News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by tootie on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:08PM (#27213006)
Aside from not really knowing what Freenode is/was (a bunch of IRC servers?) none of that really makes clear what Andrew Lee is actually doing that is so objectionable.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by crdrost on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:06PM (#27213781)
Yes. Freenode was the largest public IRC relay network, something like 30 servers, 80k+ users, 40k+ channels, originally directed to open source software but e.g. I would mostly hang out on ##math and ##physics and help students out with problems. This is not a "back in the day" situation, like, it continues to be extremely popular as far as non-Web non-Email internet usage goes.

As for the situation, if I understand correctly:

- Andrew Lee unexpectedly transferred control of the domain names without telling the community of maintainers who actually volunteer, unpaid, to keep the relay servers running.

- The maintainers perceived the company that now held the domain names as "sketchy." Andrew is the director of the company but it looked like its corporate filing status was out-of-date or something.

- In a damage control chat, Lee explained that the domain names were transferred because someone at the sketchy company had a plan to "decentralize ownership of the domain name" (which sounds kind of ridiculous up-front?). Lee also made references to proposals he'd never proposed to those folks which documented the transfer, and other such things... there was apparently also some reference to Freenode costing "millions of dollars" which the maintainers did not appreciate -- responses with the emotional tone of "you mean our donated compute and time that we don't get paid for is costing you millions? how?? and if not, how dare you complain that the main burden is on you rather than on us?"

- And part of the problem is that Lee isn't, you know, a peer of these volunteers running his own Freenode server and having conversations with them on a daily basis, so he came across as a domineering outsider.

For these reasons it looks like the volunteers have basically decided to flee the one domain name and start up a separate one, in the hopes that the users get the message and head on over to the new domain.

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by nullc on Thursday May 20, 2021 @12:02AM (#27217243)
You can see Lee lying about their acquisition of freenode on HN a couple years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21614362

> Freenode is a non profit organization that benefits from support from Private Internet. It is not owned by Private Internet. We are serious fans of IRC and the open source community, so it makes sense for us to divert profits to orgs like freenode among others.

> To be clear, we also donate to other orgs: https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/pages/companies-we-spo... Our new merged company will continue to do the same as we are in fact the same company going forward - just much better resourced.

They're all a bunch of shady scammers. I don't understand why people trust the freenode staff either, since they evaded or demured when challenged about selling freenode to scammers years ago.

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by gwillen on Thursday May 20, 2021 @06:38AM (#27219492)
I don't think anybody trusts christel anymore, but I'm not sure why any of the other staff would be implicated in the sale. As far as they all claim, anyway, they were not aware that Andrew Lee believed/claimed he had ownership of the network; and in fact they claim they were all promised by christel that this was not the case.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by nolok on Thursday May 20, 2021 @07:15AM (#27219687)
They knew he got the domain name, not that he claimed to own the rest and the users data. They had his promise that he would not involve himself in the governance.

Said promise is in writing, but only has a few chats message, nothing official (they are a bunch of volunteers doing that for a couple decades as friends, hard to fault them).

Christel seemed to sell out, and when she got kicked out of her op at freenode by other staff Lee came out of the shadows.

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by johncowan on Sunday May 23, 2021 @04:09PM (#27258111)
She wasn't "kicked out"; she resigned rather than answer certain questions, as was her right.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by XQtN2s7Mo on Thursday May 20, 2021 @05:29AM (#27219139)
Freenode staffers were lied to by the person who made the sale. Read their resignation letters, some are very detailed.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by 88 on Thursday May 20, 2021 @05:50AM (#27219243)
Do you have evidence to support the implication (for Lee to be lying, as you claim) that Freenode is owned by Private Internet Access?
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by gwillen on Thursday May 20, 2021 @06:36AM (#27219483)
Well, from the current front page of freenode.net:

https://web.archive.org/web/20210520103526/https://freenode....

"The rumors of a 'hostile takeover' are simply untrue - I've been the guardian and owner of freenode since 2017, when Christel, the former owner approached me and asked if I was interested in purchasing it, as we had in previous years discussed this."

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by 88 on Thursday May 20, 2021 @06:55AM (#27219587)
Andrew Lee ≠ Private Internet Access
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by exo762 on Thursday May 20, 2021 @06:28AM (#27219440)
Lee owning the domain does not make him an owner of freenode. It's a community project.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by nairboon on Thursday May 20, 2021 @07:54AM (#27219982)
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by 88 on Thursday May 20, 2021 @09:39AM (#27220963)
As above, Andrew Lee said Freenode was not owned by Private Internet Access.

It doesn’t appear he was lying, because by all accounts he owned it personally.

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by pmlnr on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:11PM (#27213849)
I love how everyone skips the part that freenode's democratically elected former leader was the one who simply sold something they shouldn't have been able to - blame should first be directed at them.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by lapinot on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:30PM (#27214082)
Possession of stolen good is equally punishable as theft..
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by FeepingCreature on Thursday May 20, 2021 @12:38AM (#27217429)
It's not so much a question of possession so much as ... if the good was stolen, you simply have no contract, because the seller didn't own it. It's not your good to begin with. You may not have stolen it, but you still need to return it.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by bipson on Thursday May 20, 2021 @07:02AM (#27219632)
Interestingly enough, there are drastic differences written in law regarding this. In some countries, you are in fact allowed to keep purchased stolen goods, if they were bought in good faith. While in other countries, you as the buyer can be in serious trouble, even if you couldn't know if it was stolen and at least need to prove that you were misled and did everything you could to prove ownership.

I guess you were arguing morally, just pointing out this isn't legally true everywhere.

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by that_guy_iain on Thursday May 20, 2021 @02:42AM (#27218120)
They weren't stolen though. They gave someone leadership power and that person entered into contracts on behalf of the organisation. Multiple blogs mention there is no legal recourse so they have asked lawyers and it's all legit.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by FeepingCreature on Friday May 21, 2021 @07:43AM (#27232787)
An organization doesn't get ownership over a volunteer run project by sharing a name.

It might just be that there's no affordable legal recourse.

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by that_guy_iain on Friday May 21, 2021 @09:36AM (#27233800)
They get ownership of the domains and name. They said specifically no legal recourse with a likelihood to win.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by nomadiccoder on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @07:19PM (#27215671)
*Knowingly
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by Tyr42 on Thursday May 20, 2021 @10:09AM (#27221279)
Also he vetod the appointment of a mod mod or something, and deleted all trace of that blog post.

Since the volunteers previous could do this, and were promised that nothing was going to be changed it was pretty upsetting.

Then one other person comes in saying Andrew said he could be a mod now, please grant permissions.

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by ryanlol on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @06:22PM (#27215290)
>you mean our donated compute and time that we don't get paid for is costing you millions? how??

Sounds like you forgot about the very expensive conference freenode staff organized with rasengans money

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by XQtN2s7Mo on Thursday May 20, 2021 @05:30AM (#27219147)
rasengan was very adamant that the conference takes place. It was a contractual obligation.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by mjw1007 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:56PM (#27213674)
I have no special knowledge, but I think it goes roughly like this:

- a few years ago, the previous head-of-staff ('christel') became an employee of Andrew Lee's company

- sometime last year they left the company and also stopped being active as a staff member

- the rest of the staff elected a new head ('tomaw')

- Andrew Lee didn't recognise tomaw as christel's successor (and maybe tried to appoint his own choice of successor)

So I think it isn't so much about anything Lee has done, so much as the fact that he's no longer taking a hands-off role, as (the staff apparently think) he promised.

Also perhaps that his claim to be in a position to take charge is based more on his ability to pay for lawyers than a solid legal foundation (it's clear that he bought something, but not so clear what, and not clear that it was the seller's to sell).

I think the underlying problem is that freenode's previous parent organisation was dissolved in 2013, apparently without setting up an official successor.

https://web.archive.org/web/20130322063238/http://blog.freen...

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by tootie on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @05:35PM (#27214785)
Seems he hasn't done much of anything and it's more that he rubbed everyone the wrong way. And is being opaque in his decision-making to the point that the volunteers believe he's being dishonest. I get it, but it still seems like an overreaction.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by Aeolun on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @07:12PM (#27215634)
> it still seems like an overreaction

Maybe if he’s your actual boss and you are being paid.

Free isn’t enough to deal with this kind of shit (when you can set up and own your competing server in a few seconds).

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by Doxin on Thursday May 20, 2021 @02:39AM (#27218100)
The problem is that the guy doesn't own freenode. No single person owned freenode outright at the time it was ostensibly "sold" to him.

Of course this isn't stopping him essentially staging a coup by ejecting the original volunteer staff and replacing them with a staff of his choosing.

Freenode is a community project that is in the process of being co-opted by a shady organisation.

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by varjag on Thursday May 20, 2021 @03:32AM (#27218412)
He'll have to pay the new staff, pay for new compute resources, and regain the community trust. Good luck with that.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by Doxin on Friday May 21, 2021 @02:31AM (#27231117)
Paying the staff isn't something that happened before, so I dunno about that. I am assuming none of the donors are daft enough to keep donating compute to this new "freenode". The community seems to be moving over to irc.libera.chat so regaining their trust seems rather unlikely at this point.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by detaro on Friday May 21, 2021 @02:34AM (#27231133)
If you assume that none of the donors are daft enough, why would you at the same time assume people would become staff for free? (I'd guess there will be some for both though)
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by Doxin on Friday May 21, 2021 @03:26AM (#27231384)
Because there are a lot of bored power-hungry 13 year olds on the internet. Even when talking about an old-timey protocol like IRC.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by varjag on Friday May 21, 2021 @05:35AM (#27232039)
Freenode was successful precisely because it wasn't run by power hungry teens.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by Doxin on Friday May 21, 2021 @08:41AM (#27233271)
I'm not saying new "freenode" will be successful, just clarifying why I think that they won't have too much trouble setting up a new volunteer staff.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by varjag on Friday May 21, 2021 @02:35AM (#27231140)
Point is he'll have to pay staff because he sure ain't getting any volunteers.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by JohnJamesRambo on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @08:44PM (#27216150)
Sounds like the start of many religious schisms.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by ryanlol on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:22PM (#27213996)
> - Andrew Lee didn't recognise tomaw as christel's successor (and maybe tried to appoint his own choice of successor)

Is this really correct? As far as I understand tomaw tried to claw back freenode assets from rasengan which initiated this whole mess.

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by XQtN2s7Mo on Thursday May 20, 2021 @05:32AM (#27219153)
tomaw did no such thing, staffers tried to operate the network as normal. But after publishing a blog post about how freenode developers will start to collaborate with oftc developers, tomaw started receiving threats.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by gpvos on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:27PM (#27213248)
Putting adverts on the website, apparently. Some projects just fiercely want to stay noncommercial, so they will object at this. I am reminded of a comment from the time when Wikipedia was trying to figure out how to cover their costs: The bigger danger isn't advertisers manipulating content, but that people will no longer see Wikipedia as theirs, they will see it as yet another place that corporations bombard them with adverts. — Sid http://gondwanaland.com/mlog/2007/01/02/wikipedia-advertisin...
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by asix66 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:44PM (#27213488)
Interestingly, at the bottom of freenode's website [0] is a link to a non-comercial CC license [1]. So not sure how anyone could "sell" freenode. At the top of the site is a link (not given in this post) to a commercial product, so again, not sure how they can do that given the CC license. That said, I am no legal expert.

[0] https://freenode.net/ [1] https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by jreese on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @08:50PM (#27216178)
CC no-commercial does not mean the owner of the content can't commercialize it. The owner is explicitly granted all rights by law, regardless of how they license it to others. In this case, the license is to the content of the site, so someone else can reuse that content elsewhere, but not in a commercial context.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by jhugo on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @10:14PM (#27216591)
The license applies to the content of the website, not the organisation itself...
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by fairity on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:37PM (#27213396)
> Putting adverts on the website, apparently.

Where is this motive made apparent?

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by jethro_tell on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @10:16PM (#27216603)
They put ads on the site, no?

edit: s/add/ads/

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by nolok on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @06:18PM (#27215259)
Freenode was a very popular (for its target) irc server used by a lot of open source projects and communities over decades.

Freenode was managed by volunteers without any official organisation. A couple years ago, the person that the volunteers considered their "head" informally made a UK company that would own at least the name and domain name, merely out of a wish to have some legal structure instead of random staff users owning random parts of it. How much of it is owned by the company is very vague, staff are not on contract, servers are loaned without any paper signed by third parties, ...

Then recently, that head sold said company to Andrew Lee's company, who made the promise to the staff to not involve himself. Then that head pushed for profits ads on the website, with no warning nor explanation, and with the profits going to said company. Staff complained a lot, head is removed from the freenode staff and then removed from the board of the company she had sold.

Conflict of management erupts, and was justified freenode having no clear admin structure. But Lee comes out of it acting as if he was the boss and owner of the entire platforms, ask that servers and users data gets transferred to him. When staff rebels and refuse that, he "removes them", which ends up with the hilarious moment of him asking them to de-op themselves (remove their admin status) which he can't do himself since he doesn't even have the authority. On several occasion he claims that "the board of freenode voted to have you removed", while he means the board of his private company freenode ltd (which the staff have no relation of any kind with), and he is the only member of said board.

Most of staff agrees about a need for a proper structure, but refuse to see everything transferred to an opaque and for profit company. Lee argue that's it's the only solutions. Several head of major communities or projects hosted on freenode make the suggestion of transferring the control and data to an official not for profit like the FSF and Lee and staff being given the lead in the interim to a proper governance.

Lee reacts by trying to "bribe" some of them with admin powers and/or financial sponsorship for their project if they side with him, which goes terribly wrong, and them saying "Now I will never have anything to do with Freenode under Lee anymore".

That's a summary of the event as understood by me. It seems the governance issue was real, but it also seems one side is saying "it should be owned by a non profit with clear governance and clear rules for data protection" and the other side, Lee, is saying "all the data and admin privileges should be given to my for profit that doesn't report to anyone else than me".

Frankly, while there is gray on both side, his action made it pretty clear that I wouldn't want any of my data in his hands.

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by throw7 on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @09:59PM (#27216527)
Thanks for the summary. That "head" of freenode that sold off the name and domain... that's a really scummy thing to do. She should be ashamed.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by nullc on Thursday May 20, 2021 @12:05AM (#27217259)
> Then recently, that head sold said company to Andrew Lee's company,

Not recently. In 2017. Why did freenode staff support (or at least refuse to engage in complaints about it) until now?

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by colde on Thursday May 20, 2021 @04:05AM (#27218623)
They were told at the time that the company had no rights to freenode the network, but were only used to run https://freenode.live/
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by fairity on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:47PM (#27213531)
> None of that really makes clear what Andrew Lee is actually doing that is so objectionable.

I second this sentiment. Can anyone summarize objectional actions that Andrew has either taken or committed to taking in the future?

As far as I can tell, he found a way to purchase legal rights to Freenode. And, he's communicated this control in a way that pissed off existing mods.

But, as a Freenode user, what I really care about is how this will impact me as a user. If the only potential impact this will have on me as a user is a smaller user base, there's a clear solution: don't leave?

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by varjag on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @03:58PM (#27213692)
Freenode is a volunteer-run organization, with some volunteers doing the work for better part of two decades. There is no unique technology behind it; it's a community that's been successful for many years thus far.

From what has been revealed, Lee wiggled himself in from conference sponsorship side. He used this inroad to strike a secret ownership deal with a person who the rest of the crew reckons was not in position to decide. Freenode is not a commercial enterprise. It's more like a community soccer club sold to a sponsor by a guy who happened to be a secretary with a stamp - after the years you've been tending the lawn and volunteering with training.

Yes, they are understandably pissed off, as one would be with hostile takeover by some renegade crypto prince (yes he really claims he's a prince).

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by fencepost on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @06:32PM (#27215379)
Also relevant is that while they might be able to fight it that would involve substantial personal outlay of lawyer money by volunteers (all so they could continue to volunteer) and as unpaid volunteers the first thing attacked would likely be questions of standing.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by BFatts on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @04:28PM (#27214054)
There are reports of Lee, or one of his contacts, offering admin roles for money basically to allow for paid harassment. Whether that is true or not isn't clear to me, but that would be a big issue if true.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by derangedHorse on Thursday May 20, 2021 @05:37PM (#27227646)
His broken promise that FreeNode will be run independent of his control is pretty objectionable. Like others have pointed out, you can even find hackernews posts from him saying that. The fact he’s now asserting control to self appoint what would essentially be the leader of a decades-long group of volunteers without their say-so is pretty ridiculous.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by fapjacks on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @08:14PM (#27215977)
At least some of this is because Andrew Lee is a supporter of Donald Trump and this rubs some people the wrong way.
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by dang on Thursday May 20, 2021 @12:14AM (#27217310)
Please don't take HN threads into partisan flamewar. Nothing good can come of this.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by fapjacks on Thursday May 20, 2021 @09:50PM (#27229661)
However this is a statement of fact, not partisanship on my part. How do you suggest someone say this in a more neutral fashion? You can see some of the comments in #libera on the new network, and here is one of the staffers saying it in their resignation letter: https://web.archive.org/web/20210520142350/https://blog.bofh...
Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by genmud on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @11:03PM (#27216916)
Is it supporting Trump which rubs people the wrong way, or that Trump supporters generally rub people the wrong way.

I know its a bit of semantics but I have found that many (if not most) of the loud and proud DT supporters are incredibly irritating. I find them just as bad or worse than the hyper politically correct/SJW crowd.

Re:Welcome to Libera Chat by fapjacks on Wednesday May 19, 2021 @11:43PM (#27217126)
I think we are exposed to the loudest and most annoying of these groups by media that has every incentive to showcase the nutjobs for clicks, and so this is what we remember, even though most people aren't this way.