So this study doesn't have enough statistical power to say how vaccines compare to previous infection. Could be better, could be up to 3 times worse within a high confidence interval.
(disclamer: back-of-the-napkin math, did not double check everything)
Total participants: 52238.
Previously infected: 2579, of whom 1220 vaccinated, 1359 not vaccinated. No subsequent infections in either of these groups.
Not previously infected: 49659, of whom 29461 vaccinated (15 subsequent infections), 20198 not vaccinated (2139 subsequent infections).
Comparing previous infection with vaccination, we have 0/1359 infections in the previously infected and 15/29461 infections otherwise. According to Fisher's exact test, the two-tailed P-value for this is 1.0, which is very much not significant. You're correct to say that the study doesn't show how vaccines compare to previous infection. The study is way underpowered to show that.
For the unvaccinated, it gets more interesting. We have 0/1359 infections versus 2139/20198. According to Fisher, that has a P-value of 2 * 10^-64, which is most definitely significant. The study is not underpowered to show this at all. A previous infection is definitely protective.
With the caveat that the participants didn't have asymptomatic screening, so there is quite possibly bias due to people with a previous infection getting a second milder case and not being tested.
Using the exact method, 95% confidence intervals for infection rate are:
Previously infected, not vaccinated: 0% to 0.3%
Previously infected, vaccinated: 0% to 0.3%
Not previously infected, not vaccinated: 10.1% to 11.0%
Not previously infected, vaccinated: 0.03% to 0.08%
Could be. But it would be great if they'd just say having had a confirmed case is equivalent to getting the vaccine because several studies have now shown that to be roughly the case. It's also conventional medical wisdom although it varies by virus.
You'll notice they say - we don't have enough data. Then data is incomplete. Then we can't really say because study was X / Y / Z.
They ignore the MASSIVE difference in your chance of being infected if you are unvaccinated and have not been infected vs many other combos.
Just treat folks who've been infected as vaccinated, they can get booster / variant shots with everyone else when the time comes.
This is a weird trend these days. Medical science refuses to take an engineering approach to anything and only accepts statements based on controlled studies. That includes rejecting previous understanding of how immunity works in general. Early on when claims were made about HCQ, Zinc, or whatever, they were shot down as "not approved treatment" even though there were no approved treatments! The utter failure to recommend vitamin D supplements is another failure - we know deficiency weakens immune response, we know most (Americans) are deficient in the winter, it's a no-brainer but in their mind it was not "proven" so not even mentioned or recommended for anyone.
The only pattern I see considering all cases like that is the underlying notion that people must not do anything for themselves.
The UK is enterring a third wave, and has a high number of elderly people having been fully (2 shot, mainly AZ) vaccinated. Early indications are that those enterring hospitals now on the whole have not been fully vaccinated.
Edit: nicely presented here: https://www.bmj.com/content/370/bmj.m3259
There are still many over 70s who haven't had any shots though. My (estranged) uncle and his mother-in-law haven't left the house for 18 months, he disinfects his food deliveries and leaves the post in a box for 3 days. He refuses to get the vaccine because he's worried about catching it. Chances are he won't end up in hospital either, but people like that could skew the cases as more data comes out to allow spurious claims from anti-vaxers (They might claim that 'before 2 in every 100 over 80s were going into hospital) , now it's only 1 in every 100 unvaccinated over 80s going in to hospital), because the chance of catching covid from the population still unvaccinated dwindles because of continued isolation
The same goes for variants, which a lot of people expect to break through vaccines because that's how the flu works, but it doesn't actually seem like they will.
> Immunity to the coronavirus lasts at least a year, possibly a lifetime, improving over time especially after vaccination, according to two new studies. The findings may help put to rest lingering fears that protection against the virus will be short-lived.
> Together, the studies suggest that most people who have recovered from Covid-19 and who were later immunized will not need boosters. Vaccinated people who were never infected most likely will need the shots, however, as will a minority who were infected but did not produce a robust immune response. Both reports looked at people who had been exposed to the coronavirus about a year earlier. Cells that retain a memory of the virus persist in the bone marrow and may churn out antibodies whenever needed, according to one of the studies, published on Monday in the journal Nature. The other study, posted online at BioRxiv, a site for biology research, found that these so-called memory B cells continue to mature and strengthen for at least 12 months after the initial infection.
> “The papers are consistent with the growing body of literature that suggests that immunity elicited by infection and vaccination for SARS-CoV-2 appears to be long-lived,” said Scott Hensley, an immunologist at the University of Pennsylvania who was not involved in the research.
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/26/health/coronavirus-immuni...
Just yesterday the news had an article about how a national level soccer player for Sweden who had been infected previously in the past managed to get infected again and infect parts of the team.
The player in question had been infected about a year ago initially (before the British strain was found) and with the British strain now being the main one in Sweden I don't think it's a far fetch to say that re-infections of a different strain is actually quite likely once a certain amount of time has passed.
Off topic, but at this stage I find this geographical naming of strains being much more confusing than useful.
Besides risking moral overtones ("the British strain? Typical - when they aren't being Hollywood baddies they're busy incubating viruses") it only tagged where a strain was first isolated, not necessarily its geographic origin (not that it actually matters whether the Kent variant actually came from that Home County)
[1] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2021-06-08/covid-19-variants-del...
So a geographic label was widely used before Biden without apparently causing ructions. It was adopted because the released name for the variant, lineage B.1.1.7, was less convenient or distinctively memorable for the public. If it had been repeatedly referred to as the "Kentish virus" by senior politicians then a similarly hostile reaction might have been seen as was for "Chinese virus".
> Coronavirus variants get Greek names — but will scientists use them? From Alpha to Omega, the labelling system aims to avoid confusion and stigmatization.
Based on my own personal experience (see my other post in this thread), I agree.
Unless someone gets a PCR positive, has the virus sequenced, and then gets a separate positive later, has the virus sequenced again and can confirm they were actually infected again with live virus (perhaps using live viral culture) they can’t really be sure.
They then went on to unwittingly spread the infection at a small gathering of friends, even though their rapid tests were negative. A subsequent rapid test showed negative for one, positive for the other. PCR tests nailed it down, and they went through the whole contact tracing malarkey to get everyone tested.
It may be as simple as someone not taking it completely seriously, or someone 100% unwittingly becoming a carrier, even with negative tests.
We had a late night call saying he was unlikely to last the night, so we were allowed in to see him.
The next morning we were waiting for the phone call. And we had one. From Test and Fucking Trace, who wanted to speak to him. They were insistent he wasn't in hospital so we hung up on them with a rather non-polite scream.
His swab (which was from before we saw him) came back and he was positive, so we had to isolate. He did last the night, and then was moved to a covid ward.
So he clearly caught it in hospital on a non-covid ward. While I was holding his hand a nurse came along to give him an injection. She had a mask on, over her mouth - not her nose. Clearly lots of unconcious people who had frequent negative tests and weren't moving around a ward aren't going to be spreading covid, the only close contacts were the medical staff.
As it happens he lasted another 3 weeks before he came home for palative care. The vaccine presumably helped with fighting covid, but the damage caused by the siezures meant he couldn't even swallow.
He died 29 days after the positive test, so didn't go on the T+28 day stats.
Got it at Christmas from a gathering with only 3 other family members.
Non-huge indoor spaces, absence of masks, breathing the same air for longer than 15-20 min all increase infection rates.
Not OP.
He wouldn't wear a mask in the house (because "I'm fine") and kept coughing up the place, though.
I wear an N95 or KF94 - I like the ones with the valve / vents so do a surgical over that if I use one of those.
I've got friends in covid care who had pretty high exposure with a good N95 and face shield without being infected.
So when people say they were masked up and got infected, you need to ask, was this just some fleece cloth or a mask designed for infection control.
Even these slow down transmission so it’s a function of having a mask, time spent together, flow/amount of air, proximity.
- Me: no idea, we were careful :(
- Friend 1: had son in school, son's classmate's father got it and by the time they knew, the kids had met. This was during a wave and contacts weren't tested, only symptomatic people.
- Friend 2: stupid, stupid colleague came to work to pick up laptop when she got quarantined.
He was admitted with suspected sepsis, and tested negative on admission. He had a new cough when he was discharged, but we didn't think much of it as he had COPD so periods of coughing weren't unusual. A few days later, he was readmitted with a recurrence of his original symptoms, but this time his admission test was positive. Six of the other family members tested positive the next day, and developed symptoms over the following days.
[1] The only other person in the house who hadn't been isolating subsequently tested negative. Everyone else had been nowhere but home for at least the proceeding two weeks, so the chance of another vector seems remote.
What was her name? ;-)
I'm not sure how I caught it. I had left my car into the garage a few days before I showed symptoms and had to get an Uber home, then back to the garage to pick it up, so my strongest suspicion is one of the Uber drivers or previous passengers had it or potentially a mechanic had it and it remained in the car.
The strangest thing is my girlfriend and I had spent the day before I showed symptoms together and she slept over that night but she didn't seem to catch it off me. She even had an antibody test about a month after which was negative suggesting she hadn't already had asymptomatic Covid.
a) Just go to the store and back wearing a mask while indoors b) Spend most of their leisure time outdoors - because what else can you do?
I haven't been holed up this whole time. I'm outside multiple times every day (dog walks, kids playground etc.) and I don't know anyone who works in a factory, meat processing plant, hospital etc. hence my curiosity how people think they're getting it.
[EDIT: I read further down this page, dang commented that he'd edited in the 'evaluating' just 1m before parent's comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27453952 So, yes, fair enough, 'necessity of' is ambiguous, as I went on to say in my original comment continuing below.]
Necessity is the concept as well as describing one possible state of it.
Another example: when 'my hunger is sated', I do not 'have a hunger', I am 'not hungry'.
They also mentioned 0 infections in fully vaccinated which is odd as other countries are seeing a number of infections in their vaccinated front line workers.
https://twitter.com/sporeMOH/status/1402637555263098884?s=20
No, they had infections in the vaccinated. They had 0 infections in the previously infected, although another poster pointed out that the vaccinated (but never infected) group is much larger than the unvaccinated but previously exposed.
Frankly since the vaccine trains the immune system on the spike proteins I would think they're roughly equivalent and either both will offer similar duration of protection. If that turns out to be only a year I'm going for the vaccine next time, as the infection kinda sucked.
The spike protein has been picked for the reason that it's unlikely to change.
As another comment mentioned though, the spike protein is unlikely to change much, and if it did, the virus would loose a major weapon in infecting people. So the vaccine is probably as effective as natural immunity in practice.
(1) A friend of mine who works as a doctor in one of the vaccination centers in South Germany told me that re-infection rates with problematic outcome after full vaccinations are ~5%. This is what they tell their patients in the information talk before the shot. Note that my friend could not give me a higher resolution of the data (age, etc).
(2) I think I wrote that in one of my prior comments ~ 9 month or so ago - Another medical doctor aquaintance of mine that was working in the local health department Corona group told me that in the town of Tuttlingen (pop ~ 100K) there habe been 9 re-infections with the SARS-CoV2. At the time there were only 7 known cases in literature.
sorry for the late reply. Had to get back to my contacts re your questions. I did not check or ask for reference / primary data sources, but I was talking to medical doctor directly involved in the German SARS-CoV2 vaccination program on a local level.
> Is that with AZ or an mRNA vaccine?
It seems to be unclear by now which combination of vaccination dosages (and their timing) gives the best results. When it comes to double shots, I was told that
- AZ: 1 in 5 get infected
- Biontech: 1 in 20 get infected
> Also by "problematic", do you know if they meant WHO's "mild" or "severe"? "Mild" is still quite bad, just not enough to hospitalize you.
Unfortunately, I did not ask regarding these specifics, but I believe that the wording was according to WHO standards.
According to my source, after two shots:
- AZ: 90% less severe cases, 85% less infections
- Biontech: 85% less severe cases, 95% less infections.
So, statistically speaking, AZ is better to avoid bad cases, while Biontech is better for spread.
In southern Germany, it seems that there is increased activity in administration a combination of both vaccines. This is done because there seems to be an indication that a combination might be better than a mono-vaccine, and/or because of the supply situation / available vaccines.
There is a meta study coming out in the UK regarding AZ/Biontech/Moderna vaccine combination and vaccination timing effects.
Hope it helps a bit.
I’m convinced I had Covid twice, in March 2020 and again in December 2020. So in my case, “natural” immunity did not last 9 months. (Although there were presumably different Covid variants at play here. I’m in London where the “Kent” variant was dominant in the December peak)
Only the second time was confirmed by PCR test (no testing available in March 2020), but symptoms and progression were nearly identical both times.
But it has some distinct features: high fever/temperature which lasts < 24 hours, changes in taste (foods which I normally enjoy tasting bitter and disgusting, toothpaste tasting like bitter chemicals, etc), severe fatigue, mild-to-moderate nausea, shortness of breath, and muscle and joint pains. Some of these symptoms lingered for quite a few weeks.
I only know 1 person who almost died from it, my friend's mother who had to be put on a ventilator, but she survived.
> "Almost everyone I know that had COVID said that the flu was worse."
I'm inclined to agree. I've had a few severe flus in my lifetime that felt worse and more intense, but again, in my experience the symptoms of flu feel quite different to Covid.
That said, I certainly don't recommend getting Covid!
> "Change in taste can be attributed to blocked nose which radiacally changes the taste of food."
I did not get a blocked nose/sinus from Covid.
Also I never really had that much of a cough. Just a mild, intermittent dry cough.
The duration of the study being 5 months.
There's no indication from this study what would happen after 5 months.
> This study was not specifically designed to determine the duration of protection afforded by natural infection, but for the previously infected subjects the median duration since prior infection was 143 days (IQR 76 – 179 days), and no one had SARS-CoV-2 infection over the following five months, suggesting that SARS-CoV-2 infection may provide protection against reinfection for 10 months or longer.
As such, most infected participants would have been recently infected in a situation with low and decreasing virus circulation. Nobody thinks there's any risk of reinfection at that point.
This study helps us put some bounds on how many people this might happen to (assuming there are no mutations to the virus) but it doesn't rule it out completely, because of the prior existence proofs
The early Nevada case involved a relatively younger person who caught it once. Then they caught it again while caring for a parent who also had it and was hospitalized. The case was confirmed by PCR analysis of the samples that were taken combined with validating that the samples had the subjects DNA in them.
But they likely had a very mild initial infection and being young they fought it off with mostly an innate immune system response and didn't generate a lot of antibodies or adaptive response.
Then when their parent got sick (in the same household) I would bet money the cared for that parent taking little to no precautions believing that their prior infection granted them survivor-island-style invincible immunity to disease (which is how most people think the immune system works). They likely got a whopping large viral dose which (probably combined with a bit of bad luck) is what caused the second infection to be severe and require hospitalization.
And due to selection effects that unusual case bubbled up to the top early because it was someone in the hospital with covid who had positive evidence that they'd caught it 3 months earlier. A lot of people with mild covid both times would never have landed into a study and the clinicians wouldn't have bothered with genetic sequencing.
10 months separated the first and the second infections.
Both were mild, the second was worse (English variant).
The important point here is that we got re-infected almost a year later with a variant.
From my experience, it looks like the flu.
You could be PCR tested positive, while experiencing a cold or flu (which you would now understandably think were Covid symptoms), but would not have immunity for a future, larger infection from Covid.
Though statistically unlikely, it's bound to happen sometimes.
Remember that immunisation makes antibodies but only provides something like 50-95% protection (depending on the vaccine) - it's not surprising that actually catching it does the same thing
Sure, but these things are rare enough that it can be only people with a wonky immune system or some other exotic condition.
“The cumulative incidence of SARS-CoV-2 infection remained almost zero among previously infected unvaccinated subjects, previously infected subjects who were vaccinated, and previously uninfected subjects who were vaccinated, compared with a steady increase in cumulative incidence among previously uninfected subjects who remained unvaccinated.
Not one of the 1359 previously infected subjects who remained unvaccinated had a SARS-CoV-2 infection over the duration of the study.”