News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Tech Loses Out by Fordec on Sunday May 02, 2021 @06:06PM (#27019501)
At the core of it, the very core of it, tech is waged work. Just like in manufacturing, which was outsourced quite prolifically. Tech isn't special in this regard.

The thing that hasn't come about yet though is, sales, marketing, accounting can also be outsourced. Dare I say automated. It is at the end of the day, still waged work. Marketing is not an asset class. Accounting isn't capital ownership. Fabrication is a tool, tech is a tool, social media is a tool.

The moment that this sort of stuff gets automated there will be a reckoning on how businesses are built in western society. I don't mean a saleforce competitor with a slicker UI, I mean completely abstracting away payroll and the like.

Imagine for a moment:

You could say to anyone, "I like the work you do want to work for me?" either in person, online, even here. They say yes. Now suddenly a pipeline process kicks off, like a CICD for recruitment. You have your budget metrics all in place, the receiver has their negotiation asks, etc. And AI hashes out a negotiation, in browser or on your phones etc. comes up with a negotiation contract, highlights the important bits or deal breakers that need a higher level sign off. "Click 'Yes' to work." Done. Hired. Here's your onboarding package and account credentials, your paycheck comes in at the end of the month.

All the while, the two people at the table or on twitter have just been continuing on with their lives. Nobody talked to HR. Nobody had to manually do filings with the IRS. The business owner never opened a dashboard or logged in to their negotiation.ai account. It is not this easy at the moment. But no rule of physics says it can't be in the future.

Entire classes of work could crumble while people could create in a much more competitive manner.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by jdgoesmarching on Sunday May 02, 2021 @07:24PM (#27020011)
It’s kind of terrifying how few people in this industry take this seriously and dismiss unionizing and organization efforts. Every publicly owned company is incentivized to squeeze every possible penny out of their income statement and we know from history that corporations will fight hard to eliminate high wage labor whenever possible.

Our salaries and power won’t last forever, and if we don’t turn around our culture of worshipping techno-aristocrats quickly then we’re all going to have a rough time in the next few decades.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by rawtxapp on Sunday May 02, 2021 @07:30PM (#27020042)
To play the devil's advocate, that would also mean keeping things inefficient on purpose to avoid job losses.

I want my taxes to be automatically by some computer without having to deal with a human that's more prone to errors. I want self-driving cars so that I don't have to deal with another human that's more prone to accidents, etc, etc. The list goes on.

I think it's inevitable that we will see some kind of UBI, otherwise there would be big revolutions when most jobs are automated to some degree.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by robocat on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:08PM (#27021221)
> I want my taxes to be automatically by some computer without having to deal with a human that's more prone to errors.

This is already in progress in New Zealand. The government simplified taxation rules and everything is fairly automated now, the payments and the end-of-year. I got an email this year from our IRD (≈IRS) telling me that my annual tax return was already completed by them (electronically) and I just needed to login to confirm/authorise it.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by mcbishop on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:58PM (#27021483)
There's an argument that tax prep companies block that automation in the U.S.: https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/otm/episodes/its-tax-ti...
Re:How Tech Loses Out by matkoniecz on Monday May 03, 2021 @02:50AM (#27022335)
Re:How Tech Loses Out by matkoniecz on Monday May 03, 2021 @02:48AM (#27022324)
In Poland taxation rules were not simplified, but tax filings for individuals are automatically generated based on documents supplied by employees.

You only need to claim subsidies, select NGO which gets your 1% of tax - or skip that,

Tax files itself automatically,

If you are in weird situation, you can relatively easily modify it.

Tax code is still awful (not sure whether I filed taxes correctly due to my weird situation), but frontend is one of better sites that I have seen. And the best government site that I encountered.

Any functional government can setup this.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by tremon on Monday May 03, 2021 @07:43AM (#27023842)
Same in NL, your employer already supplies the tax service with your wage information, and banks already supply the tax service with year-in/year-out balance information on your accounts. You can login on their portal, verify the pre-filled data on the form, and submit it. You only need to enter your own deductibles, if relevant.
Re:How Tech Loses Out by skinkestek on Monday May 03, 2021 @01:48AM (#27022004)
Around here taxes are automatically deducted from my income by the employeer.

Skatteetaten (≈IRS) then sends us a letter in early spring telling us what we owe or what we will get back, we get a chance to add extra expenses etc and then a final calculation is done and you either get an invoice or a payment, most likely a small payment as taxes payments are typically slightly larger than they need to be.

Except if you run a business, then it is slightly more complicated depending on the size of your business, if you have employees etc. I have a small company so I need to report income from the company as well.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by Ygg2 on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:14AM (#27023014)
> I think it's inevitable that we will see some kind of UBI

Is it though? I don't think it's impossible we see some kind of cyberpunk dystopia, where powerful live isolated lives, protected by the police/military, and the rest live in squalor.

What happens if you automate everything, and realize you don't need to feed millions of mouths. And, hey, police-military complex is already automated, so just send the drones and let them remove the excess humans.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by commandlinefan on Monday May 03, 2021 @02:20PM (#27028761)
> some kind of cyberpunk dystopia, where powerful live isolated lives, protected by the police/military, and the rest live in squalor.

Even in that scenario, if all useful work is truly automated, there's either still some sort of UBI (just not enough to live comfortably) or the people living in squalor are subsistence farmers eating whatever they can manage to grow in whatever land they can lay claim to.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by goatinaboat on Monday May 03, 2021 @04:32AM (#27022801)
To play the devil's advocate, that would also mean keeping things inefficient on purpose to avoid job losses.

Well... yes? The purpose of life isn't just to enhance shareholder value. Some stuff really is just inefficient of course but a lot of what looks like inefficiency in a pure economic sense is actually what people back in the day would have called living a good and satisfying and meaningful life.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by rawtxapp on Monday May 03, 2021 @11:13AM (#27026121)
Imagine if we did that when printing presses came along replacing the scribes or cars came along replacing the coachman, our civilization would stagnate.
Re:How Tech Loses Out by goatinaboat on Wednesday May 05, 2021 @03:19AM (#27047085)
Imagine if we did that when printing presses came along replacing the scribes or cars came along replacing the coachman, our civilization would stagnat

Yes, there are things that have taken genuine inefficiencies out, I wouldn't go back to the days e.g. of standing in a queue at the bank rather than online banking. But an efficient world looks like 996 and I don't think that's actually a good way to live https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/996_working_hour_system

Re:How Tech Loses Out by throw123123123 on Sunday May 02, 2021 @07:57PM (#27020208)
I'm very excited about this reckoning. New grad engineers making 200/300k a year in the US vs Sr 10+ YOE engineers make 40k a year globally will be a wonderful collision.

Better get more tech stock when that happens!

Re:How Tech Loses Out by throwawaygh on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:26PM (#27021311)
New grads don’t make 200k a year. There are some rare exceptions. Top kids from top schools. Very occasionally a quite special kid from a non-top school. It’s not normal.

And IMO the majority of 10+ Yoe engineers are actually 1 yoe * 10, or more usually 2 yoe * 5.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by rawtxapp on Monday May 03, 2021 @02:35AM (#27022264)
I think the parent comment is talking about Silicon Valley salaries where the ballpark starting compensation at FAANG is roughly in line with ~180k$ (that was my starting comp many years ago, it probably has increased since). In the Bay, that's the norm, but then again, cost of living is also very high.

You don't have to be from a top school, but it does help.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by throwawaygh on Monday May 03, 2021 @11:26AM (#27026303)
Yes, I know. But again, it’s not even close to normal. There are a LOT of engineers outside of the bay and the fangs.

It’s a bit like saying that finance pays well in Manhattan. Sure. But most people in the USA who work in finance are making mid/high 5 figures. Wall Street is small.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by tarsinge on Monday May 03, 2021 @03:08AM (#27022412)
That’s not terrifying, that’s awesome. Economists were saying decades ago that near the year 2000 we shouldn’t working much because of the gains of productivity. We would be free while everything would be automated. But instead we have billionaires confiscating the gains and owning the means of production. Not arguing, just saying automating work isn’t bad and can be good in itself, that’s the society rules that make it so.
Re:How Tech Loses Out by specialist on Monday May 03, 2021 @07:57AM (#27023941)
Automation implies boosting productivity. Who gets to keep the surplus (profit)?

During New Deal and Great Society, Capital shared that surplus with Labor. Since the mid 1970s, not so much.

Instead of automating, we could simply eliminate huge swathes of work. Squint a bit, and all the bureaucratic burden (bullshit jobs) just look like very complicated rent seeking.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by novok on Sunday May 02, 2021 @06:52PM (#27019793)
So you mean, how work was done before the modern nation state, income tax, passports, visas and mass literacy? All of the work you describe was created by human bureaucracies for human bureaucracies. Beforehand you didn't need the paperwork.
Re:How Tech Loses Out by Fordec on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:11PM (#27021235)
The difference being, before there was no paperwork, at all. In such an automated system, the checks, balances and oversight all still exist. They're just invisible to the human eye rather than libertarian style just gone.
Re:How Tech Loses Out by novok on Monday May 03, 2021 @09:01PM (#27032904)
You don't need AI or advanced software for automated background bureaucracy made well. All of that is possible today, and the amount of extra work it is today consuming human time is still ultimately a choice of humanity.
Re:How Tech Loses Out by tgbugs on Sunday May 02, 2021 @07:29PM (#27020036)
The real trick will be to make sure that the AI negotiating on your behalf is really your advocate and has not somehow been subverted (by any variety of means).
Re:How Tech Loses Out by Fordec on Monday May 03, 2021 @01:19AM (#27021865)
Basically the same dilemma industries with actual union representation encounter when individuals are picking what union to join today. Some unions have lower membership prices, some have more negotiation strength, is the organization competent etc.
Re:How Tech Loses Out by sgt101 on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:05AM (#27022961)
Also solving the complexity of dominant negotiation strategies in unconstrained settings algorithmically would be good
Re:How Tech Loses Out by meowkit on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:56PM (#27021161)
Sounds like a business opportunity if 3rd party algorithms become a thing. Pick our negotiation bot! Will get you the best deal! Only $100 per analysis!
Re:How Tech Loses Out by Fordec on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:13PM (#27021245)
Then go a step further and get ensemble negotiation bots that aggregate the negotiation providers. Or meta-negotiate the best deal among the negotiation AI providers.
Re:How Tech Loses Out by Mengkudulangsat on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:38PM (#27020427)
Sounds like a precursor to Distributed Autonomous Organizations. Although previous experiments in these have been disastrous to say the least, I find the idea very appealing.
Re:How Tech Loses Out by pm90 on Monday May 03, 2021 @02:05AM (#27022093)
Would you know where I could read up more on Distributed Autonomous Organizations? Sounds fascinating.
Re:How Tech Loses Out by Mengkudulangsat on Monday May 03, 2021 @02:43AM (#27022306)
The DAO fiasco from a few years ago [1] comes to mind. Personally I think capital allocation is way too complex an endeavor to automate. Data annotations maybe...

[1] https://www.gemini.com/cryptopedia/the-dao-hack-makerdao#sec...

Re:How Tech Loses Out by zo1 on Monday May 03, 2021 @02:27AM (#27022234)
Not quite what you were asking, but the first thing that popped into my head are "dispute resolution organizations" which come from Libertarianism and other schools of thought. Might be an interesting avenue of reading if you want to learn more about inter-actor relations and contracts in the absence of centralized control.
Re:How Tech Loses Out by medium_burrito on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:10PM (#27020289)
Automation is the next outsourcing. I'm one of the people making it happen.

People forget that it doesn't need to be 100% automated. If I can automate 25% of the work of a staff-level engineer, that's amazing. If I can do 50% of a junior engineer, superb.

Right now software engineering is still in baby steps as far as tools are concerned, but the next decade will see some remarkable stuff happen once we have a more solid foundation and start applying the previous few decades' progress in machine learning and statistics.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by brandonmenc on Sunday May 02, 2021 @09:20PM (#27020678)
> People forget that it doesn't need to be 100% automated. If I can automate 25% of the work of a staff-level engineer, that's amazing. If I can do 50% of a junior engineer, superb.

This has been the trend since ENIAC.

And yet, the demand for programming is higher than ever. It could be another century before those lines intersect. Maybe longer.

We keep automating ourselves up into higher levels, only to discover that there is a ton more work to be done up there. Which, imo, is a very good thing.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by groby_b on Monday May 03, 2021 @12:34AM (#27021632)
You know, I truly hope that's true. At the same point, that has been the mantra for a while. Back in the 80's, when I was but a wee lass, as it came time to choose a college path, my uncle warned me not to get into software engineering because his buddies at IBM told me that it'd be all automated away in the next decade.

4GLs happened, but the work didn't really become less. (And 5GL spectacularly face-planted)

In the 90s, we got widespread adoption of the Internet and search engines, and the prognosis was we'd just be able to look up everything.

In the aughts, it was javascript & frameworks that were going to eat everybody's lunch.

In the 2010s, did we ever build fancy linear regressions^W^W^W machine learning solutions.

We always talk about how that somehow would reduce the work, but instead we continue to build barely maintainable mountains of complexity at the outer edge of what we can handle.

I wish you success. I'm not holding my breath it'll significantly reduce software engineering work. It'll shift what we do, no doubt. I'd be surprised if this is the decade where we make a significant dent. We'll just heap on more complexity.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by brazzy on Monday May 03, 2021 @01:04AM (#27021773)
> Back in the 80's, when I was but a wee lass, as it came time to choose a college path, my uncle warned me not to get into software engineering because his buddies at IBM told me that it'd be all automated away in the next decade.

> 4GLs happened, but the work didn't really become less. (And 5GL spectacularly face-planted)

Hah. The pipe dream is older than that.

They said that in 5 year's time there would be no demand for professional programmers. You see, there's this new programming languge that's so easy to use that anyone can write the software they need themselves.

That was in 1960.

The language was COBOL.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by adrianN on Monday May 03, 2021 @12:50AM (#27021704)
There is still _so much_ untapped demand for programming that I'm not terribly worried about partial automation. Just look how many manual processes exist is governments or large corporations that would be more efficient and less error prone if a computer assisted, but the necessary programming is still too expensive to switch over. Sure, programmer wages might decrease in the future to more reasonable levels, but I don't see mass unemployment looming.
Re:How Tech Loses Out by torgian on Monday May 03, 2021 @01:19AM (#27021858)
I hope not. Today’s reasonable ( 100k a year? 150k? ) is tomorrow’s poverty.
Re:How Tech Loses Out by adrianN on Monday May 03, 2021 @03:34AM (#27022552)
Surely you're either joking or implying that 90% of the people live in poverty.
Re:How Tech Loses Out by torgian on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @12:38AM (#27034118)
From what I’ve seen, I’d say around 50-60% of the world population lives in poverty or close to it.

But take the States. In the 1980s, having a 120,000 usd annual salary would be insane. You could buy a nice place in Santa Barbara for that money.

Due to inflation, that same salary buys much much less in today’s money.

Give it another 20 years, 120k per year will buy even less than that.

But now consider that most people in the 80s would make 20-40k per year. That was enough to have a good life on the high end. A decent car, a house in a good area with a mortgage.

Can you do that now? No. Not unless you live in the sticks, and good luck finding a job there!

So to suggest that engineer salaries should be “more reasonable” is basically saying you want people to be poor in twenty years. Because that’s exactly what will happen.

Oh and your future 40k per year job will be even harder to make ends meet, if nigh impossible, because most jobs will not be in cheap areas to live.

Hell, even the cheaper areas to live are more expensive now.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by LegitGandalf on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:20PM (#27020355)
>The thing that hasn't come about yet though is, sales, marketing, accounting can also be outsourced. Dare I say automated.

Yep, just consider how much sales, marketing and accounting work the App and Play store has automated. Not to mention software delivery and installation work.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by specialist on Monday May 03, 2021 @07:47AM (#27023882)
1/2 of jobs are pointless. 1/2 of labor will be automated.

Coincidence?

It'd be amusing to re-score the highest risk jobs with the bullshit jobs criteria, measure the overlap.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_Jobs

https://willrobotstakemyjob.com/highest-risk-jobs

I worry that automating bullshit jobs will embed those tasks deeper into our economy, like technical debt. Better to just eliminate the bullshit jobs.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by TheCoelacanth on Monday May 03, 2021 @04:55PM (#27030516)
I think it might not be a coincidence, just in the opposite direction you are suggesting. The non-bullshit jobs will be automated, the bullshit will remain. Many of categories of bullshit jobs are actually unusually resistant to automation.

> flunkies, who serve to make their superiors feel important, e.g., receptionists, administrative assistants, door attendants

Impossible to automate. The whole point of the job is to be wasting a human's time to feed someone's ego.

> goons, who act to harm or deceive others on behalf of their employer, e.g., lobbyists, corporate lawyers, telemarketers, public relations specialists

Automation will make your goons more effective, but the arms race against the other side's goons who also have automation will prevent the jobs from going away.

> duct tapers, who temporarily fix problems that could be fixed permanently, e.g., programmers repairing shoddy code, airline desk staff who calm passengers whose bags do not arrive

If they aren't going to pay the upfront cost to fix the problem, they aren't going to pay the upfront cost to automate it either.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by benhurmarcel on Monday May 03, 2021 @08:12AM (#27024071)
It seems to me that you overestimate the cost of people making all that happen currently, and underestimate the difficulty of automating it (and maintain that automation).

A lot of work isn't impossible to automate, it's just not worth the cost. Lots of people unfortunately earn very low salaries, they're cheaper than a machine. This is the case both in manufacturing, and administration.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by Noos on Monday May 03, 2021 @03:15AM (#27022456)
But who would they sell things to?

I mean, if we're just down to the capital class, there simply will not be enough of them to buy from each other to sustain an economy. Those payroll and hr people also happen to buy people's products, which AI never will. If there is no IRS and no tax filers, there goes a lot of purchasing power.

You can't create or compete if no one is there to buy them.

Re:How Tech Loses Out by Fordec on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:21AM (#27023063)
Skipping over the same argument that comes up every time an industry gets threatened. Farmers, Textile workers, Miners, Machine Operators. It boils down to an inability to see what comes next and a fear for ones own quarter in the year the argument gets made.

But why can't AI buy products? What makes a purchase more legitimate by the click of a human finger over the automated confirmation by a piece of software? Hierarchy of needs? Why can't automated systems that have energy, networking, AWS Bill's etc. not also have needs?

And then there's a simple fact of there is a finite number of moths to feed. In the billions, but finite. Why can't an industry of trillions of digital actors, that scales far faster than biological ones, not be an even bigger economy in it's own right?

Re:How Tech Loses Out by mellavora on Monday May 03, 2021 @05:47AM (#27023192)
we could automate the purchasing? Remember the stories about self-driving taxis which would purchase their own maintenance out of their earnings? I think it was supposed to use blockchain.

Our current economy seems to rely on "the modern consumer", as per your point-- and we are told that our main role is to "consume". Seems to me this would be extremely easy to automate. Then we don't need people any more, the robots can consume themselves!

Anyone want a paperclip?