News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by BryanBeshore on Monday September 27, 2021 @09:33PM (#28678289)
Also, part of the infrastructure bill gives $15,000 credit to new EV car purchases (if the manufacturer hires union labor). Musk is fighting this.
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by kjksf on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @12:19AM (#28679296)
Every car maker that makes car in US without union labor is fighting the union provision: Toyota, Honda, BMW. Why are you singling out Musk?

And for the record: the last version of the bill is $7.5k + additional $4.5 if made by union.

Car makers that don't use union fight the $4.5k union provision, not the whole credit.

And for a good reason. The union provision would be historically unprecedented government handout to unions and potentially illegal. There are laws limiting what the government can do and this kind of discrimination of US workers that don't belong to union may very well cross the line.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by seattle_spring on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:54AM (#28679753)
Some politicians are fighting to get an income cap as low as $100k, which would all but kill the tax credit.
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @02:53AM (#28680019)
>as low as $100k

Which is nearly 50% higher than the median wage. We cut down these incentives in the UK because they appeared to be a bung for the rich.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by frumper on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @12:29PM (#28684643)
I have doubts that the lower 50% of wage earners buy new cars in general. I'm very doubtful that they would be buying any new electric vehicles.
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by option on Monday September 27, 2021 @09:45PM (#28678368)
This is a disgusting example of political lobbying by unions. Fords makes Mach-E in Mexico while Tesla makes cars sold in US in US. Why is the one who makes cars here and who is effectively the reason why this market exists at all should be excluded from the incentive??
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by runako on Monday September 27, 2021 @10:17PM (#28678575)
"Every F-150 is proudly assembled at Ford’s Dearborn Truck Plant in Dearborn, Michigan, and Kansas City Assembly Plant in Claycomo, Missouri." [1]

(Obviously, various quantities of parts for all vehicles assembled in the US will be imported. I do not know how Ford compares to Tesla in this regard.)

1 - https://media.ford.com/content/fordmedia/fna/us/en/news/2020...

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by natch on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @12:36AM (#28679397)
The post you replied to said Mach-E, not F-150.

And assembly is not manufacturing. The sentence you quoted is making careful use of weasel words by zeroing in on assembly.

Tesla brings in rolls of aluminum and steel (and other things) and puts out cars. Even the seats are manufactured in the same town. The motors are wound from scratch on site. Casting and stamping happens on site as well. Like you, I don’t know the full picture on externally sourced parts, but there are a lot fewer parts, and I do know weasel words when I see them.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by runako on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @12:53AM (#28679489)
I stand corrected on the Mach-E.

But automakers all necessarily focus on assembly because at a minimum the electronics are imported. It would be a good idea to know fractions of parts that were sourced domestically, but an effort to do this in the 80s failed because it's too easy to game and ultimately consumers do not really care.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by Dylan16807 on Monday September 27, 2021 @10:20PM (#28678586)
What I found is "Most recently, the US Senate Finance Committee passed a reform bill that would increase the tax incentive to $10,000 for EVs produced in the US, and to $12,500 for EVs produced in the US by union workers."

That seems like a good deal to me, and the bonus money won't go to any mexico-made models.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by natch on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @12:40AM (#28679417)
IANAL but I’ve heard that under the terms of our cross border agreements with Mexico, “Produced in the US” is a legal term that can also be applied to items manufactured by Mexican workers in special economic zones in Mexico on (the Mexico side of the) US border. In other words, take it with a grain of salt.
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by TheParkShark on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @12:07PM (#28684404)
I believe it also includes Canada.
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by ncallaway on Monday September 27, 2021 @10:29PM (#28678639)
> Why is the one who makes cars here and who is effectively the reason why this market exists at all should be excluded from the incentive??

This bill hasn't passed yet, so it's hard to speak definitively about it, but the current draft bill provides:

a $12,500 rebate for vehicles that are:

- assembled in the United States, - with union labor

or a $7,500 rebate for most other electric vehicles

https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-house-democrats-propose-...

As such, being made and assembled in the United States would be a requirement for the $12,500 rebate.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by GavinMcG on Monday September 27, 2021 @10:22PM (#28678597)
No one is excluded. Like all tax deductions/credits, this one incentivizes a goal decided on by the legislature. One major purpose of government is realigning incentives. If this makes it cheap enough, Tesla will likely use union labor; if not, they won't.
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by kjksf on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @12:23AM (#28679320)
At the same time discriminating against US citizens that chose to not join the union might very well be an incentive that the courts will deem illegal.

Many people believe this won't end up in the final bill.

But if it does, it's 100% sure it'll be challenged in court by every car maker that makes cars in US and doesn't use union labor: Toyota, Honda, BMW and others.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by bpodgursky on Monday September 27, 2021 @10:35PM (#28678669)
Tesla can't "use union labor" unless their employees vote to unionize... which they are perfectly free to do.

Unless you are suggesting Tesla... threaten to fire their employees unless they unionize? That doesn't sound very worker-friendly.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by GavinMcG on Monday September 27, 2021 @10:45PM (#28678729)
Not illegally firing them for trying to unionize would have put them on the right track.

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/25/business/musk-labor-board...

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by ghshephard on Monday September 27, 2021 @10:51PM (#28678770)
Honest question - don't you believe that Tesla Factories don't unionize because Tesla puts a significant amount of effort, manager training, and probably millions of dollars of investment into preventing them from unionizing? And, if Tesla stopped that effort - wouldn't they naturally unionize fairly quickly?
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by bpodgursky on Monday September 27, 2021 @11:01PM (#28678829)
Something like 13% of private-sector US workers are unionized... choosing to unionize is not some kind of default position. It's pretty rare.

And not every employer is pushing hard to prevent it from happening. Most employees just aren't that unhappy and would prefer to work under their own contract w/o answer into another intermediary that gets a cut of their money.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by GavinMcG on Monday September 27, 2021 @11:19PM (#28678933)
Most employees aren't even aware of what a union is or does. When something isn't part of your experience, you don't even have a preference one way or another.

Your comment is evidence: it sets up a false dichotomy. The whole point at a workplace that chooses to unionize is that they want to work under a different, better contract, and they're willing to invest in the organizing that it takes to get there.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by ecpottinger on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @12:41AM (#28679421)
Sorry, I use to work for GM under a union. When I left and started working in non-union businesses I never once said "I wish we had a union here.".

Unions have done a lot of good in the past, but for the last couple of decades they seem to be more organizations more interested in paying big paychecks to their own representatives.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by GavinMcG on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @08:08AM (#28681821)
That's fair! But you know your workplace and you know what a union could look like. The union I was in paid a little bit to a national parent union, and got a lot more than we paid for when it came to legal representation in a contract dispute, training, etc. And all the local leadership was entirely volunteer.

Still, the vast majority of workers in the U.S. don't have much exposure to what the tradeoffs even could be, so as to even make a decision. And frankly, for the folks here on HN, it's not especially surprising that a union isn't a priority. But there are a lot of people who would be grateful for things like consistent week-to-week scheduling, health coverage, fair dispute resolution, etc., and don't even know that there are peer workplaces that have all those things thanks to a union.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by runako on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @12:55AM (#28679501)
This is interesting. Do you do the same kind of job that you did when you were a union employee?

My understanding of unions is employers hate them in part because they make labor more expensive, which would seem to be exactly why one would want to be represented by a union. Is that not correct?

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by rsj_hn on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:00AM (#28679525)
It depends on how much of that extra expense you can capture as your own pay and how much is dead weight costs (e.g. union overhead or additional costs imposed on employers), as well as how likely it is to mean you can't get a job in the first place. So it depends very much on things like overall economic growth, how the union cooperates with management, etc. In Europe, unions collaborate with management whereas US unions have historically been more adversarial. In the US, for example, managers can't be union members whereas in some places in Europe union reps have board seats and are partners with management in trying to get the company to grow.
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by runako on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:27AM (#28679624)
Quick stats check via Google shows that in the US, union workers earn ~11% more than non-union workers. Which would seem enough to warrant a modest membership fee. Also aligns with the management rhetoric that union labor & benefits are expensive and reason enough to move entire factories to the South to escape collective bargaining. (It does not make sense that they would do this to save the cost of union management's paychecks, the numbers are not big enough.)

What I was trying to understand from the OP was what's missing from the picture and whether perhaps her role was somehow an outlier.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by rsj_hn on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @02:18AM (#28679836)
By that logic, if we fired everyone earning below $20/hr, then the average wage of workers would go up, but that doesn't necessarily mean workers as a whole would be better off under that deal. Yes, the company with unionized workers pays 11% higher wages. It also hires fewer workers.

By limiting employment to only workers earning that extra 11%, yes, those workers are doing well but overall employment is lower, there are deadweight losses to pay for the union fees, and that isn't necessarily a policy that can scale to the whole economy. This is why there are such problems with youth unemployment in nations with high unionization rates -- it's tougher to break into that labor market.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by runako on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @09:20AM (#28682425)
Yes, obviously unions have problems scaling to the entire country. But I was specifically asking why someone (the OP) who is presumably earning 11% more would rather work in a non-union shop.
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by rsj_hn on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @11:42AM (#28684122)
So think of the union as hiring someone to negotiate for you.

there is option A:

In option A, you are already being paid the market wage for your job. The job has a number on it for the wage. That number doesn't change. When you unionize every job with a low number disappers. Thus joining a union can only hurt you, because at best you stay where you are (but pay the union overhead). Nevertheless the jobs that are unionized earn 11% more.

People who think of themselves as having bargaining power view themselves in this bucket, e.g. that they are being paid the market wage already and don't benefit from the union.

Then there is option B:

Unions cause the same workers to earn 11% more - the number does change -- and the firm just scales back on hiring (or lays off workers) until it's total labor expenditure is back in line with its expenses. People without a sense that they have market power (e.g. that the labor market is driven by real competitive pressure in which companies bid on your skills, as opposed to firms mandating wages to workers without better options).

Now someone who views themselves in category B would or would not join the union depending on whether they thought the risk/reward trade off was worth it. E.g. yes, maybe you'd be less likely to get the job but if you did you'd have a better life so maybe its worth it to you.

But note that these choices are not exogenous: once a lot of people join unions, the labor market as a whole becomes less flexible and they end up with fewer options. Thus their market power decreases and they are more dependant on the union. This is especially true if an industry as a whole unionizes. That gives unions a stickiness because those workers know it would be really hard to find a better job on their own. So unions are something you join out of greed but stay in out of fear.

Then of course people make irrational choices as well. E.g. they oppose unions purely because they are morally offended at price fixing, even if it's for their benefit, or support unions purely because they are morally offended by low paying jobs existing, even if there are people who would rather have those jobs than be unemployed. The fact of the matter is that labor markets are not always competitive but it's also true that in many cases they are quite competitive, or close enough to being competitive that they wouldn't justify the overhead of the union. So it depends on how competitive your particular labor market is, whether the union will help you or hurt you, and that is true even if people working for unions earn more on average than those who do not.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by runako on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @12:02PM (#28684353)
Sorry, I wasn't clear. I wasn't looking for the game theory of unions. The person to whom I replied made a claim about their lived experience having worked as a union employee, and I just wanted to learn more about their thoughts on the matter. No amount of theorizing will suffice to replace that perspective.
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by bpodgursky on Monday September 27, 2021 @11:59PM (#28679179)
Right... and the Tesla employees didn't.

You seem really convinced that if Tesla forced and up/down vote on a union their employees would vote yes, and I just don't think that matches the reality of labor in the US.

At the root of this thread is that someone implicitly suggested forcing workers to unionize (or be fired) as a solution to Tesla not being unionized, and I stand that that's a gross distortion of what it means to grant rights to labor.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by GavinMcG on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @08:10AM (#28681838)
Not at all convinced. It takes a lot of work to organize a workplace, and a lot of people are skeptical of unions—for some good reasons, and some bad ones.

I don't see anyone interpreting things as "forcing workers to unionize" except you. The argument you're making seems to be a strawman.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by bpodgursky on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @12:00PM (#28684325)
> If this makes it cheap enough, Tesla will likely use union labor

How else could this be accomplished?

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by GavinMcG on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:04PM (#28685003)
They can invite workers to unionize and facilitate that with education, obviously. They could even share some of that $15,000 tax credit directly with workers!

Or maybe I'm wrong, and Tesla is just going to have to reap what it sowed in violating long-established worker rights. That's another way a tax incentive could work: by translating into market rewards. That doesn't make it exclusive.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by bpodgursky on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:21PM (#28685174)
You can cut this however you want with pretty semantics, but your argument is predicated on not giving the workers the right to choose whether to unionize. If they choose no, Tesla has no option but to replace them.

You want to "educate" workers in order to help them make the right choice... you are not coming at this from a position where you actually respect the rights of workers to make a choice.

Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ... by GavinMcG on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @02:03PM (#28685628)
Of course they have an option! They can follow the law, not fire their workers for making their own choices about (non)representation, and just not get the tax credit.

Saying that Tesla would be forced to do anything here is absurd. I'm not the one making an "argument predicated on not giving the workers the right to choose."