No, it’s pretty much a stupid idea on its face. This is one of many thousands of examples of cronyism in the country, but the political justification at least sounds nice (as they tend to do), in this case the sugar takes the form of protecting local businesses.
> and opening a new store is not undercutting any existing dealers
They wouldn’t be undercutting existing Tesla dealers because there aren’t any, but they would be going Mano-a-Mano with dealers selling other cars. There’s not a Tesla market and an automobile market separate from that.
The wording is irrelevant. The law is working as intended, although it can’t account for dealerships outside their jurisdiction (on Tribal land or out of State). It’s just a bad law.
So it remains in the present that it is 1. cronyism, one of many thousands of forms of it in the country 2. stupid on its face and 3. basically indefensible, but people who have buy-in can be persuaded that it is very defensible.
I have no knowledge about any of this whatsoever, but would venture to guess that in states where this kind of thing happens, licensing to become a distributor may be very difficult. For example, the total number of licenses may be constrained.
“Notify us when you want stock, and we will instantly order, receive and deliver your product to your warehouse. Flat rate charge no matter how large the order.”
However, consumption based taxes (direct or indirect) also disproportionately proscribe lower income people from engaging in such activities. Tax a carton of cigarettes? Worthless if I can just hit the Rez or hop to another town that doesn’t tax. Screwed if you don’t have that kind of mobility. There’s a disturbingly classist nature to them, which gets all the more concerning when it involves fundamental rights - if only the rich can afford to own a gun, get an abortion, speak freely, for example.
Additionally, vice taxes at some high point are effectively prohibition. Make alcohol too expensive (directly/indirectly) and bootlegging becomes more popular, with its attendant health risks, crime, etc. Make cocaine too expensive and meth gets more popular. Sell untaxed cigarettes and witness how laws are only enforced with an implicit threat of violence that may become explicit (ask Eric Garner).
Tough job, controlling societies.
But like many things that are opined on on HN, it's a little more complex than what you wrote, in that they were also trying to prevent tied houses (1) and vertical integration wherein brewers would basically tie into every local bar, creating a local monopoly.
Washington State got rid of the common three tier (2) system in 2012, and it seems to have lead to higher prices. (3)
The options we have for alcoholic consumption might not exist without these sort of regulations.
To be clear I'm not an expert on liquor laws and their economic impacts, but my point is that it seems like there is a complex interplay wherein regulation, enforcement, and power relationships between companies can affect availability and pricing in complex and sometimes counterintuitive ways.
And that's not even getting into smaller regulatory policies that I don't know enough about to even throw out an opinion on. Unlike food, alcohol distributors aren't isn't pay for play slotting fees for shelf placement, and many states require distributors to post and hold prices for 30 days, for example.
1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-tier_system_(alcohol_dis... 2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tied_house 3 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4608622/
What is stopping Tesla from structuring a corp owned dealership in NM? I know there are lots of "dealerships" that exist only on paper with no lot or cars that exclusively sell OEM parts online.
Why is Tesla going so far out of their way to avoid state laws here?
Undoubtedly being protected from competitors is good for someone, but it is rarely the consumer that benefits. Its hard to see how car dealers could be the exception.
Thing was that by allowing dealers to open the business first, manufacturers could entirely offload that risk of opening a location that wasn't profitable, and watch the orders from the dealers. Anywhere that sold well, just open up your own store and undercut the dealer until he goes out of business and then return prices to what the dealer was originally selling for.
Putting in laws was meant to put a stop to that practice. Like I said, it's just something I vaguely recall reading on the internet so take it for what it's worth.
But I wouldn't bet on it, since Amazon already has all the people capable of doing anything in their pockets anyways.
Was there any legitimate basis for this fear though? Was this a tactic that was ever provably executed by a manufacturer? Or was it just a made-up scenario by dealerships to push these laws that massively benefit them?
Amazon of course denies that it does this, but the anecdata seems irrefutable to me.
They could easily undercut the dealers and drive them out of business. The law was designed to protect the dealers from the manufacturers.
We are seeing it more and more now in many markets and niches as manufactures are cutting out dealers that built the markets and selling 'direct to consumer'. The difference is that most manufacturers saw what happened to the car companies and are trying to carefully avoid having the same thing happen to them.
“Oh don’t open a Chevy dealership, in 6 months they’ll come in and undercut you”. And then there it is. Either you don’t open a dealership (fine) or the manufacturer builds a reputation for not undercutting dealers (also fine).
IMO the law was protecting special interests from the start. This is an example of poorly regulating capitalism.
Then again, Apple dicks its partners over and hasn't suffered much.
There are Apple stores but they don't really compete with the big box stores that sell Apple products. Though I would be interested in seeing data on where most Apple products are purchased from.
If so, I guess I'll have to eat my words, but it just really sounds like a hypothetical scenario the dealerships would have cooked up to try and push these laws that massively benefit them.
High voltage parts are a little different, but I expect that even that will change as demand grows and training becomes more readily available. Right now there are some real safety concerns there.
It kept more profits in the states with dealerships versus car manufacturers.
Let's say non-manufacturer revenue over a car's TCO is X. The largest portion of X will be spent on non-local goods and local labor regardless of who takes the profit, which has to be low enough to prevent stronger 3rd party service. It isn't like all cars would be shipped back to the factory for service.
But did it ever actually happen before those laws were put into place? Or was it simply the justification of the richest man in town creating a monopoly for himself?
It's almost like the interests of the market lead it to self-regulate or something...
Proving that there was a market for cars? If so that seems unlikely that you'd need to prove that there's a market for them in NM. So perhaps the dealers proved the market for specific types of cars, like Fords and GMs. In that case, they never did that for Tesla, so it's not a fair law. In any case, this belongs in a contract, not the legal code.
A law to protect a useless middleman? Seems completely stupid to me.
To come in and undercut dealers is much less risky! the manufacturer would be effectively be avoiding the risk (proving the market) and stealing the reward.
I have zero idea of whether or not it's good to regulate against that type of thing, but there's logic there.
In the case of the law, it seems ridiculous that there's no room to say "well clearly this is an exception that doesn't violate the reason the law exists" - is this a matter of dealers pushing to uphold the law because they don't want competition?
It wasn't a stupid idea to provide some protection to dealerships from the manufacturers they represent, but it is stupid to use it to block manufacturers that have no dealers.
In general though, I’m always elated to see sovereignty of native nations.
Think what they're really protecting here is that dealerships must house, maintain, and purchase a lot of very expensive merchandise (vehicles) and if a more "official" distribution channel popped up in town, that'd hose dealerships that have invested a lot in a particular brand(s).
But usually it's very hard to change them, and so they pile up as so much Legacy Code.
The intent of the NM law that prevented Tesla from doing this e.g. in downtown Santa Fe was to prevent manufacturers from undercutting dealers who had done the work of proving a market by opening their own stores in direct competition. There are arguments for and against this, but it's not clearly a completely stupid idea on its face.
But of course, the law wasn't written to deal with a scenario where there's a new(ish) manufacturer that has no dealers anywhere, least of all in NM, and has no plans to ever have dealers. It only sells its cars in company-owned stores, and opening a new store is not undercutting any existing dealers.
Would the legislators who voted for the legislation have understood the difference if the idea had been presented to them back when this was passed? Would they have worded it differently?