News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @09:08AM (#27737570)
For me and a friend, we'd joke about our existential despair. "What's wrong?" "The Void"

Any philosophy that just asserted that the Universe has meaning was a non-starter, for me. There is nothing that I can see that unambiguously tells me that the Universe ultimately has absolute purpose or meaning. It could, but anyone who tells you they know the fundamental question of why we are here is delusional or a liar. The only overarching framework that could situate me confidently in the world would have to explicitly acknowledge that the Universe could in fact be meaningless.

An English course in college helped me out with this. A lot of the course covered Norse religion and philosophy, which was intensely bleak. Ragnarok, in one version, is the End. There is no rebirth or renewal. The world will be consumed by Fenrir and the chaos wolves, and after, for eternity, the world will be Winter. In that philosophy, this is a fact of life: this future is preordained. Your best outcome is to be invited by the Gods to fight - and lose - in the final battle against the Forces of Chaos and Despair. You're going down, but the highest honor you can bring yourself and your kin is to go down fighting.

Humans create meaning in the face of an uncaring, indifferent Void. It's our superpower. Human-created meaning is arbitrary, but no less real for that. The fact that Vikings chose to create meaning by slaughtering their unfortunate neighbors is a bit beside the point. That was their interpretation, but it's not the only, nor best one.

Hwæt! The Universe might be meaningless, these nihilistic Viking ghosts whispered to me, across the centuries. Live bravely, do not allow yourself to wallow in despair while entropy gathers itself. Make meaning, fight, build, love, stay healthy right in the face of the Uncaring Void. It's the only thing you can do. Entropy will win. Until then, make it meaningful.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by brundolf on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:56AM (#27738606)
To add to this: I grew up with religion and eventually broke away from it. I went on this hyper-realist streak, looking to break down life and reality into its most fundamental parts. I assumed this would include true meaning. It didn't.

What I found is that meaning is like a delicate ecosystem, and I was strip-mining. I thought I was breaking reality down into its most fundamental pieces, harvesting them and learning the truest truth, but it turned out there were important things that couldn't survive the process, and I was destroying them.

It was only by allowing myself suspension of disbelief and embracing the meaning I already knew inside of me that I was able to pull myself out of nihilism and find happiness again. Meaning was there; I simply had to stop getting in its way. It may not have any physical or metaphysical reality, but it has a reality in the human spirit, and that's really all it needs to be. The proper response to "But meaning is just a fragile idea that lives only in our minds!" is "Yes! And that's why it is so precious and so important to guard carefully!"

We must tend to our gardens, not grind them down for their components

Epilogue: I didn't return to religion, though I did come to appreciate how many things religion got right via millennia of accumulated human experience. And a nice thing about knowing that meaning doesn't come from metaphysics is you don't have to subscribe to any one doctrine; you can internalize the pieces that seem true and set aside the pieces that you believe are wrong, morally or logically.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by SMAAART on Monday July 05, 2021 @11:49AM (#27739132)
> Meaning was there; I simply had to stop getting in its way.

You just described the Hero's Journey (Monomyth). The end of the journey is nothing more than the return to the starting point, the world has not changed, the Hero is the one that has changed.

Many people do know this, understand this, and see (their) life as a Journey; what people miss is that not everyone is a Hero.

Welcome home.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by physicles on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:56PM (#27741739)
I had a very similar journey. Even after 10 years I sometimes still slip into existential despair, and the remedy is, as you said, a bit subtle: don’t outright ignore it, but also don’t attack it directly. No matter how hard you stare into the void, you will never see anything but darkness.

It’s a bit like happiness: if you pursue happiness directly, you will surely fail. Instead, pursue worthy goals and care for others, and happiness will take care of itself.

I also learned that, as you wrote, we can lean on human biology. If one asks, “Why should I wish to strive to make progress in life and keep living?” the a suitable answer is simply “Because I’m human and that’s how I’m wired.”

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by brundolf on Monday July 05, 2021 @05:49PM (#27742142)
I look at it a bit more like Tinker Bell: meaning may only exist while you believe in it, but that doesn't make it not real. When you believe in it without picking it apart, it's as real as can be. So let yourself.

As a musician I like once put it, careless realism costs souls

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by handrous on Monday July 05, 2021 @11:27AM (#27738915)
> For me and a friend, we'd joke about our existential despair. "What's wrong?" "The Void"

The "vacuum the rug" comic went over well in my social group.

https://imgur.com/d9KdAvH

And so did a certain look into Mister Peanutbutter's inner life, which re-contextualized some things, after seasons of his being a goofy and dopey character (though, very occasionally, and tellingly, not—also, thematic/character spoiler warning for Bojack Horseman, I guess?):

"The universe is a cruel, uncaring void. The key to being happy isn't a search for meaning. It's to just keep yourself busy with unimportant nonsense, and eventually, you'll be dead."

And of course there's Frost's "Maple", which, for me, always comes to mind when "meaning" is the topic:

http://famouspoetsandpoems.com/poets/robert_frost/poems/731

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by hungrykoala on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:09AM (#27738164)
I think the "Universe/life has no meaning" sentence can mean two completely different things:

1. It could have a meaning, but there is none. For example food can have taste, but if it has none, we assume there is something wrong with it.

2. It is not possible for it to have a meaning, because it simply lacks that property. For example: what is the color of running? There is no color, and could never be.

I think "Universe/life has no meaning" falls in the second category, and I have absolutely no problem with that.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by all2 on Monday July 05, 2021 @12:53PM (#27739797)
> There is no color, and could never be.

This illustrates the scope of experience we apply to the world. I have never seen a color of running, but somoeone has. Synesthesia is very real and to those who possess it, there is a color of running. There are whole worlds of understanding that we cannot see because we lack the ability to see them.

Some we can learn to see, some we deny because of reason or they have faded in our memories, some we dismiss out of hand because, well, "that can't possibly be true".

All that to say: you might be missing the meaning of life, the universe, everything because you are not equipped to see it.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by naasking on Monday July 05, 2021 @01:14PM (#27739939)
> This illustrates the scope of experience we apply to the world. I have never seen a color of running, but somoeone has. Synesthesia is very real and to those who possess it, there is a color of running.

Subjective properties are not objective properties. Synesthetes perceive subjective interpretations of objective properties. The perceptual distortions enabled by psychedelics are also not reflecting objective properties of the world, but subjective properties related to the information processing in your brain.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by all2 on Monday July 05, 2021 @01:28PM (#27740037)
You're sidestepping the metaphor.

The point is that you and I may not be mentally equipped to observe reality in a way that shows underlying purpose.

There's the assumption that the thing yields its purpose when inspected.

Consider a screw driver. If you and I see it but lack the knowledge of context into which it was created (driving screws) we would say it is obviouslymechanical, obviously designed and manufactured. A screw driver (or other mechanical apparati) don'thappen by accident. But no amount of inspection, theorizing, or philosophical discourse would yield its purpose or its use cases to us.

We assume, by looking at the universe, that it (the thing) will yield to us purpose or reason for being. We can't get that information about the universe from the universe. We need to step back and consider "where did the universe come from". The context of origin may yield the purpose of the thing.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by pmoriarty on Monday July 05, 2021 @02:43PM (#27740743)
"We assume, by looking at the universe, that it (the thing) will yield to us purpose or reason for being. We can't get that information about the universe from the universe."

Unless you can ask the universe about the universe, which some people think they can.

Even if they're right, though, I'd argue that you could never know if you got the truth from the universe, if it was lying, or if you were just deluded.

People can find meanings in all sorts of things and in all sorts of ways. Doesn't mean they're right.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by all2 on Monday July 05, 2021 @03:43PM (#27741217)
> People can find meanings in all sorts of things and in all sorts of ways.

I've been grappling with this recently. Specifically the question of "What amounts to fantasy and superstition and what reflects reality?" Pyschedelics is a rabbit-trail followed from here, as well as the idea that "nothing is actually real, this is just a simulation". And following those is the idea "reality is what you make it" and "you are God". But those conclusions run up against things that we cannot change like death and taxes (the taxes part is a joke, but only kind of). We're left with a dissonance of "all is illusion" vs "there exist things that we cannot change and things that are consistent outside of ourselves".

If we were in a dream-state and there was not actual object permanence then I'd agree with the conclusions of the religious pyschedelics crowd, as well as the all-is-illusion crowd. (Except there's some math from quantum physics that shows things don't exist unless you look at them...[0] or something like that. Conversations like this make me wish I took more comprehensive notes.) So I guess it is all an illusion until we touch it. :D That reminds me of the early graphical rendering method "culling" where if something isn't in the rendered field-of-view (FOV) then it doesn't get passed through the graphical pipeline.

How this informs the quest to extract meaning from the universe, I don't know.

This is a bit of a rabbit trail by itself. I do wonder at the fabric of existence from time-to-time, but I don't wonder at the purpose of it all -- religious convictions being what they are to me.

[0] https://www.sciencealert.com/reality-doesn-t-exist-until-we-...

[edit for spelling]

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by pmoriarty on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:07PM (#27741399)
"What amounts to fantasy and superstition and what reflects reality?"

I don't see how we can ever really know. We only ever have access to our own experience. How could we ever find out what the world is really like beyond our own "subjective" experience?

"Pyschedelics is a rabbit-trail followed from here, as well as the idea that "nothing is actually real, this is just a simulation". And following those is the idea "reality is what you make it" and "you are God". But those conclusions run up against things that we cannot change like death and taxes (the taxes part is a joke, but only kind of)."

Who's the "we" that can't change that?

Some believe that our "true self" is the universe itself or god, and we are just deluded in to thinking we're separate individuals. In that view death is illusory as the universe or god don't die, and taxes and everything else about the world is created by the universe or god (ie. by your "true self").

There are many other views too, even if you reject yourself being god or the universe, that consider everything in the world (including death and taxes) as illusory. Many mystics, for instance, considered the material world to be illusory and the heavenly world or the world of god (or of "ultimate reality") to be real.

"We're left with a dissonance of "all is illusion" vs "there exist things that we cannot change and things that are consistent outside of ourselves".

Do we really need to be able to control the world for it to be an illusion?

If we're, say, brains in vats, then we might just be fed our illusory experience and be unable to change it.

"If we were in a dream-state and there was not actual object permanence then I'd agree with the conclusions of the religious pyschedelics crowd, as well as the all-is-illusion crowd."

I don't see why you'd need any kind of object permanence either for the world to be an illusion.

Also, one's belief that there's object permanence could itself be yet another illusion.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:30PM (#27741546)
Descartes' I think therefore I am has become a cliche, but it is profound. I can chuck any questioning about whether I actually exist or not. How do I know that I exist? Well, because I am thinking.

It's at this point all I (we?) can know with probability 1, metaphysically speaking. We could just be a brain in a box, stimulated to believe we are alive in this world. But at core, we (or at least I) do exist, brain-in-a-box status notwithstanding

As for the rest, well, act as if it's all real and things will go better for you.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by naasking on Monday July 05, 2021 @06:01PM (#27742213)
> Descartes' I think therefore I am has become a cliche, but it is profound. I can chuck any questioning about whether I actually exist or not. How do I know that I exist? Well, because I am thinking.

This is a common mistake. Cogito ergo sum actually assumes the conclusion by asserting the existence of "I" while asserting that "I" exists.

The fallacy-free version is "this is a thought, therefore thoughts exist". Still profound, but it does not prove as much as you think.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by pmoriarty on Monday July 05, 2021 @07:16PM (#27742725)
"this is a thought, therefore thoughts exist"

This is more of a tautology disguised as an argument, as the word "is" in that sentence already indicates existence.

So that sentence can be rephrased as "this thought exists, therefore thoughts exist". Well, yeah, but that's not saying much... also the premise is arguable, since what do you even mean by "thought" and "exists", and how do you know either?

A bit more fundamental would be "experience is" (without trying to break up experience in to artificial distinctions like "thought" and "non thought").. better yet is just saying "is" or pointing, and best is simple silence and basking in existence itself.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by naasking on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:42PM (#27741642)
If you only intended to metaphorically claim that running may have a colour as some kind of thought experiment, then that wasn't apparent from your description. You literally said that synesthetes experience "worlds of understanding" to which we don't have access, thus implying that they are perceiving something real. That just isn't true.

As for the metaphor itself, "side-stepping" it simply shows that there is no known or valid analogue to what you're trying to describe, which should raise skepticism as to its validity. You're basically asserting Russell's teapot.

Either what you're describing can be materially observed, or it cannot. If it can be observed, then it will be discovered by empirical means. If it cannot, then there is no reason to posit its existence and it can be dispensed with.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by dsego on Monday July 05, 2021 @02:04PM (#27740395)
It could be something intangible, an emergent property, you know it when you find it sort of thing.
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rhizome on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @12:53AM (#27744341)
Both examples are category errors. In #1 there's no such thing as food without taste, and in #2, verbs don't have physical attributes.
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by ajb on Monday July 05, 2021 @03:58PM (#27741331)
"One of the most potent elements in that fusion is the Northern courage: the theory of courage, which is the great contribution of early Northern literature. This is not a military judgement. I am not asserting that, if the Trojans could have employed a Northern king and his companions, they would have driven Agamemnon and Achilles into the sea, more decisively than the Greek hexameter routs the alliterative line—though it is not improbable. I refer rather to the central position the creed of unyielding will holds in the North. With due reserve we may turn to the tradition of pagan imagination as it survived in Icelandic. Of English pre-Christian mythology we know practically nothing. But the fundamentally similar heroic temper of ancient England and Scandinavia cannot have been founded on (or perhaps rather, cannot have generated) mythologies divergent on this essential point. 'The Northern Gods', Ker said, 'have an exultant extravagance in their warfare which makes them more like Titans than Olympians; only they are on the right side, though it is not the side that wins. The winning side is Chaos and Unreason'—mythologically, the monsters—'but the gods, who are defeated, think that defeat no refutation.' And in their war men are their chosen allies, able when heroic to share in this 'absolute resistance, perfect because without hope'. "

-- Tolkien, "The Monsters and the Critics"

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by pizza on Monday July 05, 2021 @11:26AM (#27738904)
Is it even meaningful to say that the universe - everything - has an entropy? Isn't it not even meaningful to talk about the entropy of something that is in a non-equilibriated state? People point to experiments about gas particles bouncing off the walls of closed boxes to prove how entropy is always increasing, but it really makes no sense to transfer that to the whole universe.

I have been much more convinced that the universe, starting from a maximally structured configuration, tends to even greater structure, as Julian Barbour wrote about in the Janus Point. Structure emergence, as opposed to catastrophic mixing. My perspective used to be like yours but it has become: the game is only starting.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by bengarrr on Monday July 05, 2021 @12:28PM (#27739567)
Entropy IS always increasing. Water is always gonna flow downhill. Its not possible to go from maximally ordered to even more ordered, except in some kind of highly localized phenomena. But it is possible that it can return to that maximally ordered state after it reaches a maximally unordered state. This is the idea Roger Penrose has for the big bang is that it is the state of the universe immediately succeeding the heat death of the universe, at a certain point maximally unordered and maximally ordered can look the same, at least mathematically.
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by pizza on Monday July 05, 2021 @12:40PM (#27739688)
I'm not really talking about things that violate energy conservation or statistical mechanics. I'm talking about how the uniformity of the state during the big bang lead to something clumpier. Structure formation. And I still find it suspect to apply the concept of thermodynamical entropy, something defined for isolated systems at thermal equilibrium, primarily, to even make sense at universe-scale.
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by bengarrr on Monday July 05, 2021 @01:07PM (#27739894)
Structure is not entropy though unless I am missing what you are saying. The arrangement of macro level objects like a supercluster has less to do with entropy and more to do with dark matter/energy or what ever that stuff is. Also I dont follow the reasoning that this concept of entropy is incorrectly being applied to the universe... energy is energy I have never heard that the thermodynamics only applies to isolated systems in equilibrium.
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @02:44PM (#27740748)
> Is it even meaningful to say that the universe - everything - has an entropy?

The overarching approach to possible lack of meaning applies whether the universe increases entropy, sheds it, or maintains static equilibrium forever and ever and ever. It's kind of beside the point, really. Read entropy here as a metaphor for creeping existential despair or random chaos, whichever makes more sense to you.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by alisonkisk on Monday July 05, 2021 @12:05PM (#27739322)
How can there be greater than maximal structure?
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by pizza on Monday July 05, 2021 @12:18PM (#27739469)
I might have messed up that wording.. basically as I understand it the universe started out pretty much homogeneous and uniform, minor deviations became magnified into seeding the structure that exists today, and basically some mix of inflation + gravitation will create additional structure forever, as measured by a value called the "shape potential" C = l_rms/l_mhl of a spatial configuration of particles [0]. l_rms is the root-mean-square length of the system and l_mhl is the mean-harmonic-length. He makes this argument that there are many potential geometric configurations that the universe could have started out as but he believes it started from the one that has the maximum shape potential, iirc. [0] https://physics.aps.org/featured-article-pdf/10.1103/PhysRev...
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by SkyMarshal on Monday July 05, 2021 @11:56AM (#27739221)
What you’ve described is pretty close to Optimistic Nihilism, eg “The universe has no intrinsic meaning, so I’ll make my own.”

https://duckduckgo.com/?q=optimistic%20nihilism

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @01:32PM (#27740079)
Thanks. I'd love to know more about it
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by bengarrr on Monday July 05, 2021 @12:52PM (#27739794)
I was thinking about this the other day actually and I believe consciousness serves a higher purpose. If you think about it without any consciousness in the universe, nothing would ever be observed. Without consciousness the universe would just be an empty library, full of history and knowledge but with nobody there to read the books (assuming we are the only conscious life form in the universe). And that's fine I guess, the universe obviously could care less if we read its biography, but at the same time I think about how lucky it is that there is a biography to read at all. We could have been conscious beings in a universe that is truly chaotic and could never be made sense of but here we are in this nice one. That is able to be quantified and one that can be appreciated. One filled with unimaginable beauty and mystery to appreciate. Even if we have no tangible purpose, we still have the ability to observe and in a limited sense manipulate the universe around us and I think that is a highly overlooked facet of what makes being a human not completely unbearable. To me the meaning of life is to just simply to be. Butterfly affect applies here, just simply existing can have an unknowable cascade of effects that ultimately shape the story of the universe. My version is a little different: Entropy will always win. Until then, just exist and enjoy.
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @01:31PM (#27740065)
Perhaps. Personally, I don't find these notions comforting. It could be that our consciousness serves a higher purpose of some sort, or it could be it is but sweet delicious nectar for hungry entities, and we are but fodder.

My philosophy must allow for either and neither.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by pmoriarty on Monday July 05, 2021 @02:37PM (#27740680)
"Any philosophy that just asserted that the Universe has meaning was a non-starter, for me. There is nothing that I can see that unambiguously tells me that the Universe ultimately has absolute purpose or meaning. It could, but anyone who tells you they know the fundamental question of why we are here is delusional or a liar."

For Victor Frankl the meaning of life is not an answer you find out in the world but a question the world asks of you, and which you answer in the way you live your life.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by saiya-jin on Monday July 05, 2021 @02:52PM (#27740805)
I guess that's about it for the topic, anything else are just speculative farts in the wind.

The problem is, tons of people despair for a guidance. A bulletproof manual so they don't have to face uncertainties that life brings daily, and do hard moral choices. And what you state, no matter how correct or not, is simply not enough for them. It still scares the shit out of them.

Thus, relatively independent formation of various religions that directly or indirectly address this existential question #1 and much more. Its funny how at the end almost all say the same 'be good, don't do evil, and you shall be rewarded'.

I do honestly believe that if a person was 'indoctrinated' into religion in their young age, abandoning it completely in later life is extremely hard and impossible for many (ie due to environment they live in, like cigarettes). I can see it in my circle of friends. It would create hole so big in their core personality that they would fall apart like house of cards when first hardship comes. And eventually they always will.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by tartoran on Monday July 05, 2021 @02:49PM (#27740782)
Whenever I feel a hopeless meaningless in my life, Victor Frankl comes to rescue and I reorient my thoughts on the meaning of life, of our lives. The fact that the universe has no meaning does not imply that life cannot be filled with a meaning and fullfill that.
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by Xc43 on Monday July 05, 2021 @12:12PM (#27739401)
Faith: patience with mystery

You and I are not much different.

The difference I chose to believe because I know we humans are story machines. I prefer being part of a story, as co-author than author of my own pointless story. That is all. What allows me to say "Jesus is my Lord and Savior" is my patience, my faith. I do not know more than you. But I like the story that Jesus started and am willing to be part of it at a personal cost. It is better than nothing.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @01:57PM (#27740329)
I'm afraid I cannot frame this question in a way that does not sound judgmental, and for that I am sincerely sorry.

I'm genuinely curious why you would pick an arbitrary story out of the infinite multitudes and "choose to believe it" as a way to combat existential despair. It would be as if I, gaining some comfort hearing about Ragnarok, "chose to believe" that Odin literally exists and somewhere there is a bifrost bridge I could visit. Can't you like the story and gain value out of it without also believing in its literal truth?

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by Xc43 on Monday July 05, 2021 @03:31PM (#27741151)
Choosing to believe is mainly suspending disbelief. Or patience with mystery. Forever. The more patience, the greater faith.

Liking a story is not sufficient to benefit significantly from it. In other words, to have skin in the game makes you gain more. The story you contribute to does not matter until you have faith. When you have faith, in any thing, you enjoy conviction, certainty. Conviction is intrinsically valuable.

What if I had the proof your life is very valuable to Humanity? Would you live differently?...

This is the sort of proof and subsequent gain faith gives.

While, sure you can gain something out of liking a story, but the gain is lesser, the lesser your faith in said story.

I choose Jesus' story because I chose him in the past and so far have been rewarded for my decision. I informed myself about other stories when I was openly atheist, out of curiosity. I did not think I could make a fully informed decision about this so I went with was closest.

Since learning more about it and other stories, I believe, this is the best non disproven story. So I sacrifice myself to it. It is a pro-humanity story. Integrity. Joy. Anti-mimesis (yes, René Girard is part of the picture). Those are very tangible gains.

It is not about being the greatest or being obedient. At its core, it is the story self-sacrifice/service for the benefit everyone, yourself included.

There is only one piece of advice I dare give atheists: intentionally have faith in something. See where that leads you. There is only so many stories that rings true to a human being throughout their whole life and that of their progeny, I believe Christianity is one of them if not the only one.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:15PM (#27741454)
> There is only one piece of advice I dare give atheists: intentionally have faith in something.

I mean that makes sense that you would do that. If you can get an atheist to accept the premise that faith is somehow necessary, then you have validated your own worldview.

To me, faith is not some noble stance in the face of uncertainty. It is a metaphorical shrug in the face of cognitive dissonance. The correct spiritual answer to cognitive dissonance is to bravely resolve it, not prop it up with the crutch that is faith. Of course philosophies that require its adherents to accept manifest absurdity are going to have a safety valve like faith or enlightenment. That's the only way people could ask a question like "How could God, who is Perfect and Good, allow such Evil to exist?" and go on and on and on without coming to the obvious conclusion embedded in the question itself.

Or Why the hell are we taking seriously the fevered imaginings of desert goat herders dead these 2000 years? well, because faith

So, yes, I get why you're asking atheists to have faith. Ask yourself why you need that validation.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by Xc43 on Monday July 05, 2021 @05:35PM (#27742034)
Don't get me wrong, I do not give advice unsolicited. Faithful or not it is just a bad idea. I dare give advice when asked. The end of my last comment could have been better built.

I never stated that faith was necessary, only useful and empowering. It is not a purely religious concept. It is one of those things that cannot be conveyed through words, the same way I cannot convey the color red or wetness without the receiver experiencing it. I imagine color blind people will never get red the way most do.

I would never expect a self-professed atheist to recognize the nobility of religious faith but to at least acknowledge its difficulty, yes. It is difficult. To act with conviction in the face of uncertainty, that is difficult and I claim noble. To start a startup requires faith in yourself, your product, team because no can one guarantee success yet you need certainty to act. Faith is not a purely religious concept.

Faith is recognized by its repercussions. An example of that is that we do take seriously desert shepherds dead 2000 years ago. But, it is not faith alone. It is also about the foundation for that faith. If all are able of faith, I guess the Norse had it. Why is that religion dead though, why did people stop believing?

It is because after 2000 years people worthy of my trust in their intellect think of Jesus that I considered this man named Jesus worthy at least to think about.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @04:01AM (#27758573)
Fair enough. To the annoyance and solid resistance of most atheists, I assert that Science occupies the same archetype as Religion in our society and psychology, even for devout atheists. They often respond that Science is True and Religion is not. Which makes me giggle: most Believers believe their religion is True, so that's an argument the devout of all stripes would make. The truth (or not) of which though is irrelevant to my argument: like Religion, Science contains the highest Mysteries that we know, with endlessly arcane, esoteric rituals that require lots of education to understand. Its priests, in the form of scientists, deliver encyclics on various matters which we follow because they are True. Exactly the role of Religion in the past. I suspect that Jung is right: human beings need this on some deep level. We will always have this.

We all ostensibly can verify the pronouncements of scientists ourselves, and this is a difference between religion and science, but how many actually do that? We trust that all of the books and scientists are correct about, oh, the age of the Universe and the speed of light, but very few of us have verified these ourselves. We are content to accept them on faith

> Why is that religion dead though, why did people stop believing?

For the same reason that religion is being supplanted by science today. Its story and adoption offers an immediate improvement to individuals' lives. Christianity offered an improvement to the lives of Vikings, for various reasons. No more intramural slaughter allowed, for one. It also offered a literal break from the relentless pressure of dead ancestors, for another (I didn't discuss that part of Norse mythology, but if you behaved like a coward, all of your ancestors would be thrown out of Valhalla for the shame of bearing you). The Norse religion was adopted before that because it offered improvement in the lives of its adherents over whatever had existed earlier. Most likely by honing them into truly fierce, zero-fucks-given badasses.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by Xc43 on Saturday July 10, 2021 @02:00PM (#27795209)
Scientific claims are indeed accepted by faith in the scientists and the scientific method.

Yet it cannot fully replace religion because it does not offer a way of living, a common set of values, a story to tell. What it offers is a method to gain the truth. Truth is not intrinsically good.

We need a method to gain the "good"/an ideal. I claim by personal experience and observation of history that Christianity leads to the perpetuation of the group and the individual. Arguably survival is good but insufficient which brings back to existential depression. Not only does a complete religion (i.e. unlike the incomplete religion of science) lead to survival but also to striving for what will make you thrive, beat existential depression. i.e. A "complete religion" gives a compass and a North star, a goal worth pursuing, a definition of good, a desirable ending to the story of one's life. A complete religion teaches you to reach the "good" and what "good" is.

Of course, one can take the path of "there is no God", whatever that means, and believe that everything always was, that there is no cause. That is human. I have been reading the Odyssey lately and gods are everywhere yet humans care only when it is to their benefit. The whole book would not exist if Agamemnon would have freed the daughter of a priest of Apollo when the priest asked for her with a ransom.

My definition of god is: higher power. What does higher power even mean? I would suggest the 4 fundamental forces are just some angels doing what God says. I cannot prove it and no one can disprove it. I lose nothing and gain a definition of good. All that is required is faith in some story.

In a not quite related note: The bit about the pressure from dead ancestors is very interesting. I like perpetuating some stories while not having faith them in order to promote imagination, art and action. This is one of them.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by wpietri on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:36AM (#27738427)
Yeah, I think one of the issues people have with lack of intrinsic meaning is that they experience it as a loss.

My parents weren't religious, so I grew up an atheist. I never believed that there was intrinsic meaning, intrinsic purpose. That was intimidating in my youth, as I was learning about the vast scale of the universe. Now it seems great. The universe is a blank canvas: we can create meaning for ourselves.

One related thing I especially love is the art documentary "Rivers and Tides", about the work of Andy Goldsworthy. It does a great job of conveying beauty and meaning even when it is transitory. Especially when it is transitory. It's only when give up the belief in vast, universal meaning, that meanings we create for ourselves and one another can be seen in their proper scale.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @03:16PM (#27741038)
> Yeah, I think one of the issues people have with lack of intrinsic meaning is that they experience it as a loss.

This is kind of a clueless, dismissive response. If existential despair has not touched you, how marvelous for you. It passes most people by. I would not read that article and then smugly congratulate myself on this. Your self-satisfaction at being raised correctly is no different from someone being just fine with the answers they received in their Orthodox upbringing.

I grew up in a secular, non-religious household as well. There was no crisis of faith for me. There were simply no good answers and a lot of bullshit answers. Even pure empirical explanations are useless as to the why.

The article discusses why some people wrestle with existential questions like why are we here, what is the purpose of existence from a young age to the point of depression. There is nothing there about people being particularly religious, or having disappointed expectations.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by wpietri on Monday July 05, 2021 @07:39PM (#27742854)
I don't mean it as dismissive, just factual. Loss is hard. I'll leave its cluelessness for others to judge.

But you're wrong to say, "There is nothing there about people being particularly religious." The author describes it as the start of things for him, writing "I, on the other hand, had grown up in the Deep South in an insular culture that had limited vision and rigid beliefs; my loving parents were traditionally religious and tried to live conforming, righteous, and conventional lives."

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by stared on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:35AM (#27738420)
> Human-created meaning

Could you give an example for "meaning" which is not "human-created"?

A human (and possibly other animals') instinct to create meaning might be not different from a spider's instinct to make a web. "Meaning" looks like an evolution-selected motivation tool for long-term goals.

If it is true, it is an ill-motivated question whether there is some universal meaning. The same as if there is an objective cobweb.

Still - yes, it might be sad for us that "meaning" does not extrapolate beyond our human psychology.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by NL807 on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:41AM (#27738474)
> Could you give an example for "meaning" which is not "human-created"?

There is none, and that is the point. "Human-created" is just an emphasis that meaning is a fabricated construct by the human mind.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @02:10PM (#27740449)
You got it
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by svcrunch on Monday July 05, 2021 @12:55PM (#27739807)
> Could you give an example for "meaning" which is not "human-created"?

Without providing a more objective definition of "meaning", this question seems circular.

Hypothetically, if someone gave you the example you seek, I see two possible responses:

  1. You see the "meaning". You'll then say that it implies the meaning is "human-created" (since it was *you* who found it meaningful).
  2. You do not see meaning in it, so you remain unswayed.
Neither outcome would cause you to change your position, which implies your position is actually just a definition.

If you argue that meaning is inherently subjective, then there is no point in asking for meaning which is not "human-created".

I will make a proposal for an objective definition of meaningful: something is meaningful if it is non-random, in the sense defined by Kolmogorov, i.e., it is compressible.

Using this definition, there is meaning all around us, very little of it human-created. Statistical reasoning, which drives the scientific endeavor, is among our most powerful tools for discovering this meaning.

The question really is: where does all this meaning point?

Unfortunately, even our best statistical methods fail badly in answering such questions. A concrete and convincing example is presented here:

Could a Neuroscientist Understand a Microprocessor? (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5230747/)

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @02:23PM (#27740553)
> "If it is true, it is an ill-motivated question whether there is some universal meaning. The same as if there is an objective cobweb."

Perhaps. And yet, the only easily accessible answers to the question why am I here are "I know why, and if you attend my seminar I can tell you more about it"

It's also not a helpful answer. Imagine: Dad, why are we here? Son, that is a ill-motivated question. Might as well ask if the is an objective cobweb. Now take the garbage out

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by johnchristopher on Monday July 05, 2021 @11:29AM (#27738948)
> Hwæt! The Universe might be meaningless, these nihilistic Viking ghosts whispered to me, across the centuries. Live bravely, do not allow yourself to wallow in despair while entropy gathers itself. Make meaning, fight, build, love, stay healthy right in the face of the Uncaring Void. It's the only thing you can do. Entropy will win. Until then, make it meaningful.

Those vikings are more existentialist than nihilistic to me ^^.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @05:13PM (#27741863)
Their answer to existential questions was to throw their lives away slaughtering each other and innocents in battle, so they could drink mead in Valhalla until the Final Battle. The question is Existential. Their answer was nihilist.
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by johnchristopher on Monday July 05, 2021 @06:32PM (#27742428)
Agree to disagree ?

> The fact that Vikings chose to create meaning by slaughtering their unfortunate neighbors is a bit beside the point.

Nihilism is specifically about the idea that there is no meaning and no will to create some.

Creating meaning, seeking it, is the inverse of a nihilist answer.

If Vikings were nihilists they would have engaged in a multitude of different activities without justifications rather than creating meaning by all fighting anyway. This fighting they do, despite the fact it won't change anything is an existentialist trait and an existentialist answer. I'd concede it's close to a philosophical suicide.

I am not fluent enough in English and I remember not much from philo 101 so allow me to quote wikipedia:

A pervasive theme in existentialist philosophy, however, is to persist through encounters with the absurd, as seen in Camus' The Myth of Sisyphus ("One must imagine Sisyphus happy")

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rubicon33 on Monday July 05, 2021 @01:48PM (#27740224)
Thank you for sharing this! I’ve wrestled with existential questions my whole life. This is one of the best explanations for our existence that I’ve seen. Simple, and meaningful. I also love that this explanation also gives you a framework to live by. Meaning and purpose are arbitrary, but that’s really the value in them. You choose to make your life valuable. Would you really want it any other way?
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @02:19PM (#27740529)
So glad it helped!

Before that course, existential despair was nearly constant, from 10 years old through my 20s, and for much the same reasons for me as for the article writer. What is this world, where adults talk about high-minded principles but then act reprehensibly in the shadows? What are principles even for, then? Why are we here? Why am I here? Anyone?

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rubicon33 on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @02:13AM (#27744757)
Would you mind sharing that course? I’ve very interested in learning more.
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @10:25AM (#27749051)
It was 20 years ago, and the lecturer was a Vietnam Vet in his spry 60s, named Robert Milgram. I just looked at the faculty list and he is no longer there. It was a "Medieval English Literature" course that started with a long-assed tangent about the "Germanic peoples" and the Vikings, and all of that about Ragnarok and the Norse worldview was delivered by lecture over the course of several weeks.

I haven't ever been able to verify my particular understanding of their worldview, but I understand that it changed quite a bit after Christianity got a foothold. All that about rebirth and renewal after Ragnarok was a later addition. Or, my lecturer could have been mistaken, but I doubt it.

I wish I could be more helpful, but he did mention Tolkien as a Norse scholar quite a lot.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rubicon33 on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @11:44AM (#27750057)
Fascinating stuff. I appreciate the threads to follow. I’ll see what I can dig up.
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by NL807 on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:39AM (#27738450)
I think I'm cool with that. There is no meaning to any of this chaos, but I make an effort to make my life feel meaningful, and that's all that matters. Like clay, on its own has no purpose, but you can fashion it into bricks and build something with it.
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by bitexploder on Monday July 05, 2021 @11:39AM (#27739052)
Though we know of the universe and it’s vastness, now, the thing that keeps me grounded is that we exist in a framework. The framework of the planet, of our evolution, of our exact position in space and time, etc. it all surrounds us. It is a great cosmic accident, or triumph if you want to be glass half full, that we exist. It seems a shame to not fully explore this framework of ours and understand as much as we can. I know I am just making up my own meaning, but I like to juxtapose the realness of discovery, knowledge, the human experience with the vastness of the cosmos. We are infinitesimal blips in the cosmos, yet for us it is everything. I think deep inside of me is an insatiable curiosity about everything and that drives me and keeps the existential crisis at bay because… there isn’t really one. It’s just us here on earth and we are enough. This isn’t a rigorous philosophical statement or way of approaching the world, but it works for me. (I have read a lot of philosophy and even dabbled in formal philosophy to try and make sense of everything, but I keep pulling up to simpler concepts to rationalize it all)
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by all2 on Monday July 05, 2021 @01:02PM (#27739866)
Chaos is an interesting word to use. Underneath all the chaos is so much order. Dare I say the universe is mechanistic in its working. The earth orbits in an orderly fashion, set at a distance from the sun that is just right to sustain life. The moon makes its transit, and with us all the planets here move in their own ordered fashion.

Or I suppose we could go smaller. Your body moves and goes, replicating one of the most complex forms of machine code known to man. That replication is paired with voltage gradients across groups of cells that determine macro organization of cellular structures.. The human body is self replicating, self correcting, and even keeps itself clean.

You see chaos, I see order (and I admit the order is becoming more chaotic). But that you recognize the chaos gives light to the fact that you desire order. And there is order to be seen if you look for it.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:01PM (#27741352)
I'm starting to see that chaos and entropy are metaphors that we who have experienced existential despair are using to describe something else that may not be clear to those who have not. Not sure, but people keep getting distracted by those terms, but it seems to be missing the point.

Upstream post may well have said there is no meaning to all this order. Paying attention to the underlying order doesn't address the lack of meaning which is the essential part of the statement. There is no meaning to all this... *gestures vaguely around* might get at it better

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by all2 on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @02:11PM (#27752220)
> there is no meaning to all this order

This resonates (for lack of a better term) with me so much.

I recommend reading the book of Ecclesiastes. The author's frequent refrain is "'Vanity of vanities', says the Preacher, 'all is vanity.'"

You're right, chaos is a useless word. I've often tried to describe it as emptiness or worthlessness or a lack of intrinsic (self-contained) value. That is the efforts of my life are motes of dust in the history of the universe. The affect I have is empty, gone, "dust in the wind" as one artist puts it.

I guess looking at a well organized array of widgets does not exude meaning. Those, too, are meaningless without context. I mentioned in another comment that the universe itself does not contain the context into which it was created and that context -- I believe -- is where the true meaning and value of everything arises.

A tool is useless without the mechanic to use it. Clay is formless, void (meaningless) without a craftsman to shape it, fire it, and put it to use.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by NL807 on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @03:23AM (#27745148)
There are emergent relationships from a system that is indeed chaotic, but ultimately this is all subject to entropy. Everything is converging towards maximum diffusion.
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by acituan on Monday July 05, 2021 @01:31PM (#27740072)
> Any philosophy that just asserted that the Universe has meaning was a non-starter, for me.

> Humans create meaning in the face of an uncaring, indifferent Void.

I hope you realize that your assertion, which asserts a complete lack of meaning, is just as strong as the philosophies that assert meaning. To me, both are non-starters.

To make progress one has to question the framing of the problem, which is actually what most of the continental philosophy enlightenment onwards was about.

Maybe meaning already requires consciousness that looks out at the world, so it would be a contradiction to claim the things in themselves has meaning. (subjective)

Or maybe there is meaning in things themselves, but there is an intelligibility problem and we can't have a sufficiently comprehensive representation of it internally. (objective). Think it as the model file not fitting a single machine.

Or maybe meaning is a process that requires both the conscious looker and a meaning in things themselves, and is dynamically loaded. (neither subjective nor objective). It can still be constrained by cognitive capacity or intelligibility, but maybe we're doing a pretty good job at it nonetheless because we are able to conform to reality in an adaptive manner, and survive better than any other species with our modeling. Also we have been coming up with technologies to beef us up on the intelligibility and capacity fronts; like invention of literacy!

So maybe existential depression is a mere stuckness in a local minima of this meaning making process between the conscious looker and objective reality, in no small part thanks to our current philosophical and other institutions really sucking at training us on the dynamic loading process. Nor we have the supporting education to leverage the collective intelligence of the best of the humanity (remember, we've invented literacy, but what is the use if we don't read the most important stuff on this matter?). Without these constraints addressed, "there is definitely no meaning" sounds to me like giving up on looking for one's keys because they are tired and don't feel like they have made any progress. I am not saying there are definitely keys either, but it is a worthy endeavor to try getting better at looking for it at least.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by AnimalMuppet on Monday July 05, 2021 @01:50PM (#27740245)
> So maybe existential depression is a mere stuckness in a local minima of this meaning making process between the conscious looker and objective reality, in no small part thanks to our current philosophical and other institutions really sucking at training us on the dynamic loading process.

There are multiple philosophical schools in operation, and they each want to unload what the others have dynamically loaded.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by thrww20210608 on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:07AM (#27738151)
The many Marian apparitions that have been documented, makes me certain that there is meaning to life:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marian_apparition

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracle_of_the_Sun

Feel free to ask me more about Catholicism if this piques your interest!

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by thrwwmbkpr on Monday July 05, 2021 @04:51PM (#27741699)
I come from a Protestant background and have always been very interested in reports of possession as a "proof" of a spiritual realm. It can't prove everything (and even the fact of possession can't verifiably be established as far as I've read), but it can present a powerful argument for forces at work beyond our scientific knowledge. Your links got me very interested in Marian apparitions. Are there any other good sources you would recommend?
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @02:35PM (#27740668)
Whatever works for you, and I have sincere respect for you Christians (mostly, some are assholes), but at the core, you just have to take a leap of faith in order to accept that philosophy.

I am constitutionally unable to accept a metaphysics that depends on its adherents willfully disregarding anything at all.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by costcopizza on Monday July 05, 2021 @10:54AM (#27738580)
What book should I read?
Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by alfor on Monday July 05, 2021 @12:59PM (#27739831)
There might not be meaning to the universe, but there is meaning in the human enterprise.

We went from animals, to highly effective and conscious of ourselves and the universe. The human developpement keep pushing forward.

I think that the main cause of meaninglessness is our rejection of our own culture ( mostly Christian). There is good reason to reject them as the bearded magician in the sky seem stupid to a modern science minded person, however if you look at those stories at a second degree there is a lot of parts that make sense.

Theses stories were the bedrock of our civilisation and the spine of our consciousness. We need to update theses stories with what we now know instead of throwing them out because science make them look outdated.

Take a look at Jordan Peterson biblical series, it explain in evolutionary terms how we invented theses stories, what they mean, what we can learn from them.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f-wWBGo6a2w

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @02:04PM (#27740392)
Not sure why you're getting downvoted, but I do appreciate your response.

Sure, as metaphors and origin stories and cultural touchstones, they're worth knowing more about. But thinking these tales as literal truth is... not helpful to address existential angst. Not to someone like me, anyway. Not one among those stories explicitly says "Yes, the Universe might indeed have no meaning. That observation is valid, rational and sane. Given that, here's how to handle it..." They are all, to the last, have faith, my child, accept this {patent absurdity}, and that will save you from {other patent absurdity}

I'm not really convinced of the Jungian framework, but I do get a kick out of it. It's a hell of a lot of fun.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by alfor on Monday July 05, 2021 @02:40PM (#27740714)
I think that everything Christian or from Peterson get downvoted in this left leaning place, they are seen as backward or even evil.

Theses stories made me realize that we are part of millennia of human understanding evolution. To me there is sometime a deeper meaning at a second level but I have to get past a first reaction of disdain that i got from all things Christian. We are more open to other culture religions as we don’t know their flaws as well.

Jung is still opaque to me.

Re:Dabrowski’s theory and existential depression (2020) by rendall on Monday July 05, 2021 @02:59PM (#27740884)
Peterson is a Jungian, which is why I brought it up. Check out Memories, Dreams, Reflections by Carl Gustav Jung himself, for a fun accessible entree. Basically, the theory is that humans are deeply wired to use stories to understand the world, and some stories are even embedded in our subconscious.