Totally for high speed rail depending on if the money gets to it. Japan has shown a private/public transportation system is possible. That being said, it'll probably go to a politicians friend's company and it'll end up like the $90 billion California train.
The current K-12 public school system is a joke, lets fix that first. I'd rather see school of choice. You can already qualify for preschool if you need it. For college, let's lower tuition before making the tax payer pay off the current tuition debt and then paying for free college for even more. (but really lets not pay people's debt)
I get what you're saying, but consider this. If you explicitly funnel money to these people for the purpose of warfare, they will only make weapons and train people to engage in warfare and supporting activities.
Best case scenario, you got some specialists who are "also" proficient in adjacent technical skills, related to warfare (e.g. cybersecurity), and a bunch of military hardware sitting on parking lots (or falling into the hands of the Taliban).
But if you engage them for education or high speed rail, sure, they pad their pockets, sure, but at the end of the day you at least got some infrastructure for schools, rail engineers and supporting roles for those fields. You don't have to deal with depreciating military machines, who are only fit for destruction.
I don't mean to say I have the ultimate truth regarding this, but personally, I will pick the $90 billion California train over 300 days in Afghanistan every single time.
Making "universal" programs is the same thing as Afghanistan, you won't get anything out of it in the end and it'll end up costing you trillions.
The best government program is near to no program. Don't print more, let it hold it's value, don't steal from the people. Then you'll have oodles of wealth to help the true people in need, either through private companies or through limited government programs with oversight.
Stop giving them tax payer fund spigots, they can't be trusted.
If you want your country to have healthcare, at the very minimum you do the Swiss system.
That being said, no I don't believe in socialist programs, Sweden was a pretty good example they aren't feasible, it crushed their economy and they are slowly reversing course. I think there should be safety nets, but the government should not be in charge of your life.
There's a reason America is the economic powerhouse it is today, limited programs, less taxes. Our private healthcare system is expensive but leads the world in innovation (cancer treatments, experimental drugs, vaccines, etc.) The American people pay for that R&D while the world gets it basically for free. I don't have an issue with universal healthcare, but we should lower costs first, not throw more tax payer money to hospitals and pharma.
The American healthcare system is not better because we spend more money, it’s better because we have good universities and lots of immigrants.
Agree we should lower costs - deregulation does not lower costs in this case.
1000x no! We need government to work - that's not negotiable - the question is not whether it works well enough to make you happy, it's what it should work on. The US didn't go to the moon or build the interstate highway system by saying, "Politicians suck, I hope the private sector solves this."
I'm all for R&D spending, defense spending, infrastructure spending, etc. But time and time again OUR recent government has shown they cannot be trusted with the funds and programs they suggest. They make these massive bills and none of the money makes it to anything meaningful.
I'm for SPECIFIC programs, not UNIVERSAL slush funds.
Name the bridges you want to repair, repair them. Don't try to steal $5 trillion while funneling it to "green companies" without fixing a single pothole.
You will get.. infrastructure, healthcare, education. How is this nothing?
Otherwise they’re better off burning the money.
So before we jump onto thinking about making internet free (if that was ever even a plan), I think it would make sense to make water+electricity free first.
Having utilities free sounds pretty good, but idk how helpful it would be to deal with homelessness (which is one of the main issues with basic access to all of those things), given how small of a fraction utilities make up when it comes to overall housing costs. Don't get me wrong, I am absolutely not in the camp of "just because this improvement proposal might have some issues, we should just sit and do nothing", and free utilities would definitely be an improvement, and a massive one at that. I just think that, while we are floating those proposals, we shouldn't forget the elephant in the room either, which is "how do we make sure that everyone who needs access to housing has access to housing".
This would greatly increase the amount of critically thinking population. I do not think it lines up well with what the government and elites want.
I'm of the (apparently dated) notion that we are the government.
And I don't mean with a (token) vote. I mean actually designing and implementing national policy, designing and setting up monitoring of outcomes, and reporting back to everyone else on how the policy idea performed.
https://scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/mgilens/fi...
I wish I were as optimistic as you.
...which is why the government subsidizes college tuition with grants and guaranteed loans? Or that banks give out the same loans as well?
Those taxpayer guaranteed loans are just taking money from future taxpayers and giving it to the higher education business by letting them increase tuition without limit since there is no underwriting process.
And of course the students get saddled with lifelong debt with no exit since they are not dischargeable in regular bankruptcy, and future taxpayers get soaked with paying for the defaulted loans.
Private banks used to give out those loans because they were still guaranteed by the government, and I think Obama changed that, but they still have special status that make them harder to discharge in bankruptcy.
Tl:dr taxpayer funded loans for higher education are a net negative for society
Ignoring how expensive and difficult that is if you're already saddled with 6 figures of debt for the purpose of discussion. I'm not American and haven't found a clear answer though my Googlefoo.
This can have various consequences depending on the new home country and its agreements with the US - from credit issues and possible legal action, to absolutely no consequences at all.
Obviously if the person moves back to the US, they'll likely be chased by debt collectors and possibly the IRS.
To be clear, I think the other ideas are great, except that one.
Yeah that's a dumb idea. All that would do is cause houses to be even more expensive.
Edit: to poster below, it varies, very noticeable if you are traveling. For your cost of living, it's noticeable over the month if you are living paycheck to paycheck. My point is don't just "print away", inflation is a tax on the poor.
Car rental 87.7% (y/y change)
Used cars 45.2%
Gas 45.1%
Laundry machines 29.4%
Airfare 24.6%
Moving 17.3%
Hotels 16.9%
Furniture 8.6%
Bacon 8.4%
TVs 7.6%
Fruit 7.3%
Shoes 6.5%
Fresh fish 6.4%
New cars 5.3%
Milk 5.6%
Rent (OER) 2.3%
Most things have not had anywhere close to that. The things that have draw more attention, though.
For something more recent, look at US home prices over the past year. It's crazy.
Food costs are also rising. Anecdotally, grocery prices have gone up quite a bit. Restaurants, too. I don't remember a large pizza costing $25 a couple years ago.
It's been 40 years. Applying the rule of 72 ('cause I can't be bothered to do a more sophisticated analysis) and assuming that your "200%" means prices have doubled since then, that comes to 1.8% annual inflation. Very reasonable.
Still, it's about 2.8%. Not bad, if you look at it that way. But it adds up.
I know some normal tech guys with 3 or 4 million in assets. They'd barely be 80's millionaires.
But yes, being a millionaire isn’t what it used to be.
Make a countrywide high speed rail system.
Universal free preschool
Universal free college
(Edit: for scale rather than an example of necessarily a good) Paid off half the mortgages in the US
The list goes on and on. Let nobody say we don’t have money for improvements to our society.