of subs, aren't there automated warnings and such? Certainly the computers are monitoring the signals as much as the humans.
Certainly the humans shouldn't be overworked, but how does a ultra high end military vehicle (?) strike something?
Re: Sub Sailor
Took y'all long enough to get with the times. The civilian contractors have been doing these for years.
Give me back days of dross PPTs please.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_Vanguard_and_Le_Triomphant...
> The navigation paradox states that increased navigational precision may result in increased collision risk. In the case of ships and aircraft, the advent of Global Positioning System (GPS) navigation has enabled craft to follow navigational paths with such greater precision (often of the order of plus or minus 2 meters), that, without better distribution of routes, coordination between neighboring craft and collision avoidance procedures, the likelihood of two craft occupying the same space on the shortest distance line between two navigational points has increased. [1]
It got to the point on many routes where regulators had to mandate an offset in opposite directions along common flight paths to effect "lanes" of traffic. [2]
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Navigation_paradox
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_lateral_offset_proce...
I saw the story about USS San Francisco earlier today and that led me to reading about the USS Thresher... Really sad story but it led to changes that years later resulted in the USS SF surviving intact. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Thresher_(SSN-593)
If a submarine crashed in to a whale, it would not only have the forces of trying to accelerate the mass of the whale, it has to accelerate an object with a large surface area under water.
Aerodynamics vs hydrodynamics might skew your perception of the forces involved.
Also, this happened underwater, so the harder-to-displace water would give more resistance ("inertia"?) to the whale maybe?
In the debates surrounding some of the most recent incidents (see, e.g., https://www.propublica.org/series/navy-accidents-pacific-7th...) I remember reading claims to the effect that submarine captains are the last ones in the Navy who actually know how to pilot a boat. I know that claim is hyperbolic rhetoric but those Pro Publica pieces really make me think it's not far from the truth, and that while submariner training may still be exceptionally rigorous and responsive to newly identified risks, that's not necessarily true in the case of surface ships.
We operated that way even when steaming on the surface in the shipping lanes shared with the Port of New York.
So it isn't always a matter of "actually knowing how to pilot a boat". Sometimes its just plain recklessness.
Edit: this one
https://features.propublica.org/navy-uss-mccain-crash/navy-i...
But submarines don't spend a heck of a lot of time on the surface where piloting skill matters. They stay submerged through the Straits of Gibraltar, the Straits of Hormuz, a lot of the Red Sea, etc. Submarines are slow on the surface and appear much smaller than they really are, so it's generally best for everyone if they go underneath or around chokepoints.
Theoretically yeah, but radar is pretty great for resolving ambiguity.
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/98/USS_Los_...
To answer your first question, a significant amount of RCS for a capable commercial radar, not least of all because it is rounded for hydrodynamics, which is a terrible shape for minimizing RCS.
Second, I should have been clearer: the submarine stands to gain by operating their own radar rather than working from sonar alone.
Finally, submerged transits are mostly advantageous for security concerns.
Given that there is a collision about to happen, isn't there a sensor that would give some type of warning? And I'm guessing that the answer to my stupid question is that a sensor would give away the position of the submarine because anything emitting a signal would defeat the point of the sub?
Is this how the Navy deals with accidents? I can understand being fired for failing to do your duty but operating a sub is both hard and dangerous. Things are going to go wrong. If everyone did their job isn’t this just a learning opportunity?
But if you're the captain of a ship that's at fault in a crash? The inadequacies revealed in the crew's training are kinda your fault.
For example, in 2017 when the USS Fitzgerald collided with a container ship [1] and the captain was relieved of his command, despite the fact he'd been in bed during the collision.
It's normal, in 95% of jobs, that if you cause $$$$$$$$ of damage by making a mistake, you get fired.
I imagine it'd be like being on a glacier, hitting another glacier.
Ding ding! "Knuckledragger, arriving!"
(For those mystified: This is an inside joke.)
Is there any reason why they can't check what's above them before ascending?
This was a contributing factor to a collision in the Mediterranean about a decade or so ago.
And Iron Mike probably had the conn aboard the cargo ship .... (Source: A similar experience in the South China Sea.)
From what I overheard in cafeterias frequented navy navy men while living in Vladivostok is that active sonar is used all the time unless deep blue waters.
Navigational active sonars are nowhere near as detectable as long range military ones.
It's the "flashlight in the dark room" problem. Your sonar ping has to travel to an object and reflect back to the submarine. But an adversary just needs to hear the original ping to know what direction it came from, so you can be detected at a longer distance, and potentially a much longer distance, than you could reliably detect the other submarine at.
That's not to say active sonar is never used, but at least with the U.S. it's not going to be continuously used, and it's going to be rare to use it if you're in a mission area.
A sonar transducer that can emit a ping with directionality is sometimes useful (e.g. a fathometer to measure depth to the ocean bottom, since the crushing pressure of the depths ensures the area below you is generally clear of enemy subs), and those are used. But even there, that wouldn't be useful for navigating when otherwise blind; you use fathometers to confirm that you're approximately in the area you think you're in based on the chart readings.
I mean the difference is possibly hundreds of metres to hundreds of kilometres in between navigational sonars, vs sub detection sonars.
Also pressure proofing cameras are not cheap I presume.
You can see it in the last Smarter Every Day video[1] where they're talking about surfacing a submarine in the arctic ocean.
At several points you can see a video monitor showing an upward view of the ice.
[1] https://youtu.be/XFJnWp1tAdU?t=1427
e: to be clear, that upward looking camera isn't going to be enough to detect much beyond your own footprint. If someone is about to cross that area you'd need some other way of detecting them.
This is because they need to stay undetected, and rely completely on passive sensors; which can be dicey.
The inputs they'd be able to use would include:
1. GNSS location (only if surfaced)
2. Passive sonar data (detecting location of electromagnetic signals through water e.g. acoustic noise of another ships propeller)
3. Active sonar data (only if stealth is unnecessary)
4. Radar data (only if surfaced)
5. Bathymetry models/charts[2] (accuracy depends on location in the world)
6. Tide prediction models[3] (availability is location dependent)
7. Inertial navigation sensors (dead reckoning so accuracy drifts over time)
8. Surface Electronic Support Measures sensors (allows geolocation of signals from other ships, aircraft and ground transmitters)
[1] https://osimaritime.com/solutions/software/ecpins-submarine/
[2] https://www.admiralty.co.uk/digital-services/digital-charts/...
[3] https://www.admiralty.co.uk/publications/admiralty-digital-p...
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLjHf9jaFs8XWoGULb2HQRvhzB...
- how submarine systems work: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLF9K78gj2FP2fDVRu_Bkc...
- sonar acoustic signal analyses: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLF9K78gj2FP2D-EIZkYN1...
- overview of sub classes: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLF9K78gj2FP0hID8jeOp_...
If you're up at periscope depth you can stick a periscope up to see and other antennas. If you're on the surface you typically send people up into the sail and the boat is commanded from there. (Only a couple people fit up there, so the people actually operating the rudder and navigating are belowdecks).
Overall you generally get a good indication of what's happening, but... it's definitely possible to be surprised.
This increase in recent collisions (including training jets) is probably due to the Navy's "five and dimes" sleep schedule that basically guarantees every squid mustang and sardine is a combat worthless zombie due to sleep depravation.
https://www.usni.org/magazines/proceedings/2017/july/let-our...
But there was one piece of equipment on board that normally runs for ~20-30minutes at a time. It had to run continuously until the ship came into port or the submarine would have sank and 130+ people would have died. They got VERY lucky everything worked out.
Silly question: how do you identify a target? Sound only? It seems like you would want something visual.
During sea trials of a new boat, they have it do passes specifically for sonar to listen to it. Partly so they can learn its sound signature, but also to see if they can hear annomalies during construction. They've found toolboxes left inside a double hull by the builders.
They do have visuals with the waterfall displays and what not. Last I looked into sonar operations was in the early 90s, so not sure what the kids are using now.
They can do all of this without making a sound to allow someone else to know they are there.
The Navy trains to do a series of maneuvers that helps you understand the range to the ships you do hear, and positions the sub most safely to come to periscope depth. And then while you're coming to periscope depth you're looking out to see if there are any indications you've screwed up. But yeah, there's nothing visual available when you're under the water.
My understanding is that US subs don’t travel in packs, so anything they detect is generally the enemy, and especially so if it’s submerged, unless they are escorting a carrier.
It could be hitting the bottom of the ocean (which nearly killed 130+ people on the USS San Francisco years ago - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_San_Francisco_(SSN-711)#Co...), it could be hitting another ship above it (coming to and/or operating at periscope depth is dangerous), or potentially another sub.
Invariably people get fired, and whatever happens becomes a lesson learned that the Navy trains on in the future.