News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by stolen_biscuit on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @08:41PM (#27284708)
There's a lot of people in the comments saying that Vietnam didn't really "win" the war. Their political and military objectives were ultimately successful, those of the US/South Vietnam were not. That's what a victory is. The cost of victory was very high, but it was a pretty unambiguous success for the Vietnamese.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by ska on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @08:44PM (#27284737)
It's impressive how deep some of these psychological things run nearly 50 years on. It was such a blow to self-image that, let alone all the related domestic political fallout, people still have a hard time accepting what happened.

The sheer amount of ink and celluloid spent trying to come to terms with this is awesome, and a little depressing.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by nine_k on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:26PM (#27285037)
How many wars did the US win (as in "achieved the political goals") since WWII?

Korean war: half won, half lost.

Vietnam war: lost.

Grenada invasion: sort of won.

Gulf war 1991: I'd say won, despite Saddam staying in power.

Gulf war II: I'd say lost, despite Saddam deposition.

Afghanistan: lost, despite the killing of bin Laden.

Syria: can't tell yet.

It's a pretty depressing tally.

With that, I'd say that the US was on the winning side of a number of wars before that: WWII, WWI, Mexican war, Spanish war.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by hooande on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:58PM (#27285276)
The goal of the US in Afghanistan was to deny Al-Qaeda the use of one third of a country to plan their operations. That required taking control of that territory from the Taliban, who were allowing Al-Qaeda to operate without restriction. The US did that. They harassed the Taliban and denied them complete control of territory for 20 years. Not sure how this could be viewed as a strategic defeat in any way
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by kumarvvr on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:10PM (#27285348)
What happened to all the "we don't negotiate with terrorists" thing then?

At the end of 20 years, US indirectly had to negotiate with them.

So the other way of looking at it is, a bunch of un-educated, poorly trained, poorly equipped mountain people, who themselves are divided into many warring factions, stood their ground against the mightiest nation on earth, for 20 year, and in the end US negotiated with them for transfer of power.

Now, I see this as sheer political and administrative failure. Militarily, sure, the US has an upper hand and can pile up bodies like no other, But it failed to win the "war on terror" in Afghanistan. It could not change the govt., it could not bring stability and democracy to the region, it could not transform the society, and it could not even change the idea of itself in the minds of the Afghan people.

US is too powerful, militarily, to formulate effective strategies that further its goals. It is good in doing that economically, through sanctions, etc. But as a military force, it is too powerful for its own good.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by jlkuester7 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:52AM (#27286509)
Heh, you would think that after literal decades of (moderate) sustained success in resisting incursions from three superpowers (British, then Soviets and then the US) the Pashtuns would get a little more credit then just being called "a bunch of un-educated, poorly trained, poorly equipped mountain people."

Even Churchill said of them: "Every man is a warrior, a politician and a theologian."

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by kumarvvr on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:20AM (#27287040)
To be fair, US has decades of high tech warfare experience, institutions that study war and constantly research about it, has best infrastructure, excellent means to project power and has virtually unlimited resources.

The Afghans have no proper education system, no institutions other than local commanders directing their bunch of troops and have virtually no good infrastructure. They literally live among mountains and have no good networks for transportation.

I am giving the Afghans a lot of credit, because what I said about them is true. They won in spite of that.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by MikeTheGreat on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:12PM (#27285368)
My recollection of how the conflict was presented was "We need to go to Afghanistan to defeat Al-Qaeda" 20 years later we're still fighting that same war, which is how many people look at the situation and say that the US hasn't achieved it's goals (i.e., has been defeated)

I suppose one could say that the US hasn't lost yet, but it's pretty tough to say that the US has won.

Honestly, at this point it feels like any discussion of the US staying in Afghanistan seems like it should devolve into a discussion of the halting problem. (/s, but only slightly)

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by afterburner on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:12AM (#27286230)
They definitely defeated Al-Qaeda, they just didn't wipe out the Taliban.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by vkou on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @05:26PM (#27296329)
Al-Qaeda was defeated? How does that reconcile with ISIS popping up a few years later, and Libya and Iraq still being in the grips of civil war?
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by afterburner on Sunday May 30, 2021 @12:19PM (#27334295)
Where do I even start with this. Do you just call all your favourite bad guys "Al-Qaeda" and group them all together as if they were all one organization?
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by badmadrad on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:46PM (#27285592)
Agreed, We literally took over Afghanistan in a month and installed a government but somehow we lost? We just don't really have a dog in the fight anymore. This isn't defeat.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by anigbrowl on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:44PM (#27286027)
Yes, the US lost. The government in Afghanistan doesn't have much institutional depth or very firm control of the country. It's not a military defeat in the sense of having your army crushed, but an occupation that never achieves peacetime status is a failure by great power standards. Don't feel bad though, the US is the 3rd empire to make the exact same mistake in Afghanistan. It'd be comical if there weren't so much human suffering involved.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by BelenusMordred on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:51PM (#27286073)
Giving up isn't defeat? If this was sports would anyone accept that definition?

The US just signed a peace deal with the Taliban agreeing to and withdraw all their troops and release aligned 5000 prisoners, the Taliban are also allowed back in government. Technically they could be in power at the next election.

What actual goal was fulfilled here after two decades of war?

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by teclordphrack2 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:43PM (#27285562)
You lost. Deal with it. The level of immaturity... coming up with stories to tell yourself.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by badmadrad on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:47PM (#27285598)
We didn't lose though.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by teclordphrack2 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:17PM (#27285832)
Who is pulling out? Who's puppet government is already falling? Who is taking back control of every area we pulled out of? What did you "win". Do you really like getting kicked in the nuts?

Al-Qeada and other groups just shifted to other unrested regions and even caused unrest. At a global scale the war only caused other countries harm.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by anigbrowl on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:46PM (#27286037)
Tell someone in your social circle that you're considering a business deal with a company in Afghanistan and might be flying out there next month, see what sort of reaction you get.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by whimsicalism on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:36PM (#27285106)
I'd say we won Gulf war II, we've definitely lost Syria by now, Afghanistan probably lost.

That said, many of the well-known, long haul conflicts that the US are involved in are the ones they are most likely to lose. The ones they win they usually win quickly and are less well known.

There are plenty of interventions post-WWII that have been quick successes for the US, esp. in Latin America.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by dillondoyle on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:13PM (#27285372)
Yeah Syria is interesting

The problem with all these conflicts is winning is so poorly defined or multi-goal.

What's winning in Syria? Getting rid of assad and then leaving? We could probably do that in a week or less and utterly demolish the country if we wanted. The consequences of 'winning' that war under that definition would probably be pretty horrible.

But that doesn't seem to be the goal right now?

There's the wider goal of not wanting to poke the Russia bear too much while simultaneously not letting Russia run too wild (arguably they are..).

Though Afghanistan is pretty simple imho. there aren't nearly as many global power stakes... The taliban explicitly does not want Democracy so if that is 'winning' it's doomed to a loss by default.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by whimsicalism on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:19PM (#27285410)
> We could probably do that in a week or less

Eh - I'm not sure. Getting aircraft overhead would be difficult east of the euphrates when they have lots of anti-aircraft guns and they are also supported heavily by Russia.

The only Western power currently conducting airstrikes east of the euphrates is Israel and they have had planes shot down by Syria & Russia.

The US has a preponderance of military power, but I do think people are quick to assume that this means the US could easily topple lots of foreign nations. For some, that is definitely true, for others, like Iran, I think that is a misplaced confidence.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by darksaints on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:15AM (#27286646)
If the goal is total to level the country to the ground, we've had that capability for decades now: supersonic and stealth bombers, as well as SLBMs, SLCMs, and ICBMs. And there's always nukes of course.

The whole collateral damage aspect is pretty high. But if we were willing to deal with the humanitarian and diplomatic fallout, we could do it pretty easily.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by whimsicalism on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:40PM (#27292753)
Fair enough - we can get a lot done with cruise missiles, but as you said, it would be challenging to do without significant civilian casualties.

The anti-aircraft guns obstacle is, as you've said, more than surmountable. The likelihood of Russian reprisal, imo, is not.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by pie420 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:59PM (#27285679)
Winning in Syria was helping Qatar build their Qatar gas pipeline to Europe, but Russia stepped in and didn't let that happen. It was too big of a threat to Russia's most crucial export monopoly: energy to Europe.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by baybal2 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:02AM (#27286575)
> There's the wider goal of not wanting to poke the Russia bear too much while simultaneously not letting Russia run too wild (arguably they are..).

Excuse me, but the goal should be that exactly. Not leaving an inch of flesh of the bear unpoked.

If you resign your emotions, and try to think about it seriously, it makes a lot of sense strategically to conduct a massive provocation.

Right now, it's completely the other way around: Putin delivers one grievous provocation after another to NATO. NATO grovels, shivers, but does nothing, for the whole world to laugh on.

It earns him client states, and satellites. You absolutely don't want your enemies flocking together.

If you turn that around, the world, and his wannabe clients that it's him now who can't do anything, but throw adorable tantrums, his construct will melt away withing years.

2 birds 1 stone.

It's also the types like Orbans, Sisis, and Assads who are only showing the voice now, because they can afford to look brave when the West is intimidated. That will pull the carpet from under them too.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by somesortofsystm on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:25AM (#27286707)
Nonsense, NATO is literally surrounding its so-called 'enemies' with endless streams of base-building. NATO is not groveling or shivering - it is slowly invading proxy countries and extending the US empire, creep creep ..
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by dillondoyle on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @03:29PM (#27294990)
* I agree. But also parent has a point, Crimea, election hacking, extrajudicial poisoning on British etc soil didn't have a robust response - that we know of at least.

I do think Trump was very dangerous and damaging in regards to NATO and pushing our allies away. By not understanding that 'america first' means so much more than simply scraping a few billion more from allies. That's playing checkers in terms of only being able to think in slogan-first 1st order logic. 2nd order or more is understanding why NATO was formed in the first place and the current role it has advancing our interests.

And I think it's critical to actively work against movements of authoritarian nationalism and hold Europe and our allies together.

I'm glad and think Biden is doing a better job in the Pacific in that regard.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by kumarvvr on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:19PM (#27285408)
I would not classify Gulf war II as a "war". It was a blatant incursion, which even Saddam knew would not last, hence the focus on looting the victim, rather than planning for an occupation.

Saddam bet that if no ones does anything concrete, he can get away with it, else, he can return back.

I would call than an "occupation" rather than a "war".

Edit : I retract my comment. I meant Gulf War I, the occupation of Kuwait.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by whimsicalism on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:20PM (#27285418)
The government was toppled, a provisional government was installed by the US, and then replaced by a government that was, at the time, US-aligned with democratic elections.

I think it was a bad war and a mistake, but I don't think we "lost."

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by selimthegrim on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @08:50AM (#27289833)
People in USA usually call the war from 1980-88 “Iran-Iraq War” after 1991
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by whimsicalism on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:12PM (#27292360)
Ah yes, I misunderstood what they were saying. I was confused because the details didn't quite match up...
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by yourapostasy on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:49PM (#27285198)
> How many wars did the US win (as in "achieved the political goals") since WWII?

Depends upon whose interests are answering the question. These aren't so much "wars" as "resource shifting actions marketed as kayfabe [1] wars". This also isn't a new phenomenon. Such "wars" have existed throughout history, and is a side effect of a political sphere's emergent, loosely-defined requirements.

For common people in the path of destruction, a war has an unambiguous win/loss demarcation. For defense contractors if they are being honest with themselves, less so. For politicians with uncanny honesty, even more ambiguous.

With the scales involved today in not just people, speed, and destructive power, but also of information range and depth, I think it is time for a deep re-think of the "war is 'just' a political tool" paradigm.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kayfabe

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by vkou on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:33PM (#27285952)
The US won the Korean war, according to its objectives at the start of the war (Retain the status quo).

It did not win it according to the objectives set by MacArthur (Drive the commies into the sea). He was, incidentally, relieved of command, thanks to his escalation of the conflict to include China.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by azernik on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:26PM (#27285905)
Gulf War 1991 is definitely a victory - deposing Saddam was not the goal of the US or its allies.

Similarly, Gulf War II is absolutely a loss, even though it "accomplished more" than 1991, because its strategic goals included dictating the post-war political arrangements in the country.

Victory and defeat are always relative to the parties' strategic goals.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by stjohnswarts on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:45PM (#27285174)
We can win the battles but we can't win the War. Keeping the enemy out of Kuwait was the biggest win we've had since WW2. If you want to win the war these days it takes total war like in Japan/Europe. You have to break the enemy or they will keep coming back and the modern world doesn't have the stomach for it.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by JoeyBananas on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:00AM (#27286902)
Korea was an American victory in the sense that we achieved the mission. It was not a military disaster caused by poor leadership like the Vietnam war. The leadership during the Korean war was extremely good and the outcome was more than satisfactory given the situation.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by Taniwha on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:57AM (#27286547)
To be fair none of these actually involved a declaration of war, the US congress ha not declared war since ww2 - these have all been wars by stealth
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by darksaints on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:05AM (#27286597)
I'm not really sure what the difference is between a declaration of war and an authorization of war, but we've had congressional authorization for a couple conflicts since then. I would argue that if Congress voted on it in the affirmative, it's not really a secret or stealthy war.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by Taniwha on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:16AM (#27287011)
The constitution only provides for declarations of war, and requires that the congress (not the president) declare war
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by darksaints on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:36AM (#27287148)
The war powers act has been around for 50 years now, and the supreme court has not invalidated it yet. I think it's safe to say that they believe it is constitutional.

Regardless, even if you believe that authorization for use of force is unconstitutional, that does not make it secret. Only Bill Clinton's engagement in Bosnia/Kosovo could be considered a secret war... The others were done with full authorization of Congress.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by somesortofsystm on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:27AM (#27286723)
A declaration of war means that the government has to answer to the people for its war crimes, per international legal standards.

An authorization for war means that war crimes can be committed and war criminals can get away with it, because there is no legal basis for defining that war, except for what Politician-de-jour says it is.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:01AM (#27286912)
> A declaration of war means that the government has to answer to the people for its war crimes, per international legal standards.

No, it doesn’t. A declaration of war has no effect at all on liability in international law. War criminals are responsible under international law whether or not war has been declared; the establishment of universal personal accountability of war criminals, including heads of state, for war crimes -- first unambiguously declared in the Nuremberg Principles -- declarations of war (which previously gave a veil of legitimacy to non-defensive war) have been pretty much irrelevant since non-defensive war was unambiguously itself declared to be a crime against peace.

> An authorization for war means that war crimes can be committed and war criminals can get away with it,

No, it doesn’t.

> because there is no legal basis for defining that war, except for what Politician-de-jour says it is.

Formal declarations of war and war authorizations have no difference in either international or, to the extent the latter is a recognized thing, most national laws in terms of what legal basis there is for defining the parameters of the war, and whatever difference in effect they might have under the terms of local law has no bearing on liability under international law.of those engaging in war crimes, crimes against peace, or crimes against humanity.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by caf on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:14PM (#27285799)
Kosovo?
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by pie420 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:57PM (#27285666)
Korean War: won, South Korea was transformed into an american colony a la Japan, and is now used as a platform to counter China in the east as well as trading partner and military base.

Vietnam: countered Soviet expansionism and prevented Vietnam from becoming a communist regional superpower, Vietnam has not done much besides be a trading partner for the US since.

Grenada: won

Gulf wars: overwhelming victories. Destabilized the middle east, provided an opportunity for american megacorps to heavily profit and exert massive influence. Led to Arab spring which further destabilized the middle east. The middle east is essentially no longer in the picture in the game of global hegemony, and in large part has to rely on American refineries and american corporations to handle oil extraction.

Afghanistan: success, stimulated the American economy, very successful unemployment program (provided jobs for America's high school dropouts for 20 years), justified further weapons development plans, allowed america to build tons of bases to help counter China's Silk Road initiative by destabilizing the region.

Syria: mostly a failure at this point. The hope was to break Syria and build the Qatar gas pipeline to hurt Russia's hegemony on european energy supplies. Looks like that is a lost cause at this point, but of all the wars America has recently waged, this one is probably the most justifiable.

The world is no longer about winning wars and conquering territory. It's about destabilizing rising threats to your power. It's about toppling dictators and installing democracies, which are much easier to bribe. It's about countering your enemies/competitors (Russia, china, the middle east) initiatives and causing chaos in their neighborhood.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by cbHXBY1D on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:15AM (#27286253)
> but of all the wars America has recently waged, this one is probably the most justifiable.

We now have strong evidence that both the Ghouta and Douma attacks were not chemical weapons attacks by the Syrian government. In the case of Douma, the OPCW leaks have very strongly shown (in my opinion, conclusively) that it was staged and put on by the White Helmets, a US/UK funded organization. Senior OPCW officials then reedited their official's report to make it seem like the Syrian government used chlorine gas. Don't believe me? Listen to Noam Chomsky explain it. [1]

Why does this matter? It was used as a pretense for the Trump administration to bomb Syria, which it did a few days later. [2]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w_KgRcw7mag [2] https://www.thenation.com/article/world/opcw-leaks-syria/

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by baybal2 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:07AM (#27286606)
> Syria: mostly a failure at this point. The hope was to break Syria and build the Qatar gas pipeline to hurt Russia's hegemony

Please open a map, and take a look where Qatar is.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by xzlzx on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:54PM (#27285235)
IMO it’s a tad silly to say that the U.S. lost these wars. Can you really lose a war with a massive nuclear arsenal on your side? It’s crazy that this seems to never be mentioned.

This seems quite similar to Americans demanding their gun rights to protect themselves from the government. Well, I hate to inform you of this, but the government could out gun you since time immemorial. It’s a wild argument for gun rights.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by jerglingu on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:43PM (#27286017)
> IMO it’s a tad silly to say that the U.S. lost these wars. Can you really lose a war with a massive nuclear arsenal on your side? It’s crazy that this seems to never be mentioned.

An observation not lost to the ground forces. I was in the US infantry 10+ years ago. We were well trained and lethal. We had an overwhelming technological targeting advantage. We had the support of a sizeable amount of the local population that we generally stayed a few steps ahead of the lower and mid tier rungs of whatever insurgency we were fighting (Al Qaeda in Iraq [ISIS predecessor], the Taliban, whatever-local-Afghan-village-thugs-in-later-deployments). We understood the war wasn't purely militaristic in "kill counts" or territory sieged, and the lessons of irregular warfare (hearts and minds) were beaten in to us.

The biggest issue, at least for us that actually had to kill and be shot at, was that the progressively restrictive rules of engagement (ROE) defanged us, both from lethal and willpower standpoints. There were so many nested bullet points and gotchas and just a wide breadth of rules that no person that wasn't a lawyer could keep up with it. Arbitrary things like "if you are in a gunfight with insurgents and they fall back into a cave, no matter who the insurgent is or how many casualties they were lucky to have inflicted on your forces, you absolutely cannot roll grenades into the cave." Very specific, very arbitrary, very confusing. Furthermore, it was beat into us that the full weight of the law was to fall on our heads if we screwed these things up. Which makes sense from a humanitarian point of view, but that lingering legal guillotine built in a sizeable amount of self-doubt and apprehension in us where we weren't ever sure when or if we were allowed to be lethal.

I imagine a set of ROE was drafted, and enough bureaucrats scribbled in "small edits" that the overarching sense of direction was lost in the sea of Great Ideas by Smart People and nobody with both the political clout and common sense was able to get to these revisions before they were inflicted on us on the ground. Not dissimilar to scope creep you see in software, except parties involved couldn't just vote with their feet and leave. That, and those functioning as the wars' PM's weren't as much concerned with delivering results as they perhaps were with empire building and political posturing. Just a god damn mess

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by jlkuester7 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:11AM (#27286626)
Firstly, thank you for your service!

Secondly, I think you definitely hit the nail on the head when it comes to the ROE being the main limiting factor in the "effectiveness" of the US military in being able to subdue its enemies, not just in Afghanistan/Iraq, but also in Vietnam and even to some extant in Korea. It seems to be one of the weird side-effects that nukes have on armed conflicts that when you have nukes, you really can never actually "fully commit" to a conflict. (Since going "all-in" could be apocalyptic.)

One thing I have always wondered, though, is the relationship between the ROE and irregular warfare. If the military personnel on the ground had broader discretion over their actions, would help or hinder the goal of "winning hearts and minds"?

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by cloverich on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:44PM (#27285571)
> It’s a wild argument for gun rights.

Not really, because it changes the political calculus for exactly the reasons you mentioned. If the US government wants to forcefully take over, and they aren't aligned with gun owners, they have to go through them. In that scenario its more likely they are a shade of grey evil than "lets methodically exterminate all of our citizens". In the former, gun owners standing their ground would be a major political hurdle.

I'd actually argue pro gun rights are a bit silly because those same parties aren't pro encryption / privacy. So they give up the tools they'd need to defend themselves (encryption) from all but the most direct assault. And I'd consider a soft assault by violating their privacy much more plausible.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by xzlzx on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:04PM (#27285306)
How can you “win” a war when the other country can press a single button and eliminate 100% of the people in your country?
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by anigbrowl on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:50PM (#27286066)
Well, bring it down to the personal level - that's like losing a fistfight but comforting yourself that you could go and burn the other person's house down any time because you have a tank full of gasoline at home. I mean, you could, but that wouldn't unbloody your nose.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by ant6n on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:03AM (#27286584)
Because they won’t hit that button. Just look at how Vietnam won.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:56PM (#27285657)
"Can you really lose a war with a massive nuclear arsenal on your side?"

How is that usefull unless you are willing to commit genocide?

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by enraged_camel on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:18PM (#27284981)
I'm not a native-born American and don't feel like I have skin in that game. I just feel like in war, there may be victors, but there are no winners. Especially in the modern age, if you get in a war, all sides lose. Victory is just a matter of who manages to lose less.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by stjohnswarts on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:48PM (#27285184)
This is a cliche understanding. Wars can and have been won since warfare started. However, the actual people doing the fighting aren't winning, they're just dying and mostly (unless defending their own country) giving up their most valuable asset (life) so that rich men can play Axis and Allies.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by stolen_biscuit on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:14AM (#27286247)
I think WW2 had pretty decisive winners and losers
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by ant6n on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:05AM (#27286594)
Although some of the victors were also losers (like the Soviet Union). Basically the only decisive winner was the US.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by xenophonf on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:25PM (#27285032)
In war there are no winners, only widows.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by afterburner on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:10AM (#27286223)
I think many people forget that it took until the Gulf War (90-91) to dispel those demons.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by jasonwatkinspdx on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @08:56PM (#27284821)
People in the US misunderstand the Vietnamese perspective on the war pretty badly. Interestingly enough one of the best sources you can look at to learn about this is the documentary interview with McNamara, Fog of War. He's surprisingly frank about his own mistakes in perspective, as well as talking about conversations he had with his counterparts in later years: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YONEXPMVaQM
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by postalrat on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:19PM (#27285406)
The fog of war is an incredible documentary. I'd suggest it to anyone who is willing to watch it.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by jasonwatkinspdx on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:36PM (#27285524)
It and Iraq in Fragments (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiu8cXhjpX4) are the two most incredible documentaries I've ever seen on this topic.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by crossroadsguy on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:15PM (#27284958)
It’s just how we Indians keep telling ourselves we didn’t really lose those wars against China. But we literally were thrashed at will and when they (China) kind of got tired or thought they taught us a lesson they stopped.

Exactly the same way our close neighbours Pakistan keeps thinking they didn’t really lose any wars against us.

Even the people who were not even a foetus during those wars. Emotion trumps facts it seems.

Being in denial for so long.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by kumarvvr on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:15PM (#27285382)
Totally agree. The narrative about China is mostly political tomfoolery, as the party that faced the war, was in power for decades after the war, giving it a tremendous opportunity to re-write history. They conveniently blamed some scapegoats and shut down the discussion, more or less.

Nehru was more interested in appeasement than long term strategic thinking, when it comes to international affairs. I think it stems from the deep seated inferiority complex that the British left in the elite and intellectuals of the country. Most of the leadership during the initial decade of Indian independence were heavily influenced by the British and looked up to them for guidance.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by crossroadsguy on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:49PM (#27285609)
I agree to some extent but since you referred to the past I’m kinda doubtful where you’re going with it.

Nehru was quite a long-term thinker and a statesman. Hell it’s a miracle he navigated the country through the hell hole the cold war was.

Sad thing is he inherited a country and the people who just couldn’t rise above a certain level and that was where the Brits left us. On top of that the Brits ensured they left us broken and finished and deliberately at that I believe. I maybe wrong but I just can’t bring myself to look at the colonisers in any positive light. Trust me I’ve tried.

Again since you mentioned Nehru (while I’m not accusing you but it’s a pet “But Nehru” phrase used by the ultra nationalist right wing India of today[1]) and the past Govts, and yes they had their own follies and drawbacks, I just want to set the record straight that the current Govt has set India even further back by decades and I don’t see it recovering. Especially so as I majority will again elect current party for religious bigotry and things like temple.

While the past Govts could’ve done a lot lot better the current Govt has been successful in delivering the final blow.

[1] To others who aren’t familiar with the country and its pilots and scene today it’s actually funny. If something BJP the ruling ultra right wing party does and it fails and harms the public ;usually the case) the national chorus becomes “but what about Nehru”. Even if the intention was to fail or harm the public the chorus remains the same. Also Nehru died in 1964.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by kumarvvr on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:52PM (#27285632)
This sounds suspiciously like whataboutism.

"That person may have done better, but what about the present person?"

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by crossroadsguy on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:56PM (#27285655)
I actually updated my comment and mentioned whataboutism I saw in your comment. Glad that we both saw it. Also I usually don’t check other comments of a person so I was not able to be sure. Now I am. Also HN (selectively) hates flame wars so I’d say let’s stop here.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by coliveira on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:24PM (#27285030)
Many people in the US never accepted that they were defeated. And the US media did a good job of never making this point (the defeat against Vietnam) clear. It is a version of the "lost cause" phenomenon of the US south.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by dleslie on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:03PM (#27285300)
It's not simply accepting defeat that poses difficulty; it's being anything but the best, and first, and most able. American exceptionalism isn't just a cliche, it's a cult of identity, a nationalist truth that cannot be abridged without violent opposition.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by coliveira on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:22AM (#27286685)
Well, exceptionalism is a cult that is part of American education and media since early childhood. It is not just nationalism (loving your country), it is ultra-nationalism that preaches the idea that they're superior to other countries.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by kumarvvr on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:24PM (#27285440)
Yeah. The downfall of great nations begins with denying the reality. That slowly seeps into every nook and corner of the society, leading to rot from within. You can see this already happening in the US.

The drive is politics, the lube is the media. The denial of reality and the rejection of truth is more prominent than ever and it is showing its face everywhere in US politics.

As on date, for the last decade, no politician has ever resigned for lying or cheating, personally or professionally. The character and integrity of those in power is off the table for discussion (what he/she does in personal life is not for discussion)

Here is the fact. Perhaps in other jobs, white or blue collared ones, personal life may not affect the job. But when it comes to jobs that move the nation, political positions, powerful bodies, and what not, the personal character and integrity of the person ought to be the scale of foremost importance.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by ant6n on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:06AM (#27286601)
Then again, denying reality has been ingrained in the us for what, 200 years?
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by BurningFrog on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:44PM (#27286024)
Maybe a nitpick, but it's weird to call "Vietnam" the winner in the civil war between South Vietnam and North Vietnam.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by stolenmerch on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:04PM (#27284881)
Completely agree with you about Vietnam reaching its military objectives. However, I only see a couple of commenters disagreeing with that, which is not "a lot". Only curious about this because I wonder how prevalent that viewpoint is versus the perception of that viewpoint being prevalent. Perhaps this is off-topic but it seems this disparity between perception is central to so much of America's hangups with this war 50 years later.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by vmception on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @08:47PM (#27284756)
Yeah I dont really understand the cognitive dissonance people have over that war.

Vietnam has a single party Communist Party that teaches Marxist ideals while having upgraded to state capital patches like every other marxist ideology worshipping party. They are geopolitically irrelevant enough for that never to bother anyone. The US was there to stop that specific thing from happening and didnt. US lost, Vietnam was unified and the control was consolidated under Vietnamese representatives of the communist party and for them they won. That’s the same standard we use for any conflict. Why single out that one to a higher standard where we point out the loss of life? Doesnt make sense. Vietnam won a unified country, and it is under communist rule. There once was a side that didnt want communism and they lost, too!

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by yossarian1408 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:17PM (#27285834)
Depends on what you think the objectives were. Did the USA want to add another star to the Star Spangled Banner? Then yeah, they lost.

But if the objective of the USA was to prevent a domino of communism taking over all of South-East Asia, we can pretty clearly see where the advance of communism was stopped.

And if an American and a North Vietnamese communist from 1955 could see into the future 70 years, taking a tour around Hanoi or Saigon, I don't know if either would be so certain on their verdict of who 'won' or 'lost'. It might have been the North, but it certainly wasn't the communists.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by vmception on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:24PM (#27285888)
I don't think anybody indoctrinated with marxist teachings is satisfied with any current or attempted version of communism. So in that regard I would agree, I still say its an impossible standard not used for other conflicts.

Even the last massacre in China was because the protestors wanted to democratically have more communism instead of the liberalization of the markets and private ownership. That gets reduced to “students wanted democracy”, geopolitically it would have even been worse. (It is sad they were killed and that unity in that country relies on never mentioning it or any other strife)

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by afterburner on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:03AM (#27286169)
> But if the objective of the USA was to prevent a domino of communism taking over all of South-East Asia, we can pretty clearly see where the advance of communism was stopped.

But Communism flourished in Vietnam. So if you want to argue domino theory (which was wrong anyways), they certainly didn't stop the Vietnamese domino. So they didn't win in Vietnam.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by kumarvvr on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:03PM (#27285304)
The worlds most advanced, wealthiest and militarily powerful country did not obtain it's primary objective in the war, stopping the spread of communism.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by darksaints on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:21AM (#27286678)
What's really amazing is that we could have done nothing, and it still would have failed eventually. There aren't any communist regimes that have been truly successful. The Soviets succeeded in industrialization, but then ate itself from within. The Chinese succeeded in industrialization, but only after transitioning away from maoist communism and more towards state capitalism. Everything else basically failed outright.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:29AM (#27286731)
> The Chinese succeeded in industrialization, but only after transitioning away from maoist communism and more towards state capitalism.

Leninism and all its descendants, including Maoism, are, ab initio, state capitalism. What the CCP moved toward is more of xenophobic totalitarian corporatism than state capitalism; essentially fascism without, or at least with less, overt expansionism.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by darksaints on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:44AM (#27287182)
I guess I can see that, but whatever it was, it wasn't communism.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by abrookewood on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:08PM (#27284900)
Wikipedia is pretty unambiguous: "Following Vietnamese victory against the French in the First Indochina War, which ended in 1954, the nation was divided into two rival states: communist North and anti-communist South. Conflicts intensified in the Vietnam War, which saw extensive American intervention in support of South Vietnam, while the Soviets and the PRC supported the North, which ended with North Vietnamese victory in 1975. After North and South Vietnam were reunified as a communist state under a unitary socialist government in 1976"
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by jollybean on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:22PM (#27285427)
I'm doubtful that this is really the best way to put it.

The US escalated it's involvement until the early 1970's when via strategic bombing of the North (which the US was unwilling to do previously), decisively destroyed the North Vietnamese ability to fight.

Then, the Americans left.

A couple of years later, the North Vietnamese rehabilitated their forces, and invaded the South.

The reality is such different perspective than 'North Vietnam Won' to the point wherein it's basically almost misinformation to just state it like that.

Finally, the tactical and strategic advantage of the US bombing with Nixon was enormous. The US could have feasibly stayed for a long time - after shedding their fears of 'Bombing the North' and just 'doing it', they finally gained the 'obvious advantage' that a major power should have had.

But Nixon ran on a platform of 'Getting out of Vietnam', and the folks back home lost interest in a miasma of populism.

I think those nuances are important, because I think it demonstrates how tactics, politics and populism fuelled the outcome.

The lessons of 'Fight to Win Only' and 'A long grinding war will turn your population against you' are straight out of the Art of War.

Those lessons informed the 1st US invasion of Iraq (and 2cnd), which was led by Vietnam vets. 'Overwhelming Force and Boots on the Ground to Unambiguously Overwhelm Enemy Forces', though the 2cnd occupation didn't go quite as well.

Finally, literally one day after Barack Obama ordered the last US units out of Baghdad, then Iraqi PM Malaki ordered a purge of Sunnis from his party and government. The Sunni Tribes, in fear of their lives from the then-emboldened Shia dominated Iraqi Army ... invited ISIS in. This very well could have been avoided by keeping a few units, neatly tucked away 'behind the wire' in Baghdad - just enough ongoing oversight and leverage to keep people like Malaki from self-destructing. It would have been better in hindsight to take a longer view of that situation as well.

It's hard to say if there is a direct parallel with Vietnam but it kind of looks like that.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:06PM (#27285740)
"and the folks back home lost interest in a miasma of populism"

Or, maybe they didn't like their children being draft into the army and coming back crippled?

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by akdor1154 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:53PM (#27285640)
I'll happily accept 'if the US didn't pull out before winning, they might have won', but this isn't the same as 'the US won'.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by afterburner on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:07AM (#27286190)
The hilarious thing is, the entire time the US was in Vietnam, top leadership in the US admin was pretty much convinced they could never win, but had to put in a good show.

So they were never even "winning" in the sense that the US leadership thought they were winning.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by jollybean on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:32AM (#27286753)
I'm doubtful of your assertion that 'top leadership didn't think they could win' and especially in the context of 'put on a show'.

Which elements of 'top leadership' believed this?

For whom would that 'show' be for?

You'll have to state which individuals took that position.

"never even "winning" in the sense that the US leadership thought they were winning. "

This directly contradicts your first statement. Did US leadership think they were winning or not?

The data (i.e. 'body count') was initially misleading, but that lesson was learned quickly enough.

By 1965 , at the start major escalation, The Pentagon wanted to do strategic bombing of the entirety of North Vietnam. US political leadership wanted to avoid Hanoi and other targets for political reasons i.e. 'Rolling Thunder'.

Rolling Thunder failed.

Later, with political limitations removed, Op. Linebacker I and II (in 1970's) successfully dismantled N. Vietnam's ability to fight.

Imagine how history would have changed were, in 1965, the Pentagon were able to fight on it's own terms? The big rise in casualties to 1969 probably never would have happened, and the political repercussions would have been at least somewhat less.

Even the populist miasma is affected: when people are dying, it's one thing if 'major progress' is being made (think sicily and european campaigns against Hitler, once they started and were winning, it'd be impossible to bring them back until it was over), but altogether another if there's a stalemate or there isn't evidence of material progress.

But history is 20/20 and that's the whole point.

In 2021 we're still not done politicizing this war, the PBS documentary had some very good elements, but was still only one lens and entirely ignored the geopolitical aspects.

Macnamara v. Pentagon was realized 'All Over Again' with Maj. General Tommy Franks vs. Donald Rumsfeld. This time, the Army mostly go their 'Boots on the Ground and Overwhelming Power' to guarantee a fairly immediate collapse of the enemy. Too bad there was no plan for the occupation.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by afterburner on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @09:26AM (#27290202)
> Which elements of 'top leadership' believed this?

Macnamara. LBJ. Kennedy.

> For whom would that 'show' be for?

For the American people, for Congress, for the world. To prove that the US stands by its allies and can still win wars. To prevent accusations of being losers by domestic political opponents, both in the same and different parties. Pretty basic stuff, these political dynamics are in play in nearly every war.

> This directly contradicts your first statement. Did US leadership think they were winning or not?

You are misreading the line. I am saying there were not winning either in reality nor in the leaderships minds. The US leadership did NOT think they were winning.

> Imagine how history would have changed were, in 1965, the Pentagon were able to fight on it's own terms?

How do you propose to fix the problem of Chinese troops overwhelming any serious success like they did in Korea? That's nearly the entire reason the US couldn't fully commit to destroying North Vietnam.

How do you even fix the problem of having unreliable and problematic allies in Southern Vietnam that could never really rally the country properly?

You have learned no lessons.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by nearbuy on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:36AM (#27286782)
It's not surprising the nuclear power with the largest military in the world could have won against half of a smaller and much poorer country under the right circumstances.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by AzzieElbab on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @08:55PM (#27284814)
50 years of misery ongoing, Vietcong won bigly.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by wolverine876 on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:57PM (#27285263)
> The cost of victory was very high, but it was a pretty unambiguous success for the Vietnamese.

N. Vietnam won, but that doesn't make war a success.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by afterburner on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @12:04AM (#27286175)
It was for the northern regime. They took control of the south, by force. That's pretty straightforward war-winning.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by wolverine876 on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @01:22PM (#27293375)
As I said,

> N. Vietnam won, but that doesn't make war a success

Wars are disasters. 500,000 - 1 million (?) people died, the country was physically destroyed. That's not a good outcome.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by VWWHFSfQ on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @08:54PM (#27284799)
I think if you're talking about the acute win/loss of the Vietnam war, then absolutely the North Vietnamese won. If the USA really wanted to win the war then they could have done it outright in 1967. But that would have been very ugly. Not an option.

Did the Vietnamese people win the war? No. They've been living in poverty for 50 years and most of them still are in 2021, 50 years later.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by bawolff on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:16PM (#27284961)
> Did the Vietnamese people win the war? No. They've been living in poverty for 50 years and most of them still are in 2021, 50 years later.

Do "the people" ever win a war? Something like 600,000 - 2 million civilians died in that war. If you're implying that people would be better off ecconomically if the other side won, that seems highly speculative with no evidence to back it up.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by VWWHFSfQ on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:18PM (#27284978)
USA fought a very similar war in Korea 10 years prior.

Would you rather live in North Korea or South Korea right now?

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by bawolff on Wednesday May 26, 2021 @02:47AM (#27287207)
Its hardly identical, much of N. Korea's current struggles have direct causes that are more recent than the war (massive sanctions), and even if it was, a sample size of 1 is meaningless.
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by jollybean on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:27PM (#27285462)
S. Koreans are unambiguously 'better off' than their counterparts in the North.

That's the closest comparable we have.

If the US were to have 'stayed' in S. Vietnamese, much like they did in S. Korea, that S. Vietnam would look 'somewhat' like S. Korea, but not nearly as prosperous given their agrarian history etc..

But definitely better off.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by tuan on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:50PM (#27285622)
Vietnam GDP historical data: https://tradingeconomics.com/vietnam/gdp

From https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/vietnam/overview:

"Vietnam’s development over the past 30 years has been remarkable. Economic and political reforms under Đổi Mới, launched in 1986, have spurred rapid economic growth, transforming what was then one of the world’s poorest nations into a lower middle-income country. Between 2002 and 2018, GDP per capita increased by 2.7 times, reaching over US$2,700 in 2019, and more than 45 million people were lifted out of poverty"

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by worik on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:30PM (#27285067)
10% of USA people live in poverty.

50 years on, still in poverty.

Win or loose, live in poverty.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by VWWHFSfQ on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:40PM (#27285140)
Big difference between "USA poverty" and "Vietnam poverty".

But you're right, it's poverty nontheless.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by kumarvvr on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @10:34PM (#27285512)
They may be living in poverty, but they are living in self-respect. They have problems, but who doesn't. Do you think only money matters?

Such regressive thinking, that too about whole societies and nations. As if they are not human.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by drzaiusapelord on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:07PM (#27284895)
Maybe their soceity would have been more successful if it wasn't bombed to hell and back by the Americans then made a soft client state of the USSR and then boycotted by the West.

If left to develop its communist government by itself, it could be like China today - a superpower that's going to overtake the USA by important measures.

Lets stop pretending that years of war against a superpower didn't come at a cost for them and the US should have left them alone.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by VWWHFSfQ on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:09PM (#27284912)
Are the Vietnamese people winning in this scenario? Are the Vietnamese people winning right now?
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by bawolff on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:27PM (#27285045)
Are you asking if the vietnamese people are winning in the crazy scenario drzaiusapelord suggested where viet nam is a super power - i think the answer is an obvious yes. But that's an unrealistic scenario.

Would they have been better off if france agreed to decolonize instead of trying to hold on to their failing colonial empire with force (leading to everything that came to follow)? Maybe we'll never know.

But i don't think there's any particular reason to assume that if the south won they would be any better off. South Vietnam hardly seems like it was the most stable/well run of governments - they were into fixing elections and persacuting buddhists, etc. Hardly what i would call an ideal state.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by knz_ on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:57PM (#27285262)
> If left to develop its communist government by itself, it could be like China today - a superpower that's going to overtake the USA by important measures.

Ho Chi Mihm was a puppet of china. There was no 'developing on their own'.

> Lets stop pretending that years of war against a superpower didn't come at a cost for them and the US should have left them alone.

Yeah, letting Russia and China subjugate the world would have gone SO MUCH better. What good has it done for nicaragua, cuba, north korea, afghanistan or the many noname countries in Africa? The USSR left only poverty and death whereever they went.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by ClumsyPilot on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:19PM (#27285844)
Ah yes, Afganistan, where Operation Cyclone funelled weapons to mujahadeen, which they used indiscriminantly against civilians. What could possibly go wrong?

And once USA took control of Afganistan, how has the situation improved?

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by anigbrowl on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:40PM (#27285994)
Ho Chi Mihm was a puppet of china. There was no 'developing on their own'.

Vietnam is communist but they're not very friendly with China, nor have they been since about 1975; vietnam is certainly not a satellite of China. Starting in 1979 they fought a low-intensity border war with China that went on for over a decade, a fact you seem to be unaware of.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by wrevock on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @11:56PM (#27286117)
Ehh no, we have history of thousands of years clashing with China so no we aren't that close to China. We might have some "co-operation" geographically and politically but the best depiction of our relationship is 2 guys shaking hands with knives on the other hand.

Oh and if you do some digging you will know that HCM sent a few letters to Trumman asking for US's aid, we could have been ally 70 years earlier, but no, the US branded him as a commie and the rest is history. Btw, the first line of our Proclamation of Independence is pretty much a paraphrase of the US's Declaration of Independence, that's to show how much we wanted the US to be ally.

Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by _-david-_ on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:20PM (#27285007)
Various countries which were "bombed to hell and back" are doing well now. Various Europe countries, Korea, Japan, etc
Re:Vietnam War images from the North Vietnamese side by bawolff on Tuesday May 25, 2021 @09:29PM (#27285062)
Helps that it was in usa's geopolitical interest for these countries to be strong to counter communism (Marshall plan)