Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ...
by GavinMcG on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @08:10AM
(#28681838)
Not at all convinced. It takes a lot of work to organize a workplace, and a lot of people are skeptical of unions—for some good reasons, and some bad ones.
I don't see anyone interpreting things as "forcing workers to unionize" except you. The argument you're making seems to be a strawman.
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ...
by bpodgursky on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @12:00PM
(#28684325)
> If this makes it cheap enough, Tesla will likely use union labor
How else could this be accomplished?
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ...
by GavinMcG on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:04PM
(#28685003)
They can invite workers to unionize and facilitate that with education, obviously. They could even share some of that $15,000 tax credit directly with workers!
Or maybe I'm wrong, and Tesla is just going to have to reap what it sowed in violating long-established worker rights. That's another way a tax incentive could work: by translating into market rewards. That doesn't make it exclusive.
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ...
by bpodgursky on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:21PM
(#28685174)
You can cut this however you want with pretty semantics, but your argument is predicated on not giving the workers the right to choose whether to unionize. If they choose no, Tesla has no option but to replace them.
You want to "educate" workers in order to help them make the right choice... you are not coming at this from a position where you actually respect the rights of workers to make a choice.
Re:Ford to invest in EV and battery plants in Tennessee and ...
by GavinMcG on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @02:03PM
(#28685628)
Of course they have an option! They can follow the law, not fire their workers for making their own choices about (non)representation, and just not get the tax credit.
Saying that Tesla would be forced to do anything here is absurd. I'm not the one making an "argument predicated on not giving the workers the right to choose."
You seem really convinced that if Tesla forced and up/down vote on a union their employees would vote yes, and I just don't think that matches the reality of labor in the US.
At the root of this thread is that someone implicitly suggested forcing workers to unionize (or be fired) as a solution to Tesla not being unionized, and I stand that that's a gross distortion of what it means to grant rights to labor.