Pretty sure apple’s developer documentation would still be bad though.
Every app delivered on this store must go through the same review process whether it's internally built or not. This has led to healthy innovation on the app store and deep empathy for the 3rd party developer.
To be fair, it is possible to ship components that are part of the core platform outside of this mechanism, but I think just having one subset of internal development go through the same review/approval channels as 3rd party apps has been very positive for our developer community.
I'd love to see the same thing here.
It doesn't actually need this. The phone app can just ask for permission to access your location, which you would then give it when you call 911 because you want the emergency responders to know where you are.
Anyone who really wants to can already deny the phone their location by using a Faraday cage with a WiFi access point in it so the phone has internet but no GPS or cellular triangulation. You can't prevent it by not allowing the user to deny the permission.
There is no excuse for special permissions.
It doesn't need special permissions. You should be able to deny it your location if that's what you really want to do. It just needs good defaults.
For example, Apple Music should not have privileged access to location services - it should be using the exact same location APIs and permissions as 3p apps.
> Every app delivered on this store must go through the same review process whether it's internally built or not
Believe it or not, but internal Apps go through an even more stringent review as they have Apple branding. The exception is they're allowed various privileges that wouldn't be appropriate for 3p apps (security or even that a framework isn't quite ready for prime time & needs some bake time with internal users for whom back compat isn't a concern).
There are other standalone arguments calling for a breakup, but agreeing with the parent doesn't automatically lead to the conclusion that a breakup is required.
It works in theory, but when the application team and review team both report to the same CEO, the review team will be pressured to bend the review policy.
The evolutionary history matters a lot in these things, since they set the culture and precedent on the platform.
Macs and desktops started (or at least, became popular) as an open environment where users obtained software directly from vendors. iOS and Android (with the caveat that it has always supported sideloading) started as closed systems, and the vast majority of customers are used to getting their software from the official app store.
UPDATE: Fixed a typo
Not necessarily alternative app stores / install mechanisms, which is a separate issue.
Seems very related.
Perhaps the iOS and Android app stores are also middle men that provide close to zero value but forced themselves onto mobile phones.
Not so much for the rest of the world, though.
As a thought experiment: how many companies would leave the official iOS App Store if offered a choice tomorrow? Epic Im sure... but the experience on Android suggests to me not that many. As with Android, I think a lot will still want a presence on the default/"official" store regardless of the 30 percent take. Don't forget Apple have also done the hard part of getting a customer to enter their CC number to their iCloud account for their store, removing an enormous amount of friction in the sales process too.
- every app has their own licensing system
- I have to keep track of emails, license key files, logins and other bullshit manually instead of having it synchronized automatically at application install. Not to mention I have a boatload of shop accounts that have collected my payment and other personal data (e.g. postal address) and whom I have to trust now that they keep their data secure enough to not have it stolen.
- for subscription stuff, I have to update payment details for an awful lot of individual shops instead of having one single place
- refund policies vary wildly, as is tax compliance for foreign companies
I agree that Apple and Google must be reined in - 30% cut are absurd rip-offs, and the fact that stores can censor legal content (e.g. anything marijuana/tobacco/drug related or adult content) is troubling - but the central store model does have advantages.
At the same time, MAS is not suitable for many business customers. Eg. some companies buy software exclusively through resellers -- not possible on the Mac App Store. So you need to sell licenses outside the store as well, at which point you may ask yourself: Why bother with the app store?
Suppose you could buy iOS apps from Google Play and vice versa, and also buy both kinds of apps from Amazon, Microsoft and Epic. They still take care of all the payments and licensing bullshit, but now the developer gets to choose how to distribute their app, so the competition drives down fees.
And then once all the stores are charging low fees because otherwise nobody would use them, developers tend to put their apps in all the main stores and the user can choose the stores(s) they prefer to buy through.
Whether or not Apple permits alternative payment systems for iOS/iPadOS, all the apps will likely remain sandboxed.
You'll pay the same price, but instead of getting a license you can run on unlimited of your own machines, or sometimes a fixed number like you can register it to 3 machines at a time, you can only install it on other computers that are managed by the same iCloud account. I've learned this the hard way with a bunch of productivity apps, if you want to use it on a personal machine and a work machine in the same way you can easily install all the free apps that you use on both machines, you're out of luck if you bought it on the Mac App Store. I've ended up re-buying a few different productivity tools over the years that I made the mistake of buying on the Mac App Store first, so that I actually had a portable license I could use that wasn't tightly coupled to making my personal text messages and iCloud files available on the same computer I want to use the license on. You also can't install mac app store apps via homebrew in a setup script or any kind of tooling you use to manage the computer (maybe this is getting better with shortcuts, but I'm not aware of a way to do it).
If it's a cross-platform app, you pay the same price but lose the ability to ever run it on Windows in the future if you buy it from the app store. If it's one of the few AAA games that support MacOS at all, if you buy on Steam you usually get a cross-platform license and there will often be a bunch of bundles that include extra DLC packs at a discounted price. Once a game is a few years old it will start going on sale all the time on Steam. The mac app store version usually won't go on the same sales and usually doesn't have any bundles available either.
If you have multiple user accounts created on a computer, you can't even upgrade a free app that a different user installed via the Mac App store, even if your user also has admin privileges. Only the same user that originally installed it can upgrade the app even though the app is available to every user on the machine.
There's really no reason to ever install anything from the Mac App Store, other than first-party Apple apps where you have no other choice (like XCode, Garage Band, Keynote, Final Cut, etc.)
I hate anti-steering so much that I hope any future legislation against it also enforces retroactive refunds for a significant period of time. Whatever money they have made is basically entirely due to pulling wool over users’ eyes, and they need to be losing millions from this as a punishment.
There's a choice of app store in Android and almost nobody uses Amazon App Store, F-Droid, Samsung App Store and so on. It's great that they can exist, but I don't think the Mac App Store (which has been neglected since day 1) offers any guidance.
People mostly use what they know or are giving by default. In desktop, be it Windows, Linux or macOS, people aren't used to app stores.
It's a shame because the old Fire tablets were pretty good for kids, but now the malignant ad and micropayment cancer has returned so it's no good anymore.
You also can't install the various alternate stores themselves through Google Play and Google purposely makes installing APKs a pain for regular people.
And then it's "see, nobody wants them" after they purposely put a wall in front of them which most people can't get past.
So developers still need to be in Google Play to get all the users who can't figure it out, but if everything is in Google Play then even the customers who could figure it out have no incentive to go through the trouble.
At the very least Apple should improve the store to make it Amazon level in feature set. But it feels like they abandoned it.
Not Mac user but I guess it is the same as for Windows. I have some desktop products for Windows. The thought of releasing them to MS Store had never crossed my mind.
https://panic.com/blog/coda-2-5-and-the-mac-app-store/
MAS requires sandboxing, distribution outside the store does not. That said, Apple turns the 'default sandboxing' screw another half turn with every release.
In addition to subscription revenue, upgrades are possible by releasing a new product version (e.g. "OmniGraffle 7" in MAS) with a free tier ("read-only mode") and in-app purchases for new users as well as upgrades from OG 6.
I believe you can read purchase receipts within your developer team to determine upgrades.
But I have concerns about additional stores, not about entropy and all the multistore problem from a UX perspective, but as a privacy threat. I like the current Apple politics "we are a hardware company, not another user data selling platform," and they do great things in that way.
But what happens, if Facebook move their apps to their store without any restrictions on privacy? So they can do anything they want, and not only they. If now App Store got strict rules about privacy, what will happen in that situation?
It's not so unbelievable that Facebook will try to get back their "data profit" from Apple users.
They’re moving to selling subscriptions and data is critical to that.
Strict rules would actually give them a huge edge over their other services competitors on platform and if they could couch it in anti-trust, that would be quite a coup.
At least they kept it out of Buddy this time haha.
That would take away from the smaller person's chance.
That list grows stale and complaints over who is on the list starts.
It’s just surprising to me that Apple didn’t take such a basic step to do this, when it seems it would so clearly increase the value of the platform. It is why it is difficult to believe anything they say about how much they “love” the Mac...every single action they take to “help” the Mac platform is just baffling.
If they simply listed all major Mac apps, e.g. linking to their web sites or download links or whatever, they would hugely increase the value of the Mac platform and bring enough direct benefit to developers to be worth some kind of fee (and of course Apple gets $99/year anyway). Instead, they tried to port the same clueless, greedy, review-burdened scheme to that store, layering completely unnecessary requirements on top (like poorly-thought-out sandboxing). And since developers had a choice, they mostly said No.