News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by iso1210 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @03:05PM (#28461632)
My kids have no concept of linear TV. My 9 year old came back and told me that a friend had a broken TV as when they turned it on, the program was already half way through.

Their 'channels' are netflix, amazon and disney. When I had the choice and they were pre-school then sure, we watched things like Alphablocks on iplayer. I can force them to watch Attenborough or Blue Peter, and they enjoy it, just not enough to want to watch them over things on disney. There's so much competition of things to do.

I do watch BBC (iplayer obviously) occasionally, but the material I'm interested in isn't as accessible as it is on disney/apple/prime/netflix/youtube.

We watched Eurovision and Euro2020 (England games) this year. Aside from that the only BBC output we watched was Roadkill about a year ago, and the one Doctor Who episode which had John Barrowman in. I would watch have I got news for you, but whenever I remember to watch it, it's not on.

This itself might not say a lot, and I still have a TV license despite the limited direct value I get (listen to a lot of BBC radio, and the news website), but what's interesting is I actually work for the BBC. If my household barely watches it, where does the future lie.

Linear TVs days are numbered, but the underlying cultural links that prime time TV provided in the 60s through 90s has already gone. 1 in 4 people in the UK used to watch the same shitty sitcoms in the 80s because there was very little choice.

It's not just BBC or the UK that has this cultural difference. "It's a wonderful life" is an American classic. It is because it was shown on every channel every christmas year after year, generation after generation, and kids watched it, because it was that or reading a book.

I think Star Trek was right with its outlandish prediction from 1988. TV as a form of entertainment won't survive much past 2040 (I think linear TV will still be going in 10 years time, but probably not 30).

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by spinningslate on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @03:33PM (#28461934)
Won't argue with the your observation on consumption: I see the same with my children.

However: there's nothing intrinsic to the BBC that requires linear delivery or consumption. iPlayer was, after all, one of the first streaming services: a genuine bit of innovation from the Beeb.

I dearly want to see the BBC not only survive, but to prosper.

That may be rose-tinted/delusional/whatever. Why? Because it represents a collective service for society, by society. I don't watch all the content: not even some of the big stuff (Strictly). But I really value the breadth of content: that it caters to interests - people - that are diverse. It can do that because it doesn't have to slavishly chase advertising in a race-to-the-bottom death march to mediocrity.

Similarly, its aspiration to impartial news coverage - to inform and educate, not impose a political doctrine - should be invaluable. It certainly hasn't always achieved that (and sometimes by a long way) but at least the aspiration is there. It would be greatly helped here by some structural protection from government meddling, but that's another story.

Like the original article, I see the writing on the wall. But I don't think it needs to be a death spiral. In a world of hyper-targeted-advertising-driven-sensationalist-fact-free-fake-news in 140 characters or less, I want to believe there's a market for diverse, challenging society-enhancing content. I can't think of an organisation whose charter would better fit with that aim.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by teamonkey on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @03:52PM (#28462173)
> iPlayer was, after all, one of the first streaming services: a genuine bit of innovation from the Beeb.

This is absolutely worth remembering, iPlayer was revelatory 12 or 13 years ago. Infuriatingly the innovation seems to have stopped there.

Case in point, it's a corporation nearly 100 years old, yet its back catalogue is extremely poor. You should be able to watch every episode of Doctor Who on demand since the original black & white pilot, instead you're mainly limited to items shown in the last month, plus some randomly curated stuff. Channel 4 has a better online archive.

When I lived outside of the UK I would have paid a subscription fee equal to the licence fee to gain access to iPlayer. It's worth paying for! But there's no way to give them money for services other than be a licence payer within the UK.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by kmeisthax on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:34PM (#28462690)
>You should be able to watch every episode of Doctor Who on demand since the original black & white pilot

I hate to break it to you, but not even the BBC has that.

Most of their early work was never archived, as the technology to actually do so either didn't exist (television predates magnetic video recording), was so expensive as to make full archival prohibitively expensive, or was explicitly prohibited by contractual arrangement. No, seriously, TV actors insisted that tapes were wiped and reused after a period of time so that reruns would not usurp the market for new productions. The same goes for a lot of other countries' early television. Just finding working copies of all of those Doctor Who episodes is an ongoing preservation project.

Things like not being able to pay for iPlayer outside of the license fee is a similar problem - politics dictating the market. The BBC's license-funded activities are specifically firewalled from the part of the business that sells commercial TV internationally. Even if that particular diktat didn't exist, the BBC would still be following the ordinary TV business practice of selling each show off on a per-country basis. Even the big streaming services do this with their own originals, many of which are not streaming-exclusive outside the US. The idea that you have a single "owner" that just does everything and sells the work globally is mostly unheard of outside of the videogame industry.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by deadbunny on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:13PM (#28462430)
> Case in point, it's a corporation nearly 100 years old, yet its back catalogue is extremely poor.

This was due to the Competition Commission saying the BBC putting up their back catalogue would stifle competition.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by chuckee on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @07:48PM (#28464456)
Sounds like internal sabotage.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by asdff on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:29PM (#28462626)
Isn't it because they don't physically have a lot of the back catalogue anymore? I read that they taped over a lot of shows and there aren't copies left for some.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by Bluecobra on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @06:03PM (#28463618)
> When I lived outside of the UK I would have paid a subscription fee equal to the licence fee to gain access to iPlayer. It's worth paying for! But there's no way to give them money for services other than be a licence payer within the UK.

This drove me nuts! There were a bunch of great series I was into that were simply not available in US even if I purchased a premium cable subscription to BBC America. Another show (programme?) I really enjoyed was Ramsay's Kitchen Nightmares. The UK version was much better than the over the top version we got on FOX in the US. I ended up paying for a cheap VPC in the UK that I would SSH into and use it as a SOCKS proxy so I can watch the shows I wanted. I would have gladly given BBC/Channel 4 money if I could.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by native_samples on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:42PM (#28463421)
There's a difference between aspiration and execution. Every TV channel will claim they aspire to inform, educate and be diverse. No TV channel in history has said their goal is to misinform, dumb down and present homogenous uniformity day after day.

The BBC is clearly failing at its goals. Most of the UK population no longer trusts its news output; that's huge and a new phenomenon, although of course it's been a long time in coming. Unlike normal TV companies the BBC cannot receive a reality check from the market because people are forced to fund it, so there's no way to break the downward spiral. It just gets worse, every year.

Indeed it would be sensible to argue that the BBC's problem is too little government interference, not too much. The government is, at least in theory, accountable to the people. Sure, it's only every 4 years and many different issues are conflated together. But there is at least a vote. The BBC is accountable to nobody. It's not accountable to its viewers. It's not accountable to elected representatives. It is not even really accountable to Ofcom, given the incredibly weak enforcement of the vaguely worded regulations on fairness and neutrality. If you have a complaint about the BBC you can complain to, well, the BBC itself. Or you could complain to an MP who will do nothing because the BBC is de-facto independent of the government.

If the BBC were actually controlled by the government then it would have already been forced back to more mainstream political views. The ruling party is very unhappy with the BBC's wokeness and openly biased news (e.g. "Brexit threat to sandwiches" being a memorable headline). That unhappyness is not self-serving politics but rather, reflecting the frustration that their voters are telling both them and opinion pollsters. The public no longer perceives the BBC as "society enhancing" but instead society damaging. Yet, they can do nothing about it. The political will to reform the BBC isn't there.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by eynsham on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @07:41PM (#28464403)
> The BBC is clearly failing at its goals.

Well, the Proms this year were bound to be disappointing, but I’m sure matters will improve next year. And the cricket commentary is still perfectly sound.

> Most of the UK population no longer trusts its news output

This is simply untrue: >60% of the population trust the BBC’s news output.¹

> The government is, at least in theory, accountable to the people.

It is less accountable when the public broadcaster is under its thumb. This is how e.g. Orban stays in power, and it’s not healthy regardless of the ideology of the person in power.

> Sure, it's only every 4 years and many different issues are conflated together.

Four years? It sounds like you’re rather unfamiliar with the UK.

> The BBC is accountable to nobody

The BBC survives because it is popular. Like any Quango or government body, it can be abolished by an act of parliament. If it is special, it is worth asking why it is special—and the most obvious answer is that people like it.

You also ignore that there are mechanisms other than accountability to ensure that people do things—institutions can have a culture. All your criticisms could be applied to the UK judiciary, yet its culture precludes certain behaviours that e.g. the prospect of removal from office alone cannot explain.

> If the BBC were actually controlled by the government then it would have already been forced back to more mainstream political views.

It is amusingly naïve to think that that would be the only response. I prefer having fair elections and avoiding entrenching one party rule to whatever non-mainstream views the BBC propagates.

> BBC's wokeness and openly biased news (e.g. "Brexit threat to sandwiches" being a memorable headline)

Is that really ‘woke and openly biased’? It’s not that implausible that something in the supply chain is affected by Brexit. The Conservatives, like governments of all stripes, are unhappy with the BBC because it is not in total agreement with government policy, has (excepting a commitment to democracy and human rights) no official stance in the first place making agreement or disagreement with policy something of a category error, and is not entirely under its thumb. That alone isn’t very good evidence of ‘wokeness and open bias’.

> The public no longer perceives the BBC as "society enhancing" but instead society damaging. Yet, they can do nothing about it. The political will to reform the BBC isn't there.

If turning the BBC into a UK version of CCTV were a popular policy, Boris Johnson would not shy away from it: cf. Brexit. Polling clearly indicates that you are wrong and the BBC is still quite popular: this is far more consistent with the evidence than some mysterious unwillingness to impose the will of Number 10 on the BBC.

1: https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/digital-news-repo...

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by native_samples on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:06PM (#28474673)
I'm British. As the sibling comment has pointed out, my understanding of UK elections is fine.

You appear to be arguing that the only way to hold the BBC accountable is to convince Parliament to entirely abolish it, which is rather making my point for me. That is the most limited form of accountability imaginable.

Opinion polls on trust in the BBC vary, perhaps by time, but reputable and recent polls show that most people do not trust it any more:

https://yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/2019/1...

"YouGov figures show British trust in the press to tell the truth has fallen, with less than half believing BBC news journalists are honest and impartial."

This document shows trust in BBC News by year - as you can see it has constantly fallen since 2003, the earliest year they started polling:

https://docs.cdn.yougov.com/vf1qhxf7kh/YG%20trackers%20-%20T...

This fall in trust is deserved. If you genuinely believe the "supply chain" for two pieces of bread with some stuff in between could have been disrupted by Brexit then you're exactly the sort of person the BBC is pandering to, which is probably why you don't see the problems. There is nothing special about the BBC beyond its archaic funding model. As discussed elsewhere in this thread, it is being regularly beaten by Netflix, Amazon and other larger scale content producers.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by eynsham on Thursday September 09, 2021 @10:47PM (#28477212)
> As the sibling comment has pointed out, my understanding of UK elections is fine.

‘Every’ is not the same as ‘on average’.

> You appear to be arguing that the only way to hold the BBC accountable is to convince Parliament to entirely abolish it, which is rather making my point for me. That is the most limited form of accountability imaginable.

‘There are mechanisms other than accountability’ does in fact appear above. And no, this is simply untrue: the BBC can also be reformed by an act of parliament, or, say, turned into a Quango to farm garlic.

> https://yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/articles-reports/2019/1...

> "YouGov figures show British trust in the press to tell the truth has fallen, with less than half believing BBC news journalists are honest and impartial."

First of all the BBC suddenly looks rather special according to YouGov (see e.g. https://yougov.co.uk/topics/media/articles-reports/2020/04/2...) for a longer perspective. Second, ‘not much’ is a pretty vague category and not trusting journos much to tell the truth could quite easily encompass still thinking that the Beeb is still all right given the alternatives. This is also confirmed by e.g. this: https://www.ipsos.com/ipsos-mori/en-uk/bbc-most-trusted-news....

> If you genuinely believe the "supply chain" for two pieces of bread with some stuff in between could have been disrupted by Brexit then you're exactly the sort of person the BBC is pandering to, which is probably why you don't see the problems.

I can’t tell whether you’re joking. The article read:

> Sandwiches would be one of the first victims of a breakdown in the food supply chain in the event of a disorderly no-deal Brexit, according to a senior grocery executive.

This is, simply, er, true. If goods were delayed for a week at the border, we would have a lot of rotten tomatoes and not very much to put in our sandwiches. This seems to be some sort of weird reaction to catastrophising about Brexit where somehow Brexit has no effect on supply chains whatsoever. A ‘disorderly no-deal Brexit’ would have been precisely that.

> There is nothing special about the BBC beyond its archaic funding model. As discussed elsewhere in this thread, it is being regularly beaten by Netflix, Amazon and other larger scale content producers.

Only somebody who does not consume the output of, say, All India Radio, CCTV, Channel News Asia &al. could say that the BBC is ‘not special’. I find it difficult not to be thankful for the Proms, and for cricket broadcasts without incessant American-style—to be thankful for civilisation, really.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by iso1210 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @04:13AM (#28467452)
> Four years? It sounds like you’re rather unfamiliar with the UK.

I agree OP sounds like an uninformed american, but since 1979 there's been an general election every 4 years on average.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by revolvingocelot on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:13PM (#28462429)
>I think Star Trek was right with its outlandish prediction from 1988

Ah, classic TNG. S1E25 "The Neutral Zone". [0]

Other near-term predictions from 90s Star Trek include terrorism-powered Irish reunification in 2024 [1] (how's Brexit coming along, again?), as well as a DS9 time-travel episode set in the same year that's not exactly about UBI and censorship and othering the poor, but those words might be the best way to describe the fake-issues of that episode's San Francisco [2].

And, uh, the periodic nuclear exchanges of World War III, starting in 2026 and continuing for a few decades, with a death toll of at least six hundred million.

[0] https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/The_Neutral_Zone_(episo...

[1] a throwaway reference in https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/The_Hunted_(episode)

[2] https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Past_Tense,_Part_I_(epi...

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by iso1210 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @06:41PM (#28463951)
Irish reunification in 2024 certainly plausible. Slightly plausible that in years to come brexit will be deemed to be an act of terrorism too.

It was "The High Ground", not "The Hunted" though -- and due to that line the episode wasn't shown for years in the UK (this was during the time UK cities were being regularly blown up by terrorists)

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by revolvingocelot on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @07:10PM (#28464203)
Aah good call. Wrong terrorism episode, alas.

I can't believe I've done this, Memory Alpha was right there.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by nate on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @03:25PM (#28461856)
I got such a kick out of my 7 year old at my grandparents. We turned on some random movie that was half way through and she said: "Oh, let's watch this, start it from the beginning." When I told her that's not how cable TV works, she looked at me like I was telling her some kind of stupid dad joke.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by aclelland on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @03:31PM (#28461910)
My 6 year old thinks that the screen goes black in some shows because that's when the exciting part is about to happen. Of course, it's actually where the program would normally break for ads . On Netflix/Disney+ this doesn't happen (yet!) so he's come to the conclusion that it's just a signal of impending excitement :)
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by ChrisKnott on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:39PM (#28463389)
This is normal in the UK because BBC never had ads. I remember foreign cartoons would often actually cut back in time slightly. It could be quite confusing but I just accepted it as some weird characteristic of TV.

For example Scooby Doo would be falling to his death... Fade to black... Fade back in... and he's higher up (?!)... Shaggy swings in and saves him.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by pedrocr on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:21PM (#28463223)
That is how modern cable TV works though. With the now fairly standard IPTV boxes the linear programming can be rewatched straight from the on screen guide and there is a "start from beginning" button on live shows.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by kazinator on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:18PM (#28463188)
What works well is Linear TV with a history, so you can go through a calendar, say, going back 30 days.

All the Japanese IPTV streamers work that way and it's a very natural integration.

You can watch the current streaming, or just go back in the calendar to whatever you want in your selected channel. And the past items flow from one to the next as if they were live. You watch through last Monday's 8:00 p.m. one hour show and it falls through to the 9:00 p.m. show of that day as if it were last Monday.

There is no annoying "recording" workflow; the full content is just there going back about a month.

The organization concept that certain shows occur regularly at certain times is very useful; it won't go away that easily; it remains useful when you're able to navigate through the calendar.

Japanese TV, as such, is pretty great though. It is not replaceable in any way by other forms of content.

E.g. families with small kids depend on the NHK E channel; there is no equivalent content. Everyone knows what that is; it's not ignored, like BBC or PBS.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by deadfish on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @06:07PM (#28463647)
I worked on a project a while back called Freeview play in the UK which I think works in a similar way to how you described. You can watch live TV over the air or scroll backwards in time along the EPG to stream recorded content over IP.

I think the BBCs childrens content is one of its strongest assets. I don't have any data for it, but I would say most families in the UK with small kids consume a lot of CBBC and CBeebies content. It's much better quality content than children's content on YouTube or Netflix.

Peoples viewing habits are more fragmented and from a wider variety of sources than 10 or 20 years ago and the BBC definitely doesn't have the same mindshare that it used to have when there was only X channels. But, I think when people are looking for some high quality curated content in the sea of 'please like and subscribe' then they will come back to iPlayer - I know I do.

Maybe it's just wishful thinking on my part?

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by hakfoo on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:00AM (#28466774)
I think it's less about specific times and more a form of curation.

The streaming options out there either tend to be "you wanted to watch one episode of this show, so here's every single other episode of it, followed by the German translation" or a seemingly random walk through the catalog that ends in Elsagate.

The guy running the schedule at the local broadcaster is a little more intelligent than that, and can make a better selection.

I'd love to see a streaming service that let you build "channel-like playlists"-- pick a few favourite series and it would populate a sequence to watch, not just those shows but also closely-correlated other programs. You'd only see one or two episodes of a given series in a row unless you intentionally skipped around on the list.

Ideally, the suggestion logic would be smart enough to identify "randomizable" shows versus "serial" ones, and pick appropriate episodes based on those rules.

There could be various UI refinements-- "I enjoyed Blah, but I've already seen up to Season 5, so skip all of those, but still weight it for the recommendation component."

In the end, it would be like network TV all over again: sit down at 7PM, press one button, and you'll watch four sitcoms and an hour-long drama, before switching over to a news product.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by nerdawson on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:13PM (#28462432)
Euro 2020 only reinforced how important the BBC actually is. iPlayer were streaming matches in 4K HDR while ITV were pumping out shockingly poor resolution low frame rate content that was barely watchable. Hard to believe that ITV were the ones with commercial funding behind them. Seeing that a match was going to be aired on ITV filled me with dread.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by zimpenfish on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:24PM (#28462561)
> while ITV were pumping out shockingly poor resolution low frame rate content that was barely watchable.

Don't forget the adverts and the several occasions when their streaming servers just plain couldn't be arsed to deliver any data to people during important games.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by jbarrs on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:57PM (#28462963)
This is depressingly true. Whenever ITV were hosting the match, I generally just resigned myself to not being able to watch it. Besides that, when it did work, the commentary was absolutely atrocious and did nothing but state the obvious. The BBC's coverage on iPlayer was superb, and I'll admit before I paid for any streaming service I used to comb through iPlayer the same way I comb through Netflix now.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by denton-scratch on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:43AM (#28466983)
> the commentary was absolutely atrocious and did nothing but state the obvious.

I've always assumed that how sports fans like their commentaries - vacuous, uninformative and shouty. If fans wanted intelligent commentary, surely broadcasters would hire intelligent commentators, rather than ineloquent retired sports stars?

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by vmilner on Thursday September 09, 2021 @03:10AM (#28467124)
Thankfully for track and field athletics on the BBC we have former world mile record holder Steve Cram, who's the epitome of an intelligent commentator.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by 908B64B197 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:02PM (#28462320)
> Their 'channels' are netflix, amazon and disney. When I had the choice and they were pre-school then sure, we watched things like Alphablocks on iplayer. I can force them to watch Attenborough or Blue Peter, and they enjoy it, just not enough to want to watch them over things on disney. There's so much competition of things to do.

> This itself might not say a lot, and I still have a TV license despite the limited direct value I get (listen to a lot of BBC radio, and the news website), but what's interesting is I actually work for the BBC. If my household barely watches it, where does the future lie.

The entertainment sector is one of the most profitable on Earth. Marvel, Disney made billions making content that people want to watch and are willing to pay for. I'm not getting the reason why there should be government sponsored entertainment, especially seeing that people aren't even interested in watching it.

Why not simply compete and let the consumer decide?

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by bjohnson225 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:14PM (#28463140)
The BBC is there to “inform, educate and entertain”. It gets government(/licence fee) funding because only the last of these is likely to be profitable.

The BBC is far from perfect, but its documentaries are great and it remains the most trusted source of news in the UK - give the news division a requirement to be profitable and the sensationalism that follows would destroy that trust pretty quickly. The last thing we need is a news landscape even more similar to the US.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by 908B64B197 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:35PM (#28463356)
> and it remains the most trusted source of news in the UK - give the news division a requirement to be profitable and the sensationalism that follows would destroy that trust pretty quickly.

It's kinda interesting that the journalist supposed to criticize the government are... on the government's payroll. There's a massive conflict of interests right there.

> The last thing we need is a news landscape even more similar to the US.

You mean several different organizations with different viewpoints and financial support from backers with known agendas?

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by robbiep on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @06:33PM (#28463868)
You mean like how opposition politicians are on the governments’ payroll and their job is almost entirely to criticise the government?

The government pays for lots of people who are not always friendly to them. Including judges, anti corruption bodies etc.

I’m in Australia so I don’t know as many specifics about the BBC but our ABC which is modeled on the BBC in many ways (except it’s not a license fee but actual government funding that pays for it) has a charter which says ’as a publicly-funded broadcaster, the ABC is expected not to take editorial stances on political issues, and is required under its charter enshrined in legislation to present a range of views with impartiality.’

Given the number of complaints by government and oppositions at various times it does this job pretty well

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by 908B64B197 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @07:15PM (#28464234)
> You mean like how opposition politicians are on the governments’ payroll and their job is almost entirely to criticise the government? The government pays for lots of people who are not always friendly to them. Including judges, anti corruption bodies etc.

These functions are pretty much guaranteed by the constitution. They ARE the government, not some state funded parallels organization with no way of fighting back. A simple majority could severely defund the BBC and pretty much nothing could be done. Makes for a good incentive to be nice to the government.

> as a publicly-funded broadcaster, the ABC is expected not to take editorial stances on political issues, and is required under its charter enshrined in legislation to present a range of views with impartiality.

For how long? Soon they might stop granting exit rights to dissidents! Australia is on a slippery slope and it seems it's only accelerating [0]

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28451066

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by robbiep on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @10:31PM (#28465559)
Again, over the long history of both the ABC and BBC there has been a strong record of investigative journalism that has been critical of the government at times. The independence for these purposes has been enshrined in law and withstood some pretty strong challenges from governments that were on the wrong side of their reporting at times. The organisations survived. The governments did not in all instances.

Re: your hyperbole on Australia turning to authoritarianism, don't believe the hype. I could just as easily say soon the United States might begin locking up immigrant children or knocking down doors hunting for illegals. Or maybe offer bounties on people having abortions. Oh wait, they already are?

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by ChrisKnott on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:41PM (#28463409)
The BBC aren't on the government's payroll and are very willing to criticise the government.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by 908B64B197 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:43PM (#28463438)
> The BBC aren't on the government's payroll

But where's the money coming from?

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by ChrisKnott on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:55PM (#28463533)
Mainly (70%) from a TV licence, the rest from selling their IP to other markets.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Television_licensing_in_the_...

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by 908B64B197 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @06:14PM (#28463703)
> Mainly (70%) from a TV licence

Whose existence is voted and that is managed by... the Government?

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by ChrisKnott on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:37AM (#28466954)
It's not managed by the government, it's a Royal Charter.

In the UK, parliament is sovereign and can ultimately do anything so they could vote to change this arrangement. This is the case with anything. Parliament could vote to execute left handers.

The fact remains, what you said is false;

1. The BBC are not on the government's payroll

2. They regularly hold the government to account

Your criticism is nonsense Libertarian speculation that is refuted by the real world.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by 908B64B197 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:32PM (#28472310)
> In the UK, parliament is sovereign and can ultimately do anything so they could vote to change this arrangement.

So tomorrow morning they could threaten the BBC with a massive funding cut unless they don't publish things they don't like... and there's nothing stopping them from doing so.

Interesting.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by iso1210 on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:22AM (#28481170)
Parliament != government. In theory it could pass a law to get rid of the royal charter. Tomorrow morning Congress could threaten ABC with confiscating its license unless they don't publish things they don't like. The German army could storm broadcasters with armed men and for them to broadcast what they say.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by chrisseaton on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:33PM (#28474928)
This argument is meaningless, because the government can already threaten any institution with changing the law to disadvantage them.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by jodrellblank on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:19PM (#28462500)
This feels like saying "why not get rid of government funded schools and have children watch Marvel and Disney instead?". The BBC's mission was to "inform, educate and entertain", Disney's and Marvels is more like "entertain, addict and profit". From Wikipedia about the origins of the BBC:

> "The British Broadcasting Corporation came into existence on 1 January 1927, and Reith – newly knighted – was appointed its first Director General.[...] British radio audiences had little choice apart from the upscale programming of the BBC. Reith, an intensely moralistic executive, was in full charge. His goal was to broadcast "All that is best in every department of human knowledge, endeavour and achievement.... The preservation of a high moral tone is obviously of paramount importance." Reith succeeded in building a high wall against an American-style free-for-all in radio in which the goal was to attract the largest audiences and thereby secure the greatest advertising revenue. There was no paid advertising on the BBC; all the revenue came from a tax on receiving sets. Highbrow audiences, however, greatly enjoyed it. At a time when American, Australian and Canadian stations were drawing huge audiences cheering for their local teams with the broadcast of baseball, rugby and hockey, the BBC emphasised service for a national rather than a regional audience. Boat races were well covered along with tennis and horse racing, but the BBC was reluctant to spend its severely limited air time on long football or cricket games, regardless of their popularity."

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBC#1927_to_1939

Americans will hate the state telling them what to watch for their own good, many Britons don't like the way it's the Oxbridge upper classes telling the rest of us what to watch, but regardless of that there was some attempt to be more than just entertainment, some values other than ad revenue. Has Marvel, Disney or Netflix made a Tomorrow's World, a Blue Peter, or anything like the Reith Lectures ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reith_Lecture ) ?

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by iso1210 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @04:21AM (#28467487)
The problem is people used to watch Blue Peter, Tomorrows World and Reith lectures because there was limited choice. Now they on the whole don't.

The article isn't advocating getting rid of the BBC, it's just reflecting on reality. The BBC has for a century been part of the nations culture. People from all backgrounds and all areas of the country earned their blue peter badges because they came home from school and blue peter was on.

That's decreasingly the case now.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by pharmakom on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:40AM (#28466649)
But equally has the BBC made a Simpsons? The Wire? Sopranos?
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by jodrellblank on Saturday September 11, 2021 @06:28PM (#28496680)
Iconic comedy? The Office, Monty Python's Flying Circus, Only Fools and Horses, BlackAdder, Red Dwarf.

Iconic political shows? House of Cards, Yes Minister.

Gritty crime/drama? Peaky Blinders, Wallander, Luther.

Massively popular? The above, plus Dr Who, Top Gear, Top of the Pops.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by pfranz on Thursday September 09, 2021 @06:57AM (#28468357)
From what I hear from other parents, the PBS Kids app is a great space where parents can trust kids and has decent content. YouTube Kids is a garbage wasteland and regular YouTube needs diligent monitoring for young kids. I find the app silos and bespoke UX (and behavior of things like offline viewing) of Netflix, Disney+, et al inscrutable for kids and some adults. I also think cable and TV manufactures helped push away young kids with their poor UX. "Back in my day" you turn on the TV you get a picture, you change the channel and instantly get another picture (admittedly, I did grow up with tuning into stations with an antennae)--but cable has been terrible for decades. Turn on the TV, turn on the cable box (and maybe stereo, too), make sure the correct input is selected, click to the next channel and wait 3-5 seconds. Good luck explaining that to the babysitter or parents staying over. They usually just use their phone.

I feel like PBS Kids has been doing a decent job. I also think NPR has done similarly well with podcasts--but I'm not sure how mainstream that is. Maybe BBC transitions to only documenting cultural milestones? I was just watching a BBC recording of Oscar Peterson from the 70s yesterday. I don't know if people like him were as popular as "shitty sitcoms in the 80s," but I'm glad someone was sponsoring and preserving these performances.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by throwaway287391 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @03:36PM (#28461961)
> I think linear TV will still be going in 10 years time, but probably not 30

I think you're probably right, but I'm one of the few millennials who will miss it when it's gone. I still like being able to turn on the news or some dumb show as background noise, it's an old habit from my boomer parent upbringing. I'm a bit surprised I haven't really met anyone else around my age with a nostalgic attachment to linear TV.

I stream things that I actually want to watch deliberately, but as a replacement for linear TV it's just not the same. It's a lot more effort (paradox of choice, beyond just the UI itself necessitating a lot more "clicks") and there's something nice about knowing that people around the country/world are watching the same thing at the same time as me. I'd like to say it could be a startup opportunity, but I think I might be the only one who cares.

Not to mention, currently an antenna will get you much better picture quality than many/most streaming services (definitely true for the BBC News stream available on iPlayer -- that looks like crap to me).

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by MattPalmer1086 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @03:47PM (#28462098)
I agree with all of that. Streaming is about choice, but linear TV is about an event and/or serendipity.

I have a lot of movies on Plex, but when we browse them it's rare for us to select one. On the other hand, we often watch those movies when they're on TV. "We have that on Plex" has become a household joke.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by iso1210 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:03PM (#28462329)
Netflix have a "watch something" button. I've never used it, but I assume it's there to match the serendipity aspect.

Amazon I think have a "watch party" feature, but that's not the same as 10 million people all watching Mr Blobby get gunged. There seemed to be a small amount of cultural "togetherness" with the guy doing the PE (Joe Someone?) during lockdown, not sure as I didn't watch it (too busy working).

But yes, events (sport, moon landings, etc) are great on linear tv. I suspect that even after most of the spectrum gets removed, there will remain a BBC linear TV channel for events for some time, and most households will have a working antenna for a long time to come.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by asdff on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:33PM (#28462681)
The problem with the watch something button is that its not truly doing what linear TV did. Linear TV was still programming. You settled on a channel that you knew was going to have decent enough stuff on at the time. You hit "watch something" on netflix and it might pull, best case, stuff from all over my watch history with no particular rhyme or reason, when really what I want is to throw on adult swim for an aqua teen hunger force marathon interspersed with similar content like that. The big advantage of some of these older networks was that I trusted their curation. If a station like MTV saw that Jackass was a popular show, they would give me a four hour Jackass marathon sometime this week and I'd probably have it on. I don't trust netflix's curation on the other hand. I'm honestly on the hunt for some live streams of 2000s era cable channels and watching that.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by QuercusMax on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:46PM (#28462832)
That seems like an easy problem to solve, if somebody at Netflix wanted to. Make it easy for people to create their own curated playlists / streams, and then you can just turn on "Jimbob23's Stupid Funny Stuff" or "Best of Late Night Cartoons" or something.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by throwaway287391 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:20PM (#28463211)
I doubt Netflix could (easily) make a product that replicates linear network TV (as much as linear TV itself is kind of a shitty product, which I say as a defender of it here). Here's why:

(1) Based on what I've seen from spending many hours scrolling through their available content (or what the algorithm will show me of it, anyway!), I'm not actually sure Netflix could put that content together into a 24/7 program that resembles a linear TV channel, even given how repetitive and often shitty linear TV content is. I could definitely be wrong about this, but I think Netflix lacks both the dynamic breadth and thematic depth of content. On the "dynamic breadth": Linear TV is at least 95% repeats, but if you watch it one day and then watch it again 6 months later, the content in your latter watch will usually be totally disjoint from the first watch. Meanwhile whenever I go on Netflix I swear like 75% of what I'm shown is things they were showing me 2+ years ago. Maybe they could still assemble their content into a 24/7/365 schedule that mimics linear TV programming, but I wouldn't bet on that.

(2) A linear TV channel isn't just a bunch of shows concatenated one right after another. At a minimum it has interstitials between shows/segments telling you what's next and what's on later. These are what gives the channel its personality/brand, and I'd assume it takes at least a few full-time staff per 24/7 channel. Think Discovery Channel's "Shark Week". It was mostly a bunch of repeats of shows they already had that happened to be shark-related, but the interstitials for it marketed it into a national event. And, dare I say it...linear TV often has ads. Ads can be a nice part of TV (especially for shitty/campy TV) -- they're when you go to the bathroom, get a snack, and/or chat about what you just watched. Certainly not a required part of linear TV (HBO and BBC are good linear TV channels and don't have ads), but hard for Netflix in particular to recreate if they were aiming to replicate the full linear TV experience.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by MattPalmer1086 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:45PM (#28462823)
Yep, I've never used the watch something button either.

I also think the shared experience of many people watching the same thing is part of the "event" nature of TV.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by function_seven on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:50PM (#28463496)
I don't think I've ever sat down and watched The Shawshank Redeption or Goodfellas. Like, made plans to watch either of those.

But I've seen both movies probably a dozen times at this point.

It's always been a matter of me stumbling upon it while channel surfing (1990-2005) or "guide scrolling" (2005-2018), landing there to kill a few minutes, and watching through to the end. A couple of times I've gotten lucky and caught the movie at the start, so I can actually say I've seen these movies. But I've seen way more of the middle and end parts than the beginning parts.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by MattPalmer1086 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @06:05PM (#28463634)
Recognise that feeling when you watch a movie for the fourth time and go "I don't think I've seen the start of this before"!
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by noir_lord on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @03:32PM (#28461923)
The irony for me is I watch zero bbc content but I love Radio 4 comedy.

So my BBC content consumption has gone up over time not down.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by wazoox on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @03:59PM (#28462275)
The main problem with the BBC is that too much of its nice content isn't available out of the UK. I see no reason why it couldn't be watched all around the world.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by iso1210 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:37PM (#28462719)
Rights issues, and of course the fact that BBC content is -- a fair whack of BBC funding comes from Worldwide (or whatever it's called this week), which sells BBC material internationally. Watch a BBC production on CBS or PBS or BBS or whatever and some money goes back to the BBC. I believe Britbox is an option too.

Same with television formats. Dancing with the Stars I believe is a popular US program based on a BBC show, the format has been licensed to half the planet.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by n8cpdx on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:49PM (#28463483)
I still don't understand why I (an American) can't pay the BBC money for access to iPlayer. BBC has been saying hell no to my money for over a decade now. It doesn't make sense. Free money! You could lower your TV tax!

I think it must be BBC official policy that they want the whole world buying VPN and pirating the content. It doesn't make sense. Throwing money away and then asking why they aren't competitive with the commercial offerings.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by iso1210 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @04:19AM (#28467480)
1) the rights to show those programs outside the UK don't exist

2) If they do exist, this would cannibalise the income via global sales, and someone has (rightly or wrongly) crunched the numbers and determined that selling Top Gear to foreign broadcasters makes more money than having iplayer as a subscription. There may also be political issues with having iplayer as a subscription too (including a call from the right wing to make iplayer subscription based for everyone. After OnDigital/ITVDigital collapsed, the BBC got in very quickly with freeview, ensuring that large numbers of decoders lacked a CAM and thus making it harder to argue for subscription)

See also Channel 5 sell Peppa Pig to Nickleodon rather than doing it direct. Or paramount selling rights to Star Trek series' via netflix or amazon rather than paramount plus outside the US.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by abdallabbc on Thursday September 09, 2021 @07:57AM (#28468692)
You may want to have a look at BritBox, which combines content produced by BBC and other UK outlets (ITV..etc).
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by goatlover on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @07:38PM (#28464385)
Sports and other live events are still linear, to the extent you wish to keep up with real time and not have it spoiled for you elsewhere. Pandemic aside, people still go to bars and friends houses to watch live events (usually sports).

Not sure that will change by 2040.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by rhdunn on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @03:25PM (#28461862)
I've completely switched to subscription and live-based content (mainly YouTube, with some Twitch). About 2 years ago I was only watching a handful of TV shows from traditional channels (BBC) and mainly there via iPlayer.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:56PM (#28463539)
You could consider the BBC to be a subscription + streaming model. Don't bother to watch on your TV, just fire up iPlayer, watch whatever you want, whenever you want. The subscription fee? Your TV license.