Question for PG/HN: Where do you think we stand on your list of "ideas"?
About three years ago, Paul penned his essay "Startup Ideas We'd Like to Fund". Three years along, how do you think this list stands up today? Are any solved (in part or in whole)? Anything new you would add to the list?
I ask, because I remember reading this years ago and getting inspired to work on a few things (that didn't pan out). Given the popularity of (and success of YC), it would be interesting to see what Paul and HN see as the state of the world for this list.
(
103 comments
| 172 points
| on HN
)
AirBNB is a competitor to Craigslist in that it is helping to take it apart piece by piece. Hopefully other YC companies will take on other categories / pieces
Other companies are competing with other parts of Craigslist (e.g. StubHub)
The question is though, what problem does it solve? It was very hard to explain to people why they would need it or care about it.
Spent a year developing it and spent alot of money on it. For nothing in the end. A very cool technology and I still like it alot.
Lesson: build something people want, or that solves a real problem. Don't build a solution looking for a problem.
People talk about ideas as being worthless, etc. No, they're not. You can't get an oak tree with a mustard seed. But there's a big difference between even oak trees. Idea and execution are the same thing, just two ends of a continuous line.
The films La Femme Nikita and Point of No Return have nearly the exact same plot. The former is one of the greatest action films ever made; the latter is one of the worst.
That whole "build something people want" is only for people who want to make money. And honestly, if what you want is to make money, be a dentist.
People waant Facebook and Twitter and Farmville. But they need core technological innovation. They need better ways to work with data. You did the right thing, Andrew. It wasn't a waste of time. And I won't stop either, because the world has far too much of what it wants and far too little of what it needs.
I've compulsively weaned myself off the "solve a problem" mentality because it gets in the way of building truly innovative products, IMO.
And if all you want is to build something just for the fun of it, don't start a company. You'll lose money, time and nerves. There really are only to options when building something. Either build something people want (and if somebody built it before you did, build a better version - see: Altavista, Yahoo and others vs. Google) or build something, and then make people want it (see: iPad). But don't start a company to build something just so you can satisfy your professional curiosity. That's what side projects are for.
I think I understand your point. AltaVista is nowhere and google is.....
I am also a fan of the original (the french version) Nikita - great shootouts.
I'd suggest that if this product wasn't a success you either didn't understand how end-users currently use spreadsheets as a 'poor man's database' or the marketing let you down.
I still very much like the idea of being able to build lists from web based API's with only a handful of lines of Javascript.
You built something that was supposed to be an Excel clone, but you didn't implement the editing functionality?
Isn't that pretty much 99% of the point of Excel? I mean yes, people do use Excel to share data as well, but most scenarios involving shared Excel spreadsheets involve multiple people editing the same spreadsheet, and then generating reports out of it.
That's where the pain is, and that is what I had assumed you were aiming at. If not, then what did your system do exactly?
(Also, build lists from web based API's with only a handful of lines of Javascript isn't Excel, either)
Edit: I see further down you noted that your system was desktop based software. A web-based Excel/database hybrid isn't a big requirement list, but I'm not convinced you are covering a whole lot of it..
We built it a a desktop application too which I think was a mistake. Getting people to download and install things is hard.
As an analyst/controller I work with Excel every day, let me know if you want to know about issues with Excel, there are tons of problems to solve.
http://hypernumbers.com
Our core business case is to address the problems of distributed business processes implemented in spreadsheets. We want to continue to offer the flexibility of the spreadsheet paradigm whilst addressing the most weaknesses of the current paradigm.
This short video (when its finished) will be the centerpiece of the new release: http://vimeo.com/25937882
Point is, there must be a market out there for some functionalities that Excel does not have, it also should not be that difficult to build such a solution (call it a hunch, but I think with nosql that should be really easy to do). But the whole thing requires stopping thinking logically (of course excel makes no sense) and start thinking business(ly) (how do I get people to understand and use my solution).
I think it's only when you make a complete rewrite from the bottom up in another paradigm that you can extend the power while retaining the usefulness.
True, but again, look at the users. People with very poor IT knowledge and very scared of change. Any new solution pointing at this market will have to:1) be as easy to use as excel; 2) much better than excel (why change otherwise?).
I think that being better than excel overall is impossible, but looking into specific businesses and uses it should be.
Personally, I have been giving it a lot of thought and I can't come up with a complete better solution. But other (Palo, Hyperion) seems to make money on solutions that do not change the excel paradigma.
We disagree.
The base of users with knowledge of Excel is very large. Most organizations have a built in base of knowledge of Excel. Why swim upstream and go against that. Try to make Excel work in that environment.
Take a look at www.excelcube.com. It may be helpful.
Have you looked at google fusion table and google refine? These are powerful tools in same space for non-enterprise applications.
Most/many hedge funds manage billions of dollars on the back of very complicated excel spreadsheets, mostly because the "talent" understand excel and can bend it to their needs.
But auditing these things is an utter nightmare, which version was used to lose a million here or a million there. Is it still on bobs laptop? How can I reuse code?
By providing a excel like front end and a centralised, versionable, auditable back end, they got a lot of interest going.
The space is still very wide afaik, but I have been out of the City for some years now.
(In fact you could take a similar approach to any CFO's office)
Jane Street is very unusual in having such an advanced technology management set up (IIRR OCaml, directors review the code before production etc etc)
http://blog.dabbledb.com/
It might be that the lesson pertains here, too.
I only ever played with it, but it seemed like a great piece of work, and was all coded in Smalltalk (Seaside).
I will be presenting this at the Seedcamp in London later in the year. I am really exciting about the project, so I wont be giving anything away here! Unless PG wants to get in touch directly...
They're really saying, "I love Excel".
Don't forget it's only a tip of iceberg. Users will complain more about missing features after you built something users have cared about.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yuSDU0JiI2c
Stupid name - NeoGopher.
The basic idea was that with 10 to 15 lines of Javascript you could bring back results from any XML or JSON web based API and display it as a list. You could then link any row or cell to any other list.
In a way it was like a reinvention of the old "gopher" protocol which allowed the user to navigate from one data list to another.
The site is gone now.
The problem is - it is almost impossible to get funding for such projects in domestic markets.
So, it is a very simple and obvious idea to build Enterprise software using the same technology that powers modern global-scale online services, targeting emerging markets, but it is quite long and very expensive journey.
There are huge demand for hosted niched services for small and medium business, such as tour operators (schedules, synchronizations), goods carriers (simplified logistics), B2B systems (customer - supplier) and so on.
Like, i.e. an all-in-one service: build your SaaS platform against our framework, and we'll handle all i18n issues on this given list, for this given set of countries and languages, including payment handling and shipping, and take a cut. A successful startup often doesn't have time to deal with its own internationalization before local competitor clones get the jump on it (e.g, Ebay, Groupon). So what I'm envisioning is a company that acts at a higher level than the usual outsource-to-the-translator-agency routine, yet has product-ized its offerings enough that it's not locked into the consultancy business model.
It would be very hard for a startup to compete in this space though - perhaps a better opportunity for a partnership between a payment gateway and a major distributer.
- Simplified browsing has happened ala tablets, mobiles etc, especially purpose-specific apps.
- Photo/Video sharing services .... they went mobile, big time
- CRM ... I think twitter, facebook and internet outrage are changing that pretty rapidly
- Web office apps ... I (still) don't get the sense there's any major urge to move to web office apps, but obviously the 800 pound gorilla in that space is (went?) web
- Online learning ... Kahn Academy
- New payment methods ... Square, NFC et al
- The web os ... kind of became redundant with the explosion of mobile and tablet, but Chrome OS might end up mattering
- Application and data hosting happened in a huge way lol
Disruption on the scale of displacement happens all the time. And mark my words, it will happen to each of your opinions listed above.
And so I don't think it's going to be Chrome OS, also because it has to work on any kind of device to be the web OS not just a Chromebook and too many partnership deals would need to be signed for Chrome OS to spread as quickly as the web OS needs to spread.
Mobile and apps certainly have helped. But, there is still a problem of knowing what urls (in the case of a browser) or sites to search or which apps to get to help out.
It seems like there should be a better way of just "getting information" based on location/interests/curiousities...
The big boys of online data preferences who Could do these things would be Google, perhaps FaceBook (which still brings up ridiculous unrelated ads to my interests, however, I don't "click" any apps or "like" many pages out of privacy). More on FaceBook, even my "prolific" friends (checkins, 200-400 friends, likes and friends with 100 or so movies, bands, apps, etc.) still don't click ads.
NetFlix seems, after 4 years, of finally getting a semblance of "interests" down.
That is quite a bit of data, time length, and me, the user actually rating the movies I watch in a semi-diligent manner.
I would, in fact love to log onto Google, or wherever, see my "bored" category of movies I may like to watch online, at the theater, local events going on that evening, something coming up tomorrow and all somewhat related to what I would enjoy, not just "pushing" or scraping a bunch of different calenders / pooling app info together.
Very difficult problem.
"Hey iPhone, is there anything fun to do after work?"
It grabs your location, sees you have a late meeting blocked off from 6-7, sees you were watching Transformers 3 trailers a few days ago, sees your buddy Mike tweeted "Transformers 3 looks pretty rad, I definitely want to see that".
It now has an approximate time and location, a pretty good idea of what you're interested in (both long term and short term) based on app data, and can see if any of this aligns with your social graph...
Would you be interested in seeing Transformers 3 at 7:30 with Mike?
"Yes, send him an invitation." iMessage sent with all the details, when you get a yes from him, Fandango launches and you buy your ticket, it gets added to your calendar so you get a reminder after your meeting, maps out directions, etc.
It's a stretch but if anyone can make harvesting that much of your personal info look appealing, it's definitely Apple.
Edit: as much as I despise the term, Social App Store. You would need algorithms like Pandora uses, that tracks how often and for how long a user uses certain kinds of apps, and through categorization, tailor a "Recommended" page to popular apps in the same category, as well as ones that "friends" use on a regular basis.
How is the answer "mobile" the answer to anything? it's like hearing microsoft saying "cloud"
About purpose-specific apps, how this even get close to simplified browsing? It's the opposite! What to read website X on mobile? wait 7 months until they launch an app. And if they already have an app, you will probably have to go to the desktop to do something trivial (like adding a video to a list on youtube under android... you will have to favorite it so you can find, go to the desktop, move the video to a list)
My mobile browser for sure does not make anything simpler! Took me several minutes to import a bookmarklet to change the background to black and text to white on the current page. It involved setting up a webserver on another computer because it could't open pages on the local memory.
Remember that time a blog accidentally outranked Facebook for 'facebook login' on Google and people couldn't find Facebook anymore? The web is hard for a lot of people.
We are back to the BBS days, everyone's downloading binary files!
The idea I'm trying to leverage is that typing long search queries on mobile devices is super awkward, but the touch screens make clicking much easier and more fun. My site displays similar search results geographically near each other on the screen, allowing you to make your searches more focused just by clicking on certain areas. Right now, it only works on blogs with RSS feeds due to my limited internet crawling resources. I hope to add media (picture,movie, and maybe music) search by the end of the summer. I don't see this necessarily working as a Google replacement though.
You can check out the prototype at http://blogumbus.com and visit the developer blog at http://dev.blogumbus.com.
How are you working out whats related? Links or some deeper textual analysis?
As for linkedness, I'm going to do a detailed blog post about it sometime, but here it is in short:
Use the HITS algorithm to get hub and authority scores for each domain. Pages are related only if websites with higher scores link to both of them. This makes spam much less of a problem (I think!), and will make for some interesting search algorithms that I haven't quite implemented yet.
Not many users. It tends to get a lot of SEO traffic though (usually breaking news stories funnel through it pretty quickly and you see a large spike) with anywhere from 50 to 500 uniques a day.
Ah interesting. Chunews does statistical word ranking on each article it pulls down to group similar stories together. From memory it uses links as well but in reality since it checks exact links that never affects this.
One of these days I may iterate on it but for the moment it shows me whats happening in the world at any point which is fine for me.
Considering it's a search engine, you should probably not hide the search box behind an extra click.
I've been wondering whether or not it's best to hide the search box. I decided to hide it because I don't really want people to use it. As you've pointed out, it's not really that good. I'd rather people find blogs similar to ones already on the screen by clicking. That's where the strength of my display comes in, I think.
I wanted to experiment in new search interfaces, but I thought that taking on google directly would simply be too hard. That's why I didn't jump right in to general purpose search.
- Match.com solved it by starting in 1995 and working really hard.
- eHarmony solved it by attracting the christian crowd with endorsements by pat roberson and great offline marketing.
- plentyoffish solved it with a great brand name, and using the "free forever" look, feel, and marketing.
- OKcupid solved it by creating tons of questionnaires that were fun and interesting.
- AshleyMadison solved it by targeting the infidelity niche.
- AdultFriendfinder solved it by marketing to suckers on gaming and porn sites.
The pattern is clear. There is no pattern.
1) Make it a one-side market. For example you could let guys set up profiles and then buy Facebook ads to advertise those specific guys ("Think Brad is cute? - He's single, click to find out more") to single girls in their areas with similar interest.
2) Leverage off of another userbase. Tastebuds.fm is a good example that leverages off Last.fm's userbase. If I wanted to take this approach I'd make a dating service for users of 23andme's genetic analysis service. Newspapers will literally fall over each other to write about a dating service that uses DNA to match couples.
3) Take the primary feature of your competitors and turn it into a weakness. Most dating websites focus on having x million members. Turn around a build an exclusive dating website ("fed up having to search through hundreds of profiles and getting most of your messages ignored?"). Only have 20-30 members of either gender at a time and only give them access for a limited period (say a couple of weeks). Have a wait-list for people who want to get on. People will want to signup even without knowing how many people of the other gender or on the system.
http://dilbert.com/strips/comic/1992-09-09/
The dating site would let you create a landing page to promote yourself (You could also do things like A/B testing on it) and buy advertising to promote it on places like Facebook. It's absolutely irrelevant who else is using the site to promote themselves.
The only unique thing about this idea is that it starts by worsening the chicken and egg problem.
Can you tell me why advertising on Facebook for your profile wouldn't work if there already were women on your dating site? Why not just start selling advertising to people who have profiles on OKcupid, eharmony, PoF and other existing dating sites? If it's irrelevant who else is using the site, then how does excluding one side of the marketplace improve my odds to find a partner?
You are thinking too traditionally.
Imagine the site was called "BankersLookingForDates.com". You charge $5000 (or more?) to become a member, then go visit other dating sites to find women who might be good matches for your members, contact them, vet them and arrange the date.
Makes using it a drag, because lots of people never reply to any of their messages, but make it fun still seems like a good place to start.
solve chicken and egg by giving the women free drinks or food when they get to a place. this helps the dating network AND the bar by attracting more people to both.
A form of search that depends on design. Google doesn't have a lot of weaknesses. One of the biggest is that they have no sense of design.