News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by Andrew_nenakhov on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:28PM (#28731286)
If such efforts are not curbstomped early, we'll end up with fully closed computing devices architecture, belonging to different vendors who provide whole vertical from bare metal to OS. There will be Google's processors/OS/software, Apple's, Samsung's, plus some shit CCP will come up with, like, TikToks, and all of them will be mutually incompatible, with own programming languages and data formats. The future looks bleak.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by Lex-2008 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:40PM (#28731380)
> all of them will be mutually incompatible, with own programming languages and data formats. The future looks bleak.

Server hardware had (still has somewhere): SPARC from Sun, PowerPC from IBM, HPPA from HP, etc... See for example list of supported architectures for Debian4: https://www.debian.org/releases/etch/hppa/ch02s01.html.en

But it feels like amd64 is winning today. Don't you think that eventually one of these architectures you're talking about (Google's, Apple's, Samsung's, CCP's) will win over others, one way or another?

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by mattnewton on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:48PM (#28731436)
Only if they have an incentive to sell it as a commodity.

x86_64 didn’t win on technical superiority alone.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by shepherdjerred on Saturday October 02, 2021 @07:26PM (#28733078)
amd64 is going to lose to arm64. arm64 is significantly cheaper in a server context.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by NavinF on Sunday October 03, 2021 @03:08AM (#28735152)
Is it though? I can't find any new ARM server CPUs for sale anywhere. I can assure you that "request a quote" pricing is anything but cheap.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by hansel_der on Sunday October 03, 2021 @04:19AM (#28735459)
i'd guess there are about an order of magnitude more arm devices on the planet than intel/amd64.

it's called "ARMada" for a reason

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by heavyset_go on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:06PM (#28731597)
If you're developer, it's guaranteed that these companies will attempt to capture 15% to 30% of all of your revenue on these platforms, too. They already do it with phones and tablets.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by jb1991 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:36PM (#28731344)
How bad is that, though? The success and impressive performance, battery life, temperature of the Apple M1 suggests that this kind of integration can have outstanding results. So there are tradeoffs, at least.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by beckman466 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:38PM (#28731366)
Apple M1 didn't come out of nowhere, they learned from everything that came before. Your comment sort of implies that the innovations came solely from being developed behind closed doors (or in some kind of vacuum), which denies credit to workers who made the thousands of incremental breakthroughs that landed in the commons and which has helped us to arrive in the place we are now.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by ketzo on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:58PM (#28731535)
No, GP made a pretty specific point: that vertical integration can clearly provide some serious benefits in the realm of computer hardware.

Now, the fact that vertical integration usually implies closed doors is relevant, yeah; but I don't think anyone is denying credit anywhere, and I think it's important to acknowledge upsides.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by 8note on Saturday October 02, 2021 @07:03PM (#28732906)
I think there's a stronger argument that breaking backwards compatibility allows for big increases in performance
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by Jensson on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:21PM (#28732639)
> impressive performance, battery life, temperature of the Apple M1

From my perspective Apple just made it so non Apple hardware couldn't get fast CPU's for another year.

M1 is a 5nm CPU that is faster than 7nm low power CPU's, and uses less power than 7nm high power CPU's, but to me it isn't obvious that it will perform significantly better than others 5nm low power CPU's when those hits the market. Others 5nm will hit the market once Apples contracts to use all 5nm fabs runs out, but before then we are stuck with only Apple having that tech.

You might think that this situation sounds great, but it doesn't look that great to me. I'd prefer if Apple didn't work to lock in hardware components and tech as they do.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by yazaddaruvala on Saturday October 02, 2021 @11:56PM (#28734422)
I feel you’re missing the fact that Apple fund’s TSMC to build 5nm and now 3nm at scale.

Yes without Apple’s money TSMC would have still built 5nm, but likely a few years later.

ex. https://wccftech.com/apple-secures-3nm-tsmc-chip-production/

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by Jensson on Sunday October 03, 2021 @01:31AM (#28734767)
Ok, but I still don't see how M1 performance is evidence that this kind if integration is a great thing? Rather M1 is evidence that excessive money from one area can be used to expand your influence in other areas. Rather, the "tight integration" here has nothing to do with technical bits but instead economic, Apple can guarantee funds for them since they have money from other parts of the stack. Funds of that scale doesn't exist for many other companies, except Google. Google could also do something like that and compete with Apple, which might be why Google is now entering this space?
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by yazaddaruvala on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @05:26AM (#28757080)
> Ok, but I still don't see how M1 performance is evidence that this kind if integration is a great thing?

Because humanity and every company now has access to 5nm infrastructure? Because Apple created the greatest marketing campaign TSMC ever benefited from? Because Apple proved that custom silicon design is no longer fools gold and can be profitable and competitive? Because Apple showcased that more instruction parallelism, heterogeneous core types, co-processors, etc are all beneficial design choices and every competing company can take advantage of them? Because Intel is now competing with TSMC? Because AMD and Intel might lose the monopoly on x86 and need to compete? Because Rosetta 2 and universal binaries pave the way for Apple to invest and eventually transition to RISC-5 or …?

Do you not see any of these points as great? If not, why not? I’ll use your reasons to try to come up with better examples.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by fendy3002 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @10:05PM (#28733929)
If only they make them vendor locked and not following specification.

I guess that spareparts are harder to get and third party repairing will be almost non existent. It'll also make new competitors with good concepts harder to come into industry (steam deck, framework laptop).

Imagine if every car vendor (bmw, mercedes, toyota, etc) start making a very specific tire that can only be used by their own model.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by Andrew_nenakhov on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:17PM (#28731708)
What good are performance and battery life if you don't get to decide which apps you are permitted to run on this device?

Does the recent removal of apps [1] from russian appstore ring some bells?

[1]: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/17/world/europe/russia-naval...

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by ajconway on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:01PM (#28732048)
> What good are performance and battery life

For the average consumer — everything.

I'm kind of torn between the two opinions. I wish my iPhone would be able to run anything I want to run. I also recognize that nobody forced me to buy this iPhone.

Mobile phones are mandated to have emergency calling functionality. Maybe in the future we'll have some "general purpose computing as a human right" law.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by Andrew_nenakhov on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:37PM (#28732307)
> For the average consumer — everything.

> I'm kind of torn between the two opinions.

I am not torn. Because of us two, apparently only one lives in an authoritarian country. When your computing device blocks you from accessing anything not praising the current regime, it kinda devalues the user-friendly interface and manufacturing quality. Shiny chains are still chains.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by ajconway on Sunday October 03, 2021 @01:27AM (#28734751)
Well, that’s a different kind of issue. Should politics have anything to do with mandating which technologies have the right to exist? The Internet itself enables global surveillance by sufficiently funded actors, but it also makes this conversation possible. I like my internet, I don’t want it to go.

I also welcome tech companies trying to extract every tiny bit of performance from the silicon that powers computing today. It may lead to developing something incompatible with existing solutions, but surely no regime on this planet is to blame here.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by jb1991 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:22PM (#28731752)
Assuming we are talking about the desktop, you can run whatever you’d like. The App Store is just one avenue for software distribution on the Mac. The situation is of course different on iOS.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by sneak on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:40PM (#28731892)
> Assuming we are talking about the desktop, you can run whatever you’d like.

Only sometimes. Have you ever tried unlocking a Pixelbook to run a different OS?

It needs a custom cable and significant RE efforts by the community.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by jb1991 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:07PM (#28732101)
Sorry, I thought the question was a critique of macOS, not the Pixelbook, and I offered a clarification that macOS is actually pretty open and you can run whatever app you like, in most cases.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by sneak on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:50PM (#28732390)
For the moment. You also can't run any of the iOS apps (an advertised feature of macOS on M1) if you disable SIP, so this isn't really a true statement logically speaking.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by linux_is_nice on Saturday October 02, 2021 @07:52PM (#28733260)
For what it's worth, another option for disabling the write-protect is to temporarily remove the battery.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by haberman on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:06PM (#28732095)
The people reverse engineering the M1 found that it uses an architecture that will likely make it easier (not harder) for Linux to support new generations of Apple hardware as it is released: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28183176
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by capitalsigma on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:19PM (#28731720)
This is literally what competition looks like, the opposite of a monopoly. Isn't that what we all want?
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by dvdkon on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:47PM (#28731938)
Yes, it's certainly better than a Qualcomm monoculture would be. But ideally competition on CPUs would happen in the CPU market, instead of in the target product market with lots of vertical integration.

In a world where all device manufacturers design (or even fab) their own CPUs and make their own software/cloud services (we're already there in some ways, sadly), any newcomer would have to start with transistors and work their way up to a long-term cloud ecosystem. That probably won't happen any time soon, standalone chip designers will continue to be competitive or at least good enough, but you can see how proprietary chips can actually make competition harder in some ways.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by fendy3002 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @10:08PM (#28733942)
If it's vendor locked, then it'll be vendor-scoped monopoly rather than global-scoped monopoly. If Microsoft start manufacturing their own CPU and locking the OS for their model only, it can be said that Microsoft monopolize the windows hardware market.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by dehrmann on Saturday October 02, 2021 @09:37PM (#28733806)
I'd prefer a handful of architectures driven by industry groups. A competition free-for-all optimizes for architecture advancements and better software from vertically integrated players, but limits software from smaller players.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by anyfactor on Sunday October 03, 2021 @01:58AM (#28734855)
I was watching a podcast interview of one of the founders of Wikipedia. He was describing the effects of creeping control over Wikipedia and the definitive ideological narrative being set on the internet through Wikipedia. It is a very interesting interview but the thing that most surprised me is that he talks about how he has a personal server to host his website.

Of all the things he said, I found that simple idea to be the most surprising. The internet is already being dominated by a handful of cloud providers, few domain registers and select social media.

It is damn difficult to go against the tide and even though we are falling off a cliff.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by anyfactor on Sunday October 03, 2021 @04:59AM (#28735633)
Link to the video: https://youtu.be/l0P4Cf0UCwU
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by McP on Sunday October 03, 2021 @03:41AM (#28735307)
Sounds like an interesting interview. Do you have a link?
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by anyfactor on Sunday October 03, 2021 @04:58AM (#28735630)
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by yellow_lead on Saturday October 02, 2021 @08:35PM (#28733478)
> all of them will be mutually incompatible, with own programming languages and data formats. The future looks bleak.

Isn't it already like this? We already have to make our apps in Obj C / Swift for iOS and Java/Kotlin for Android. You can use C/C++ libraries but you typically need to recompile them anyways. So if iOS or Android switch to different CPU architectures what's the problem? We will have to change our build processes, but the platforms are already fragmented.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by VLM on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:16PM (#28732156)
> and all of them will be mutually incompatible, with own programming languages and data formats

All of them will be 100% compatible with SaaS over the internet offerings, no end user will notice.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by Andrew_nenakhov on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:52PM (#28732824)
Unless the internet will be fractured into 'google's net', 'Apple space', 'TikTok realm', 'Microsoft fief'. If you think that this will never ever happen, think again. Not so long ago some SaaS internet offerings worked only on one operating system and on one infamous browser.

Once you are deep in a vendor lock-in, you are trapped to use whatever he allows you to.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by vbezhenar on Sunday October 03, 2021 @07:10AM (#28736222)
It might happen, but so far all most of the tech giants did not enforce their position despite being able to do so. I can browse porn from iPhone Safari, what a scandal. Surely they had an idea of building a curated whitelist which would satisfy a majority of users, but they did not follow that idea so far.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by oblio on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:36PM (#28732720)
Yeah? How are progressive web apps working on iOS?
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by kevin_thibedeau on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:39PM (#28731374)
DEC, Sun, IBM, and many others did this. The world still survived.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by kwertyoowiyop on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:46PM (#28731422)
And for the most part, they did not.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by oblio on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:38PM (#28732739)
The new corps learned from the old corps. I'm not sure <<we>>'re going to survive them.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by 5faulker on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:38PM (#28731364)
Maybe we should start with universal cable format first. Seems easier to implement.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by user-the-name on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:30PM (#28732259)
This is what computing used to be. It wasn't bleak, and I would say it was a lot more interesting. Most of the retro computers that people remember with great fondness were like this.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by kovek on Sunday October 03, 2021 @01:13AM (#28734693)
Will it be possible to one day make custom orders to the fabs for custom designs at very low volume?
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by wmf on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:33PM (#28731316)
Chrombooks are pretty open, although totally non-standard.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by spankalee on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:23PM (#28731764)
What's non-standard about them, and compared to what exactly?
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by wmf on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:47PM (#28731937)
They don't use UEFI/ACPI like every other PC.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by surajrmal on Saturday October 02, 2021 @07:11PM (#28732963)
They use ACPI. Not using UEFI was a perfectly reasonable choice. The bootloader is fully open source, led to improvements in boot speed and security. Booting non-chromeos images is possible and reasonably well documented. A standard bootloader may seem nice from an interoperability standpoint, but I'm not sure UEFI is a great place to land.
[dead]
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by unknownOrigin on Saturday October 02, 2021 @08:27PM (#28733439)
How about no. How about people use curbstomp whenever they damn please. I'm very well aware of what you're implying and what you're trying to do here. Poison the well, police the conversation. Just like the OK sign just means "ok", curbstomp just means curbstomp. The fact that someone somewere used these things in a racist context means nothing, as these words/signs are not racist at all. Racists also use toilet paper, are we going to ban it? How about air or water. No, all of these attempts to police and cancel speech need to go to hell.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by wffurr on Saturday October 02, 2021 @08:37PM (#28733499)
It literally means a horrible violent act which has no place in a conversation about computer chips in any way shape or form.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by rgarrett88 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @08:43PM (#28733535)
GP didn't even call it racist just mentioned a movie. Racist rant just came out of no where...
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by colordrops on Saturday October 02, 2021 @09:14PM (#28733695)
There was a clear implication, let's be honest here. Extreme violence is a normal part of our culture - young kids watch hulk smash violently in marvel movies and no one bats an eye. The reason strong offense is being taken here is because of the racist context of the violence in the movie.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by COGlory on Saturday October 02, 2021 @11:26PM (#28734295)
It's a metaphor, is it not? Akin to "kill it with fire"
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by SquareWheel on Saturday October 02, 2021 @10:22PM (#28734006)
Yeah. I haven't seen the movie, but I recoiled just reading the sentence. It was a very graphically violent term to use here.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by Andrew_nenakhov on Sunday October 03, 2021 @07:06AM (#28736195)
Thank you for your concern. I have seen that scene, and similar scene from Sopranos. This is the exact meaning that I think is appropriate in this context (a horrible violent act aimed at a victim to stop him once and for all from having certain ideas), because the danger to the society from such initiatives is that severe.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by wffurr on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:09AM (#28737254)
That’s really horrible that you think that a company commissioning custom computer chips somehow deserves violence.

I don’t know why anyone would possibly think that’s ever ok. Or why you would think that’s possibly ever appropriate to invoke in a discussion about computer chips or anything other than the act itself.

If your intent was to invoke a visceral reaction in the reader that causes the rest of your point to be completely ignored, then well done. Otherwise, if you want to actually communicate your ideas in a civilized fashion, please reconsider your choices.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by Andrew_nenakhov on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:41AM (#28737543)
You should probably look up for things called metaphors and hyperboles. Rhetorical devices are used by people in order to make their speech less boring and bland.

Computer chips have no literal teeth that can be taken out during curbstomping. However, companies DO have figurative poisonous teeth that harm society, and those CAN be taken out. And they should.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by zucker42 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:39PM (#28731372)
Is it that much of a problem as long as alternate OSes can be installed by the user? For example, the M1 chip can run Linux. I don't see how Apple and Google producing their own chips is much different as a consumer than the Windows/x86 monoculture that's existed for a long time.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by retrac on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:41PM (#28731392)
The M1 can run Linux after an extensive reverse-engineering effort. And Apple didn't take particular active measures to prevent running your own OS on it; they just didn't offer any help. Many Android device manufacturers actively try to prevent that. Apple actively tries to prevent it on iOS devices. Some early Chromebooks actively tried to prevent it, too. (Though not Google's own flagship developer devices.)
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by runjake on Saturday October 02, 2021 @03:43PM (#28731406)
> For example, the M1 chip can run Linux.

No, not in any useful form it can’t.

And any architectural changes could require another lengthy reverse engineering process rendering these devices unbootable with non-Apple OSes until then.

I would not be surprised if Apple completely closes off the Mac ARM64 platform for “security” in the next few years. The option to boot third-party OSes seems like a short-term gimme to keep the pitchforks and torches at bay.

I make this distinction because this is precisely the issue being discussed.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by easton on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:56PM (#28732854)
There was too much engineering work put in to make the M1 be still secure by default while allowing you to run other OSes. If Apple wanted to make it so you could only run signed kernels then the best time to make that breaking change would’ve been when the first Apple Silicon macs were released, not three or four years down the road when suddenly they say “throw away that bespoke firmware and all that special security work we did, just load the iPhone bits on there”.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by yjftsjthsd-h on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:28PM (#28731805)
>> For example, the M1 chip can run Linux.

> No, not in any useful form it can’t.

Yes, it can? Ex. https://www.tomshardware.com/news/apple-m1-debian-linux - you're welcome to point out that drivers for the rest of the system are a WIP, but the CPU is fine and the rest is coming along.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by runjake on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:08PM (#28732106)
Try it on a physical Mac Mini machine and tell me it’s useful.

Progress is being made by REs such as marcan and others but it’s not useful, yet. And I speculate that by the time it is solid, the M1X/M2 machines will be out and a bunch of additional REing will be done.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by ducktective on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:41PM (#28731897)
In other news, Nvidia's support for Linux is "coming along™" and Lenovo says drivers for fingerprint auth for thinkpads is just-around-the-corner®
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by zucker42 on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:24PM (#28732219)
Nvidia actively prevents open source support through firmware signing.
Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by drekipus on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:29PM (#28731814)
If I remember correctly that's similar what the PS3 did, but that's a different issue and comes with cool discussions

This talk is about the PS4, similar in concept https://youtube.com/watch?v=QMiubC6LdTA

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by heavyset_go on Saturday October 02, 2021 @04:09PM (#28731626)
> Is it that much of a problem as long as alternate OSes can be installed by the user? For example, the M1 chip can run Linux.

And yet you can't run alternate OSes on iPhones and iPads because of Apple's efforts to make sure that you can't.

We're relying on the goodwill of companies that have all the financial incentives in the world to lock users out of the hardware they own, and those are the same companies that already lock users out of their mobile devices.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by Shorel on Saturday October 02, 2021 @10:28PM (#28734034)
That's precisely the issue.

Alternate OSes can't access all hardware functions.

We already have that problem with Linux support for battery life and hibernate.

It doesn't work in the vast majority of laptops, while with Windows it does.

It also happens with Smartphones, to the point that alternate OSes for Smartphones have trouble doing the most basic functions, like making calls and using GPS.

Just because it can be installed, it doesn't mean that everything will magically work.

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by zucker42 on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:55AM (#28736829)
> We already have that problem with Linux support for battery life and hibernate.

> It doesn't work in the vast majority of laptops, while with Windows it does.

That's kind of my point. The status quo is already not ideal, this doesn't seem necessarily worse than the status quo, as long as Apple and Google aren't overly restrictive in preventing alternate OSes (which of course is a big if).

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by oblio on Saturday October 02, 2021 @06:37PM (#28732731)
> For example, the M1 chip can run Linux.

Can it run native Windows?

Re:Google developing own CPUs for Chromebook laptops by rdsnsca on Saturday October 02, 2021 @09:40PM (#28733826)
Apple said they would do drivers for a new version of Bootcamp if Microsoft had a non OEM version consumers could buy. So the ball is in Microsoft court.