News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by 908B64B197 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:02PM (#28462320)
> Their 'channels' are netflix, amazon and disney. When I had the choice and they were pre-school then sure, we watched things like Alphablocks on iplayer. I can force them to watch Attenborough or Blue Peter, and they enjoy it, just not enough to want to watch them over things on disney. There's so much competition of things to do.

> This itself might not say a lot, and I still have a TV license despite the limited direct value I get (listen to a lot of BBC radio, and the news website), but what's interesting is I actually work for the BBC. If my household barely watches it, where does the future lie.

The entertainment sector is one of the most profitable on Earth. Marvel, Disney made billions making content that people want to watch and are willing to pay for. I'm not getting the reason why there should be government sponsored entertainment, especially seeing that people aren't even interested in watching it.

Why not simply compete and let the consumer decide?

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by bjohnson225 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:14PM (#28463140)
The BBC is there to “inform, educate and entertain”. It gets government(/licence fee) funding because only the last of these is likely to be profitable.

The BBC is far from perfect, but its documentaries are great and it remains the most trusted source of news in the UK - give the news division a requirement to be profitable and the sensationalism that follows would destroy that trust pretty quickly. The last thing we need is a news landscape even more similar to the US.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by 908B64B197 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:35PM (#28463356)
> and it remains the most trusted source of news in the UK - give the news division a requirement to be profitable and the sensationalism that follows would destroy that trust pretty quickly.

It's kinda interesting that the journalist supposed to criticize the government are... on the government's payroll. There's a massive conflict of interests right there.

> The last thing we need is a news landscape even more similar to the US.

You mean several different organizations with different viewpoints and financial support from backers with known agendas?

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by robbiep on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @06:33PM (#28463868)
You mean like how opposition politicians are on the governments’ payroll and their job is almost entirely to criticise the government?

The government pays for lots of people who are not always friendly to them. Including judges, anti corruption bodies etc.

I’m in Australia so I don’t know as many specifics about the BBC but our ABC which is modeled on the BBC in many ways (except it’s not a license fee but actual government funding that pays for it) has a charter which says ’as a publicly-funded broadcaster, the ABC is expected not to take editorial stances on political issues, and is required under its charter enshrined in legislation to present a range of views with impartiality.’

Given the number of complaints by government and oppositions at various times it does this job pretty well

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by 908B64B197 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @07:15PM (#28464234)
> You mean like how opposition politicians are on the governments’ payroll and their job is almost entirely to criticise the government? The government pays for lots of people who are not always friendly to them. Including judges, anti corruption bodies etc.

These functions are pretty much guaranteed by the constitution. They ARE the government, not some state funded parallels organization with no way of fighting back. A simple majority could severely defund the BBC and pretty much nothing could be done. Makes for a good incentive to be nice to the government.

> as a publicly-funded broadcaster, the ABC is expected not to take editorial stances on political issues, and is required under its charter enshrined in legislation to present a range of views with impartiality.

For how long? Soon they might stop granting exit rights to dissidents! Australia is on a slippery slope and it seems it's only accelerating [0]

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28451066

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by robbiep on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @10:31PM (#28465559)
Again, over the long history of both the ABC and BBC there has been a strong record of investigative journalism that has been critical of the government at times. The independence for these purposes has been enshrined in law and withstood some pretty strong challenges from governments that were on the wrong side of their reporting at times. The organisations survived. The governments did not in all instances.

Re: your hyperbole on Australia turning to authoritarianism, don't believe the hype. I could just as easily say soon the United States might begin locking up immigrant children or knocking down doors hunting for illegals. Or maybe offer bounties on people having abortions. Oh wait, they already are?

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by ChrisKnott on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:41PM (#28463409)
The BBC aren't on the government's payroll and are very willing to criticise the government.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by 908B64B197 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:43PM (#28463438)
> The BBC aren't on the government's payroll

But where's the money coming from?

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by ChrisKnott on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:55PM (#28463533)
Mainly (70%) from a TV licence, the rest from selling their IP to other markets.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Television_licensing_in_the_...

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by 908B64B197 on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @06:14PM (#28463703)
> Mainly (70%) from a TV licence

Whose existence is voted and that is managed by... the Government?

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by ChrisKnott on Thursday September 09, 2021 @02:37AM (#28466954)
It's not managed by the government, it's a Royal Charter.

In the UK, parliament is sovereign and can ultimately do anything so they could vote to change this arrangement. This is the case with anything. Parliament could vote to execute left handers.

The fact remains, what you said is false;

1. The BBC are not on the government's payroll

2. They regularly hold the government to account

Your criticism is nonsense Libertarian speculation that is refuted by the real world.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by 908B64B197 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:32PM (#28472310)
> In the UK, parliament is sovereign and can ultimately do anything so they could vote to change this arrangement.

So tomorrow morning they could threaten the BBC with a massive funding cut unless they don't publish things they don't like... and there's nothing stopping them from doing so.

Interesting.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by iso1210 on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:22AM (#28481170)
Parliament != government. In theory it could pass a law to get rid of the royal charter. Tomorrow morning Congress could threaten ABC with confiscating its license unless they don't publish things they don't like. The German army could storm broadcasters with armed men and for them to broadcast what they say.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by chrisseaton on Thursday September 09, 2021 @05:33PM (#28474928)
This argument is meaningless, because the government can already threaten any institution with changing the law to disadvantage them.
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by jodrellblank on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @04:19PM (#28462500)
This feels like saying "why not get rid of government funded schools and have children watch Marvel and Disney instead?". The BBC's mission was to "inform, educate and entertain", Disney's and Marvels is more like "entertain, addict and profit". From Wikipedia about the origins of the BBC:

> "The British Broadcasting Corporation came into existence on 1 January 1927, and Reith – newly knighted – was appointed its first Director General.[...] British radio audiences had little choice apart from the upscale programming of the BBC. Reith, an intensely moralistic executive, was in full charge. His goal was to broadcast "All that is best in every department of human knowledge, endeavour and achievement.... The preservation of a high moral tone is obviously of paramount importance." Reith succeeded in building a high wall against an American-style free-for-all in radio in which the goal was to attract the largest audiences and thereby secure the greatest advertising revenue. There was no paid advertising on the BBC; all the revenue came from a tax on receiving sets. Highbrow audiences, however, greatly enjoyed it. At a time when American, Australian and Canadian stations were drawing huge audiences cheering for their local teams with the broadcast of baseball, rugby and hockey, the BBC emphasised service for a national rather than a regional audience. Boat races were well covered along with tennis and horse racing, but the BBC was reluctant to spend its severely limited air time on long football or cricket games, regardless of their popularity."

- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBC#1927_to_1939

Americans will hate the state telling them what to watch for their own good, many Britons don't like the way it's the Oxbridge upper classes telling the rest of us what to watch, but regardless of that there was some attempt to be more than just entertainment, some values other than ad revenue. Has Marvel, Disney or Netflix made a Tomorrow's World, a Blue Peter, or anything like the Reith Lectures ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reith_Lecture ) ?

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by iso1210 on Thursday September 09, 2021 @04:21AM (#28467487)
The problem is people used to watch Blue Peter, Tomorrows World and Reith lectures because there was limited choice. Now they on the whole don't.

The article isn't advocating getting rid of the BBC, it's just reflecting on reality. The BBC has for a century been part of the nations culture. People from all backgrounds and all areas of the country earned their blue peter badges because they came home from school and blue peter was on.

That's decreasingly the case now.

Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by pharmakom on Thursday September 09, 2021 @01:40AM (#28466649)
But equally has the BBC made a Simpsons? The Wire? Sopranos?
Re:The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying by jodrellblank on Saturday September 11, 2021 @06:28PM (#28496680)
Iconic comedy? The Office, Monty Python's Flying Circus, Only Fools and Horses, BlackAdder, Red Dwarf.

Iconic political shows? House of Cards, Yes Minister.

Gritty crime/drama? Peaky Blinders, Wallander, Luther.

Massively popular? The above, plus Dr Who, Top Gear, Top of the Pops.