I think these are both bad arguments. If the most used stablecoin is used for most BTC volume as well as other crypto trades, you'd expect it to be more.
>. And no one seems to know anything about how it works
What? People do know how it works, or at least as much as with many other projects.
This seems impossible because at their scale, that would make them, like, the 5th largest commercial paper investor on Wall Street. How could commercial paper investors not heard of them?
Every single time that ifinex was upfront about where the money was going, their bank accounts would be closed with little notice.
I can understand why they would stay tight lipped about where they are stashing $60B+.
Once Tether implodes, it takes the entire bitcoin market with it.
https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/tether/
https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/usd-coin/
https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/multi-collateral-dai/
Tether is at 60billion market cap compared to Usdc 30 billion and dai around 5 billion. Should probably look at volumes aswell.
I think we would get a major crash if tether fails, but I also think it will recover with usdc and other stable coins that have more legitimacy.
For now, its a house of cards that no one can really afford to remove their stake from. Those who have to use tether, are in a very precarious position.
In the end people who leave their funds at exchanges will be the one with the short end of the stick.
Why should an exchange go broke because something they trade falls in value?
(They don't.)
For instance, the attestations no longer claim that they hold backing funds.
[1] https://cryptocriticscorner.com/
[2] https://www.kalzumeus.com/2019/10/28/tether-and-bitfinex/
It always amazes me that the whole house of cards continues to stand and hasn’t completely blown up.
We also know people can be irrational so those who depend on Tether to operate simply cannot acknowledge it is a scam.
It's basically like a pyramid scheme where you can buy your way out by shilling hard enough for Bitcoin.
The risk is still right there.
My understanding was that Coinbase was 1:1 dollars, and they actually had that money in banks, etc. Then, they ended transparency and the 1:1 peg. This is when people suspect they started getting debt to buy BTC - but this is presumably legal, right?
Do they have any obligation to be transparent - being a publicly traded company?
The problem is there's a lot for the HN community to like in it, if you're willfully blind to it's hypercapitalist and manipulative nature: fun technical challenges, little-guy-vs-the-world. I get it, I really do.
And of course, there's so many problems with smart contracts - even the core idea of permanent, irrevocable transactions where bugs can leave you destitute and without anyone to speak to. And no way to unwind them. [1] Unless you're big enough, I guess, and can just fork the chain like Vitalik did with the DAO.
- defi: images hosted on url's that can disappear
- eth sites: exists since 1970?
- eth auth: a step back, lose keys, lose account. No recovery possible.
...
Can you say what exactly was "innovated"?
Inefficiency - Banks and financial institutions spend billions on opex (ex. BoA spent $53 billion on SG&A and occupancy/equipment in 2020). Well written protocols and decentralized trust can increase efficiency and collapse this number
Permissioned access - For better or for worse, anyone can create financial products and a whole market for it without asking the SEC
Opacity - Instead of using paper/hidden digital ledgers, open source contracts lets one easily follow money flow through code and transactions
Access - Turns out the world is very big and lots of people are either locked out from traditional financial institutions or their preexisting ones just really suck.
(some examples taken from article https://parthchopra.substack.com/p/part-2-why-defi-is-not-a-...)
That are inefficient too, slow and costly. 51% was possible from China anytime until they banned it. Insane workarounds are proposed for easy problems.
Instead of the SEC, some sharks/influencers are ruling the markets. Not a week goes bye without a new hack or malicious ownership of the cloud solution or an on purpose malicious contract or extreme scams ( eg. Tether, USDT, ...). Within a second, all their money is away.
People just hide money with currencies that hide their money trail.
The nr. 1 problem for access to banks is internet access, look at El Salvador. They are suddenly creating internet access that hasn't been there before, creating a fake dogma. They had access to banks, it was just a long drive away. Transferwise could reduce transfer costs, but a big problem is also a faulty governement or eg. In case of Libanon: stable electricity. Crypto doesn't solve any of that.
In the end, it's all about the hype and a lot of the end-users don't understand how it works and aren't protected from their own stupidity.
Which is exactly where eg. Opex helps.
Ps. Copy pasting your answer without a minor edit even just shows how mindless this thing has become.
And what party are you trusting for your insurance?
In which country?
And how can shares take one week to convert? My broker has a deposit account in a German bank, it takes 1 click to convert. The button's name = buy/sell.
I'm not sure if i have ever encountered a problem. I can use methods outside wire transfer to have additional funds deposited immediately.
And the shares on Defi aren't exactly shares, are they. I wouldn't touch a bank that does this and calls it "shares".
As said before, it doesn't solve any problems.
Ps. In case you didn't knew. Knowing the country is important for potential legal action ;)
Now tell me, what country is Binance located. They are one of the biggest in DeFi ? :) And how trustworthy are the "stable coins" backing the different DeFi protocols? :)
Do i need to remind you that you literally copy-pasted your "conclusion"?
You have given me no reason to proof me wrong.
Saying "do your research" is exactly the reason of my conclusion and answering with that statement is another way of saying: ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Eg. Helium Network HNT - decentralized hotspots?
Like i said, nothing new. Decentralized mesh networks already exists and those solutions are inferior to an ISP forcing a hotspot option, existing options, esim or mobile hotspot.
It's absolute bs that their "Network Coverage" page only shows info about their Blockchain and price, not actual wifi coverage that is of interest for customers, lol.
This is how it should look like: https://fon.com/maps/
Masquerading their Blockchain as a product doesn't make it useful in real-life.
At least give something that is actually useful instead of "i don't know an answer, but check this and that".
It IS a scam and it is backed by nothing. Only to pump the BTC price artificially.
The unveiling of this scam was seen and covered a mile away and was a long time coming.
To Downvoters: I'm sorry BTC maximalists, but this scandal was waiting to be cracked down and no, it is not FUD, or whatever denial spiral you are going through.
Just read: https://twitter.com/smdiehl/status/1393669812220465162
It is legitimate to raise the Tether concern yet he confidently drops into very binary conclusions driven by his pure hate for crypto.
For example, his claim that it's 100% a scam whilst this fact isn't established.
Or calling any trade in crypto "shady". This one shows his true colors. A huge amount of people just deposit dollars on a KYC exchange, then buy and sell whatever crypto they fancy.
None of this is shady. It's fully legal, taxes are paid, it's like stocks. Yet according to him, any trade in crypto is shady.
Or, the claim that the 800 billion market cap of Bitcoin is solely based on Tether. That's an absurd statement.
As said, maximalists can be extreme, but so can anti-maximalists. He deeply hates any and all crypto, has zero nuance, and is not open to any type of discussion.
> None of this is shady. It's fully legal, taxes are paid, it's like stocks. Yet according to him, any trade in crypto is shady.
True, there has been a lot of activity that was no worse than gambling. Let's tally up everything that's come out of the space, good and bad, and ask where it comes out on net. Somewhere in region of "a giant casino with a mad electricity bill on an island with no cops, teeming with scumbags who busy themselves with fleecing the innocent suckers in there desparate to come away with one of the lambos on stage". Yes, you pay tax on your winnings when you get back to the mainland.
> Or, the claim that the 800 billion market cap of Bitcoin is solely based on Tether. That's an absurd statement.
"800 billion market cap of Bitcoin" is already an absurd statement.
Again, a huge part of crypto is perfectly legitimate, just retail buying/selling crypto via KYC exchanges. It's not lawless, just a free market of assets.
Which any individual can use or ignore as they see fit. You can use an investment strategy (buy and hold), trading/speculation strategy (minority of day traders) or indeed go the gambling route: super high risk bets using leverage.
Calling this entire spectrum consisting of hundreds of millions of users "gambling" is simplistic, binary thinking. Most crypto holders have less than 10K USD worth of holdings and rarely trade on it.
"800 billion market cap of Bitcoin" is already an absurd statement."
How so? Because you think it's worth less, or perhaps zero? If you're so super confident about that, short it. You'll get filthy rich whilst proving you're right.
But you won't short it, because you have no idea.
The guy hates crypto. A normal person would declare that and move on. He makes it his life work to hate crypto. He's consumed by it. That's anti-crypto maximalism.
A source to distrust as much as a pro maximimalist. Both have agendas set in stone, are not open to reason and nuance.
It's not even zerohedge: It's copied from bombthrower.com
That ZH article's ifs, possiblies, and maybes are doing a lot of heavy lifting.
Is the Bitcoin price up? Queue the Tether FUD.
There are now >$60Bn worth of Tether coin issued. With that much money they'd be a very serious private financial institution, and yet they only have 13 employee's. They have never been audited by any independent third party. They have repetitively lied about who owns the company (the same people who own Binance, the world's largest crypto exchange own Tether, and yet did not disclose that until it was found out). They have receptively changed their story on what backs Tether coin (originally each coin had $1 in a bank account to back it, now it's majoritively unspecified "commercial paper").
There is nothing which proves that Tether actually is backed by anything and the billions in new Tether coin which are minted could very well be worthless.
I thought Tether & BitFinex were the two partners? Am I wrong?
Also, there is nothing which proves that Tether actually isn't backed by anything.
I see a lot of people jumping to conclusions about a topic they are self admittedly ignorant about. Perhaps wait for the DOJ to do their jobs if you don't have insider knowledge.
In response to -dsr's sarcasm below (rate limit), I've got a bit of my own.
"I've run a profitable business for years and haven't committed fraud during the time I spent in an unregulated environment. Now that regulators are nearing my doorstep, it's the perfect time to start committing fraud." /s
There is a lot of circumstantial evidence though. To wit:
* Tether was previously caught lying, in a manner that is attuned to how many big frauds start (you hit a small road bump, so you lie to cover up the road bump, figuring you'll be able to make up the shortfall before too long. But now your lying projections are going faster than your ability to catch up, so what was originally a "small" lie is now a "big" lie). Tether had had the cash, until it was stolen from them, and they started lying to pretend that it wasn't stolen.
* Notably, Tether has yet to provide any audited statement of their claimed finances, in over 4 years. Even the attestations that they have come out with don't actually provide much in the way of reassurance.
* Their claimed asset breakdown, the closest thing any of us have to being able to being able to validate their claims, is presented in the form of 2 pie charts with vague labels, one of which is so bad that no one knows what it's supposed to mean ("reverse repo notes").
* Doing the math in the above point, they claim to be one of the largest consumers of commercial paper. They haven't said whose commercial paper they're buying, and no one has reported transacting with them. Supposedly this is for privacy, but it is the standard in the entire industry to just list all of your holdings for transparency's sake [1].
* Also, Tether has increased its issuance to the tune of several billion dollars a month. That's the kind of extraordinary claim that requires extraordinary evidence to back it up.
[1] Unless you're Bernie Madoff and you're promising awesome financial returns with your secretive trading strategy. Except it also turned out that said strategy was a literal Ponzi scheme. Note that "we're not telling you what we're investing in" is generally one of the red flags for a fraud.
My understanding is funds in a bank account were seized and the account closed. Describing the shortfall that followed, while they tried to recover said funds, as fraud, is a tremendous mischaracterization.
Did somebody at Bloomberg have a BTC short position blowup? They have a long history of publishing FUD to manipulate markets in their favor. I hear people are still looking for the mythical SuperMicro "spy chips"... lol
They covered up pertinent facts that would seriously question their liquidity and/or solvency.
Let me put it like this: suppose you were selling your house to me for $1 million. If I had $1 million in We Are Criminals Shadow Bank, Ltd., and I've been struggling for weeks to get them to give me any of my money back, how would you feel if I told you that I had $1 million in cash without mentioning any of those details? That's exactly what Tether did.
If you still feel that calling that fraud is a mischaracterization, well, I have a bridge to sell you. I mean, I've been having a bit of trouble with the recorder of deeds over it, but that should get straightened out any day now, so it shouldn't matter, don't worry about it.
The group ... didn't do that. They kept the BTC and said "sucks to be you".
There's no evidence against it.
There's nothing proving that the boogyman doesn't exist either.
In 2017, when they were busy securing other banking partners due to accounts being shutdown.
I consider this a gap due to growing pains, as did the NYAG. How would you shutdown Tether temporarily (2-3 months) if a bank ends a relationship?
By refusing to take deposits for new Tether, and by shutting down redemptions if necessary while the banking relationship is sorted out.
Tether doesn't exist ex nihilo; it requires active management to issue and redeem coins. If it ever cannot live up to its "fully backed" claim, then continuing to operate under a pretense is fraudulent.
I agree and expect that is the lesson the $18M fine taught them.
The key point is, they had a legitimate reason for under-collateralizing during the biggest bull run in crypto history at that point. 2014-2017 was the perfect period to begin fraudulent activity if they were really interested in it.
I guess the question is, what is the best time to commit fraud in the crypto space, earlier or later (during-post increased regulatory scrutiny)?
When I see that a company founded by criminals has lied, I tend to assume that they will be lying again. I think that is a fairly safe bet.
This was while they did have a banking relationship. What was the exscuse then?
Wish we could have a 100% XMR world without even a single dollar in sight. Won't happen until the end of the petrodollar which won't happen until the end of the US military.
But why are you conflating USD with crypto anyway? USD is a currency that is actually used for purchasing goods and services. Crypto isn't used for anything except speculation. If capital gains is the goal, then yes, the USD won't be of much value to you as it's not particularly volatile.
> Federal Reserve notes are not redeemable in gold, silver or any other commodity, and receive no backing by anything
Bigger scam than Tether. Has been running for almost a century now.
> Crypto isn't used for anything except speculation.
Looks like Amazon's going to accept cryptocurrency as payment:
https://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-cryptocurrency-seeks-...
Hopefully we'll be able to put this "cryptocurrency is just speculation" argument to rest soon.
[1] https://gizmodo.com/amazon-to-accept-bitcoin-by-end-of-2021-...
[2] https://www.barrons.com/articles/bitcoin-goes-mainstream-as-...
[3] https://www.cnbc.com/2021/07/07/visa-says-crypto-linked-card...
I've helped friends move in exchange for beer and pizza but nobody would call that a transaction "backed by the US Economy".
That's what gives the rewards program credibility. Real currency still changes hands in the background, but the customer only spends 'points'. Currencies, although unbacked by gold, are still credible because they are legal tender and widely accepted in ways that rewards points are not.
Amazon and other private businesses can refuse to accept BTC whenever they want. Earlier this year, Tesla 'accepted BTC for payments', and then changed their mind a month later.
Some countries have accepted BTC as legal tender. It's only a matter of time really.
Why?
Considering the shaky fundamentals, I'd rather not trust greedy strangers to stop burning the world down trying to get rich quick.
Another truth is governments force their citizens to use their own currencies. They require citizens to pay taxes in those currencies. They probably even require stores to accept those currencies.
Yes. Speculation and their ~~criminal conspirators~~ exchanges.
> Another truth is governments force their citizens to use their own currencies.
Absolutely. Not a single person in this thread has argued otherwise. What's your point? How does that somehow make something else more stable? If the government is the big bad wolf, what's stopping it from using that same force to blow USDT's house down? What army and treasury is going to rescue USDT when it crashes? (And it will crash, eventually, just like every other market in history has, whether its due to Tether's negligence or external pressures)
Not that different from traditional banks and other elements of the financial sector.
> What's your point?
My point is there is no fundamental difference between cryptocurrencies and legal tender.
> What army and treasury is going to rescue USDT when it crashes?
When the traditional finance people screw up, the US government bails them out with taxpayer money. It should totally do the same for Tether.
This is how a fiat currency is supposed to work. Earn it, then buy some gold, silver, real estate, crypto, or whatever. And inflation is not necessary a bad thing.
The value if USD, no. It doesn't depend on US military strength. The US government and banks inflate it as much as they want.
https://www.zerohedge.com/crypto/what-effect-would-tether-be...
(Yes, I know it's zerohedge, but this is a decent article)
Tether usually has 2-3x the volume of bitcoin in any given day. And no one seems to know anything about how it works. So in my estimation, it probably is a scam...