I think programming is one of the many domains (including driving) that will never be totally solved by AI unless/until it's full AGI. The long tail of contextual understanding and messy edge-cases is intractable otherwise.
Will that happen one day? Maybe. Will some kinds of labor get fully automated before then? Probably. But I think the overall time-scale is longer than it seems.
The problem with floats-storing-money is (a) you have to know how many digits of precision you want (e.g. cents, dollars, a tenth of a cent), and (b) you need to watch out if you're adding values together.
Even if certain values can't be represented exactly, that's ok, because you'd want to round to two decimal places before doing anything.
Is there a monetary value that you can't represent with a 64-bit float? E.g. some specific example where quantization ends up throwing off the value by at least 1/100th of whatever currency you're using?
Are we in the software community not the ones who have frequently told other industries we have been disrupting to "adapt or die" along with smug remarks about others acting like buggy whip makers? Time to live up to our own words ... if we can.
No.
I'll politely clarify that for over a decade that I - and many others - have been asking not to be lumped in with the lukewarm takes of west coast software bubble asshats. We do not live there, we do not like them, I wish they would quit pretending to speak for us.
The idea that there is anything approaching a cohesive software "community" is a con people play on themselves.
Now it’s also not necessarily that bad of a state. That’s depending on ensuring a few ground elements are in place like people being able to grow their own food (or supplemental food) or still being free to design and build things on their own. If corporations restrict that then people will be at their mercy for all the essentials of life. My take from history is that I’d prefer to have been a peasant during much of the Middle Ages than a factory worker during the industrial revolution. [1] Then again Chinese people have been willing (seemingly) to leave farms in droves for the last decades to accept the modern version of factory life so perhaps farming peasant life isn’t as idyllic as it’d sound. [2]
1: https://www.lovemoney.com/galleries/84600/how-many-hours-did... 2: https://www.csmonitor.com/2004/0123/p08s01-woap.html
You really want to push for high productivity across all industries, even if that means sacrificing jobs in the short term, because history demonstrated after that, new and more human jobs emerge latter.
So the claim that this technological revolution will be different and that it will result in a broad social safety net, universal basic income, and substantive, well-paid part-time work is a joke but not a very good one. It will be more of the same - massive concentration of wealth among those who already hold enough capital to wield it effectively. A few lucky ones who manage to create their own wealth. And those left behind working more hours for less.
What part of printing trillions of dollars to stimulate economic productivity is somehow a free market system?
Doing what? Isn't the concern here that automation will push many people out of the workforce entirely?
Energy efficiency isn't relevant. When switchboard operators were replaced by automatic telephone exchanges, it wasn't to reduce energy consumption.
The question is whether an automated solution can perform satisfactorily while offering upfront and ongoing costs that make them an economically viable replacement for human workers (i.e. paid employees).
It would be a lot easier if more people on this website would just be honest with themselves and everyone else and simply admit they think feudalism is good and that serfs shouldn't be so uppity. But not me, of course; I won't be a serf. Now if you'll excuse me, someone gave me a really good deal on a bridge that I'm going to go buy...
New jobs in academic fields will not emerge. Already now a significant percentage of degree holders are forced into bullshit jobs.
But yeah remaining 80-90% of population will have quality of life and bullshit jobs because it's how the world is right now outside of western countries bubble.
How is that different from the current situation?
In the hypothetical fully-automated future, there's no need for workers anymore; automated capital can generate wealth directly, and its owners can trade the output between each other to fully satisfy all their needs. The only reason to give anything to the 99.99% at that point would be to keep them content enough to prevent a revolution, and that's less than you need to pay people to actually come and work for you.
Is that anything new? That seems to be a repeating fact of life throughout history.
We need not totally avoid such changes (i.e. shun technological advancements entirely because of their social ramifications), but we need to be mindful of their effects if we want to improve our current situation regarding the distribution/concentration of wealth and power in the world.
This is absolutely one of the things that keeps me up at night.
Much of the structure of the modern world hinges on the balance between forces towards consolidation and forces towards fragmentation. We need organizations (by this I mean corporations, governments, unions, etc.) big enough to do big things (like fix climate change) but small enough to not become totalitarian or decrepit.
The forces of consolidation have been winning basically since the 50s with the rise of the military-industrial complex, death of unions, unlimited corporate funding of elections (!), regulatory capture, etc. A short linear extrapolation of the current corporate/government environment in the US is pretty close to Demolition Man's dystopian, "After the franchise wars, all restaurants are Taco Bell."
Big data is a huge force towards consolidation. It's essentially a new form of real estate that can be farmed to grow useful information crops. But it's a strange form of soil that is only productive if you have enough acres of it and whose yield scales superlinearly with the size of your farm.
Imagine doing a self-funded AI startup with just you and a few friends. The idea is nearly unthinkable. How do you bootstrap a data corporation that needs terabytes of information to produce anything of value?
If we don't figure out a "data socialism" movement where people have ownership over the data derived from their life, we will keep careening towards an eventuality where a few giant corporations own the world.
You could call it endgame
And, of course, total surveillance helps to prevent any kind of unionization of those 99.99%.
By definition, that has always been true.
We have been in the endgame for a very long time.
And that's why I won't be using it, why give it intelligence so it can work me out of a job?
Umm, no it's not. It's possible we just have two problems - the economic problem you mention might be correct, but also that people who believe in the problems of the singularity are right as well. The existence of a certain problem doesn't negate the existence of the other problem.
I'm curious as to why it seems persuasive. Open source licenses largely hinge on restrictions tied to distribution of the software, and training a model does not constitute as distribution.
OTOH if laundering through machine learning is a fair use, then licenses can't do anything about this. Licenses can't override the copyright law, so the law would have to change.
1. Programmers will become teachers of the co-pilot through IDE / API feedback
2. Expect CI like services for automated refactoringFor google support employees cost too much.
This is an excellent example of how the AI singularity/revolution/whatever is a total distraction and that a much bigger and more serious issue is how AI is becoming so effective at turning the output of cheap/free human mental labour into capital. If AI keeps getting better and better and status quo socio-economic structure don't change, trillions in capital will be captured by the 0.01%.
I would be quite a turn up for the books if this AI co-pilot gets suddenly and dramatically better in 2030 and it negatively impacts the software engineering profession. "Hey, that's our code you used to replace us!" we will cry out too late.