"The only jobs that are sustainable are the jobs that produce something that other people actually want."
This is exactly it. You can not stimulate an economy simply by pushing up production on the supply side.
Mark Cuban's idea seems appealing on the surface, but he makes a serious assumption. He implicitly assumes a positive net benefit after you give these companies money and they create jobs with this money.
Look, if you transfer money from the government to the companies to the people then that is just a transfer payment. Moving money around like that does not create wealth within a country, and that is what we need right now. We need to spend money on things that generate positive net present value, and we need to curtail spending money on things that do not meet this criteria.
In order for Mark Cuban's idea to work, all of these companies must be employing the additional labor towards activities that are economically profitable. Here's a quick thought exercise. What is the likelihood of a company being engaged in economically profitable activities given that it is taking advantage of this program? (It is reasonable to assume that a company with a healthy balance sheet and a healthy income would not want to deal with government bureaucracy willingly.)
Also, as a side note, the following quote from the blog post is a bit inaccurate:
"(Stunningly, bailouts excluded)."
That the bank bailouts were repaid so handily owes very little to the bailouts themselves. Thanks to extraordinary measures taken by the Federal Reserve, the banks were able to borrow money at an interest rate of virtually nothing and then use this money to purchase U.S. bonds - effectively lending it back to the U.S. government. In addition to this, the Federal Reserve also took the unusual step of dramatically expanding its balance sheet (removing toxic liabilities from the banks themselves). That was the real bailout, and it was much larger than the pithy amounts that you saw reported by the administration.
To get a sense of the scale and size of the real bailout, please take a look at this graph:
http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2009/05/07/fed-balance-she...
Edit: Also, I forgot to mention one more thing. The current negative rates on U.S. debt would almost certainly change if we began to issue substantially more of it. As Europe is rapidly learning, the debt market is far from a static environment.
The point is that we have an opportunity to do responsible investing. I am sympathetic to the argument that the US government is incapable of doing responsible investing. So who is, and how can we get them to act on the US government's behalf so that we all benefit?
Is growth economics the only answer? What about creating a sustainable economy that isn't dependent on infinite growth of wealth?
In some parts of Europe, de-growth movement is quite popular and proposes to shift the focus of government policies from economic growth to population well-being (how this is reached lends itself to debates).
It doesn't mean to stop medical research or technical research, it means stopping to envision growth as being only economic growth. Growth can be seen as progress of human indicators, not the accumulation of things and economic growth for the sake of economic growth (which more and more benefits only rich people).
It originates in the simple fact that the economy can not grow infinitely in a finite world.
That is not to say working less is always a major goal, if someone was doing 20 hour work weeks for 30k they would probably rather have 20 hour work weeks that pay 60k than 10 hour work weeks that pay 20k. The great thing about free markets is they let people balance many of those less tangible goals. However, government policy can easily focus on progress that is out of whack with what people actually want so an understanding that the Chinese population might tolerate more pollution for more growth were an American population cares more about clean air than maximizing growth is nessesary to keep people happy.
The US searched growth in the 2000 at every price, even at the price of over-lending. That is where growth dominates everything at the price of well being, society consistency and eventually economy - see the 2008 crash.
And some people are so ingenious, they'll get richer no matter what you do. To make the typical voter's income at least stay even, the average has to go up then.
1) Bank owns asset of dubious value, classifies it as "Level 3 Assets" which allows it to value it using an undisclosed method that has no correlation with the reality of a burst housing/credit bubble. This also allows the bank to hide its true financial state by escaping writedowns.
2) Market for these assets is dead, especially since government bailed out Fannie and Freddie, driving investors to a new "low-risk" market (government backed mortgage securities) and away from non-government backed securities.
3) Fed offers PPIP to buy up this trash. As a side effect, this effectively lowers the risk of these dubiously valued securities
4) Security of dubious value increases in value, is sold to Fed for profit (sometimes even twice its original level 3 valuation, which already had nothing to do with reality). Fed purchased security using mix of private investor and US Taxpayer funds (such as the Treasury)
5) Fed refuses to reveal the method of valuation for securities, preventing people from knowing how much profit the banks made, and how much the Fed lost out (including US Taxpayer money)
Conclusion: Fed now owns toxic security, bank escapes consequences of poor decisions and/or fraud, Taxpayer money is wasted buying assets for a heck of a lot more than they are actually worth in the real market, barring a resurgence of the housing bubble.
I recommend reading the following article which talks about the failures of PPIP: http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2011/01/richard-alford-why-ha...
That said Keynes's primary point was that governments should invest and spend money wisely to do stuff the private sector can't or won't do.
======================================
You and I can agree that we'd love to live in a world where people pursue employment due to interest and/or a drive to make the world/economy better. That's not the world we live in, and I don't know how we get there from here.
Lastly, markets are manipulable and are manipulated, and governments aren't the only actors doing so.
I think this is why most public assistance programs in America have been tied to 'service' of one kind or another. It's why social security is at least partly tied to your taxes while you were working. We've got our pride; and yeah, I agree it's irrational, but that's just the way many of us are.
Actually, I got one of those hiring bonuses last year; I mean, I didn't know that I'd get it, and it was only a few hundred dollars, so it didn't factor in to the hiring decision, but I did make someone an actual employee, and my accountant told me I got a credit for it. (The guy was a contractor before, but he did get a substantial raise, and a steady salary rather than a varying paycheck based on hours worked.)
We do, and in fact it is necessarily so. See "Invisible Hand": (the following is a quote from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Invisible_hand )
the invisible hand was created by the conjunction of the forces of self-interest, competition, and supply and demand, which he noted as being capable of allocating resources in society. This is the founding justification for the Austrian laissez-faire economic philosophy, but is also frequently seen in neoclassical and Keynesian economics. The central disagreement between economic ideologies is, in a sense, a disagreement about how powerful the "invisible hand" is.
Before making any such broad assumptions please do read some of the Austrians and, why not, even Marx? First of all, like any true Marxist would be first to tell you, there is no "true Marxist".
The reason being that people are still in doubt, was Marx preaching for a sudden proletarian revolution (so, no support for the bourgeois economy and social doctrines, and under this light Keynes is as far from Marxism as Adam Smith himself), or for a gradual improvement of the workers' living conditions, followed by a voluntary surrender of power by the bourgeois middle-class to the lumpen-proletariat? Nobody knows.
And don't get me started on what socialist believes might have convinced Lenin that the capitalist-looking NEP (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Economic_Policy) was an acceptable thing in order to support the proletarian revolution.
Economics is more like politics, if politicians were any good at math.
Not because I think that his thoughts are necessarily the solution but because the lack of constructive criticism.
First of all I didn't read the post to say "this is to solution to end all solutions" but rather here is an idea could it work.
Second how is this a top down approach in any classical sense? His claims is that the companies who think they can create jobs with more money, exist out there and he want the find a mechanism to find them instead of simply distributing at large across the system and see what happens.
Third the US is probably the best country in the world to be an entrepreneur and business. There is very little in the way for anyone to find a need and then go out and build a business around it and there is a huge market for that. If your claim is that it can only be solved by making that part easier then the entire premise of capitalism seems flawed (I don't believe it is and I am not saying you are claiming that either)
The problem fundamentally is that you can only adjust your metrics so far before they become meaningless.
The first step to get the US out of their debt is to raise taxes. That won't make the startup environment better but it will start showing that the US as a country are ready to pay their bills instead of speculating their way out of it.
And before you start calling me a socialist and other nasty things let me just pre-empt this by the following.
I live in Denmark, a country with a progressive tax system +55% tax for the highest incomes and a sales tax of 25%. A car here cost 3 times the amount of a car in the US all because of taxes.
I am a member of the only liberal (in the european sense) political party and is fighting to get lower taxes.
So I am not saying raise taxes lightly. I am simply saying that the US have reached a point where the low tax is working against them not for them.
All systems have thresholds especially economic ones. To keep wanting more of the same ends up creating a self sustaining effect after you reach a certain point. The US have reached that now.
Someone have to pick up the bill and I have a hard time seeing who that could be besides the american taxpayers.
And just because it hasn't been done before is obvious no natural law
The money that you save by not having a military, can go to buying other goods that those ex-soldiers can provide.
I think Cuban was right that we do have a spending problem. We spend too much on things that are not important. We should cut debt, but the debate around this issue has been framed as a false and confusing dichotomy by the two major political parties.
Give anyone some money and they'll save it, not spend it. They'll save it because next week milk and eggs will be more expensive, while houses and electronics will be less expensive. on craigslist. nobody is buying new stuff when the guy down the street is selling his PS3 to make rent.
Essentials are increasing in price. Luxuries are decreasing.
What company is going to create jobs in this environment? And what if you did create jobs making more of X: now X is cheaper. Deflation.
We need inflation. And that means pissing off the Chinese.
We need to accurately price assets. And that means letting some banks fail.
Most have 2 weeks of savings or less.
If you give somebody money who is already a saver and who already appreciates the virtues of saving -- like myself or probably you -- yes, I'd save it. But that's because I spend a fixed amount, have no debt, and save excess income.
If you give a small windfall (I dunno, $100 to $5,000) to most american families, that money will be spent. Probably a good chunk towards paying down household debt, and the rest to fixing things that have long been neglected. That could be the family car, a leaky roof, etc.
Savings should be the most obvious. You're not going to save your money by hiding it under your mattress. You're going to at least put it into a bank, of not invest in equity or debt instruments. In all of these cases, the money is going right back into the economy to be used productively. If you put it into a bank, they'll loan it back out to someone in a mortgage or such. Equity investment directly fund businesses. And so on. So when you're saving, you're really redirecting the money to someone who believes he has a use for it -- and who believes strongly enough that they're willing to pay for the right to try it. And this is actually what the OP wanted in the first place, but the current system has better controls for ensuring that the money is used productively.
If I spend the money -- say, on a leaky roof, as you suggest -- then that money is going to the roofing contractor, and thence to his employees and the producers of the shingles and other materials. Again, it's being used productively.
Less obvious is if I spend the money on a TV, for example. Some of that money goes to the retailer. But much of it is going to, say, a Chinese company that makes it. This gets into more economic theory like "comparative advantage", which I'm not going to explain here, but simply state that in the bottom line it still makes us better off. People will protest that this contributes to the so-called "trade deficit". In the case of this discussion (at the very least), that trade deficit is a good thing. If we (collectively, somehow, for the sake of simplicity) owe a Chinese company some money, that is precisely the same thing as them pumping stimulus money into our economy! Perhaps you buy a Japanese car; that "trade deficit" is actually executed by, say, Toyota using the "owed" money to build a factory in America, and that again is exactly what we want.
Except that they aren't.
http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/EXCRESNS
The banks just stuff them into a safe haven. Hence the phrase "Pushing on a string".
Your roofing contractor might pay his employees, or he might try to do more with less people and pay off some debt. Or they might pay of some debt.
As soon as that money enters the bank, its gone, as far as the economy is concerned. It used to be that money was passed along in a long chain of transactions. Now there is a non-zero probability that at any point in the chain, the money goes into a bank to pay off debt, and at that point, its gone for good.
How do we change the bank's behavior? We have to create an economy where loaning out money is the only way to preserve value, instead of the opposite.
Fixing things doesn't help with deflation either.
Benanke did his disseration on the Great Depression and essentially stated that to fight price deflation they should have used monetary inflation. That's what we're doing. They don't even publish the M3 anymore but estimates are that the currency printing presses are going at full speed. The problem that Ben didn't anticipate is while rates are low and people want to borrow, banks -- flush with cash to lend -- don't want to. The monetary inflation can't keep up with deflation, which (you're right) is lethal.
The fed is, with QEx attempting to provide greater liquidity, thinking that this will cause price rises, and in turn spur spending and transactions. Of course its having no effect whatsoever. String pushing at its best.
Also: the only people who want to borrow right now are those who are borrowing just to stay fed. Rightly, the banks dont want to lend to them.
by "inflation" I mean "increase in prices", = price inflation
as opposed "greater monetary availability" = monetary inflation
You can't control price inflation/deflation, you can only control monetary inflation.
It doesn't matter why the banks don't want to lend, the point is, Bernanke's plan can't work until they do. (But let's be honest: it won't work in any case.)
I disagree. Gas prices go up when the dollar drops (not the only reason, but a guaranteed one). Make the yuan and the yen vastly more expensive, or just block imports at the port, and prices will go up. Maybe even to the point where it will be cost effective to pay americans to make them.
"The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design."
This sort of top down thinking is just toxic. It seems so great and tidy until you actually try to implement it and then you realize that your level of ignorance was greater than you could have possibly imagined. You can't solve a debt problem with more debt and you can't solve a jobs problem by just creating meaningless jobs. The only jobs that are sustainable are the jobs that produce something that other people actually want.
The whole idea of the price system is that we're given signals about the best ways to serve other people in society. The price system in financial and real estate markets is completely insane and basically non-functioning. We're all suffering with these zombie banks we've created for ourselves.
The real question shouldn't be how to create jobs but rather how to create a society where needs can be met by entrepreneurs and businesses. We've all seen that when people are having their needs met then jobs end up being created by the businesses that form in the process of meeting those needs.