News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by bwestergard on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @09:32AM (#27434929)
In Finland, everyone's taxable income is a matter of public record. One theoretical benefit of such a policy is that it eliminates information asymmetries between workers and employers in wage bargaining.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by ksec on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:38PM (#27439779)
>eliminates information asymmetries between workers and employers in wage bargaining.

WOW! Never heard of this as an argument. I think it is a very good one for working class.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by httpsterio on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @09:33PM (#27443243)
Yep, I for example learned that my two bosses (CEO and CMO) in our roughly 20 person company took home roughly 100k in salaried income each, out of the 3 million or so turnover.

Company earnings, turnover and profit, are easily found for all Finnish companies as well. It's pretty easy to weed out the companies on an unhealthy base.

I also saw the salaries as a sign that they're in it for the long term as they could've easily taken home more but they also didn't feel the need to 'save' the company money so they had trust in the current market position and I felt comfortable asking for a 25% raise, which I also got.

It's good to know where you stand among your peers and superiors.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by ksec on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:03PM (#27443414)
>in our roughly 20 person company took home roughly 100k in salaried income each

And Fresh Grad from US are demanding 200K from FAANG....

I think it will be hard for countries not currently doing it to have this system in place. But we could at least start with price bracket.

The biggest Win for me isn't the peer checking or market rate. It is that we can also stop HR and Recruiting Agency on their constant lying and BS. Constantly have to play games with them.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by httpsterio on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @08:25AM (#27447096)
I should've clarified that I did indeed mean euros.

The CEO for example owns a very large home in the most affluent part in the city. the CMO drives a new Tesla and has a villa that's about a 30 minute drive away from our capital city.

A 100k salary is not insane here, there are obviously people making more as well. Those are usually startup founders building something on loaned money or celebrities.

Im living in one of the larger cities, it takes me 10 minutes to drive to the city centrum, so it's a pretty decent location. I pay under 700 euros for 65 square meters with our own sauna. I'm roughly spending 25% of my income on rent for two people.

So, the cost of living is obviously a lot lower here, even if our salaried don't look exactly comparable. You can stretch a 1 million turnover to cover for 10 programmers and tech workers easily instead of getting just one senior developer from the Bay Area :)

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by ALittleLight on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:21PM (#27443536)
Assuming the parent comment is referring to earnings in Euros rather than USD they're talking about ~250k USD. It doesn't seem at all strange that leadership in a small company is making the same as entry developers at FAANG. For one, small business. Two, the company leadership gets more equity and a more interesting job.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by ksec on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:01PM (#27443760)
>in Euros rather than USD they're talking about ~250k USD.

Not ~120K USD?

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by ALittleLight on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:14PM (#27443839)
Oops, you're right. I was more confident I knew the exchange rate than I should've been.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by andi999 on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @01:03AM (#27444401)
True, but 120k in Finnland give you probably the same quality of living as 250k in the bay area.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by lotsofpulp on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @07:17PM (#27442320)
Price transparency is necessary for the proper functioning of any market. Otherwise there is no clean signal of the supply and demand curves.

Lack of price transparency results to inefficient markets, e.g. someone consistently ending up with outsized profits.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by RhysU on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:21PM (#27443865)
Price transparency makes sense when goods are fungible. Employees are often not fungible.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by lotsofpulp on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:33PM (#27443930)
Why does it not make sense when goods are not fungible? The buyer and seller can ascertain how fungible the good they are interested in exchanging is. If it’s not, then the other prices will not matter as much. But more information is better than less information.

Also, while employees might not be completely fungible (pretty much all are replaceable though on a long enough timeline), the employees are buying money from the employees, and that is fungible.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by RhysU on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:40PM (#27443968)
What's the value of a 1999 Camaro? How much should that number influence the price of last year's minivan?

Arguing about the relevance of information to a transaction for some good is 1:1 with simply arguing about the transaction price for some good. Just haggle directly instead of in some meta fashion.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by lotsofpulp on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:54PM (#27444050)
How does a person know which fields to pursue if they do not know wages? You have to look at the trends for which each wages are moving, where they are moving, the number of new job seekers in that field, the number exiting that field.

It is much better now with the internet, but it was not long ago that if you did not know some in a specific business, you had no idea what they would be earning. For a kid in a lower income family, they might never know about what to study to get the top incomes.

> What's the value of a 1999 Camaro? How much should that number influence the price of last year's minivan?

Depends if the buyer is trying to decide between buying a 1999 Camaro or last year’s minivan. Just like a high school student might be trying to decide which field to go into.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by LargoLasskhyfv on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @04:50PM (#27440609)
Maybe. But imagine

>enables transparency between workers and employers in wage bargaining.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by LatteLazy on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @04:07PM (#27440082)
(not OP)

There is good evidence that when wages are public knowledge minorities and women get paid more too...

https://time.com/5353848/salary-pay-transparency-work/

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by sagarm on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:47PM (#27450112)
From your own article:

However, there isn’t enough research to definitively link pay transparency to pay equality. At U.S. government agencies, most of which are required to publicly release pay information, women make 81% of what men make, according to the 2017 report from the Institute for Women’s Policy Research. In the private sector, where the majority of companies don’t have pay transparency policies, women earn 79% of what their male counterparts make.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by ffggvv on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @07:10PM (#27442281)
likely everyone else just gets paid less in the interest of fairness.. this already happens at tech companies like stripe. "Oh we dont care how many competing offers you have or how qualified you are. we pay everyone the same in the name of "fairness".
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by ncmncm on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @08:51PM (#27442967)
You would like to think so, but if we compare Finnish to American payrolls, you would find instead that instead top management gets less, if anybody. But there is more...

Economic prosperity is always most sensitive to what the bottom quarter gets paid, because they are who are obliged to spend what they get immediately.

The greater general prosperity that results benefits everybody else, in sum, more than the increased minimum wage. This was recently demonstrated in Seattle, in practice.

In short: no, you are 100% wrong. You should consider this good news.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by ffggvv on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:05AM (#27444113)
you didn’t actually provide any proof to disprove my claim and then said i was 100% wrong. either way i don’t think we’re aspiring to be finland.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by ncmncm on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @03:47PM (#27452233)
Which part of, "This was recently demonstrated in Seattle, in practice." were you not able to follow?

100% wrong, and evidently you don't consider it good news.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by ffggvv on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @03:56PM (#27452350)
just saying that and getting angry doesnt make it true.

urban areas all boomed due to the roaring economy up until covid, especially powered by the large growth in the tech sector there and corporate tax cuts (and seattle's low state tax making it an attractive place to be locate). theres no evidence seattle magically helped everyone by raising minimum wages.

likely seattle did fine despite the minimum wage increase, not because of them. Especially since you have to pay that much to attract workers there anyway because of the insane living costs. Which partially ballooned due to artificial price controls like that. and theres no measuring how many people got their jobs automated away or didnt get hired because of the wage increases.

and seattle has also had an explosion of homelessness and violent crime.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by ncmncm on Friday June 11, 2021 @01:57AM (#27469809)
Perceiving anger where there is none reveals more than you probably intended.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by MR4D on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:41PM (#27437532)
> everyone's taxable income is a matter of public record

That's an interesting approach. I have a couple questions out of curiosity.

Does that include their "offshore" income? By that, I mean income earned outside of the country, not necessarily hidden.

Also, what is income? If there is a billionaire investor and he loses $10 million, do you see that as well?

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by koala_man on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @02:11PM (#27438771)
Can't answer for Finland, but in Norway:

>Does that include their "offshore" income?

Yes. It counts as taxable income even if you end up paying 0% tax on it (such as via foreign tax credit).

>Also, what is income?

Net realized income. You can't tell the difference between earning $1M, and earning $10M and losing $9M, and earning $10M on paper but only selling $1M.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by mariozivic on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:35AM (#27457961)
In the current low interest rate environment, I've heard that it's common for founders like Musk to borrow against their shares instead of selling shares. The difference is that they pay small interest rate but don't pay larger income tax by realizing their income.

Basically, the same thing that their companies used (or maybe still use) for avoiding high tax on repatriation or their non-US earnings.

Edit: Here's a proof but with different incentives (keeping control): https://www.wsj.com/articles/elon-musk-techs-cash-poor-billi...

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by taeric on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @04:27PM (#27440327)
So what would the public record for Musk be? The number reporting usually quotes? Or a much smaller one? (Still large, of course.)
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by mariozivic on Thursday June 10, 2021 @03:40AM (#27457998)
$0 for income tax as his salary is $0 and he funds his lifestyle by borrowing against shares he owns: https://www.wsj.com/articles/elon-musk-techs-cash-poor-billi...
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by taeric on Thursday June 10, 2021 @12:00PM (#27462225)
That... Isn't accurate either. :(. He did actually pay some taxes, so income wouldn't be zero.

This whole "loan against debt" story feels off.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by mistrial9 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:36AM (#27435736)
some countries have a social "fabric" .. the USA is a geographic location with English-style law, and a lot of people who are very divided and increasingly antagonistic.. Try to build the Roman Empire, and you get Roman Empire problems in your population..
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by bwestergard on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:48PM (#27438482)
While the U.S. certainly has regional, class, and other subcultures, there is very clearly a national culture and "social fabric".

The easiest way to see this, if you grew up in the U.S. and have not traveled much, is to read tourist guides for your own country.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by marcusverus on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @02:31PM (#27439020)
Is this really the case? Imagine you're at a masquerade ball with 25 people from random countries around the western world, 5 of whom are Americans from various states. Everyone speaks perfect, mechanical, unaccented English, and you are not permitted to discuss dead-giveaway topics like geography, political parties/candidates, specific foods, etc. How confident are you that you could pick out the Americans?
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by mustafa_pasi on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:22PM (#27439626)
IMHO there is a common theme in the philosophy of life of most Americans. For example, many people have remarked on the high levels of optimism found in most Americans. It is one of my favourite American attributes.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by sellyme on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:24PM (#27443555)
> you are not permitted to discuss dead-giveaway topics

You might as well say "can you identify someone's cultural heritage without discussing anything that would allow you to identify their cultural heritage?". This stipulation makes the task definitionally a matter of chance.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by doytch on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:10PM (#27439492)
How confident are you that you'd pick out the Spaniard? Or Belgian? Or Canadian?

Generally, people overestimate the variation in their own compatriots and underestimate that in foreigners.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by anthonygd on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @05:07PM (#27440800)
I have zero confidence I would be able to pick out the Spaniard, Belgian, Canadian or American.

I'm having a hard time matching your generalization with my experience. When I started travelling I was surprised how similar people were regardless of where they were from.

Sure you can dig into political views and find themes but those aren't consistent or pervasive enough to make predictions on an individual basis.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by marcusverus on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:07PM (#27443432)
Ah. My comment assumed its parent comment was written by an American. My point was that, if you hailed from an country with a common culture, it would be trivial not pick folks out of a crowd who share your cultural background. I don't think that Americans would not have such an easy time doing this.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by jeffreyrogers on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:34AM (#27435702)
Interesting. It seems to work for Finland. In some countries it would probably make you a kidnapping target.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:46AM (#27435867)
You become a kidnapping target by being rich, whether that's a matter of public record or just someone cruising the wealthier neighbourhoods is arbitrary.

I mean over here you can't look up who makes how much, but the rough value of houses and neighbourhoods, which is used to determine property taxes, is public record.

I'm sure there's some rich people / families living in otherwise underwhelming houses, but they're generally a minority.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by btilly on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:59AM (#27436062)
Per The Millionaire Next Door (see https://www.amazon.com/Millionaire-Next-Door-Surprising-Amer... for the link), most wealthy are those who have a reasonable income but good financial discipline.

Which means that a shocking number of millionaires live in poor neighborhoods and have modest lifestyles.

Those aren't the super-wealthy, of course. But most wealthy people can't be identified by where they live.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by Retric on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:09AM (#27436198)
The millionaire next door uses an artificially low threshold for wealth. It’s not a book about the wealthy, it’s largely a book about retirement. 1M is only generating ~40k per year, if that’s your savings you can’t afford to live in an affluent area without a job.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by btilly on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:19PM (#27437209)
That book was originally written decades ago. Its threshold corresponds to about $1.7 million in savings in today's world. Their median was $1.6 million, or about $2.7 million in today's dollars.

And given that the people who attained that status on average lived in cheap neighborhoods, the fact that their income wouldn't stretch long in an affluent neighborhood isn't really a concern for them.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by Retric on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:47PM (#27438460)
Even adjusting for inflation from 1996 half the population had 1.0 - 1.6 million.

That translates to ~$1.7M - 2.7M, or an income of ~68k to 108k which is still not that significant.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by btilly on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:17PM (#27439572)
Where do you get half the population from?

According to the statistics that they gave, an estimated 3.5 million Americans were that wealthy. In 1996 the US population was around 270 million so we're talking about the top 1.3% of Americans by net worth.

For more about what this group looked like, read https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/style/longterm/books/c....

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by Retric on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:37PM (#27439769)
That’s what a a median of $1.6 million and a minimum of 1.0 million means. Half of their population was 1.0 to 1.6 Million the other half was over 1.6 million.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by zhdc1 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:19AM (#27436341)
> Those aren't the super-wealthy, of course. But most wealthy people can't be identified by where they live.

This is particularly true for intergenerational wealth. I grew up in a area with fair number of affluent households. You couldn't realize it until you became familiar the community.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by jeffreyrogers on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:56AM (#27436007)
> I'm sure there's some rich people / families living in otherwise underwhelming houses, but they're generally a minority.

There are more than you think. Pretty much every city has a nice neighborhood where the wealthy residents live. The difference between someone worth $10mm vs someone worth $100mm is not visible from the street.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by 411111111111111 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:17AM (#27436309)
Does that difference matter when kidnapping? Its not like the 100mm person has more money readily available, as they'll likely both have the bulk invested/tied up in some way.

You can only get their fluid money which is probably quite similar in a time sensitive situation like that.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by jeffreyrogers on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:44AM (#27436660)
I would assume someone with $100mm in assets has more of it in liquid assets than someone with $10mm in assets (a large amount of which would be their home).
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by yeetman21 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @08:57PM (#27443004)
when someone has a gun to your childs head, i dont think you will be thinking about longer term or short term capital gains
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by pmoriarty on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:55AM (#27435999)
The solution to this is to eliminate wealth disparity.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by carapace on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:04PM (#27436957)
Maybe. But how?

I think that, if you could somehow collect all the wealth and redistribute it equally, within a few years we would see disparity reappear. Some folks are better at accumulating wealth than others.

It seems to me that you would have to keep reallocating wealth. And many would then ask, what's the motive for generating wealth if it's just going to be taken away from you?

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by WalterBright on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:57PM (#27437723)
This has happened before.

After the end of WW2, the Allies decided to repudiate the ReichsMark (the German dollar) and issue a new Mark. Everyone who held ReichsMarks saw it go to zero. To get the economy going again, everyone was issued 50 of the new Deutsch Marks.

Within a couple weeks, the people who had been wealthy before were rapidly moving ahead, and the ones who had not been were again at the bottom.

I.e. the people who knew how to make money still knew how to make money, and the people who didn't still didn't.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by kapp_in_life on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @05:54PM (#27441439)
I'm not familiar with this case study but was wouldn't that be due to retaining asset ownership? Even if the dollar became worthless, presumably I'd still control all my assets(the stocks in my brokerage/401k, my car, etc.). The companies I have ownership for would still be able to generate goods/services for Dollar2.0

People storing money under their mattress presumably were in trouble, but doing that already puts you at risk of devaluation through inflation. And I'd imagine that most wealthy people are wealthy because they do exactly the opposite and hold assets instead of currency.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by WalterBright on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @09:44PM (#27443299)
Consider, for example, that Berlin was bombed flat. Every industrial area was bombed. The houses were carpet bombed. The remaining factories were boxed up and shipped to the Soviet Union. The rest was looted by the troops. The young men were dead or in POW camps.

The people that told me this story were in Berlin at the time.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by eecc on Monday June 14, 2021 @04:23AM (#27500467)
Or, anyone with significant enough wealth had already diversified to gold and stashed it in Switzerland. Not too conspicuously as you wouldn't want to draw the attention of the Gestapo on your "short" but enough to be in a better position for a fresh start, than a 50 DM.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by pmoriarty on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:45PM (#27438434)
This is why the system has to be designed to prevent concentrations of wealth or power.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by carapace on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:35PM (#27439753)
How? (I'm not trolling, I'm sincerely curious. I respect and appreciate your viewpoint pmoriarty even though I don't always agree with you.)

I feel like it's probably a bad idea to let individuals acquire so much wealth and power that they rival some nations, yet I haven't been able to frame an ethical way to prevent it if the "0.001%" have acquired their wealth legitimately, that is, by the rules we all must follow.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by nate_meurer on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:49PM (#27444021)
There are two ways: redistribution, and state control of production.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by Shacklz on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:43PM (#27437551)
> And many would then ask, what's the motive for generating wealth if it's just going to be taken away from you?

The same motivation that drives some folks to study e.g. philosophy, even though it's perfectly well known that this will never make you rich: Because they like it.

You don't just e.g. found a company for the sake of money - you also do it because it allows you to do things on your own terms, it gives you prestige, it gives you the satisfaction of being 'successful'. In todays day and age, this is usually equivalent with 'generating wealth', but I'm a firm believer that this does not necessarily have to be the case.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by Loughla on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:20PM (#27438065)
I find it absolutely fascinating that your arguments are shot down on this board, because it's business, but that is literally what you're told on a constant basis if you want to go into the education field in the US.

You don't do it for the paycheck, you do it because you like it. Why education, social work, and other human services fields, but not business? That is odd to me.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by w4 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @02:23PM (#27438892)
> I find it absolutely fascinating that your arguments are shot down on this board, because it's business, but that is literally what you're told on a constant basis if you want to go into the education field in the US.

It’s not actually that fascinating, and has a simple explanation: the people saying this about teachers are not the same people that are commenting here. It’s a non-sequitur.

The notion that educators (or anyone else for that matter) ought to accept bad pay or working conditions because of “passion” is completely objectionable. Teachers should be well-compensated for the important and difficult work they do.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by w4 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:01PM (#27437776)
I’m not so sure. Running a business exposes you to tremendous personal risk, especially in a litigious country like the US. It’s also incredibly hard, most often fails, and typically confers less prestige than other much more reliable and substantially less risky high paying career paths (finance, law, medicine, consulting, etc).
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by carapace on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:53PM (#27439941)
Folks who want to start and run a business and give away their profit can already do so. E.g. Warren Buffet gives away half his wealth voluntarily. Or take the case of Dan Price https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dan_Price

Is it ethical to force people to give up against their will money that they (presumably) earned "fair and square"?

Assuming we find that ethical formula (which seems dubious to me but let it ride for the sake of discussion) the next question is, would the people willing to work under that system be "enough"? And then we have to ask "enough for what purpose?"

That gets into ethical and speculative issues that cut right to the heart of the human condition. Wendell Berry asked, "What are people for?" Bucky Fuller calculated that we could bring about a secular utopia for ~$25 billion by sometime in the 1970's if we applied our technology efficiently to supplying our physical needs. I'm open to the idea that we don't need open-ended profit motive to create a good and worthwhile global society (in fact even Adam Smith thought the capitalist "greed is good" phase would be just that: a temporary phase between the old system and the new.)

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by WalterBright on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:57PM (#27437735)
Economies based on this idea tend to do very poorly.

For one thing, people won't have money to invest in new ventures.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by tengbretson on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:26AM (#27436437)
Why stop at eliminating wealth disparity when you can eliminate wealth?
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by fennecfoxen on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @02:45PM (#27439199)
This has been demonstrated feasible! We can all be similarly poor together.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by syshum on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:01PM (#27436918)
Same thing, the only way to eliminating wealth disparity is to eliminate wealth.

The Authoritarian Left that goes on and on about eliminating wealth disparity has no interest in lifting everyone up to be wealthy, not they want to seize the wealth and drag anyone down they deem is "too wealthy"

Which is ironically always someone more wealthy than the person advocating for wealth redistribution, for example Bernie Sanders used to talk about "millionaires and billionaires" until he became a millionaire, now like magic only billionaires are a problem for him

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by mola on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:24PM (#27437283)
You know being a millionaire today has a massively different meaning than 20 years ago.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by losvedir on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:41PM (#27437526)
What? Now you're making me feel old. I remember 20 years ago... it didn't seem that different from today. What's "massively different" about being a millionaire then? You mean, inflation-adjusted, how it's $1.5 million today?
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by convolvatron on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:30PM (#27438212)
you still get get to retire in comfort, but you don't get invited to the really swank parties

seriously - maybe narcissism isn't the best character trait to structure your society around?

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by ldbooth on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:39PM (#27437503)
The tax system is part and parcel with inequality.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by faeyanpiraat on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:15AM (#27436287)
We tried that already. It wasn’t pretty.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by Tostino on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @04:38PM (#27440462)
When? When did we actually try that?
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by madsbuch on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:49PM (#27438493)
The kidnapping problem is on a whole other level.

Denmark is known for "leaving babies in strollers outside of cafes". The Nordic social-liberal countries (Finland included) solve this problem not by opacity but by having social support and trust.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by jeffreyrogers on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @07:20PM (#27442346)
I know that, but you mostly don't get to choose whether you live in such a country or not. Everyone would choose to live in a country like that if they could.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by madsbuch on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @03:59AM (#27445391)
I think the point is, that the society as a whole should support public tax records. Finland (and Sweden) does.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by frockington1 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @02:29PM (#27438989)
Dumb person here. What is "leaving babies in strollers outside of cafes"?
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by a1369209993 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:48PM (#27439888)
When going into a cafe to order something, they leave their child (in a stroller) outside with the (allegedly justified) expectation that nothing bad will happen to it. (To be fair, babies aren't especially easy to liquidate if stolen, and strollers are inconveniently bulky, so this arguably says less about the amount of crime than about how petty, blatant, and asinine the criminals are.)
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by lolive on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @04:26AM (#27445547)
Reminds me of a Michael Moore movie where he goes to Canada, and checks in a neighbourhood whether people lock their main door or not. He litteraly enters a house, and asks directly to the inhabitants: "Why don't you lock your door?". And the canadians answer: "Why should I?"
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by boruto on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @04:25PM (#27440299)
> kidnapping target.

Or a target for scamming.

Seems privacy nightmare too. I hope there is an opt out where you don't ask and yours is private.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by eecc on Monday June 14, 2021 @04:28AM (#27500492)
My guess the records are public but access is not anonymous; you'd need to identify yourself and leave a plausible reason on record.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by TrackerFF on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:35PM (#27443619)
Same in Norway, but the result isn't very accurate.

For one, the wealthy don't tend to have any serious income - it's mostly capital gains for one of their holding companies or similar.

Second, those numbers can be seriously "massaged" by having debt - your income will show much lower if you have any significant debt (no mater how low the interest rate is).

For normal / regular people, the public figure gives you a very rough estimate.

Again - the rich and wealthy will almost always show up with income 0, tax 0, assets 0. You don't even need to be filthy rich to get it structured like that.

edit: What it did create, though, was a cottage industry of tax snoopers. Over here, you can see who's been checking you out - and nosy people not wanting to do that, will pay a couple of bucks for some service where others will check out your information.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by lolive on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @04:20AM (#27445514)
I am no expert but how can you reduce your income tax with debt? I thought only companies could include their debts into their global accounting, not individuals.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by zo1 on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @11:31AM (#27449098)
Interest paid on debt is seen as an expense. In some tax codes (like in SA) expenses like that offset your taxable income as a private entity.

To be fair the lines get blurry because tax codes like to tax individuals differently to business entities. E.g individuals get taxed on mostly gross profit (income) whereas companies get taxed on net profit after expenses.

IMHO the whole thing would probably be filled with less gaps if we just relied on one of the two or unified them.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by GordonS on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @05:38PM (#27441229)
I wholeheartedly agree, and I'd be in favour of such a system here in the UK.

That said, I'm not sure it would work in the US, where individualism has been taken to such extreme lengths - I could imagine it being used as bragging rights, rather than a source of moral embarrassment as it would be in Europe and Scandinavia.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by HatchedLake721 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @06:40PM (#27442033)
Moral embarrassment of what?
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by tharkun__ on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:19PM (#27443521)
Moral embarassment of earning 5 million while everyone makes 50k. And everyone seeing this and quitting and going to a company where the boss only makes 100k if everyone else makes 50k (for example).

This might be unfathomable to some people and I must admit that having all salaries public is a bit strange to me as well. I don't know if I like it. I also read elsewhere on here that it only reports net income. I wonder how many schemes of making it look like you have less net income than you really do are employed. Sort of like profitable companies making themselvesook like they are loosing money or barely scraping by to avoid taxes.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by Hammershaft on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @05:06PM (#27440793)
I am in favor of such a system.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by stjohnswarts on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @05:14PM (#27440906)
I'm not, it's dumb and makes classism which is already a problem in the USA an even bigger problem.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by yeetman21 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @08:55PM (#27442990)
makes it know who to rob
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by anovikov on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:33AM (#27435693)
You mean that workers know incomes of other workers in the same company and role and thus there is no way to negotiate wages with people individually basically linking them to their negotiation skills?
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by mlac on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:04AM (#27435361)
I would also think that this makes neighborhoods less financially diverse. I can’t see someone with a higher than average income moving into a neighborhood knowing that their neighbors might make 1/4th as much. It puts a target on them.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by lmilcin on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:13AM (#27435455)
You obviously haven't been to Finland.

In Scandinavia, the approach to other person earning couple of times more than you could be summarized by "good for you".

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by mlac on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @02:26PM (#27438954)
That's good it works that way in Finland, but my point was focused on the United States. I don't think making everyones' income public would suddenly make those in the US think like those in Finland. I also think the social services in Finland raise the bar for everyone - everyone has more basic services than in the United States, so it starts off more equal.

This happens with any disparity - education, income, wealth. Differences in these cause some people to act differently. I've met many people who think earning $100,000 a year qualifies you as "rich", and there are a lot of people who think they won't have anything in common with someone who is educated beyond undergrad.

I imagine it would suddenly be a metric on Zillow and Realtor - "average neighborhood income". People would self-select based on that, making neighborhoods less financially diverse. No one would want to be seen as the broke person in the neighborhood, and no one would want to way over-buy the neighborhood. Maybe you would, but people would "know" whether you could afford to live there or whether you were taking a house from someone else when you could afford to live in a nicer place. Either way, it would not be comfortable, not to mention if you lived somewhere for a while and your career took off - you'd then maybe out earn the neighborhood and be forced to move, rather than be able to remain and blend in.

On my earlier comment, I guess 1/4 wasn't the right ratio. My point was more that someone making 200k may not move into a neighborhood where the average income is 50k, when they otherwise would have, because they would be viewed very differently among neighbors and it would be hard to blend in. This would lessen tax revenue for low-income areas as people would be less willing to move in.

In general, talking about salary in the States is taboo, but not among hourly workers. If you hear a conversation about work between hourly workers, it generally comes out pretty quickly what they are making. I read an article stating it happens for price discovery - they mention it regularly so they can charge the right rates and work at the highest paying location.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by anovikov on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:34AM (#27435708)
But earning couple of times less lol? ) I don't think anyone at all wants live in a place where most people earn a lot less than themselves.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by michaelt on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:00PM (#27436892)
Eh, I imagine this matters a lot more at the lower income levels, due to marginal utility.

If you're living in a trailer park because that's all you can afford, if you treble your income there's a good chance you'd move out right away.

On the other hand, if you own two $150,000 Lamborghinis and a guy moves in next door with only a single $100,000 Ferrari, are you going to be moving out because the neighbourhood is going down hill? Probably not.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by jessaustin on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:39AM (#27436603)
It seems really weird not to have neighbors with different incomes. There would have to be really over-the-top HOAs and zoning to arrange such a situation.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by mantas on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:57AM (#27436032)
Nah. A lot of people care about trashiness and culture much more. And boy that does not correlate with bank account.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by gmadsen on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:44AM (#27435845)
maybe in extremes. like 100:1, but 2:1, 3:1 doesn't seem that bad... honestly better for social cohesion
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by ghaff on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:38AM (#27436586)
I can pretty much guarantee that in the semi-rural town where I live, there are households that are probably down around median US income (~$50K) and households making hundreds of thousands of dollars or more.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by Loughla on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:26PM (#27438162)
In my rural area, I was one of the rich people in our area (combined dual income from my spouse and I of around 80-90k/year). People used to give me shit for being Richie Rich (all in good fun). The income level around here hovers around 100-150% of the standard federal poverty level. Generally, most people are lower income, with some people making 100k plus. But, everyone sort of lives the same life; we hang out in the same places, our kids go to the same schools, that sort of thing.

Then real wealth started moving in to buy property as investments. Now we have people who have gates and armed guards. They have private police to scare the locals. They harass school board members for access to school vouchers for the private schools they are starting so their kids don't have to attend the public schools.

It's different around here now. It's a lot less 'community' and all it took was about a half dozen really wealthy folks to upset the apple cart.

Nobody jokes about money anymore in any context, and people seem to be a lot less happy than they used to be just in general.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by rongenre on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:23PM (#27437279)
Anybody who buys in an "affordable" neighborhood - at least in CA - is making a lot more than their neighbors who've lived there for decades. If you're polite, you don't flaunt it.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by bennysomething on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:25AM (#27436426)
I think "Diverse" is beginning to be the most over used and applied word of all time.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by mlac on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @02:34PM (#27439064)
Financial Different-ness? Financial Disparity? I just needed a word to talk about things that were not uniform or the same.

Also not saying that diversity in this case is a good thing or a bad thing - just that it exists and it may have interesting consequences or change with this policy. I would think making salaries public might limit gentrification. But it might also cause flight and impact the tax base. I do not think neighborhoods need to be uniformly financially diverse...

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by failwhaleshark on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:01AM (#27435318)
That makes the lives of gold-diggers easier too.

If it were opt-in that would be fine, otherwise it's an invasion of privacy of most people who aren't rich.

It's almost as bad as having medical conditions and STIs test results listed publicly.

Facilitating public exposure of counting other people's money doesn't help anyone except the rich to know if you can fight them in court or how much to bribe them.

Fight wealth inequality with income-&-holdings-proportional fines; simple, government-calculated graduated taxes without complicated exemptions; elimination of corporate/wealth welfare; and expand economic-advancement-oriented welfare to those who aren't super-rich who can use it.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by gota on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:50AM (#27435928)
I disagree almost completely. I understand your concerns - but they are based on weighing personal freedom above all else, and I just don't. I think there's a tradeoff there and it is favorable in favor of disclosing tax information.

To your points:

> gold-diggers

I'm not sure if this is an idiomatic term and out of my grasp, but if you mean that people will get romantically involved with others because of their money... this is a non-issue. Happy to debate it further, but it seems so silly and self-apparent that we shouldn't care at all about it

> Invasion of privacy

Arguably, but as long as only a minimum amount of whats is public, with only the lump-sums published, I think its fine in context.

> It's almost as bad as having medical conditions and STIs test results listed publicly.

I think these are very different things, the difference is not just of severity. They are different classes of things. Financial information relates to money, which only makes sense in a society (money is for trade). A disease's effects are personal. When they aren't, you are obligated to disclose them and/or to comply to other rules (for example, to quarantine).

> Facilitating public exposure of counting other people's money doesn't help anyone except the rich to know if you can fight them in court or how much to bribe them.

I think the experience where this has been applied is precisely the opposite - the rich are the ones affected the most. And - if your justice can be bought, the problem has less to do with the knowledge that the other can't find back and more to do with the legal system in the first place.

> Fight wealth inequality with income-&-holdings-proportional fines; simple, government-calculated graduated taxes without complicated exemptions; elimination of corporate/wealth welfare; and expand economic-advancement-oriented welfare to those who aren't super-rich who can use it.

Can't argue with that, even if I wanted to, in fewer than 15 pages. Complex stuff!

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by syshum on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:05PM (#27436991)
>>but they are based on weighing personal freedom above all else

and this is largely the primary difference between American Culture /Politics and the rest of the world, specifically European nations

European nations have always been more collectivist in nature, where the US was founded on Individualism, and Individual Freedom.

There are signs that the US is losing this desire, and it saddens me because unlike you I do value personal freedom above all else, and I think the world needs a nation that continues to put personal freedom above everything else.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by mola on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @12:34PM (#27437428)
Perhaps they are losing this desire because it doesn't provide the well being it promises? Because personal freedom has become a meme abused by ultra rich to disable any effort to fix systemic problems in the US?
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by syshum on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @02:56PM (#27439324)
Except that is not true at all by any objective measure. [1]

The Ultra Rich do not use Personal freedom to disable efforts, it uses Government Regulation to disable efforts, the Rich LOVE big government why do you think many billionaires vote Democrat, it enables them to control the economy to ensure the poor are kept poor and dependent on government. In the end we should look to Smash the State, Eat the Rich, and expand personal freedom [2]

[1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4J5s6aZCPSg

[2]https://c4ss.org/content/30085

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by dantheman on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @02:35PM (#27439069)
The problems in the US are primarily due government regulations breaking markets in things like education, medicine, and housing.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by whakim on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @08:22PM (#27442783)
The framework of individualism vs. collectivism is a complicated (and pretty fraught!) sociological construct. Scholars hotly debate whether individualism/collectivism applies to individuals, societies, or some mix of the two. Individualism also exists along a spectrum (if it even exists at all!) While there might be some connection here, it seems a vast oversimplification of cultures/individual attitudes to say that GP's view on Finnish taxation mechanics is a direct result of individualism/collectivism.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by gota on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @10:45AM (#27448478)
Sadly all good discussions quickly become more complex than our threshold for undertanding without in deptghresearch...

If you have any good (and brief!) resources on this please post them; I'd like to glance at how deep this discusson goes

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by whakim on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:37PM (#27449978)
Two important foundational works are Markus and Kitayama's Culture and the self: Implications for cognition, emotion, and motivation, and Triandis' Individualism and Collectivism. I am not a social psychologist so I don't have a really simple introduction that I can recommend (due to lack of familiarity!). But I have seen how, in a related field, overly simplistic and un-nuanced applications of what is actually a pretty complicated framework has lead to shoddy research and bad conclusions. That's why I called it out here.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by kwhitefoot on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @01:09PM (#27437900)
> think the world needs a nation that continues to put personal freedom above everything else.

And you think that the US does that?

Exercising personal freedom necessitates having the material and mental resources to buy stuff, to be able to move from place to place, to change jobs, etc. It seems to me that a plausible proxy measure for personal freedom is social mobility, the likelihood that you will be better off than your parents. As far as I remember the country with highest social mobility is Denmark.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by syshum on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:01PM (#27439387)
The US has pretty good Social Mobility as well, it is complete myth that the "rich" in the US is stagnate, most of the Billionaires in the US are 1st Generation Billionaires, this highlights there are income and social mobility.

As a personal anecdote, I am many times better of income and wealth wise than my parents even though we have the same education level and seemingly the same income opportunities, yet I have made better choices with my finances (learning from their [bad] example). My sibling is the same. One of my parents has zero retirement savings and will live off SocSec (likely with the assistance of me and my sibling). My other parent has slightly more savings but not by much and has lots of debt, both are within 5 years of SocSec retirement Age

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by gota on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:28PM (#27439675)
> As a personal anecdote, I am many times better of income and wealth wise than my parents even though we have the same education level and seemingly the same income opportunities

Slightly off topic - I'd wager the overwhelming majority of the HN posters are signficantly better-off than their parents, solely by virtue of being tech-workers. We tend to forget, but at no point in capitalism's history has such a numerous caste of white-collar knowledge workers been so well compensated as we are now

In your case it may well be mostly because of better financial decisions (especially if you are orders of magnitude better off, which is hard to do without consistent investment in any case), but for most of us this is also true just by 'placement luck'

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by whakim on Wednesday June 09, 2021 @12:24PM (#27449791)
> The US has pretty good Social Mobility as well, it is complete myth that the "rich" in the US is stagnate, most of the Billionaires in the US are 1st Generation Billionaires, this highlights there are income and social mobility.

Most economists of inequality dispute this. As measured by the likelihood that you'll earn more than your parents [1], or that you'll move up the income or wealth distribution compared to where you were born [2], the United States lags significantly behind most other developed nations. Social mobility in the United States is also lower than it has almost ever been.

[1] Chetty et al., The Fading American Dream: Trends in Absolute Income Mobility Since 1940

[2] Piketty, Capital in the Twenty-First Century

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by failwhaleshark on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:03AM (#27436116)
> this is a non-issue.

Who are you to have the gall to claim conclusive knowledge of an unknowable without a shred of evidence? How do you think gold-diggers and con-artists work, hang-around at airports, golf-courses, and investment brokerages waiting for rappers with the most gold chains?

> I think its fine in context.

That's your opinion that you're deciding for other people. It's the only number that matters and yet you're stilling trying hard to trivialize it.

> And - if your justice can be bought,

Nope, you automatically lept entirely in the wrong direction: it's not the justice who can be bought that is the problem, but the rich knowing how to calculate exactly how to exploit and buy-off the poor. Think Indecent Proposal or Bhopal rather than some Western movie about a crooked town sheriff.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by gota on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:54AM (#27436812)
I think you're being downvoted our of tone, rather than content. So let me respond in reverse order, as the first point seems to be the most emotional for you

>Nope, you automatically lept entirely in the wrong direction: it's not the justice who can be bought that is the problem, but the rich knowing how to calculate exactly how to exploit and buy-off the poor. Think Indecent Proposal or Bhopal rather than some Western movie about a crooked town sheriff.

I absolutely think that the core issue is that the legal system can 'be bought', i.e., it can bankrupt people even if they are right. Reforming that shouldn't be completely impossible and would by definition solve the niche problem you are describing. Btw, as a rule _any_ corporation can sue _any_ non-famously rich person and be sure that they threat of litigation costs will weight in their favor. Disclosed tax info worsens nothing from the current status quo.

> That's your opinion that you're deciding for other people.

It is opinion, yes. But all laws are someone's opinion 'deciding for other people'. And I mean absolutely all laws, even the most basic ones like the right to live or to have private property. It's all social constructs, and we decide which ones stand

> Who are you to have the gall to claim conclusive knowledge of an unknowable without a shred of evidence? How do you think gold-diggers and con-artists work, hang-around at airports, golf-courses, and investment brokerages waiting for rappers with the most gold chains?

I must say I'm surprised this issue seems important to you (and again - completely irrelevant to me). I absolutely don't care about something that I've only ever heard about in soap operas and have never, ever, heard of an example that bothered me in real life. I'm curious what makes this a relevant issue in your view, but I understand if its personal and you don't want to explain. But if you don't have any personal biases, let me argue that the problem of gold diggers is primarily a problem for the gold-dug (?). If a rich person doesn't want to marry/have a relationship with a person that only likes them for their money... then don't. I don't care, and I think nobody should

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by a1369209993 on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @03:59PM (#27440004)
> If a rich person doesn't want to marry/have a relationship with a person that only likes them for their money... then don't.

I think the claim is that you don't know whether a person is only interested in you for your money, and that this colors every social interaction you have, romantic or otherwise, with a undertone of worrying that any generosity you display is being exploited by someone who will abandon you the moment the money runs out. Cf fair-weather friends, miserliness, etc.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by jessaustin on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:45AM (#27436684)
Who are you to have the gall...

Whoa, relax. ISTM GP is probably a typical human. "Gold-diggers" are not and have never been a major threat to reasonably well-adjusted people. For weirdos who temporarily possess more money than they deserve, perhaps "gold-diggers" are a spice of life. Fools and wealth are soon parted, but that's true no matter what gets published.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by Frondo on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @05:04PM (#27440766)
> That's your opinion that you're deciding for other people

Others have spoken to your other points, but as for this, yeah, exactly.

We're talking about how we'd organize society (or some aspect of it), the basis of which involves making decisions for other people, in the sense of developing rules that hopefully people will abide by as participants in the society even if they disagree.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by lucideer on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:20AM (#27435543)
> If it were opt-in that would be fine

If it were opt-in it would be pointless. Surely that's obvious?

> Facilitating public exposure of counting other people's money doesn't help anyone except the rich to know if you can fight them in court or how much to bribe them.

This is a fair point, but I think these are relatively small individual downsides, which are also much more visible (and potentially addressable). Bribery is probably a harder nut to crack, but the legal system favouring the rich (& lawyered up) is something that one can potentially work toward balancing/mitigating with legislative measures.

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by xutopia on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:27AM (#27435632)
Funny thing my STI results are shared with my sexual partners and their partners too. It doesn't bother me one bit.
Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by sokoloff on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:32AM (#27435685)
By you and them? Laudable and sensible.

By the government? What business is it of the government to even know who my sexual partner(s) is/are (especially for a negative test result)?

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by toomuchtodo on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @10:37AM (#27435744)
Communicable disease prevention. HIV infections are typically reported to the government, for example, and does not require patient consent (nor does such data sharing incur a HIPPA violation).

> All 50 states require both physicians and laboratories to report to local or state health departments the names of persons newly diagnosed with Centers for Disease Control-defined AIDS [1]. However, because AIDS cases represent onset of the disease caused by HIV, HIV data is necessary to monitor the epidemic.

https://journalofethics.ama-assn.org/article/hiv-and-health-...

Re:We are publishing the tax secrets of the .001% by failwhaleshark on Tuesday June 08, 2021 @11:12AM (#27436249)
We already know, and we knew even before you did. Two of them were sent to test your disclosure practices, and you failed. You're an absolutely terrible person. How dare you!? Good day to you, sir/madame. I said "Good day!"

/s