Reminds of the Maoism movement in European universities (such as in France) a few decades ago, where people critical of Mao were harassed and treated as fascists. With some universities would make Maoism a de-facto precondition to be accepted as researcher.
This seems to share the same mechanism: very few righteous people having no longer any morale compass due to ideology, and cowardliness of the rest of the herd (including the administration) that refuse to stand for reason and logic.
"The minority rule will show us how it all it takes is a small number of intolerant virtuous people with skin in the game, in the form of courage, for society to function properly. "
The most extreme being (in French - https://www.deepl.com/fr/translator) the Vincennes university: https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centre_universitaire_de_Vincen...
[ TL;Dr: The most Maoist university at that time, with communists fighting (with violence) against Maoists inside the university ]
Note that this was a more "experimental" university, aimed to attract the most radical teachers (!)
There are plenty of research for the years between 65-75
Few years ago it was contained to humanities but as of recently, it started spreading in technical fields. See how AI researchers got cancelled [0]
[0] https://syncedreview.com/2020/06/30/yann-lecun-quits-twitter...
“there are only two ways of telling the complete truth — anonymously and posthumously.”
A big contributor to said reasoning out was his observing the antics of late-1960s black Cornell students (mostly admitted via affirmative action and, Sowell said, unqualified for the university's rigors), their takeover of university buildings, and their justifying doing so by claiming various outrages against themselves that were foreign to the day-to-day life that Sowell, a fellow Cornellian and Ithaca resident, experienced.
It makes sense intuitively - nothing productive is really being done when a group just engages in ever-escalating virtue signalling.
But since I'm not an expert, is there more material about this that one can access? Would love to read/hear someone who studies this.
— C. S. Lewis
Will it, though?
So, yes, it may.
To a cynic like me it just seems like they're buying good PR, and it's relatively cheap.
Read "Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix" and pay attention to how Delores Umbridge defines a set of ideas that must not be questioned. Her role of Inquisitor is similar to the role of a modern Diversity Council.
Your statement proves their point.
The defining of ideas can be contentious, difficult, jarring, and uncomfortable. That they are to one but not another doesn't disqualify them as debatable topics or make the arguer less qualified to make them.
Defending yourself rigorously with evidence and rhetoric was a skill people went to good colleges to learn. Bari argues that universities now reinforce not engaging in debate with or challenging the ideas of anyone who doesn't already believe what you believe (or their signals) but toeing an unspoken line, and that there's no room for nuanced discussion of the ideologies.
It's like a loyalty test where recognizing it openly for what it is is an instant fail.
They have been taught the magnitude of their outrage makes them righteous. And their outrage is never satiated. These people are toxic and sometimes evil. They'll eventually come for you too no matter how much you generally agree with them.
Some of them are certainly sincere. But as Milton Friedman once said, "sincerity is an overrated virtue". The damage they cause is the same irrespective of how sincere they might be.