Re:My university sacrificed ideas for ideology, so today I quit
by jfengel on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @01:19PM
(#28460190)
The author appears to me to be one of the contributors to that lesson. His posts consist exclusively of him being outraged about something or other.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:My university sacrificed ideas for ideology, so today I quit
by washadjeffmad on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @02:30PM
(#28461215)
Edit: sorry, thought you were talking about Bari.
Your statement proves their point.
The defining of ideas can be contentious, difficult, jarring, and uncomfortable. That they are to one but not another doesn't disqualify them as debatable topics or make the arguer less qualified to make them.
Defending yourself rigorously with evidence and rhetoric was a skill people went to good colleges to learn. Bari argues that universities now reinforce not engaging in debate with or challenging the ideas of anyone who doesn't already believe what you believe (or their signals) but toeing an unspoken line, and that there's no room for nuanced discussion of the ideologies.
It's like a loyalty test where recognizing it openly for what it is is an instant fail.
Re:My university sacrificed ideas for ideology, so today I quit
by native_samples on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @05:21PM
(#28463225)
How so? His story is one in which he was relentlessly harassed, and in which his attempts to tolerate and reason with his opposition resulted in him being illegitimately forced out of the university. Despite that, his "outrage", if you can call it that, is hard to spot: his letter describing the reasons for his resignation explains why he's doing it, but is low on invective.