News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by sackerhews on Sunday June 13, 2021 @07:20AM (#27491627)
I remember the Sony MiniDisk audio recorder/player. You could record digital audio, but couldn't transfer it to your computer in digital format.

Due to the possibility that you might not have had license to record what you recorded, then you couldn't have a digital version of it on your computer.

This was the end of my relationship with Sony.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by jetrink on Sunday June 13, 2021 @07:51AM (#27491766)
I loved my MiniDisk player, but the arbitrary roadblocks that Sony put up for how you were allowed to use the device and the poor quality of the management software were so infuriating that I vowed not to give Sony another cent for ten years. (I stuck to that promise too, even avoiding the temptation of the beautiful PRS-505 e-book reader. That turned out to be a good decision when the first Kindle came out shortly after.)
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by jbay808 on Sunday June 13, 2021 @12:52PM (#27494109)
Hmm, my PRS e-reader is still going strong and I remember choosing it over a kindle, specifically because it had fewer restrictions on how I use it. It could read PDFs and ePubs, DRM-free, which I believe kindle couldn't at the time. Not sure how the landscape has changed.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by nextos on Sunday June 13, 2021 @11:41AM (#27493484)
Sony sadly has a long history of limiting devices in crazy ways. Their beautiful ebook reader was a disaster from a software perspective.

Paradoxically, since they are a conglomerate some divisions have sane policies. Their mobile phone one is among the few manufacturers that release kernels and make it easy to self-compile your own AOSP.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by irontoby on Sunday June 13, 2021 @12:34PM (#27493972)
Really wishing I would have realized that before buying my Sony Bravia TV a few years ago. It's basically just an output device for my Roku, I don't want/need any of the built-in smart TV junk but a recent update now causes it to reboot just about every time I turn it on.

The reboot process takes almost a full minute, but at least the SONY logo emblazoned on the screen during that time has hopefully given me a Pavlovian aversion to their brand so that I won't make the same mistake again.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by dustymcp on Sunday June 13, 2021 @03:26PM (#27495502)
I remember buying mine, then them saying they would'nt support apps on it anymore, then a month later the netflix app stopped working, was great timing i ended up getting a pirate box instead. Never again sony, never again.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by mikepurvis on Sunday June 13, 2021 @08:20AM (#27491927)
Not that the Kindle has especially been a model of embracing open standards and user flexibility. But at least it’s popular.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by dotancohen on Sunday June 13, 2021 @03:43PM (#27495647)
You might like the Nook. I've been rooting e-ink Nooks for about nine years, and the latest model can install Android apps without root! I mostly use it for studying with Ankidroid.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by Tostino on Sunday June 13, 2021 @09:35AM (#27492447)
Sometimes it's just about not being stuck with a paperweight.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by salamandersauce on Sunday June 13, 2021 @11:27AM (#27493374)
The PRS-505 supports ePub. Can't remember if that was after a firmware update or from the factory though. And even after the Sony ebook store closed down they let you transfer everything to Kobo. And you can still sideload ePubs on with Adobe Digital Editions.

Early Kindles are going to lose a lot of functionality soon as 3G networks get shut down and they have no WiFi to fall back on.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by mikepurvis on Sunday June 13, 2021 @12:17PM (#27493821)
Oh yeah definitely, but the GP was specifically talking about the manufacturer throwing up arbitrary roadblocks.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by Tostino on Sunday June 13, 2021 @12:46PM (#27494071)
Those arbitrary roadblocks can often be the reason a device becomes unusable after it isn't "supported" any more. But yeah point taken.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by monkpit on Sunday June 13, 2021 @02:25PM (#27494968)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_roo...

Don’t forget about this! The CD rootkit thing was what really soured my opinion of Sony.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by wdb on Sunday June 13, 2021 @04:19PM (#27496004)
Imagine working for SonyBMG and needing to put music on their site and you had to avoid the copy protection lol
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by Lammy on Sunday June 13, 2021 @05:59PM (#27496937)
> This was the end of my relationship with Sony.

SONY got the bad reputation but you can thank the western record companies for this with their reaction to Sony's earlier DAT format. Check out "An Open Letter To Japan" in this 1986 issue of "Billboard" (page 9): https://worldradiohistory.com/Archive-All-Music/Billboard/80...

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by kmeisthax on Sunday June 13, 2021 @08:16PM (#27497917)
Indeed. SONY tried user-friendly copying and nearly got banned from the US for their trouble.

A common refrain during the Napster lawsuit was that "the law needs to catch up to technology". This is hilariously wrong, looking back on it. The music industry was very adamant back in the 70s and 80s that consumers shouldn't have access to audio recording technology, especially not digital copies. As a result, the law was about 20 steps ahead of technology. Any and all consumer audio recording technology had to prevent second-generation digital copies via SCMS.

The fact that MP3 players were even allowed to exist (see RIAA v. Diamond) is a minor miracle; birthed from a legal battle that I doubt Sony was at all interested in fighting. At that point they had literally bought a record label, which pushed a lot of internal corporate changes within SONY. It's far harder to justify selling devices to copy music when you also happen to sell music.

(Of course, Apple wound up completely monopolizing music sales for a decade by more or less ignoring all of the above, getting involved in both sides of the business, and just using the superior user experience to steamroll over both labels and other device manufacturers.)

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by bcrl on Monday June 14, 2021 @06:47PM (#27509326)
Today's world isn't much better. I've lost music I paid for because I'm not allowed to transfer it from a device of one generation to the next. It's even worse now that I'm pushed into streaming services on all the platforms that I use. If only NFTs meant I could actually retain ownership of my music collection....

At least I still have my CD collection!

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by fomine3 on Sunday June 13, 2021 @08:40PM (#27498061)
Another factor is that Sony became content holder by buying Columbia
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by swilliamsio on Sunday June 13, 2021 @08:26PM (#27497990)
> Apple wound up completely monopolizing music sales for a decade

iTunes was never big enough to count as a monopoly on music sales, not even close.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by kmeisthax on Sunday June 13, 2021 @10:33PM (#27498680)
No, but they were a monopoly on digital music sales. Specifically because it was the only music DRM iPods would work with, and competing MP3 players that supported other DRM schemes were pure garbage.

By the time iTunes went DRM-free (in 2009), CD sales were about a third of what they were at their peak and digital was the industry's only growth market. 90% of 40% is still a huge chunk of the market.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by throwaway2048 on Sunday June 13, 2021 @08:12PM (#27497892)
This isn't quite accurate, SONY was furious about the fate of DAT and how the recording industry sabotaged it, so they bought a major record producer (Columbia), unfortunately it seems at least for a time, the foxes came to rule the hen house at SONY, hence their 20 years of so of self sabotage with format restrictions.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by Schlaefer on Sunday June 13, 2021 @04:00PM (#27495828)
> This was the end of my relationship with Sony.

One day I couldn't transfer my legally, newly bought Sony Music CD to my Sony MD player for mobile use (on my also expensive car and mobile MD players) because of DRM.

That's when I decided I don't care anymore. What's the point if after all that money Napster and the newly released iPod provide a better experience.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by acomjean on Sunday June 13, 2021 @06:36PM (#27497217)
I have a 5 disc cd /md shelf radio. You could copy cds to mds with a few button presses. I used that a lot at the turn of the century.

I tried the mds a year ago and they work (the cd mechanisms is jammed) now the stereo is mainly used through the aux jack.

I will agree MD would have made an excellent computer disc format had Sony allowed it. (They had something called MD Data but it was terrible). https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/MiniDisc

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by tw04 on Sunday June 13, 2021 @02:15PM (#27494876)
Sony’s media group has been an absolute cancer to the device group. To this day they make some of the best hardware on the market. To this day I won’t buy any of it beyond the PlayStation because of how horribly they screw it up with DRM and associated restrictions.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by Black101 on Sunday June 13, 2021 @03:13PM (#27495368)
> To this day I won’t buy any of it beyond the PlayStation

It doesn't help much if you still buy the Playstation...

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by tw04 on Sunday June 13, 2021 @04:21PM (#27496036)
How does it not help much? I’ve probably got a total of less than $2k invested into PlayStations and games in my entire life. If I were to add up all the electronic devices I’ve purchased in my entire life that could have been Sony but weren’t it would probably be pushing 6 figures.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by CamperBob2 on Sunday June 13, 2021 @04:27PM (#27496093)
If you want to screw Sony, there's no better way to do it than to buy a Playstation and use it only as a dumb media player. They make money licensing games, not selling the console itself.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by labster on Sunday June 13, 2021 @03:56PM (#27495788)
Nah, it’s okay, GP will serve in the fifth column of the Console Wars.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by fomine3 on Sunday June 13, 2021 @08:46PM (#27498090)
But Sony media group earn much money so they contributes Sony conglomerate's stability including electrics department. Mixed feelings.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by dotancohen on Sunday June 13, 2021 @03:40PM (#27495615)

  > This was the end of my relationship with Sony.
Honestly, I still did and still do love their headphones. For the money, Sony is probably the best bargain out there by far. But I'll never own another Sony product with a mircorprocessor. Not a phone, not a camera, not a receiver/amp, not a laptop computer. And I still won't buy music under the Sony label. Thank you Muse for signing with WB!

It's a good thing that I bought my MiniDisc player in 2004, just a year before the rootkit fiasco. Because I loved that device.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by throwawaaarrgh on Sunday June 13, 2021 @05:24PM (#27496640)
Their phones used to be great. I had many Cybershot and Walkman branded Sony Ericsson feature phones over the years. The Walkman ones had good media features/speakers, and the Cybershots gave you good optics, a real flash, and generous megapixels for the time. Second only to the high end Nokias, until Apple started to eat everyone's lunch.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by failwhaleshark on Sunday June 13, 2021 @05:07PM (#27496501)
The Trinitron TVs, monitors, WalkMans, and DiscMans were awesome. Then, they screwed the pooch in the mid 90's. Their support sucked and their products started sucking.

And then rootkit scandal.

Now, they're a cheaper Bose.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by willtim on Sunday June 13, 2021 @01:35PM (#27494463)
I have lots of hybrid SACDs and I cannot extract the high-res content for playback on computer/phone without my clunky Sony Blu-ray player. This is of course by design, but I do wonder if it also helped to kill the format before it even properly landed.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by ssharp on Sunday June 13, 2021 @08:48AM (#27492136)
How would you have done this? USB wasn't around in the mid-90's, so you would have needed something that plugged into a serial port.

Would that have been that much worse than just running a 3mm cable from the MiniDisk headphone out to the computer's mic/line in? Or was Sony somehow preventing that?

I played around a lot with music trackers (production tool) during this time and often did the reverse so I could hear my productions on other stereos or in the car -- that is running computer output to a tape deck and recording to tape. This was obviously before CD burners were affordable.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by tyingq on Sunday June 13, 2021 @11:26AM (#27493366)
The very first player, the MZ-1, had S/PDIF digital outputs:

https://imgur.com/a/1mn81tN

But it had an "SCMS" copy protection scheme: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MiniDisc#Copy_protection

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by Symbiote on Sunday June 13, 2021 @10:41AM (#27493032)
I think some Minidisc players had digital audio as SPDIF or TosLink.

I'm not certain though; it's 20 years since I last used mine, and I wouldn't have had anything to connect it to except analogue audio.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by jhoechtl on Sunday June 13, 2021 @12:38PM (#27494009)
For sure they had! Had a Sanyo MD player and I certainly did digital audio transfer via Toslink.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by detaro on Sunday June 13, 2021 @08:51AM (#27492157)
I assume they are talking about the USB-enabled MD players of the early 2000s
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by sackerhews on Sunday June 13, 2021 @01:56PM (#27494660)
Correct!
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by masklinn on Sunday June 13, 2021 @09:17AM (#27492327)
> How would you have done this? USB wasn't around in the mid-90's, so you would have needed something that plugged into a serial port.

Probably the NetMD series which supported compressed storage onto “data” MDs.

While I never had a use for transferring off of MDs, the software used to manage MD contents was indeed one of the poorest I’ve ever had the misfortune to interact with. Even the worst eras of iTunes (which had generally been pretty shit especially on windows) does not come close to the utter dreck and absolute disaster that was SonicStage.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by benbristow on Sunday June 13, 2021 @11:46AM (#27493529)
Was hoping someone would mention SonicStage. Sony forced you to use that awful software if you wanted to add music to your Walkman flash memory based MP3/4 players before they eventually gave up and let you just drag-and-drop as if it were a USB stick on newer models.

That software made iTunes on Windows feel fast.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by userbinator on Sunday June 13, 2021 @03:59PM (#27495821)
USB wasn't around in the mid-90's

USB 1.0 was introduced in 1996, which is very much "mid 90s". Then again, it wasn't very popular and at 12Mbps for "full speed", it would not have been very fast.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by ssharp on Monday June 14, 2021 @06:43AM (#27501121)
I don't recall seeing USB (granted, this was my limited view as a teenager at the time) until the late 90's and I don't think I had a PC with USB until at least 2000 or 2001.

My girlfriend at the time started college in Fall 1999 and got a new laptop. She later got a CD burner and I remember it hooked up via serial port.

It definitely took a few years to see it become common. Mac may have been the first to really push it, but that would have been late-90's as well, post-Jobs' return.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by Theodores on Sunday June 13, 2021 @07:55AM (#27491780)
It was the record companies and not Sony specifically. They had to play by the rules. You probably ended your relationship with Sony for plenty of reasons that came together in these changing times. Flat screens came along and you probably got out of gaming too. I have an uncle who once had everything Sony. But now, no. That TV is LG and his music setup is Apple.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by ratww on Sunday June 13, 2021 @08:08AM (#27491857)
> It was the record companies

Sony is (and already was back then) a record company. They were a huge chunk of the group making the rules, and were in a much better position than any other electronics company to fight them.

Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by flir on Sunday June 13, 2021 @11:29AM (#27493399)
The Sony media tail was wagging the Sony hardware dog. That was the whole problem - they hamstrung their own products. End result was that they burned their own brand to the ground - there was a time when Sony hardware was cool.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by setpatchaddress on Sunday June 13, 2021 @04:46PM (#27496293)
What's really sad is that the entire reason Sony bought the media companies was to prevent them from interfering with new Sony hardware innovations. The record companies resisted the audio CD and the studios resisted Betamax. Sony seems to have forgotten this after Akio Morita stopped running things.
Re:Is Sony's 140MB MiniDisc Drive the Next Betamax? (1996) by Steve0 on Sunday June 13, 2021 @08:01AM (#27491809)
Well, it wasn't "the record companies" as a whole. The creative nomad player was during the same period and had no such limitations. Sony, being a record company and a hardware company, limited their players in this way. And basically paved the way for other companies to take over the market.

Sad because their walk-man was basically the standard before, and sony makes some good hardware.