News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by Joeri on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @01:22PM (#28370853)
Sometimes I try to imagine what the app store rules would look like if apple had to abide by those same rules for all of their own apps. I imagine the rules would be much more lenient, app review a lot less error prone, and developers would be chafed far less by those golden handcuffs.

Pretty sure apple’s developer documentation would still be bad though.

Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by haswell on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @01:47PM (#28371161)
I work on a platform that provides its subscribers with a store for 1st and 3rd party apps/solutions built on that platform.

Every app delivered on this store must go through the same review process whether it's internally built or not. This has led to healthy innovation on the app store and deep empathy for the 3rd party developer.

To be fair, it is possible to ship components that are part of the core platform outside of this mechanism, but I think just having one subset of internal development go through the same review/approval channels as 3rd party apps has been very positive for our developer community.

I'd love to see the same thing here.

Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by novok on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @02:56PM (#28372025)
So what is the platform?
Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by kernoble on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @06:45PM (#28374543)
If I had to guess it would be something like Slack, Shopify, Squarespace or some other SaaS platform that needs to meet the needs of a hugely diverse customer base.
Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by haswell on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:08PM (#28375136)
I’d prefer not to name the specific platform to maintain anonymity, but you’re in the right ballpark.
Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by frutiger on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @01:43AM (#28376733)
Somewhat obvious if you check their submission history.
Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by vlovich123 on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @01:06AM (#28376591)
Do you run 1p and 3p code in the same environment? That’s frequently the challenge mobile operators run into - the OS needs privileged access to location services (eg 911) that it can’t grant untrusted code.
Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @02:14AM (#28376882)
> That’s frequently the challenge mobile operators run into - the OS needs privileged access to location services (eg 911) that it can’t grant untrusted code.

It doesn't actually need this. The phone app can just ask for permission to access your location, which you would then give it when you call 911 because you want the emergency responders to know where you are.

Anyone who really wants to can already deny the phone their location by using a Faraday cage with a WiFi access point in it so the phone has internet but no GPS or cellular triangulation. You can't prevent it by not allowing the user to deny the permission.

There is no excuse for special permissions.

Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by throwaways885 on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @06:19AM (#28378081)
Calling 911 is one of those times when I really, really don't want to see permission popups. If I'm in a car crash, I ain't going to be lucid enough to make sure the permissions are set properly. I am almost certain there are legal restrictions in this direction.
Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by AnthonyMouse on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:21AM (#28401011)
So give the phone app access to your location before you get in a car crash. This is presumably the factory default anyway, since the app comes preinstalled on the phone, or it asks you the first time you open it.

It doesn't need special permissions. You should be able to deny it your location if that's what you really want to do. It just needs good defaults.

Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by moonlighio on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @06:51AM (#28378264)
moonlightop
Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by dannyw on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @01:47AM (#28376753)
OP isn't saying the OS goes through the same review processes, but (some) 1p apps do.

For example, Apple Music should not have privileged access to location services - it should be using the exact same location APIs and permissions as 3p apps.

Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by vlovich123 on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @10:14AM (#28380090)
All Apple apps go through review & many have the same requirements/restrictions as 3p apps. I read OPs statement more forcefully than you may have:

> Every app delivered on this store must go through the same review process whether it's internally built or not

Believe it or not, but internal Apps go through an even more stringent review as they have Apple branding. The exception is they're allowed various privileges that wouldn't be appropriate for 3p apps (security or even that a framework isn't quite ready for prime time & needs some bake time with internal users for whom back compat isn't a concern).

Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by blago on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @09:15PM (#28375512)
Ban Apple from using internal APIs? I like that.
Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by mdoms on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @02:11PM (#28371467)
I agree, Apple should be broken up.
Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by haswell on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @02:20PM (#28371590)
It's not necessary to break Apple up to implement a policy that requires Apple to apply the same process to their own apps.

There are other standalone arguments calling for a breakup, but agreeing with the parent doesn't automatically lead to the conclusion that a breakup is required.

Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by wolpoli on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @03:18PM (#28372279)
> It's not necessary to break Apple up to implement a policy that requires Apple to apply the same process to their own apps.

It works in theory, but when the application team and review team both report to the same CEO, the review team will be pressured to bend the review policy.

Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by wins32767 on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @03:33PM (#28372468)
And if it's have the policy or be broken up the CEO will be pressured to not let them bend it...
Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by CydeWeys on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @06:49PM (#28374587)
The stick only works if you actually get the stick if it's merited, though. So it could easily end up actually being broken up under your proposal.
Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by wins32767 on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @09:30PM (#28375585)
Not really. The risk to a CEO of having to deal with an angry government is waaaaaay more than the benefit from internal teams not having to deal with a bad process.
Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by haswell on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @03:50PM (#28372666)
Internal pressure is a fair concern, but is not a foregone conclusion. If anything, unfair approvals of Apple-developed apps would enrage the developer community and shine even more light on the issue.
Re:Apple and Google must allow other in-app payment systems,... by sunshinerag on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @05:10PM (#28373702)
or the users who don't like it can jump ship. really nothing holding you back.