News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Economic costs of war by JohnJamesRambo on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:22PM (#28204113)
Deaths 9/11 2,996

Deaths Covid-19 USA 621,000

207x

Lack of understanding of large numbers is a flaw in the human mind we have to figure out how to fix.

Re:Economic costs of war by bb88 on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:09PM (#28204542)
Things like 9/11 were easily played over and over again, and generated support for the afghan war in the first place.

In NZ when the terrorists broadcasted the Christchurch mosque shootings on facebook, NZ took action swiftly -- banning most semiautomatic weapons.

When BLM protests showed cops shooting, tasing, and running over people with patrol cars -- those images were more compelling than any story that could have been written.

OTOH, Last year one nursing home in NJ had stacked up 17 bodies during a in a shed during a covid outbreak -- yet none of the gruesomeness was aired. I have not recalled seeing any videos of people falling dead due to a mass shooting in the US, other than maybe blurred out video.

I'm not saying we should or should not see more graphic images, but it seems like self-censorship of the aftermath of violence or tragedy has unintended consequences.

Re:Economic costs of war by asdff on Monday August 16, 2021 @11:08PM (#28205752)
It certainly does. Vietnam was the first war with embedded journalists showing the american people live footage of real combat. It was often gruesome. It lead to people protesting in the streets, burning draft cards, fleeing to Canada, and most of all made the Vietnam war into a political quagmire and put pressure on ending it. That sort of coverage of a conflict has noticeably never happened again. Anytime you see footage these days on the news it feels like B rolls or some stock footage of a couple solders walking around the desert or a truck driving along or some far off building exploding. The media hides the reality of war from the American public after seeing how the public has reacted in the past to this content. It's disingenuous, and you end up with kids joining thinking it will be like Call of Duty and coming back home with PTSD and no easy future due to their broken condition.
Re:Economic costs of war by dillondoyle on Monday August 16, 2021 @10:39PM (#28205549)
I completely agree with that. because of HIPAA there hasn't been nearly enough media. There is more now I think a concerted effort to get testimonials of people in hospital their family dead saying they wish they got the vaccine. But it's too late.

I think if we had Vietnam style video of death from the start we wouldn't have as large of a % living in alternate realities.

Re:Economic costs of war by runawaybottle on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:25PM (#28204129)
Some related numbers for just Afghanistan:

American service members killed in Afghanistan through April: 2,448.

U.S. contractors: 3,846.

Afghan national military and police: 66,000.

Other allied service members, including from other NATO member states: 1,144.

Afghan civilians: 47,245.

Taliban and other opposition fighters: 51,191.

Aid workers: 444.

Journalists: 72.

https://apnews.com/article/middle-east-business-afghanistan-...

———

It’s funny, over 60k Afghan police/military died, and our plan was to arm 300k of them and hope they like perpetual war against the Taliban. Yeah, I think they did a hard pass on that one and just wanted it all to stop.

Re:Economic costs of war by swader999 on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:38PM (#28204253)
I think a lot of those trained had allegiances to the Taliban. Many reports of this but was ignored by higher ups.
Re:Economic costs of war by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Monday August 16, 2021 @11:14PM (#28205785)
I think what we have here is a failure to understand population motivations. I do not want to overstate this, but it seems to be lost over the fact that it was two decades now. US was the invader here. You can train all you want, but those people are not idiots or easily swayed. They survived multiple regime changes, coups, upheavals and this is just another one of them.

As insane as it sounds, in that frame of mind, Taliban is a lesser evil here compared to a foreign adversary that walks around like they own the place.

Once you understand this, and by this I mean "the population does not want you here and sees you as the invader", none of this is a surprise.

Next up, just wait till you hear what population of Iraq wants ( but we all know US simply cannot leave Iraq -- ever ).

Re:Economic costs of war by asdff on Monday August 16, 2021 @11:18PM (#28205822)
They did a hard pass on that one when their commanders were embezzling their resources and they were expected to defend a nation with shoestrings and no backup or any more resources on the way. It was a suicide mission to not give up, plain and simple.
Re:Economic costs of war by baybal2 on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:42PM (#28204287)
That's a big undercount on the civilian, and opposing force side.

If you count in excess deaths, and missing people, the count will more than double.

Re:Economic costs of war by ineedasername on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:56PM (#28204432)
Regarding perpetual war, I'm not sure that was inevitable. Without massive corruption, incompetent leadership, and Russia providing weapons to the Taliban things might not have been so bleak.
Re:Economic costs of war by ClumsyPilot on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:05PM (#28204505)
Without massuve corruption life in Russia would not be bleak.
Re:Economic costs of war by techrat on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:24PM (#28204121)
Ah yes, but Haliburton couldn't spend money on a 'war against mask wearing', so they were the true victims here.

/s, of course.

It's been obvious early on that the whole motive for our ratfucking of the middle east had nothing to do with the "WMDs" nor 9/11... lest we would have not gone under false pretenses, actually had gone after the country who financed the ones who flew the planes, nor remained as long as we had after Bin Laden was found. Instead we spent more money than had ever been spent before on one thing in our country's history... but on another country.

That money went somewhere.

Defense contractors.

Meanwhile, infrastructure all across the US is derelict.

Case in point, 47,000+ bridges in the US are now considered 'structurally deficient.'

https://www.npr.org/2019/04/05/710364158/report-finds-more-t...

Bin Laden himself said what his end goal was.

> "We are continuing this policy in bleeding America to the point of bankruptcy," bin Laden said in a taped statement. Only the smallest sign of al-Qaida would "make generals race there to cause America to suffer human, economic, and political losses without their achieving anything of note other than some benefits for their private corporations."

The article this quote was pulled from is from 2011. So, for at LEAST TEN YEARS, we knew the explicit goal was to prolong an unwinnable war in order to bleed the country dry.

https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2011/05/the-cos...

Why couldn't these defense contractors be paid to bring things up to snuff here instead of pissing it away on a 'war against terror' that we had no hope to win?

Bin Laden got what he wanted in the end.

Re:Economic costs of war by randyrand on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:44PM (#28204319)
years of expected life lost is the more important metric imo.

would still be a big discrepency.

Re:Economic costs of war by Sebb767 on Monday August 16, 2021 @09:53PM (#28205215)
> years of expected life lost is the more important metric imo.

If you start doing this, you start valuing peoples lives differently, which is a horrible thing. Going just from this, you could say that an Afghan citizen is worth about 82% of an US citizen (64 vs 78 years life expectancy) or that burning down a whole palliative care unit is less bad than shooting a 20 year old (or 16 year old Afghan).

I can see where you are coming from, but this is really not a good road to go down.

Re:Economic costs of war by amscanne on Monday August 16, 2021 @10:44PM (#28205586)
I hate to break it to you, but “quality-adjusted life years” [1] is already a standard metric for evaluating medical interventions.

While the whole “death panel” thing is exaggerated, it is necessary that insurers (incl. single payer governments) have quantitative ways to evaluate different treatments. They won’t throw infinite $$ at every treat that is expected to add a tiny amount to your life.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quality-adjusted_life_year

Re:Economic costs of war by neither_color on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:09PM (#28204544)
apples 2,996

oranges 621,000

I dont dispute your numbers at all...I just don't understand your point. They're just such vastly different situations managed by different sets of people for different reasons. The "war on terror" was excessive and over budget, but not 100% uncalled for. There WERE follow up terror attacks that happened(london bombing 2005, madrid bombing 2004, paris bataclan attack, etc) and there were some that were foiled, even if just by luck like the shoe bomber. I agree that Afghanistan went too far, too long and too expensive but what does that have to do with covid?

Re:Economic costs of war by Dylan16807 on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:13PM (#28204578)
Anti-terror efforts were called for. But there wasn't much overlap between what was called for and what we actually did.
Re:Economic costs of war by neither_color on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:16PM (#28204599)
What does that have to do with covid though? Im not here to justify the war on terror Im just wondering what the basis of comparison is. Covid has affected nearly 100% of the population in almost every country either directly and indirectly, either by getting sick or not being allowed to work or shop or show their face in public. The reach of covid response has gone far beyond having to take our shoes off in airports. Is OP upset that the nobody has calculated whether it has cost trillions yet?
Re:Economic costs of war by Dylan16807 on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:39PM (#28204751)
> What does that have to do with covid though?

The argument is that the effort we spent in the war on terror, per motivating death, was massively greater than the effort we've spent fighting covid.

> far beyond having to take our shoes off in airports

That would be a valid comparison in TSA vs. covid response. This is about much more than the TSA!

Re:Economic costs of war by dragontamer on Monday August 16, 2021 @11:13PM (#28205780)
> The argument is that the effort we spent in the war on terror, per motivating death, was massively greater than the effort we've spent fighting covid.

We can't even get people to take the vaccine willingly after we made every vaccine free.

When will we learn that money doesn't solve everything? It is only a sufficiently motivating factor to greedy people. Religiously motivated people are explicitly raised to be weary of money (you cannot serve two masters: choose God or mammon, where mammon is roughly translated as money, greed, or material wealth)

--------------

We can't spend money to grow the Afghan army, because they weren't motivated by money. We can't spend more money to fight COVID19, because the anti-vaxxers aren't motivated by money either. Our vaccines are sitting in storage and expiring.

We designed and built the vaccines in record time. I'm not entirely sure how else we could add money to this system and expect any benefits with regards to COVID19. Student nurses are regularly helping out in hospitals before they're even graduated, we're pulling retired doctors/nurses out of retirement to help fill hospitals. Etc. etc.

Money isn't the solution anymore. We've spent as much as we're able. The remaining problems that face us are entirely independent of money.

----------

The only consistent thing between Afghanistan and COVID19 is that Americans have overspent money hoping that overspending will fix everything.

Re:Economic costs of war by throwaway0a5e on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:49PM (#28204816)
Is it lack of understanding or simply a difference in priorities?

It's very fashionable around here to call millions of people stupid for not sharing whatever the "right" opinion is.

Re:Economic costs of war by havelhovel on Monday August 16, 2021 @11:34PM (#28205924)
There have been numerous studies demonstrating our inability to rationally assess terrorism relative to other threats. Acknowledging our psychological shortcomings is the first step toward self-improvement.
Re:Economic costs of war by glitchc on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:33PM (#28204205)
It’s not the what, but the how. A terrorist attack on home turf is a slap in the face of every American. Outrage is to be expected.
Re:Economic costs of war by mikeodds on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:37PM (#28204231)
Take a look at how many people die from domestic shootings in the US
Re:Economic costs of war by asdff on Monday August 16, 2021 @11:15PM (#28205797)
It wasn't the first terrorist attack on home turf and it wasn't the last. The outrage was drummed up by the media to build support for the war. Remember the Dixie Chicks getting ostracised for speaking out against the war? They were one of the most popular artists at the time and their careers were over after that in an instant due to how gung ho everyone was. I think part of the initial support was that people were envisioning another Desert Storm, less than 50 days and done thanks to superior American training technology firepower etc. When it came to not be the case that support seemed to evaporate fast and many awoke from the collective stupor enraged at the outsized response with ill defined goals, some of the more clearly defined ones being entirely false (Saddam's WMDs).
Re:Economic costs of war by markdown on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:43PM (#28204307)
Patriotism is a sickness that the world would be better without.
Re:Economic costs of war by ineedasername on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:54PM (#28204410)
I'd replace the word patriotism with jingoism. A certain amount of pride in your country seems reasonable.
Re:Economic costs of war by mc32 on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:50PM (#28204378)
Is that what we want t tell all the revolutionaries around the world?

Would the taleban take your words to heart?

[dead]
Re:Economic costs of war by Sebb767 on Monday August 16, 2021 @10:03PM (#28205278)
Or people of all colors and nations (some of them surely white guys) angry that the "white guy choice" did win the election. DC was quite boarded up [0] and it was not in fear of a Trump loose.

Please don't be a racist and call the factions by what they are, not by their gender or skin color.

[0] https://wjla.com/news/local/a-look-around-dc-hours-before-el...

Re:Economic costs of war by diognesofsinope on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:54PM (#28204847)
I chalk it up to politics (politicians) -- the reality is the Republicans would never live 9/11 down if they didn't go to war.
Re:Economic costs of war by teawrecks on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:29PM (#28204156)
Assume it will never be fixed. What's another solution?
Re:Economic costs of war by nostrademons on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:35PM (#28204217)
Create a system where ignorance of the laws of large numbers means that you go bankrupt and have to work for someone else, thus putting the number-crunchers in charge.

This is basically modern capitalism. It works, as a way of managing large numbers. Most people hate it, though, because it has a tendency of reducing humans to numbers.

Re:Economic costs of war by ClumsyPilot on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:07PM (#28204521)
"of reducing humans to numbers."

Or making them slaves, exploiting children, etc. If the laws allow such

Re:Economic costs of war by nostrademons on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:18PM (#28204616)
Same difference:

"Evil begins when you begin to treat people as things." -- Terry Pratchett

Slaves, exploited children, etc. are just resources whose dollar value you try to maximize and whose wages you try to minimize.

Re:Economic costs of war by travisgriggs on Monday August 16, 2021 @09:43PM (#28205145)
HN needs a +50 button for Pratchett references.
Re:Economic costs of war by fengsui170 on Monday August 16, 2021 @10:29PM (#28205462)
Loss of 621k lives on one side or two or more doesn't really amount to War. Ike never lost 1 life in the mil. for the term of his admin. Eighth grader mil. brass knuckleheads promoted too far these days are puppets on the mil. industrial complexes's strings. Do the share buy backs the mil. firms do go ultimately to sovereign wealth hedgefunds such as the Communist Party behind smoke and mirrors?
Re:Economic costs of war by s5300 on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:31PM (#28204193)
I swear dude.

I cannot understand just why it is that the average person seems to be so incapable at understanding statistics and large numbers. It's mind boggling. Ever since my freshman engineering stats class, it's like everywhere I look at where there's stupid bullshit happening, a large reason as to why the stupid bullshit is happening is because people have zero understanding of statistics and large numbers.

It's always been incredibly intuitive to me as somebody schooled in the US public education system, and I wasn't even good at math until college because the school teachers were just terrible at teaching actual concepts. And like, I know that I am very much nothing special. But to too damn many people, it just seems to completely blow over their heads...

Re:Economic costs of war by pessimizer on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:41PM (#28204285)
Statistics are not intuitive, and it's the assumption that they are that leads people into error.
Re:Economic costs of war by s5300 on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:51PM (#28204388)
No, not all statistics are intuitive, definitely a reason why there's statistics, and then engineering statistics in most colleges.

However, the simpler parts/beginning of either course... really do seem like they should be intuitive to anybody who made it with a D through middle school math. Basic applied ratios and such. Like the fact near 5 billion covid vaccines have been administered worldwide now and there are still people vehemently arguing about the horrible things that are going to happen to them specifically if they get a vaccine...

Re:Economic costs of war by SV_BubbleTime on Monday August 16, 2021 @11:46PM (#28206003)
> there are still people vehemently arguing about the horrible things that are going to happen to them specifically if they get a vaccine...

Can you make a steel man argument on their behalf?

Or is that so preposterous that it beneath you and wouldn’t waste your time on that?

Because I’m starting to wonder if people with strong opinions like yours seems to be really are any different than the true believers on “the other side”. Or if you just feel confident in your echo chamber as “unquestionably right” because you (or I) aren’t questioned.

I find the more I know about a topic the less I make absolutes like the one I quoted. You can’t make legitimate arguments against the covid vaccines? Shouldn’t we all be able to?

Re:Economic costs of war by s5300 on Tuesday August 17, 2021 @12:45AM (#28206319)
What?
Re:Economic costs of war by bumby on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:53PM (#28204396)
I don’t think we evolved to think about statistics in an intuitive manner. I think we tended to think more causally and with computationally less intensive heuristics. Asking most people about the birthday problem veridical paradox is a quick way to illustrate this.

I would also argue it’s why humans are bad at estimating risks regarding low probability events. See: spacecraft mishaps that seem obvious in hindsight

Re:Economic costs of war by baybal2 on Monday August 16, 2021 @07:49PM (#28204356)
I can say so for politics.

Average Americans don't understand American politics.

To me, the transition from Bush to Obama was paradoxal.

One thing, Obama marketed himself as a change man, as well pretty much everybody. It's very generic.

On the other side, his true colours weren't even hidden, his electoral programme told very candidly about his national security views, views on civil rights, and etc for which he got flak later.

If I haven't seen the name, and explicitly liberal branding on these electoral materials, I could've said it's coming from a conservative, doctrinaire statist very much like Bush.

The point is people are angry at Obama exactly on the points they elected him for.

Re:Economic costs of war by gsk22 on Monday August 16, 2021 @09:53PM (#28205218)
This will be an issue as long as the US has first-past-the-post elections.

In the current system, many people simply vote for the least bad option, because voting for a party that actually represented their beliefs would make their vote irrelevant (or worse, give an advantage to the party they really dislike).

Re:Economic costs of war by ineedasername on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:04PM (#28204502)
My impression was that Obama wanted to be more progressive-- domestically if not internationally. But he got derailed spending 2 years of a supermajority on a single issue (healthcare) partly because more centrist democrats objected to the more progressive ideas, and partly due to special interests. After the midterms he had little chance at passing more progressive policies, leaving a fairly centrist foreign policy agenda.
Re:Economic costs of war by cjsplat on Monday August 16, 2021 @10:59PM (#28205698)
First, the ACA passed in March 2010, so not really 2 years on health care. The tweaks folded into reconciliation were not a major distraction.

Second, if by super-majority you mean filibuster-proof, then in reality this was nowhere near 2 years.

Al Franken (the 60th vote) was not seated until the court challenges finished on June 30th.

Ted Kennedy died August 25. So that is about 8 weeks of super-majority.

Paul Kirk was seated on Sept 24, and Scott Brown took over on February 5th. So a little over 4 more months.

That is a total of about 6 calendar months of filibuster proof majority.

A glance at the legislative calendar shows a total of a little over 110 total Senate legislative days, out of a total of about 350 legislative days in 2009/2010.

So in reality, Obama had a filibuster proof majority for about 1/3 of his first 2 years.

Re:Economic costs of war by ineedasername on Monday August 16, 2021 @11:29PM (#28205885)
You're correct, I meant filibuster proof. On everything else you mention, the major pieces of the ACA-- given it was a #1 priority-- could have been laid down well in advance so that things were ready to go once the people were in place.

I am probably being unfair though: cleaning up the end of the financial crisis took significant effort as well, so managing that and any single piece of significant legislation should be counted as a productive half-term. I suppose that even if all pieces of the ACA had been in place for the earliest possible vote, it still would not have left a lot of time for another significant bit of progressive legislation.

However I stand by my core point, which was perhaps not well expressed: Obama's campaign message conveyed a significant progressive agenda (at least on the domestic front). I don't think that was false on his part. I think the extent to which that agenda was not achieved is because after the mid terms there was no chance of passing progressive legislation.

Again, I think I botched my prior comment by not making that clear. I may have botched this one as well... Let me know, I like to know when I'm wrong.

Re:Economic costs of war by supperburg on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:33PM (#28204710)
Can you provide a source for COVID deaths? Is there a source that gives the number of deaths that were caused by COVID and nothing else? They say that anyone who died and tested positive for the presence of COVID was considered a COVID death even if they got hit by a bus for example. And many elderly people died from it who were on the brink of death and were just as likely to die from some other minor insult. I wonder how many life hours were lost, I think that might be a more accurate metric.

Traffic deaths in USA over 2 years ~80,000. Nobody cares.

Re:Economic costs of war by SilverRed on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:35PM (#28204727)
>Traffic deaths in USA over 2 years ~80,000. Nobody cares.

Many people do care about this and advocate for less car infrastructure, safer streets, better walkability and better public transport. Car centric design was the worst mistake of the last few decades.

Re:Economic costs of war by throwawaysea on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:45PM (#28204789)
There is a clear positive return on those traffic deaths. We live far richer lives because of motor vehicles and what quick private transportation unlocks. I think car centric design is great personally.
Re:Economic costs of war by SilverRed on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:48PM (#28204805)
Debatable but there is a lot of research showing long car commutes are taking a significant toll on mental health and physical health. We have constantly rising rates of depression, stress and obesity. All things that are partially linked to car usage.

We live far richer lives due to a huge array of technological progressions.

An anecdote but my life massively improved when I got rid of my car and moved somewhere where walking is my only transport method needed. I'm healthier, happier, and have more free time.

Re:Economic costs of war by koyote on Monday August 16, 2021 @10:04PM (#28205287)
Do you think that a car centric society such as the US has benefited its residents more than a society which has moved away from car centric city design such as the Netherlands?
Re:Economic costs of war by jobigoud on Monday August 16, 2021 @08:43PM (#28204777)
If anything it's underestimated, this can be seen by comparing the number to excess mortality.
Re:Economic costs of war by supperburg on Monday August 16, 2021 @10:14PM (#28205349)
Mortality doesn’t seem to have spiked. It’s just continued the trend upward that started in 2009. Looking at a chart of mortality, I don’t see anything.

https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.CDRT.IN?location...