News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by andjd on Monday September 13, 2021 @04:57PM (#28516779)
But now that these laws are on the books, the existing owners of dealerships actively lobby the state legislators to keep this as the status quo and reduce competition. The dealers, and lawmakers, hope that Tesla will give in and start selling through existing dealerships.
Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by Mountain_Skies on Monday September 13, 2021 @05:23PM (#28517062)
Reminds me of how the alcohol distribution system in some states causes ridiculous situations such as requiring Trader Joe's to sell their inhouse wine to a distributor and then requiring them to buy it back in order to sell it in their stores. Obviously the distributor loves this as they get to rent seek while adding no value at all. That gives them plenty of money to lobby with to keep them in the loop.
Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by opinion-is-bad on Monday September 13, 2021 @07:05PM (#28518062)
I can confirm this. I opened a distillery during the pandemic and had to pay a middle man during some online sales simply to cover legal requirements. The middle man never even handled the product. Very frustrating way to spend money.
Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by coding123 on Monday September 13, 2021 @10:27PM (#28519486)
Have you considered having your wife start a distribution company?
Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by kkylin on Monday September 13, 2021 @11:32PM (#28519917)
Clever idea!

I have no knowledge about any of this whatsoever, but would venture to guess that in states where this kind of thing happens, licensing to become a distributor may be very difficult. For example, the total number of licenses may be constrained.

Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by lostlogin on Monday September 13, 2021 @11:41PM (#28519965)
You could provide this service to other companies. Flat rate, instant shipping $500 a year.

“Notify us when you want stock, and we will instantly order, receive and deliver your product to your warehouse. Flat rate charge no matter how large the order.”

Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by abrowne on Monday September 13, 2021 @08:32PM (#28518709)
One difference is the alcohol rules are a remnant of (post-)Prohibition and are meant to make alcohol harder or more expensive to get.
Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by kennywinker on Monday September 13, 2021 @09:17PM (#28519023)
Right, but if the goal is to make alcohol expensive and unavailable the ideal lever to pull would be a vice tax. Instead of that money going to random unaccountable middleman, it goes to the people - who are already shouldering much of the social cost of alcohol (healthcare, policing, etc). I'm not sure i support vice-taxes, but they're clearly better than just giving it to whichever random rich person or industry insider that manages to insert themselves.
Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by kevin_thibedeau on Monday September 13, 2021 @11:15PM (#28519798)
Politicians get blamed for taxes. Middlemen are a safe hidden tax that has the bonus of padding their campaign funding.
Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by erhk on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @06:42AM (#28522722)
Maybe we should get together an angry mob
Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by aksss on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @02:52AM (#28521210)
I support vice taxes, at least insofar as their good intention is concerned - making it hard(er) to engage in the vice, while not prohibiting it.

However, consumption based taxes (direct or indirect) also disproportionately proscribe lower income people from engaging in such activities. Tax a carton of cigarettes? Worthless if I can just hit the Rez or hop to another town that doesn’t tax. Screwed if you don’t have that kind of mobility. There’s a disturbingly classist nature to them, which gets all the more concerning when it involves fundamental rights - if only the rich can afford to own a gun, get an abortion, speak freely, for example.

Additionally, vice taxes at some high point are effectively prohibition. Make alcohol too expensive (directly/indirectly) and bootlegging becomes more popular, with its attendant health risks, crime, etc. Make cocaine too expensive and meth gets more popular. Sell untaxed cigarettes and witness how laws are only enforced with an implicit threat of violence that may become explicit (ask Eric Garner).

Tough job, controlling societies.

Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by smegger001 on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @10:53PM (#28534678)
all laws are enforced with threat of violence. dont beleive me try not filing your taxes. first you will get nasty letters from the IRS, fallowed by a court summons where you may end up evicted from you home by the sheriff/police try to resist and see what happens ultimately all laws are enforced with the threat of violence its only a matter of how polite the system is to you first
Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by kennywinker on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @07:40PM (#28545926)
Yes, but it's vanishingly rare to see crimes like securities fraud enforced with ACTUAL violence. "Vice" laws disproportionately effect marginalized communities, down to the amount of violence used to enforce them.
Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by aksss on Thursday September 16, 2021 @01:38PM (#28554678)
That's probably because it's vanishingly rare that people physically arrested for securities fraud resist. That doesn't mean the threat's not there.
Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by kennywinker on Thursday September 16, 2021 @04:54PM (#28557443)
That's probably because it's vanishingly rare for people to be physically arrested for securities fraud.
Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by kennywinker on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @03:57AM (#28521650)
Yup, agree with everything you said. Just want to add that all of those problems are also present with the “byzantine monopolistic middlemen” model.
Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by lsiebert on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @12:55AM (#28520383)
Yes it's true that states want to reduce alcohol consumption; drunk driving, alcohol related illnesses and crime are all tied to alcohol use, so there is a public health aspect.

But like many things that are opined on on HN, it's a little more complex than what you wrote, in that they were also trying to prevent tied houses (1) and vertical integration wherein brewers would basically tie into every local bar, creating a local monopoly.

Washington State got rid of the common three tier (2) system in 2012, and it seems to have lead to higher prices. (3)

The options we have for alcoholic consumption might not exist without these sort of regulations.

To be clear I'm not an expert on liquor laws and their economic impacts, but my point is that it seems like there is a complex interplay wherein regulation, enforcement, and power relationships between companies can affect availability and pricing in complex and sometimes counterintuitive ways.

And that's not even getting into smaller regulatory policies that I don't know enough about to even throw out an opinion on. Unlike food, alcohol distributors aren't isn't pay for play slotting fees for shelf placement, and many states require distributors to post and hold prices for 30 days, for example.

1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-tier_system_(alcohol_dis... 2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tied_house 3 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4608622/

Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by mkhpalm on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @03:44AM (#28521567)
> Tesla will give in and start selling through existing dealerships.

What is stopping Tesla from structuring a corp owned dealership in NM? I know there are lots of "dealerships" that exist only on paper with no lot or cars that exclusively sell OEM parts online.

Why is Tesla going so far out of their way to avoid state laws here?

Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by smegger001 on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @10:55PM (#28534700)
to avoid setting a precedent that can be used against them in their fight archaic laws that have outlived their usefulness
Re:Tesla opens a center on Native American land, selling car... by unstatusthequo on Monday September 13, 2021 @07:23PM (#28518200)
This comment implies that manufacturers need 3rd party dealers/distributors. I think Tesla has globally proven their market.