Amazon simplifies my life. To be blunt, I don’t care about the “cost” (fiscal or otherwise).
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_antitrust_law#Th...
It is a huge leap to assume that the entire population doesn't care about the literal cost of something they are buying.
That is something that might be substantially harder to successfully sue under US antitrust law.
Consumers aren't paying any more. Consumers are just seeing a number with shipping prices built in.
- competition is good in and of itself, so new entrants should not be harmed and competition should be promoted and monopoly restricted purely on the basis of promoting competition as a policy goal.
- creation of new markets should be viewed as a policy goal in and of itself. Thus if a firm impedes a burgeoning secondary market or new derived market, that impediment should be viewed as a violation of anti-trust law.
- consumer harm is also a factor, but only one of three factors.
IMO, our maniacal focus on consumption while abandoning promotion of production and healthy market competition is behind many of our economic policy blunders.
In a functioning democracy, not for long
Many of us , myself included, after filling up a prime-enabled cart then go to walmart.com or some other such e-commerce retailer and then do exactly the same process you described still to check the price against Amazon.
Many times I go with the other retailer due to cost savings.
If Amazon prices things and incorporates shipping costs in such ways that people know they must double check them against other e-commerce vendors, where does the convenience and time savings come in?
What i'm saying : You're taking for granted that your convenience comes at a cost, in most cases.
The item I buy normally costs over that but every once in a while they'll send a coupon that offers 15% off that literally drops the price to like $1 under that free shipping price.
So the "coupon" ends up making it more expensive in total because the free-shipping is based off the post-discount price.
Usually, if it is cheaper at all, it's for a week plus delivery and only a few percent cheaper in total. Most of the time though, it's actually still more expensive.
I've also bought from sellers off of Amazon as they offered coupon codes and paypal purchases. It's not ideal, but it seems possible to get around this. I think it's easier for manufactures that sell direct than resellers though.
We're talking about a difference of seconds in the checkout experience. It adds to the perception of convenience, but but I don't see the miniscule time savings of the Amazon experience as being worth a higher price on the same item I could get for less elsewhere.
I've wasted far more time with Amazon trying to decide if an item is legitimate, and dealing with returns of broken, counterfeit, or misrepresented goods, than I have saved in their checkout experience.
The cost is high though. Amazon is already much lower quality than they were 10 years ago.
Could you expand on 'lower quality'? I personally have not noticed this.
The review/rating system has become untrustworthy.
It's extremely common (>50%) for me to see a 4+ star rating that turns out to be dominated by 1 star reviews and tons of complaints.
It's not unusual to find that what positive reviews there are, are for a wholly different product.
Even more frequent is that reviews for several different products are all bundled together.
I can't stand that. This doesn't matter if the product comes in various colors or something that would not change the product at all from one to the next, but then you also have things with computers with different options like video cards, memory configurations, cpu type, etc. That makes it VERY hard to find a review for the specific machine you ordered because it shows the reviews for all possible configurations.
It should show reviews only for the specific configuration chosen.
Here is how to do that.
First, make sure you've selected the product variation you want. Then:
1. Click the "nnn ratings" link at the top of the product page to go to the "Customer reviews" section.
2. On the left is a list of the percentages of each star number. Click any of them.
3. Now you have a page with a row of drop-down lists at the top. One of them will be something like "All formats". Change it to "Show only reviews for Style:" listing the product variation you selected at the beginning. You can also change the "n star only" back to "All stars", or "All positive" or "All critical".
They could make this easier to find! But once you know how to get there it's pretty useful.
Amen brother. Other review issues could be attributed to Amazon playing catch-up but this crappery is clearly by design.
Just looking for an item and finding 15 of the same one at wildly different price with different description really makes you scratch your head. What's the difference, is there one?
Then the killer for me is how they mix inventory from sellers. It doesn't matter how much I trust a certain vendor, what I buy may not be their inventory anyway, so a single bad apple can mess it up for everyone.
Bought some windex, didn't pay much attention to price, 10$, because it was amazon, I assumed the price was for a concentrated solution. Turns out it was the normal kind (3$) but the seller put this price and it landed in the search results quite high.
The benefits of lower prices online can also mean you spending more time checking things.
I’m honestly not sure about the batteries or hdmi cables. But my appreciation for the brand makes me wonder about your own experience.
My partner and I used to argue over who gets to make the monthly Costco run but now we just make it into a big family outing (Friday evenings are an amazing time to shop there).
I have had good experiences with Amazon Basics and Amazon's clothing brands.
This isn't so much a "all print on demand suffers from quality issues" but rather "the quality of the print on demand services is often an exercise in cost cutting."
I am certain that there are POD material that are as good as the traditional book print (and there are certainly non POD that employ similar cost cutting), but rather that in general, there is more investment in quality on the larger runs of a paperback book.
The customer could find the book they wanted on Amazon, purchase it for the same price or less via the bookstore's POD service, go have a snack and drink at the bookstore's cafe, and their book would be ready when they are done with that.
The bookstore essentially turned Amazon into a free book research services for the bookstore's customers.
> We can print millions of titles (including Google Books) that are in the public domain, as well as thousand of publisher-permission titles right to order!
The selection isn't quite the "anything that Amazon has."
They also make note of the quality with some of them that are from Google Books https://www.harvard.com/ondemand/kiosk/
> Public domain Google Books are the scanned collections of a number of libraries, including the Harvard University Library, and they may contain notations, other marks, and scanning errors. Harvard Book Store makes no representation or warranty as to the content of Google Books, and Google Books are non-returnable.
What does any of this have to do with printing? Those are formatting and typesetting issues. For the same final PDF it shouldn't matter how it's printed.
Now I'm seeing so many sponsored results to brands I've never heard of and seemingly only exist for drop-shipping or rebranding some OEM product. Worse, the non-sponsored results would also be no name brands, where I'd gravitate towards the ones with high reviews. Then I buy the product and see a little gift card I could monetize if I was to review the product with 5 stars, so seemingly most of those reviews are fraudulent. Worse again, the quality on this product is below, sometimes even way below, a normal brand I could get retail locally but priced about the same. I must return 1/4 of the products I buy because of poor QC or later breakage from normal, if not, light use. Support or customer service for these brands is almost non-existent too and this brand will disappear in a year anyway, so why bother trying to build any sort of reputation. Amazon is always happy to do a return so it solves that problem, but its a still a big hassle and I'm sure the carbon footprint of all these returns is scary. Then I'm playing random OEM roulette again with a similar product that will also have fraud reviews and 5 star review coupons inside of it.
I also dislike the dark pattern format of the site, which shows sponosered results in very small text and puts it in between related items. I'm not sure what Amazon's Choice really is, but its almost never a product or brand that I would consider trustworthy and I imagine is just a product that is giving Amazon good margins. In a curated department store model, recommended items would be actually recommended by staff and taste-makers at the cost or benefit of the reputation of the store. If Macy's is recommending a Braun coffeemaker, then its probably going to be a good coffeemaker as Macy's wants to please me as a Macy's customer. If Amazon recommends one, its just going to be some in-house rebrand or random OEM brand with lots of suspicious reviews (tons of 5 stars but also tons of 1 stars, with not much in the middle) and with positive reviews being either "amazing i love it!!!" or referring to an entirely different product (bots?) and negative reviews being in competent English and verbose and detailed about all the things wrong with this product.
I think like with any capitalist endeavor, without proper oversight and regulation, it naturally falls into a race to the bottom and "low road" capitalist outcomes. Amazon has been left more or less alone by legislators and its, of course, gone as bad as it can and I imagine will only get worse over time. Amazon moving from the department store model to the random street bazaar model is good for the bottom line but every year it gets harder to shop there as no-name brands with no support and fake reviews dominate its marketplace.
The regulation you mention will probably only make it much worse. It is being advocated for by the third party sellers that are making in a bad experience in the first place. I don't want to see them at all, much less give them more prominence.
I'm absolutely in love with a A$70 pair of wireless bluetooth headphones, that are more comfortable, have longer battery life, and sound just as good as my A$300 Bose QCs.
It's so good I've started giving them as gifts.
I only need their great customer service because of the poor quality products they are shipping. With other retailers, I don't know how good their customer service is because I almost never need to utilize them.
- Delivery time was like a week longer than they claimed.
- When it arrived it had a dead (red) pixel.
- Their customer support told me that dead pixels below a ridiculous amount (8 or so) do not qualify for a refund/replacement and told me to reach out to the manufacturer (overseas) for warranty replacement on a brand new item.
- Eventually I was able to return it under the regular "I no longer want this item" policy, but I had to pay a substantial restocking/returns fee (~20% of the price).
A quick search confirmed that this was very common with monitors and other items like GPUs have even more dissatisfaction/delayed shipping/shady practices.
Sure, I've had a couple of issues with late deliveries or broken products with Prime, but they've always corrected their error eventually. Returns and product issues are highly asymmetrical, where mostly you don't need it but when you do it's really important.
For expensive items, Amazon is 100% worth the peace of mind in case something goes wrong. For anything cheaper, I'm assuming I won't get help and I'll just have to eat the cost (which is ok, but of course not ideal). Not saying this could never happen with Amazon, but the risk seems a lot lower to me.
(I buy only from Newegg, not 3rd party folks selling on the Newegg platform).
If you get junk from Amazon, just send it back. No support needed.
When I compare this with all major retailers, this is true for everyone else. This isn't "fantastic" - it's standard.
Walmart was the one exception, where the employee didn't know Walmart's return policy.
Not long ago I ordered 4 pair of sunglasses from a small outfit online. Only 2 arrived. Support took a few days to get back to me, then asking for pics of what I got, the box, etc. I don't think that was unfair of them to ask and I provided all that, but it's a stark contrast to 'yeah here's your money back' in 5 minutes, no questions asked.
The matter was resolved with a refund when I forwarded the email threat they sent me to a couple relevant blogs/reviewers.
We've had groceries accidentally shipped to the wrong address (our shipping address is different from where we live b/c the building contracts a 3rd party to deal with packages). They either refund the order or send out a new delivery (mind you the other products are already delivered elsewhere and will eventually even make it to us... just with dead cold items), no questions asked.
It's things like this that make it much more comfortable to buy from Amazon than other places, as much as I would like to buy direct or from a smaller shop, etc.
Amazon delivers stuff to my place for "free" and very fast. They also make returning things as painless as possible since I don't even need to re-package my item when dropping off at UPS. It's easy to underestimate the hassle (from other merchants) of re-packaging your items and possibly paying for return shipping.
It's almost like the Walmart family thinks this online thing is a fad, and growth/sales spiraling downward will turn around any day now, just you wait and see!
I don't get it.
I spoke a while informally to someone who worked there. Sounded like a really smart person, and they were describing in detail how their team was writing this 'thing' from scratch, where thing is something numerous rock solid, fast, open source alternatives exist. Didn't seem like a good use of resources -at all- considering the sorry state of their web experience.
Lowes' website is a trainwreck, just Inspect Page it... for starters there's "todo" comments.
Home depot's experience is fantastic.
But if you wanna see the reigning champ of "online thing," www.mcmaster.com
It lets you put things in your cart that sell out. Putting things in your cart means nothing at all, apparently.
Not sure if the last line was meant in jest, but I -really- dig that site. All info and pics, clear pricing. Perfect.
It's also been this way for years. They were ahead of the game even back then.
Whatever degree of effect that building shipping costs into pricing has given them is negligible in comparison. And it is dead simple for even small retailers to do this with most e-Commerce tools including Shopify.
Ie, it's fine that a retailer charges $15 + free shipping, instead of $10 + $5 shipping. It's not fine to them force the price on all other retailers to sell at a minimum of $15. Especially not since they probably have to charge shipping.
The argument that this violates anti trust is because it raises the prices for everyone, not just the people who are fine with hasslefree free shipping
No. That just wastes your time, not the seller's. And some of these people will just buy the product anyway.
In the short run amazon makes more money (commission on the sale) but in the long run this hurts Amazon's brand.
I manage an amazon business account where this is a particularly bad issue because buyers are not spending their own money. They will literally spend $500 on something that is $50, because they like Amazon's reliability around delivery, the purchasing is very smooth, returns are smooth etc. I feel like they cracked down on this maybe 4-5 years ago? But still stuff slips through.
So yes, I very much like that they don't allow sellers to mark up crazily on Amazon's site.
I tried to avoid Amazon a couple times, to give other stores a change and all. Wasn't that great, and it was more expensive.
Bought something on Best Buy, thought about returning it. On the product page and invoice, didn't say the date I could return. It only said the return periods where on a FAQ. FAQ didn't have a specific category for that product. I thought it was something (with 30 day), but when tried to return it, got a 'no' because it was 14 days. Why not add how many days in the product page? Why not show me the exact date on my order details?
Also tried the same with books, buying on Indigo. Bought an extra book to get free shipping. The price of the books where already a dollar or 2 higher than Amazon. 10 days delivery, and one of the books has some marks like someone put a paper over the book and scribbled on it. Never had a problem with Amazon, and it's cheaper and delivery is like 2 days.
As far as using AMZ logistics, that makes complete sense. I've come to expect a high standard from items I buy from them regarding when I'll get the item. If that starts varying wildly...well what's the point of Prime? Fast delivery is AMZ's entire schtick.
The price fixing I can't defend or make an argument about.
It's logical that they add the cost of shipping to the item price, but their cost must be much lower than alternative sellers, as it is hardly noticeable on low-cost items, and comparable to prices charged by Walmart, etc. who charge extra for shipping.
This depends a lot on where you are (or at least, it did). I canceled Prime a couple of years ago, because among other things, I hardly ever got things on time, whether it was next day or two day.
I don't really use Amazon much anymore. I go out of my way to find other retailers whenever I can.
I always try to look elsewhere .
> Versus some indy site
This is a false dichotomy. Nothing prevents showing both the item price and the shipping-included price next to each item.
Nothing prevents the sites from doing that, but most sites don't do give you an option to see total price on the product page.
The same item, if you look at it logged out, will show 15$ + 8$ shipping, but when logged in will show 23$ free shipping with a nice big Prime logo next to it. That's the issue at play, not what some other sites do. This is plain misleading and deceptive.
Editing to add: I didn't intend this to say your comment isn't true. Perhaps I'm looking at something else or understanding wrong, so asking in earnest.
Thinking about it more, maybe it was duty fees (since I'm in Canada and some items from from the US). That would make more sense as those would scale with the items maybe? I specifically recall though seeing X + Y$ on non-Prime and then Z$ on Prime.
Also, as you mention, if some items are sent from the US, they might not be sold by Amazon, so they'll show you the cheapest option, but as it becomes available or not in different sellers, the price will differ.
You can try to open a product at the same time on a logged/not logged account and see if there's a difference. But you need to do that at the same time.
Further, even if it's a hair more expensive, I'll still pay it for the no hassle returns. I recently purchased a knife I saw on Amazon, but decided to go through the seller's official site to save a couple dollars. It was not worth it, and not something I'll do again.