News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by bradleyjg on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:30AM (#27014696)
People asked for the feature. The company gave a reasonable explanation of why they didn’t want to do it—-that it would increase the burden on them. As a very reasonable compromise they coded up the feature and are offering it to actual customers. That way they can offset the extra burden with money, again from actual customers. Nothing about this is unreasonable except the massively entitled whining.

This should be cross posted to r/BeggingChoosers.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by ratww on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:35AM (#27014736)
This is not a feature, though, especially not a new one. This is just asking for payment for the software to not do something to your machine. This kind of behaviour so far was only present in ransomware.

All the code required for this to work was already there. They only spent developer time changing it to only be available to Pro users.

You can rationalise this all you want, but this is just hostile, desperate and lazy behaviour from a company that's too desperate to make money, but is has continuously proven to be unable to come up with better ideas for attracting paid users. As others have mentioned, they got millions in funding so far but still have no idea how to make money.

Had it been announced a month earlier people would be sure it was an April Fool's joke.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by ryandrake on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:37PM (#27016575)
Crazy how "not doing something unwanted to my computer" is considered a feature.

I remember when the user was in control of their own computer, not rando 3rd party companies. I issue a command to the computer, and the computer executes the command. If I want to update a piece of software, I update it. I guess this is a dinosaur mentality now.

This whole "allow the software to do whatever the developer's company wants or stop using the software" trend is pretty nasty.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by m463 on Monday May 03, 2021 @01:03AM (#27021769)
Honestly, I remember getting into computers because everything was getting better. New capabilities made things faster, easier and smarter.

But sometime around the early 2000's businesses started exercising more control over the users.

I think it was basically the iphone that started a lot of bad precedents by removing the ability for the user to run his own software - both through he app store, and strict control by apple of what software could run on the phone.

I think this was initially done for security/piracy/etc, but the power grab self-propagated.

Apple thinks they are responsible for your iphone, but now they think they own it.

And when control was reverted to apple, they decided it was not important for people to see what was running on their phone, what it was doing, and who it was talking to.

At that point, software companies had more control over your phone than the users.

To me, the promise of computers got sort of tarnished - it's a little bit of a dark age.

When I hear of a new convenient feature, or smart-iot thing, I think that it will benefit the business and compromise the user.

But I still believe -- I think linux phones and tablets will be important checks and balances that can return control to the user and return to a more positive future.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by cyanydeez on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:49PM (#27020488)
you are in control: 1. install 2. uninstall 3. pay for things
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by xvector on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:46AM (#27014822)
No one is making you run Docker Desktop. It is not holding you hostage. There are alternatives in this very thread. Comparing it to ransomware is absurd.
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by krzepah on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:23PM (#27016473)
When I read things like that it pulls me away even further from continuing CS. How blind are you that you do not realise that forcing a software execution is not ransomeware ?

I'll tell you what's wrong here : Docker is a fantastic technology but it simply couldn't find a suitable market tactic.

Now it resolves to this shitty practices. I don't even know how you can begin to think that it would add ANY burden to them NOT to run the update on your computer.

And here is my problem : It's my computer, I decide what is ran on it or not.

Next day we have some idiot getting keys on the docker update system and we simply have built a technologic crash because suddenly nobody can decide wether that update is ran or not.

Keeping control away of the user is the most stupid thing there is.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by bradleyjg on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:33PM (#27016538)
> It's my computer, I decide what is ran on it or not.

Absolutely nothing docker has done contradicts this. You want docker desktop, you install docker desktop. You don’t, you don’t.

Docker has no obligation to provide a piece of software (for free!) with exactly the feature set you want. I can’t understand how anyone could think they do.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by closeparen on Sunday May 02, 2021 @03:39PM (#27018284)
I installed the Docker Desktop I wanted. Then you reached into my machine, deleted it, and replaced it with something else I didn’t want. I don’t understand how anyone could think they have the right to do that. A desktop application is not a SaaS website. Docker Desktop is the thing it was when I downloaded it, not a piece of real estate on my machine for you to manage remotely as you see fit.
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by xvector on Sunday May 02, 2021 @03:52PM (#27018412)
> I installed the Docker Desktop I wanted. Then you reached into my machine, deleted it, and replaced it with something else I didn’t want.

To clarify, you installed a piece of software with this capability. Thus, you did not install a piece of software you wanted.

Furthermore, Docker has the right to write software that functions and updates as they wish. You have the right to not install it. It's really that simple.

A lot of software today is auto-updating, where updates cannot be disabled, if they can even be delayed. It's the developers' choice whether they want their software to function like this, your choice whether you want to install it.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by Nicksil on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @11:56AM (#27038974)
>Absolutely nothing docker has done contradicts this.

Sure it does. It updates the software automatically with seemingly no way of stopping the behavior without first paying a fee.

Regardless of the intent of the individual installing the software on their machine, once installed it absolutely executes on its own; there's no denying this.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by aflag on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:58AM (#27014898)
Fair enough, ransomware is certainly an exaggeration, but the absurdity of it comes from the fact that not upgrading it just means they don’t do anything, whereas they are actively doing something and asking for money not to. Usually, people pay money to other people to solve their problems, in this case the same people asking for money to solve the problem are the people creating the problem in the first place.
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by salawat on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:19PM (#27016456)
No it isn't, not the way in whch the comparison was made.

Previously, ransomware (and some games/media) were tge only software products that asked for a higher price tag to not install extra code the user did not want on their machine.

It is a fundamentally predatory practice, because the developers completely misunderstand consent. Just because I have some or a version of your software running, doesn't mean I want to invite you the hypothetical software developer to live on my system, auto updating things from under me.

It's a pattern that has fought harder and harder amongst softdev people to ignore the sanctity of other people's computer for the user's own good that needs to die.

Not comparing it to ransomware is absurd, frankly. The more it's normalized, the more people will reach for it as a business model.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by ryandrake on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:39PM (#27016595)
If not ransomware, it's at least malware, as is anything that modifies the user's computer without consent. Also, this all-or-nothing "accept whatever the developer demands or uninstall and go away" mentality is not helpful, and a false dilemma.
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by kordlessagain on Sunday May 02, 2021 @09:47AM (#27015243)
Docker even uninstalled itself from my computer!
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by pjc50 on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:37AM (#27014747)
I call this class of thing "antifeatures". Vendor bloatware tends to be made of them.
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by stingraycharles on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:33AM (#27016126)
> This is just asking for payment for the software to not do something to your machine.

I think you’re underestimating the cost for a business to support clients that do not upgrade to the latest version of your software.

You’re not paying for the software to “do nothing”, you’re paying for the cost of Docker having a wider variety of software versions to support.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by ratww on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:47AM (#27016251)
No, I'm really not.

Docker doesn't have to support anything they don't want. They can support only the latest version and just refuse to support obsolete versions. They can even deprecate API endpoints for versions they don't want to use anymore and ask users to upgrade. They could even sell support for those obsolete versions. This is how a large part of the industry operates and a great strategy for making money.

Docker Desktop is an app that runs on local computers. Just as everyone doesn't want Google or Apple forcing things on them, I also don't want third-party software developers doing the same and risking breaking my workflow because they didn't give me the opportunity control and be careful about my upgrades.

This is entirely possible. I also work on a company that sells Desktop apps, but we sell to non-technical users. All those users understand that upgrading to the latest version is routine when you have issues.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by closeparen on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:19PM (#27016450)
As far as I’m concerned Docker Desktop, like most desktop software, was finished years ago. No update has ever benefitted me in any way. But many of them have broken things.

I don’t need “support” to slowly triage, troubleshoot, and develop a fix when I know I can always fix the problem right now by downgrading.

I don’t need “bug fixes” or “stability improvements” when the only threat to stability is the updates. I just need it to stop fucking updating.

If I need it to do something new I’ll upgrade. By 99% of the time I need it to keep doing what it did yesterday.

[dead]
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by closeparen on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:29PM (#27016516)
Alice gives Bob free stuff, therefore Alice is entitled to kick in Bob’s door at 3am, take back the free stuff, and replace it with something else? And Bob must be grateful to Alice for this?
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by waheoo on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:47AM (#27014833)
It's not free, its open source. They decided to build a company on the backs of a community that is more conducive to open source than closed source.

They got theirs. There wasn't anything free about it. They are the ones that fucked up and failed to build a successful business around an immensely popular tool.

This hostile behaviour towards a community that gave them everything is disgusting.

Companies ignoring social responsibility is pretty bad, but people white knighting dark patterns is so much worse.

This shitty behavior is so typical of docker. Their GitHub repos are absolutely full of shitty responses to the communities needs.

Their poor behavior and failure to work with enterprise is what resulted in k8s, rkt, and everything in between.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by Operyl on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:59AM (#27014914)
As much as I think this entire thing is silly, let’s set one fact straight: Docker Desktop is not open source.
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by hda111 on Tuesday May 04, 2021 @04:22AM (#27035177)
I suspect Docker-ce to be going closed source as well. They deprecated the repo docker-ce so you can only think what happens next.
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by alex_hirner on Sunday May 02, 2021 @09:03AM (#27014934)
> but is too lazy to come up with better ideas

How can you say they are lazy about that?

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by alex_hirner on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:20PM (#27016459)
FWIW, parent rephrased the quoted text in the meantime but without edit history.
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by fnord77 on Sunday May 02, 2021 @08:39AM (#27014766)
I bet they didn't check with the FTC before doing this.
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by ericol on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:13AM (#27015475)
People didn't "ask for this feature".

People asked for the feature to be disabled. There was a lengthy discussion in GH [0] aptly named "Please don't upgrade docker without asking first" few months back regarding why this shouldn't happen (auto updates, that is).

Considering that the team that codes the software acknowledged they screwed up [1] having to pay for this I have to agree with the comment that says this amounts to ransomware. "Pay us or risk getting f*ked up by our updates".

[0] https://github.com/docker/roadmap/issues/183 [1] https://github.com/docker/roadmap/issues/183#issuecomment-74...

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by bradleyjg on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:27AM (#27015596)
Ransomware holds your pictures, documents, data hostage unless you pay money. Nothing you paid for or created is being held hostage here.

The solution to your problem is entirely in your hands, just hit that uninstall button.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by have_faith on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:13AM (#27015963)
> Nothing you paid for or created is being held hostage here.

Nothing paid for sure but what happens when an auto update removes a feature you relied on previously? it's completely in their right to remove this feature from their product, it's their product, but it feels very disrespectful to potentially automatically remove working code from my machine unless I pay up.

I actually think the two sides to this argument completely come down to whether or not you see this as a "dick move" or not. I see it as a dick move, they have every right to do it, but now I'm looking for alternatives as dick moves usually predict more dick moves in the future.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by Aeolun on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:14AM (#27015971)
Uh, you’ve been happily using docker for years and have your entire infra built on it, only to have the company suddenly decide that auto update is a great idea and break your stuff all the time?

Like, it’s not ransomware, but it’s not as if you can snap your fingers and move to something else.

Even if you can, that seems entirely counterproductive for the Docker company.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by sleepybrett on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:54PM (#27016728)
just pushes more people to podman, cri-o, etc.
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by yrro on Monday May 03, 2021 @03:20AM (#27022488)
Your critical infra runs on docker desktop?
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by joshmanders on Monday May 03, 2021 @10:19AM (#27025391)
Yes it does. It may not run on it in production but a lot of us use it locally to replicate production as closely as possible. If my local machine is broken because they pushed out yet another breaking change and FORCED me to upgrade from a working version to that broken version.
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by ericol on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:38AM (#27015673)
I didn't meant that literally.

> The solution to your problem is entirely in your hands, just hit that uninstall button

Well, you might be correct here, but still having automatic updates as a paid feature seems a bit excessive.

Applying your logic, having to paid for such a basic feature is madness.

Don't forget people found out about this in the worst case possible. Imaging starting to use the app, then they introduce a breaking change and when you go researching you find out that you have to pay for avoiding breaking updates.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by bradleyjg on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:45AM (#27015725)
I grew up with shareware, nagware, and crippleware. It was annoying and we grumbled some but at the end of the day recognized that people were trying to make a living.

This doesn’t seem nearly as bad as that. They don’t want hundreds of different versions out there. As much as people claim otherwise they will get bug reports from old versions. Anyone that’s ever supported users knows that’s going to happen.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by Lev1a on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:22AM (#27016030)
> They don’t want hundreds of different versions out there. As much as people claim otherwise they will get bug reports from old versions. Anyone that’s ever supported users knows that’s going to happen.

- Make it clear that only a certain version or a sliding window of versions is supported.

- Close reports from unsupported versions.

- Done.

Other projects/companies do this just fine last I checked.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by bradleyjg on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:12PM (#27016401)
If that works for you, you should definitely run your business that way. Likewise, if you’re a customer of docker I’m sure they’ll be very happy to hear from you as to what it’ll will take to keep your business.

Yesterday I grabbed a free book off a stoop in Brooklyn. Should I go on Twitter and trash the homeowner because there are pencil marks in it?

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by grayhatter on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:43PM (#27016632)
Do the pencil marks randomly appear on pages you needed to read because the homeowner magically changed them remotely? Did the homeowner then tell you, that you could make it stop happening if you paid them? I think yeah, you should trash the homeowner for being a dick in that case. Sure, free book, and the homeowner assumedly thinks the book is better that way, but at what point does this 'free book' became the responsibility of the new owner? Where's the line between the as is, and as is but we're gonna randomly make it worse?
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by mthoms on Sunday May 02, 2021 @03:26PM (#27018149)
Let's use your analogy. Is it okay for a free ebook to remotely update (in a way that makes the version you previously downloaded gone forever)? How about a free documentary you downloaded? A textbook?

Would it still be okay if the update takes content away or otherwise makes the item less valuable? What if it introduces content you find objectionable, and don't want on you machine? Still okay?

No, it's not. That's ridiculous.

If you agree to give something away for free as part of your business strategy then you can make all the changes you want to future versions. You can even stop offering new downloads or updates for free at all. What you shouldn't be able to do is retroactively change the product you already gave me for free.

You made a business decision. If it later turns out it was a bad one then tough luck. I have rights as a consumer and as a human being. Yes, even if you give me something for free. To suggest otherwise is blatantly anti-consumer and morally bankrupt.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by ctvo on Sunday May 02, 2021 @05:15PM (#27019085)
Your whole series of replies has been "Docker can do whatever they want, don't like it? Uninstall!"

People are sharing their opinion on the direction of a popular software product. I'm confident they understand how to uninstall Docker if that was their intention. Continuously pointing out it's free like that's a valid defense is mind boggling.

> Yesterday I grabbed a free book off a stoop in Brooklyn. Should I go on Twitter and trash the homeowner because there are pencil marks in it?

For this to be valid, the homeowner who left the book out is demanding you pay them money otherwise they'll enter YOUR home and update the content of the book next time you try to read it. Of course this is completely acceptable because you can always throw the book away.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by VWWHFSfQ on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:31AM (#27015637)
omg I feel like a freaking alien right now. What are these people talking about
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by ericol on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:40AM (#27015683)
Well, it's a slow Sunday. How's yours going?

I don't mind explaining something in more detail, just let me know what.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by ljm on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:08AM (#27015432)
I don't see it that way. The team has released new versions with major issues on a fairly regular basis, and this was exacerbated by having a forced auto-update that could only be resolved by dropping down to v2.5. So they pushed people to an older, stable version they didn't want to support.

To my mind, the decision here shouldn't have been to make people pay protection money to stop a new release breaking their setup. They could make the whole damn thing paid-for instead and I'd be happier with that.

There is clearly something missing in their development and QA process that causes this auto-updating to be so visible and painful. They could have kept the feature as-is and worked on making sure new releases were solid, while also having a mechanism to revert.

I have no problem with my browser updating itself that way, as I never notice if something broken and got rolled back in the canary stage.

To be honest, avoiding criticism by whining about entitlement adds no more to the conversation than pure entitlement itself. I can't see any purpose it serves other than to start a flame war.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by syllogism on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:17AM (#27015996)
They didn't just put out Docker with a sign up that said "free stuff" though. They actively solicited the users; they told the community "Hey, use our software, you can trust us". If you do that you do have an obligation.

It's like, if you beg your friend to let you give them a lift and don't show up, you can't turn around and call them a "choosey beggar" because the lift was supposed to be free.

The response in that thread isn't _remotely_ reasonable, of course you can't make a developer tool like this auto-update.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by cutemonster on Monday May 03, 2021 @02:42AM (#27022305)
Or give away free tree planks to build houses, but then later you say now everyone has to pay for the planks, or you'll magically change the planks to an a bit weaker kind of tree.
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by wildrhythms on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:31AM (#27015636)
I don't understand- people aren't asking for Docker desktop developers to support old versions of its software in perpetuity; people are asking to forego an auto-update at their own risk. What burden do you think this places on the Docker desktop developers exactly?
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by skeeter2020 on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:07AM (#27015920)
That's how I understood it. It would be very entitled to say "Don't force me to update and support my old version until I'm ready". This move seems like the opposite of what we all expect: There's a new version, the one you are on is EOL, upgrade or beware. What was wrong with this, other than it didn't support their revenue goals?
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by cyberge99 on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:33PM (#27021053)
They’re bot saying update OR beware.

They’re saying update OR your program is dead.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by anonymousab on Sunday May 02, 2021 @11:54AM (#27016295)
There is a popular modern form of thought that developers should be the ones to decide which versions of their software are running sheets anywhere and what versions they are; that they are entitled to that level of control, and should exercise it because their users cannot be trusted to make an informed decision about running outdated and insecure software.

I think it's paternalistic and egotistical but the usual counterpoint is grandma getting a virus because Windows is unknowingly out of date. With developer tooling that holds a bit less water IMO.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by sarsway on Sunday May 02, 2021 @10:45AM (#27015722)
Sure it's in their right to do, and we can't expect to get everything for free, but making "skip update" a paid feature? How tasteless is that, do we really want to defend that? You see that button as a free user and its a bit of a slap in the face, isn't it. It doesn't make me want to pay, it makes me think the company is completely out of touch. I'd rather uninstall and look for alternatives, then pay for skip updates.
Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by bradleyjg on Sunday May 02, 2021 @12:18PM (#27016447)
> it makes me think the company is completely out of touch

As interest rates come up off the zero bound companies are increasingly going to have to learn how to make profits again. The culture this is out of touch with is not long for this world.

Re:Ignoring Docker updates is a paid feature now? by spamalot159 on Sunday May 02, 2021 @01:24PM (#27017004)
After reading your comment I think I agree with you. Most software nowadays requires you to update if you want it to keep working. You cannot play an online videogame without updating to the latest version. There is typically no way to use a previuse version of a website or web app.

We have gotten more entitled and now when we see something that doesn't exactly meet our liking then we cry about it.