News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by NoGravitas on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:13AM (#27315552)
Looks like the dominant explanation is that some adversary is using (relatively) cheap drones to get data on the sensitivity of US Naval radar systems: https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/40054/adversary-drones...

They don't even have to be all that high-tech; the US was doing similar things in the 1960s.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by flohofwoe on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:47AM (#27315965)
This Warzone story is also interesting, because it contains actual logs and emails released under FOIA. Those are much less sensationalist than the OP story:

https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/39913/multiple-destroy...

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by koheripbal on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:30AM (#27316567)
One of the counterintuitive drawbacks of advancing technology is that it will become harder and harder to demonstrate that an ET UFO is actually ET and not some advanced classified gov't object.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by taneq on Saturday June 05, 2021 @10:22PM (#27410183)
Will it, though? I'd have thought advancing technology would advance both sides (creating odd new flying objects, and identifying the same)? These days everyone's carrying a high rez high frame rate camera in their pocket, back in the 50s we relied on eyewitness accounts.

Edit: Whoops, sorry for the necro. I have to watch out better for old tabs...

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by antonvs on Saturday May 29, 2021 @11:02PM (#27330257)
That's not a real drawback, except in the minds of people who are projecting their ET fantasies onto the real world.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by thu2111 on Saturday May 29, 2021 @07:55AM (#27324670)
Is that less sensationalist? It seems they're reporting exactly the same things just using different types of recorded data. Neither article attempts to speculate on what kind of object might be capable of causing such data, nor who might control it.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by tristanj on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:37AM (#27315835)
That article completely ignores the eyewitness testimony from the navy pilots of the Tic Tac incident where they visually identify that the Tic Tac:

1) can hover a few meters above the ocean without generating rotor downwash

2) can accelerate away at 100+g

Both of those rule out any known drone or helicopter. David Fravor, one of the pilots, explains this in an interview here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aB8zcAttP1E

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by bob33212 on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:46AM (#27315948)
So there are really two options here. Either the instruments used to detect #1 and #2 are reporting inaccurate data, OR technology far beyond what the public knows about exists and has only been seen under circumstances where no one had a high resolution camera to get a detailed picture. #2 seems unlikely because the availably of high resolution cameras has gone up a ton in the past 10 years ( cell phones / satelites ), but a clear picture of a UFO has not shown up.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by oblio on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:49AM (#27315992)
That's the main thing I found funny.

Back in the day of only a handful of newspapers and of 1 camera per 1 million people (at least on the average day, the average person wouldn't lug their camera around with them), we had sightings of Yeti, Bigfoot, Nessie, El Chupacabra, etc.

Now we have the internet, an unstoppable torrent of crappy news and the mother of all tabloids, everyone has a high resolution camera in their pockets at all times, and cryptoids are all but gone.

I would have expected 16k HDR resolution photos of Yeti by now.

I feel betrayed! :-p

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by wincy on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:00AM (#27316173)
Hey it did turn out the giant squids were totally real though! So that’s pretty neat. When I was born less than 40 years ago it wasn’t known if they were an actual species.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by snowwrestler on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:10AM (#27316315)
I think you might be confused; giant squid were known to be a real species as far back as the 1800s based on specimens that washed ashore. But it was only within the last couple decades that they were imaged alive in their natural environment.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by oblio on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:08AM (#27316286)
> Hey it did turn out the giant squids were totally real though!

So I guess the correlation is: cryptids can't coexist with smartphones. Makes sense. I get a feeling that cryptids aren't the social media type.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by __abc on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:57AM (#27316112)
my kids ask me if I believe and I tell them I used to. However, given the HDR phone in everyones pocket for a decade+ and no photos of a ghost, alien, saucer, cryptid ????? I am now a non believer.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by pavel_lishin on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:07AM (#27316278)
Cryptoids down, police violence up!
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by dr_dshiv on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:10AM (#27316305)
Like they explain in "close encounters of the third kind", no one has a high definition photograph of a car accident as it happens either (of course, now that we have dash cams..)
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by hollerith on Friday May 28, 2021 @02:11PM (#27318669)
That might have been true when "Close Encounters" was made, but there are 100s of videos of car accidents on Youtube.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by jandrese on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:53AM (#27316041)
https://xkcd.com/1235/

To be fair, a warship at sea probably doesn't allow their sailors to carry their phone around for opsec reasons.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by joshuahedlund on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:58AM (#27316131)
> To be fair, a warship at sea probably doesn't allow their sailors to carry their phone around for opsec reasons.

Thus why it's the only remaining gap in the "ufo of the gaps" theory!

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by jameshart on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:39AM (#27316706)
Pilots and crew on aircraft certainly carry cameras - part of standard procedure on intercepting an aircraft includes photography for intelligence collection purposes.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by notyourday on Friday May 28, 2021 @12:17PM (#27317241)
> To be fair, a warship at sea probably doesn't allow their sailors to carry their phone around for opsec reasons.

I recall reading a few weeks ago that not only the sailors have consumer grade equipment but that there are procedures in cases like this for sailors to use that equipment so there is more footage to analyze later

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by natch on Saturday May 29, 2021 @01:31PM (#27326804)
And the warship itself in 2020 doesn't have any onboard cameras… ?

We are asked to believe the military is intelligent, but if that's the case then I have my doubts.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by bitbuilder on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:15AM (#27316382)
While I don't disagree with your point, whenever this point comes up I do feel the need to point out that getting a clear, high resolution photo of a (relatively) small moving object in the sky is actually a really hard problem for photography, especially at night.

If you've ever tried taking a photo of a particularly pretty moon with your phone, you'll know what I'm talking about. The striking orange harvest moon that seems to dominate the night sky suddenly becomes a little smear of light when you look at the photo on your phone.

Most phones or other cameras that people casually carry around have a relatively wide angle lens and accompanying FOV. That means anything at a distance will end up looking even further in the distance (ie, smaller) once you take the shot.

So to get a nice, clear picture of a distant object in the sky you're going to need a telephoto lens. That's fine, and there are plenty of people out there casually carrying around a telephoto. Except now you have a new problem: you need to track the moving object through your telephoto. Not impossible, of course, but not easy for typical person who happens to see a strange object in the sky while they have their camera with them.

Also, if the object is moving, you'll need a fast shutter speed. And if you increase your shutter speed you're going to have to increase your ISO as well. If you're seeing this strange object at night, that means you're likely pushing your ISO into a range where your photo starts to get pretty grainy.

All of these aren't insurmountable problems, people that shoot flying birds and planes do it all the time. But it takes a combination of equipment and photography skills that aren't exactly common. So now we're looking at a venn diagram of "people who see something strange in the sky" and "people who have the equipment and skills to get a good photo" to calculate our odds of having a really great photo of a UFO by now.

All that said, the point is still valid ("why don't we have more photos now?"). But at the same time, it's not as easy of a problem as many seem to think.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by behnamoh on Friday May 28, 2021 @04:50PM (#27320315)
Thanks for mentioning these points. Another explanation could be that _if_ these UFO's are in fact extraterrestrials with a technology advanced enough to travel to our planet, then it's plausible to assume that they also adapt their techniques based on our technological capabilities. In other words, if they are real and they know we have more advanced cameras compared to 100 years ago, chances are they are not going to reveal themselves to us as much as before, or they do that in situations where environment noise does not provide a high-res picture of them (like in the sea).
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by natch on Saturday May 29, 2021 @01:38PM (#27326858)
[Edit: I realize you may have been talking about 2020. Or maybe just talking about photography in general. Since both incidents are being talked about in the larger thread, and the idea of photography applies to both of them I wrote something riffing off photography that addresses the previous (2014, tic tac) incident… hope that doesn't bug you too much ;-)].

So, my comment here is about 2014 and the tic tac incident, not the swarm-of-drones incident from last year.

If they really did have reports for the two days leading up to the tic tac incident I have to think they would have tasked an aircraft with top notch (beyond any handheld camera) photographic capabilities to investigating such an alarming intrusion.

Or, they are really stupid.

Or, the radar hits in the preceding two days were just phantom hits and possibly assessed as such at the time, with jets sent up to look just as a "why not" kind of thing since they were already in the area for training.

My bet is with the last possibility, because I find it hard to think so badly of the Navy people. And the hits were just phantom / ghost hits in a new system. Which means: not alien / Russian / etc. craft.

And the actual object actually seen by the pilots was some chunks of ice falling from outer space, some of which made whitecaps and another of which was seen flitting erratically and thus moving in ways that no known aircraft is capable of. It "came up to meet" Dave Fraver AS HE WAS GOING DOWN yeah no surprise there, and, as the sonic boom from his jet slammed into the snowy ice, it, again no surprise, disintegrated and disappeared, because sonic boom, which disintegration he interpreted as out-of-this-world acceleration. OK, maybe the other Navy people are with it, but Dave may have been experiencing some effects of the G forces or something. He seems like a nice guy.

The other pilot who spoke about this described the movement of the object in a way that exactly matches what I said, a falling slab of snowy ice. Her words: "Like when you drop your cell phone in the kitchen and it bounces around."

Again this entire comment is talking about the tic tac incident, from 2014, not the summer of 2020 incident.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by nradov on Saturday May 29, 2021 @05:02PM (#27328208)
Samsung phones now have a specialized camera mode for taking pictures of the moon.

https://www.gsmarena.com/myth_debunked_samsungs_100x_zoom_do...

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by notriskfree on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:51AM (#27316024)
I always think that as well. Except, there is a large air show that takes place up the road from me; and I get a ticket some years. The aircraft are literally displaying themselves. Getting a decent picture of them whizzing past is far from easy.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by pavelrub on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:59AM (#27316159)
The “instruments” are direct visual sighting by several pilots.

It’s unclear how you’ve reached the conclusion that #2 is unlikely without knowing how widespread the use of this technology is, and in what circumstances/locations it’s being used.

Classified military technology exists and is being tested all the time, without any high-res pictures leaking.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by bob33212 on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:23AM (#27316479)
If the average persons ability to capture a photo of bigfoot or a ghost or a UFO goes up 100x I would expect the number of photos during these sightings to go up some amount. Why would bigfoot go extinct at the exact time that everyone has cameras?

I guess another theory is that aliens are pranking these people. "Hey Blart, lets go to Earth and let one guy without a camera see part of our spaceship from a distance. Everyone will think he is crazy. HAHAHA"

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by bgentry on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:04AM (#27316226)
Have you tried taking a cell phone photo of a moving object far in the distance and with less than ideal lighting? You won’t get a good result if you can even capture it.

Photographing something like this would probably require a DSLR type camera with a great zoom/telephoto lens. I would expect they have that equipment on military ships, but I don’t think the ubiquity of cell phone cameras has significantly changed the ability to photograph this kind of phenomenon.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by topkai22 on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:08AM (#27316289)
So I saw a UFO a few years back (2017)- it was a circular object that stayed largely stationary. My in laws saw it to, so I wasn’t imagining it. Obviously I took a picture, but it was so small and far away that the photo is just a white dot in the distance.

Now I figure it was just a rogue cloud, weather balloon or weird atmospheric effect, but there are still phenomena that are hard to capture on camera.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by BTCOG on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:57AM (#27316111)
While I do agree with you and find it odd that no high quality photos ever surface and things are typically just hearsay, I also understand that even these newer iPhones and Android cameras take pretty crappy night photos and especially if you were trying to snap a picture quickly of a moving object in very low lighting.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by crispyambulance on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:08AM (#27316284)
I don't get what the motivation is for these news stories and the upcoming "report" that everyone is talking about.

So far, all we got is grainy video and verbal accounts from military pilots using jargon-laden language that sounds authoritative released to the general public.

The thing is, these pilots have instruments, jobs, and mindsets that are intended to handle known things. They are neither impartial nor critical observers. The key thing is we don't know yet what they saw, nor do they. We don't even know if these are "objects" or sensor/sensory "artifacts".

Occam's Razor is intended to apply in EXACTLY situations like this.

The good news is that if these phenomena are as common as people say, it should be possible to devise procedures, measurements, and analysis to start to rule out what these are not.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by stevenhuang on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:46AM (#27316821)
Occam's razor breaks down precisely in the long tail.

> The thing is, these pilots have instruments, jobs, and mindsets that are intended to handle known things. They are neither impartial nor critical observers. The key thing is we don't know yet what they saw, nor do they. We don't even know if these are "objects" or sensor/sensory "artifacts".

There's a lot to unpack here.

Yes, they are intended to handle known things. Drones, weather balloons, cloud formations, jet plumes. These are all known, and our observations do not match them.

Impartial nor critical? I would suggest you watch the interviews with the pilots from the USS Nimitz incident. It's mentioned a major reason we don't hear a lot of these accounts is because of the stigma of reporting UFOs, which is why his copilots have been silent on the matter until now.

Lastly they are real objects. Multiple eye witness accounts with multiple radar signatures, from carriers and jets.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by crispyambulance on Friday May 28, 2021 @02:48PM (#27319101)
> ...suggest you watch the interviews with the pilots from the USS Nimitz incident.

I did and I am not convinced their observations reveal much about these phenomena. Military pilots are very capable people with good eyes, but they're trained and focused strictly on their very demanding job. They are not in the air to conduct general-purpose scientific observations, nor do they necessarily have the tools at their disposal to truly evaluate what they're seeing.

> Drones, weather balloons, cloud formations, jet plumes. These are all known, and our observations do not match them.

Do not match any? Or some? or one? There's multiple videos out there, very different from each other and each could have a different explanation.

It really does come down to Occam's Razor.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by stevenhuang on Friday May 28, 2021 @07:41PM (#27321793)
> There's multiple videos out there, very different from each other and each could have a different explanation.

In isolation yes, the videos are not remarkable. But it's not in isolation, as you seem to be discounting the context they're taken and ignoring the relevance of the eye witness accounts and their flight behaviour on radar (descending from space, disappearing and reappearing a hundred miles away, etc).

Unless you think they're all in on something or lying, which is fair enough, but from how the situation is unfolding with demands from congress, experiences of all the service members, and civilian pilots, I'm partial there is something of a phenomena here.

> It really does come down to Occam's Razor

Heuristics apply in the general case but definitionally may not when there is enough evidence the event is an outlier.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by behnamoh on Friday May 28, 2021 @04:53PM (#27320365)
Every time a person refuses comments made by another person in bullet points, I find it hard to believe they are in fact looking for the truth and are not biased.

The person who commented on your comment clearly provided information about what you said, but you're just disagreeing with him.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by crispyambulance on Friday May 28, 2021 @07:03PM (#27321533)
What “bullet points” ? In any case, I am addressing all his assertions respectfully.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by krapp on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:12AM (#27316338)
The motivation is that this is a viral story, so it's guaranteed to get views.

Bear in mind, every new story doesn't indicate a new sighting - these stories are mostly retreads of the same few incidents and a vague pins-and-twine narrative connecting other stories like the Pais patents to get some extra mileage out of it.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by crispyambulance on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:20AM (#27316436)
Yeah, there's been a lot of re-hashing and people are conflating the several different videos together along with the verbal descriptions by pilots and piecing together entirely made-up narratives.

In particular, the Alizondo character keeps popping up as some kind of head of a government research project. He's been trotting this stuff around for years, but according to a 2019 story in The Intercept, the dude's employment story doesn't check out: https://theintercept.com/2019/06/01/ufo-unidentified-history...

I suppose the news outlets are hungry for clicks now that Stable Genius isn't around to send them a zinger everyday.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by anamexis on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:48AM (#27315986)
Or the US military is fabricating this.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by frankfrankfrank on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:02AM (#27316197)
I find it far more likely that the different interpretations of UFO lead to divergent and self-reenforcing stories. What I mean by that is that UFO means unidentified flying object, which all flying objects, or even just those for which there is only a single report are classified as exactly that unidentified … opposed to identified … flying … objects.

On the flip side, the public that has both a less formal and generally lower understanding of this and other things, also led on by various forms of popular culture, have a wholly fantastical minds image when they hear "UFO".

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by GVIrish on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:22AM (#27316467)
Seems unlikely that they're participating in a large scale fabrication like this but it's possible. I think it's more likely that there is some black project that uses novel propulsion systems and they're covertly testing it against our own military to evaluate how effective it could be. Or it could be another nation that made a break through in propulsion. And of course, the extraterrestrial possibility.

One thing that will be interesting is to see if any other nations have had encounters like this and can supply video and sensor data evidence.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by dragonwriter on Friday May 28, 2021 @12:11PM (#27317169)
> Seems unlikely that they're participating in a large scale fabrication like this but it's possible

There is no major military that hasn't participated in large scale fabrications as a concealment technique for their own operations or technological developments. The US military certainly has on multiple occasions.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by meowface on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:54AM (#27316063)
Yes, this can't be dismissed. (It's also plausible the military could be intentionally deceiving some of its own personnel, for some purpose. So a military pilot recounting a story may not necessarily be lying.)

Obviously such a claim would need evidence and a plausible motive and shouldn't be suspected without evidence; but, also obviously, it's one of many hypotheses that would have a much higher probability of being true than extraterrestrially-originated visitation.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by gambiting on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:54AM (#27316054)
Not saying they aren't, but what possible reason could they have for doing so?
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by srswtf123 on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:00AM (#27316174)
Additional funding to fight this “new threat”?
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by krapp on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:06AM (#27316264)
Assuming the American military industrial complex doesn't already have a blank check and actually needs to justify spending anything to anyone, why would they concoct a threat as implausible as "aliens" when something more mundane, like "foreign drones" would be more likely to work?
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by tmn on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:51AM (#27316010)
The most reasonable explanation is psyop. This follows Occam’s razor
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by runarberg on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:02AM (#27316203)
There is also the possibility that there was some rotor downwash but conditions were such that it was hard to see for the witnesses. Or even that it was clearly visible but none of the sailors paid attention to it. Then somebody mentioned not seeing it and a group mentality kicked in where everyone now agreed clearly not seeing it.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by natch on Saturday May 29, 2021 @01:28PM (#27326769)
Or #3 a hunk of ice was falling from outer space and Dave, a self described class clown who happens to be best buddies with one of the people who works on the FLIR system and who went to his wedding, has polished up some of the details to better match what he thinks.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by dspillett on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:07AM (#27316268)
> but a clear picture of a UFO has not shown up.

Obviously the aliens have some anti surveillance tech that renders our cameras less useful!

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by vbezhenar on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:49AM (#27315993)
There are plenty of clear pictures of UFOs circulating in the Internet, but you won't believe it.

Also if there are aliens monitoring humans, obviously they'll adjust their operations as our devices change.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by tom_mellior on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:58AM (#27316129)
Statements of the form "there is X on the Internet" are typically more convincing when accompanied by links.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by gabereiser on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:59AM (#27316161)
>Also if there are aliens monitoring humans, obviously they'll adjust their operations as our devices change.

I doubt highly intelligent beings from another world would give a damn what our devices were capable of.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by BTCOG on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:04AM (#27316230)
Furthermore, how would they have a clue what our devices are, or are capable of if they are not already here at the ground level?
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by pierrebai on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:58AM (#27316136)
100g is an acceleration of 1000m/s/s, so after 1s the thing would be 1km away. Yet this was infer by eye. These fantastic values are made up on the spot and not instrument-based measurements.

Also, these stories always assume radar have no failure mode, no false indications, no possibilities of fooling. IOW, enthusiasts ignores and never consider failures but adopt never seen, never encounters aliens with impossible tech that always happens in isolated area with no other capabilities to monitor.

And all that does not even start to account for the impossibly large inter-stellar distances.

I'll take weird failure over hugely fantastical theories.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by mordymoop on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:05AM (#27316249)
Along these lines, I wish people would be extremely specific about what their eyes actually saw versus what they inferred. As you say, what Fraver saw seems to have been a reflective object that seemed to be close to the water’s surface, which vanished, and then later possibly another reflective object some distance away. If I wanted to do a magic trick along these lines, I would have two silver balloons a distance apart, pop one and then draw attention to the other. This would make it seem like the first had flown impossibly fast. I’m not saying this is what happened, but this sort of thing has to be considered when the only other explanation being offered is completely outlandish.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by jk7tarYZAQNpTQa on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:56AM (#27316958)
> 100g is an acceleration of 1000m/s/s, so after 1s the thing would be 1km away. Yet this was infer by eye. These fantastic values are made up on the spot and not instrument-based measurements.

These values are deducted by an estimation of the space traveled and an estimation of the time it took. And these estimations are consistent with the ones that come from the radar operators.

Also keep in mind that 100 G is a very conservative middle value. They said "hey, what if our estimations are really, really off", and provided a lower and upper boundaries for the g-forces, that are 40 G and 521,770 G, respectively.

> I'll take weird failure over hugely fantastical theories.

I'll take decades of constant and consistent reports over "skeptical" conclusions deducted from wrong a priori probabilities.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by bzbarsky on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:06AM (#27316256)
At 1km/s^2 after one second you would be 0.5 km away. (Average speed over that second is half the final speed, or just memorize s = 0.5at^2, whichever is preferred.)
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by lallysingh on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:46AM (#27315954)
We don't know their weight, so we don't know how much downforce they have to generate. The water's not exactly still, either.

Also, if they were radar-spy drones, they don't have to go home -- they've likely transmitted everything they need (overhead satellite or a nearby sub?). They're going away far enough to sink to the bottom of the ocean with little chance of recovery/identification.

So, I can imagine drone that carries some basic RF sensors, a basic quadcopter (or equiv) propulsion system, then a one-time-use escape system. Perhaps a short-range turbine or simple chemical rocket.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by jk7tarYZAQNpTQa on Friday May 28, 2021 @12:19PM (#27317284)
> We don't know their weight, so we don't know how much downforce they have to generate

But we can make an educated guess.

> Also, if they were radar-spy drones, they don't have to go home -- they've likely transmitted everything they need (overhead satellite or a nearby sub?). They're going away far enough to sink to the bottom of the ocean with little chance of recovery/identification.

IIRC submarines have looked for them, following that theory. Nothing was found.

> So, I can imagine drone that carries some basic RF sensors, a basic quadcopter (or equiv) propulsion system, then a one-time-use escape system. Perhaps a short-range turbine or simple chemical rocket.

The drone theory makes a lot of sense when you ignore the fact that they are flying for over 10 hours non stop, and going faster than 160kt. Oh, and that they are also moving really fast once they are submerged.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by lallysingh on Friday May 28, 2021 @04:59PM (#27320434)
Do you have a link to the analysis?
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by inter_netuser on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:48AM (#27315983)
1) rotor downwash may not be visible enough from an F16 cockpit a mile away, if the drone is small enough.

2) 100g is likely within our capability today.

Old, 400g tech: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sprint_(missile)#Engines_and_p...

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by newsclues on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:41AM (#27315876)
The us navy pilots were using imaging sensors to track those UFOs, so it’s possible that what they saw on their displays wasn’t UFOs.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by tristanj on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:42AM (#27315900)
No, the pilots saw the tictac with their own eyes. I recommend you watch the interview.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by newsclues on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:58AM (#27316127)
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by jameshart on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:44AM (#27316778)
I found this Tyler Rogoway article quite compelling: https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/28640/could-some-of-th...

The fact is that when pilots say 'there's no way a balloon could do that' or 'that doesn't look like any drone I ever saw'... pilots aren't necessarily best placed to assess the realistic flight possibilities or appearances for a drone or a balloon, because they're imaginign balloons and drones they've seen before, and aren't considering the range of possibilities for what could be created.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by libertine on Friday May 28, 2021 @12:41PM (#27317573)
>pilots aren't necessarily best placed to assess the realistic flight possibilities or appearances for a drone or a balloon

Who are best placed to identify things flying around if not pilots with hundreds (or thousands) of hours flying?

That's why they say they've never seen anything like it, and they don't know any tech that could do what those 4 pilots observed.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by jameshart on Friday May 28, 2021 @01:16PM (#27318044)
When you see a magician do a card trick, and a professional poker player says ‘I’ve never seen a deck of cards do that before’, does her thousands of hours of poker playing bear on whether or not the magician is actually a wizard?
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by libertine on Friday May 28, 2021 @01:37PM (#27318289)
I don't get that analogy, poker players aren't trained to use cards, or to do movements with their hands. Hell, a friend of mine is semi-pro poker player and sucks at shuffling.

And you'll say: you're just nitpicking the idea is that pros aren't pros at everything.

I'm not, I'll even fix that analogy for you: a croupier gets impressed by card trick.

Now the problem is, pilots are trained observers, and they get to see a lot of things from their jets. Cars, trucks, houses, rivers, trees, ships, helicopters, drones, different types of planes - not only because they do recon, they also have to target some of those things, and they train a lot for it. Distances, sizes, cost of maneuvers, etc.

With that said: what other type of people are best trained to take a guess at what things are from up above? Drone operators? Balloon operators? Weather balloon folks? Aerospace engineers?

Can they be fooled still? Probably - but if you can fool 4 pilots at the same time, their tens of million of dollars jets with sensors, and the most advanced radar systems, all at the same time, then you're not a magician - you simply have tech way superior to what those guys have.

That's the thing, it doesn't even need to be an actual craft. If it's something that can create optical illusions on jet pilots and jam radars, how are they supposed to do anything if their senses and systems fail?

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by eitland on Friday May 28, 2021 @06:52PM (#27321455)
Never underestimate magicians.

I think that if I wanted to solve this at all costs, one of tve things I'd do (in addition to working with radar engineers and scientists of course) is to hire a number of magicians to get them to try to recreate the experience of the pilots.

Because those pilots are good and highly skilled, but so are Penn and Teller and they still get fooled from time to time so it is not impossible.

I.e. I disagree with everyone: those that underestimate pilots and say we don't have good photos and also those who think pilots are infallible.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by libertine on Saturday May 29, 2021 @06:40AM (#27324328)
I don't think you're quite understanding the endeavor at hand (which is my point): let's say they could replicate it, and now they have to deploy it in a live scenario.

So now they have to go off to the coast of the USA in a restricted area used for navy drills and testing, probably coming from the Pacific side. Let's say Penn and Teller get access to a brand new submarine from China that's has stealthy as they can be, enough to set up the experiment.

Then they had to stay there for days teasing both the ships radars and navy pilots by make things pop up on their radars and make them move large distances in short periods of time (seconds), and get them to chase radar blips.

Now comes the day that a squadron of jets are asked to check something nearby their location (which mean they have to tap into Navy communications systems), launch the illusion, make it react to the pilots unexpected behavior (one dove the other remained above), and then make it desapear (and then proceed to jam radars, to eventually exit out).

(This is roughly the story of the Fravor incident.)

I think just the first point, of entering USA waters, more specifically restricted waters and air space actively controlled by the Navy - which was doing drills - already shows technology superiority.

Which was my point.

They have to know what the radars and sensors are and how they work (hackers, compromised top level people), how to jam them (superior tech), how to be stealthy (superior tech), how to create illusions for jet pilots while fooling jet sensors (superior tech).

I'm not saying these are aliens, but surely looks like tech superiority or the whole defense system collapsing all together even the pilots.

If this was done by a couple of guys, with too much free time on a shoe string budget, that can fool the most advanced navy, well that's not good either.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by dplavery92 on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:56AM (#27316093)
The David Fravor interview linked describes an event in 2004 seen by fighters from the USS Nimitz and captured by the USS Princeton. This is a separate event, and perhaps with very different vehicles or phenomena, than the 2019 event near the USS Omaha that is described above.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by natch on Saturday May 29, 2021 @01:24PM (#27326742)
What they describe from their vantage point of many thousands of feet up is not hovering, it's more like flitting back and forth with no discernible trajectory.

Like a large flake of ice falling.

The other pilot said the motion was like if you dropped your cell phone in the kitchen and it was bouncing around before settling down.

Exactly like a falling massive but flat flake of snowy ice that fell off of an object that had entered the atmosphere from outer space and fallen to the water, where the early chunks remained causing whitecaps.

Not hovering. Erratic motion.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by DennisP on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:42AM (#27315902)
If reports like that accurate and it's a human adversary, we might as well shut down our military, it won't do any good anyway.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by captainredbeard on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:52AM (#27316032)
Wrong - the enemy might not have enough of them and we haven’t tried shooting them yet AFAICT.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by pc86 on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:07AM (#27316273)
Even a Navy pilot has no actual basis or experience on which they can justify a claim to "visually identify" a 100+g acceleration. The downwash, sure (though it's just as likely they simply didn't see it, it was obscured, or had the craft been a few inches lower you'd see it).
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by libertine on Friday May 28, 2021 @12:50PM (#27317697)
Except they are probably the best people to at least take a guess of the distances covered in air and the amount of G's such maneuvers would be subject to, since they're the ones flying around at high speeds, covering great distances and dealing with high G's.

Plus, isn't that part of what the whole dog-fighting thing?

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by mckeed on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:00AM (#27316168)
Does anyone know if it's possible for these objects to be suspended by wires from a less-radar-visible drone higher up?
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by kijin on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:34AM (#27316606)
Suspended objects will behave like a pendulum as they change their speed and/or direction. I suspect they're going to look very different from the trajectory of a self-propelled object.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by giantandroids on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:34AM (#27315792)
The radio operator reported one moving at 138 knots which is approx 160mph. The DRL RacerX has recorded speeds over 163.5 mp getting a guiness world record, although this was indoors.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by leoedin on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:41AM (#27315882)
That's an indoor speed record for a quadcopter. If you're designing a drone system for maritime operation it would make far more sense to be fixed wing (maybe with some sort of VTOL or STOL capability) - the efficiencies are just so much higher.

Once you go to fixed wing, 138 knots is pretty simple. Just look at the list of unmanned aerial vehicles - it's big and dominated by fixed wing aircraft. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_unmanned_aerial_vehicl...

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by dokem on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:48AM (#27315978)
The military has been using drones since before quad copters. Anything long range is not going to be a quad, but something like a small plane. I'd imagine 'drone' in military lingo still mostly refers to fixed wing craft.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by meowface on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:11AM (#27316327)
It seems pretty crazy that the Pentagon would be completely befuddled and would have absolutely no clue that these are just foreign drones, though, no? That's what the article seems to be arguing.

To me it would seem much more likely that the top brass know or strongly suspect they're indeed drones invading our airspace but are acting like they're unexplained phenomena as part of some sort of psyop/deception/intelligence/adversary-signaling stratagem. I'm not sure what the motive would be, there, but that sounds more plausible than random speculators online having more inference ability than the entire US military. Even if you assume the height of institutional incompetence, surely someone among the most powerful military in history would propose such a theory.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by JustSomeNobody on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:55AM (#27316084)
Why can't it be OUR military testing classified tech against OUR very best systems? If our best can't tell what it is, nobody can.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by dplavery92 on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:57AM (#27316117)
It seems unlikely in that situation that the Pentagon would declassify any of the instrument videos. Then again, it's weird that they've done that in any scenario.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by JustSomeNobody on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:04AM (#27316229)
True, but maybe they feel the need to posture?
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by flowerlad on Friday May 28, 2021 @11:36AM (#27316644)
But the objects are able to fly 11,000 miles-per-hour, able to turn instantly, with no wings, no propulsion and no exhaust, disappear instantly and go into the ocean.

What kind of "cheap drone" can do that?

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by runawaybottle on Friday May 28, 2021 @12:58PM (#27317798)
Or the drones are a simple way of messing up all targeting systems. If you ever made a Carrier fleet in Starcraft 1 (where massing units was a thing), the swarm of carrier drones would force the enemy units to target those little thing instead of the main units.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by runawaybottle on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:38AM (#27315837)
Where is the drone ship? Does a submarine emerge and launch these things in the middle of the ocean?

Edit:

Listen, the US Defense department knows what these are. They are just soft letting China and Russia know that this was cute.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by meowface on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:44AM (#27315929)
There've been multiple reports of pilots reporting that they saw some sort of movement and frothing beneath the surface of the ocean - as if there were some sort of vehicle there, they specified. They then reported seeing whatever was under the water seemingly suddenly shoot up at high velocity.

I wonder if those reports could potentially be consistent with a submersible craft launching drones. Maybe such a craft could even be... "catapulting"?... or otherwise giving the drones an initial boost, too, combined with self-propulsion, which could perhaps make them fly from the surface faster than they could with self-propulsion alone.

(Obviously this is all pure uninformed speculation on my part and could be total nonsense. And one would think one of these hypothetical submersible crafts would've likely been detected at least once, given the US Navy was operating in the vicinity on multiple occasions.)

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by javajosh on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:59AM (#27316160)
I would be surprised if every player wasn't fielding unmanned submarines, themselves fitted with drone tech, powered by a plutonium battery that can loiter for months, surface, release the drones, and phone home with via satellite. Doing recon with them against an enemy is the surprising thing. This could just as well be a screw up between different branches of the US military[1] as it is a peekaboo between rivals.

[1]The Navy can't seem to avoid collisions at sea! And sea-faring navigation tech is hundreds of years old.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by captainredbeard on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:54AM (#27316053)
Finding stuff in the sea isn’t very easy. You need to be surprisingly close.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by meowface on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:58AM (#27316144)
Is this also true with sonar and whatever other SIGINT capabilities the modern Navy would have? I could certainly buy it going undetected - in Commander Fravor's case, the tic tac incident occurred a pretty far distance away from their training area, I believe.

But I would also think the Navy would the best available technology and techniques to detect what would probably have to be a foreign submersible in their waters, and that if this were routinely happening they'd likely end up detecting it eventually through some means. Or if it were one of their own skunkworks crafts, they'd probably figure that out afterwards. (I know very little about this field, though.)

Or even if they did fail to ever detect it beyond a few eye witness reports from pilots, I'd think this would be at/near the top of their list of plausible theories.

If this is indeed an explanation for some of the incidents, I could believe that they have in fact identified it and are doing some kind of psyop/deception operation, perhaps to confuse or signal to a foreign power.

Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by pomian on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:58AM (#27316123)
Captain Nemo had this technology over 100 years ago, with similar reports by observers. Thanks to Mr. Wells.
Re:Radar data confirms: USS Omaha was surrounded by swarm of... by newsclues on Friday May 28, 2021 @10:42AM (#27315891)
Cargo, fishing ships or submarines.