Oh I wouldn't be so sure about that. From their FAQ:
" Why are we pre-farming?
Chia has a novel business model to both, lower volatility of the coin and increase adoption. By loaning Chia and managing the interest rates of those loans as well as other tools like buying our stock with chia coins, we hope to lower the quarter to quarter volatility of the coin. To drive adoption, we intend to loan Chia to Global 5000 companies who will use it to pay their international vendors quickly, less expensively, and more securely. We also intend to use the strategic reserve to aid development and adoption. We plan to do things like invest in promising startups in the Chia ecosystem, potentially increase farming rewards during limited periods of time to spur additional farming, and fund corporations paying 105% of the value of their international payables in Chia instead of fiat currency.
Is Chia doing an ICO?
No. Chia is not planning an ICO. Instead, our goal is to take the company’s equity public on an American stock exchange. This way, shareholders can share risk and return with management with transparency and disclosure and we can use well understood corporate controls to make binding statements about how Chia Network intends to use the Strategic Reserve. The Chia digital money is meant to be a useful payment instrument and not an investment opportunity. Chia intends to complete a fully compliant SEC registered equity IPO and will come to market as market-timing is amenable after the launch of mainnet. "
Bitcoin may not be what it set out to be, but how is that a bad thing? The market decided whatever it should be.
What bitcoin did is inspire creation of many, genuinely interesting currencies, some even learning from bitcoin's failings: Stellar.org that aims to form a new kind of backbone for instant worldwide asset transfers; Monero that enables anonymous payments; and MakerDAO that makes it possible to transact across borders with a stable digital-currency, DAI.
Banks (like eco, onjuno, dharma) and other financial instruments on the Ethereum network (like curve, aave, compound) are a reality today. The space is far more than just currencies. Besides, networks like Cosmos, Polkadot are going to enable an even richer crossover among various currency networks that today is exclusive to Ethereum altcoins via uniswap, mdex et al.
I agree that mining seems like a lot of waste but Delegated Proof of Stake and other advances aim to address those issues.
I take you're specifically interested in what's known as "DeFi" (decentralised finance)?
Multiple things going on on that front, but you could start here: https://archive.is/bJQt4 (coincentral); this video's a pretty good overview on Ethereum's DeFi ecosystem https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/k9HYC0EJU6E and this one on what's happened in just 2020 https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/qFBYB4W2tqU
DeFi, today, is poised to grow beyond Ethereum. Check out cross-chain networks like Polkadot (https://archive.is/GZVlM) and Cosmos (https://archive.is/1pWHF). matic.network (now Polygon) is another interesting side-chain network that seeks to take Ethereum tokens cross-chain.
If you're looking to build a DeFi product on Ethereum, docs at 0x.org, aave.com are good places to start (since they integrate out of the box with decentralised exchanges like Uniswap, Balancer etc). Circle.com, Sendwyre.com, Simplex.com, and Nowpayments.io are some of the leading providers for fiat <-> crypto-currency transfer. I am sure Binance has some offering in this space too.
> We have academic papers and presentations that give detail about our new consensus algorithm and blockchain software. In 2019 we revealed our Green Paper outlining the construction of Proofs of Space and Time and illustrating many of the design choices of Chia.
>
> We have updated our consensus algorithm and you can review and commment on our working document.
>
> There is also a 2019 talk from Mariano Sorgente at MIT on how to achieve Nakamoto consensus with Proof of Space and VDFs.
>
> Bram Cohen presented at Stanford on February 2018 on Proofs of Space. Our advisors, Dan Boneh, Benedikt Bünz, and Ben Fisch published a survey of VDFs which are the underlying technology of Proof of Time. Lipa Long published an explanation of class groups that our Proofs of Time is based on. Bram presented Beyond Hellman’s Time-Memory Trade-Offs with Applications to Proofs of Space at BPASE ‘18 in January 2018 based on the academic paper and these slides by Hamza Abusalah. Ben Fisch gave a talk at BPASE 2018 in January 2018 on Verifiable Delay Functions. Bram spoke at Blockchain at Berkeley (which starts about 20:00) in March 2018 with slides. Bram gave a talk at BPASE 2017 in January 2017 on removing waste with Proofs of Space and Time (slides).
>
> Bram gave a talk at SF Bitcoin Devs Seminar about data structures for scaling Bitcoin with slides and Merkle Set code. Bram gave a talk at SF Bitcoin Devs Seminar about removing waste from cryptocurrencies.
I'm not your Bud, Pal.
But a lot is happening still. Heck, I think some of those chains even serve a actual purpose, without the computational issues. Crazy right ?
As for Bitcoin, I hope the money in it trickle down to actual useful things. But, trickling down. Well, we know how it goes .
But since this thread is about an altcoin: Almost no other altcoin enables me to run my own fully-validating node on cheap hardware. And that is 100% a requirement I have since the whole point of crypto to reduce trust to a minimum. I don't know about the details of Chia, but as far as I know most coins with "smart contracts" built into the blockchain require expensive full nodes, so I personally do not see much appeal.
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/gridcoin/comments/7mdnud/get_into_g...
You can say the same about people in adtech.
For example: a simple switch on my browser to turn on/off all ads would be much more consumer friendly, and would still allow consumers to find products if/when they wish to find them. And this is just a simple example that just popped into my head.
Why? Because by the very nature of storage, it is infinitely more profitable to farm only unused extra storage than it is to buy new storage specifically for farming. I'll follow with a more detailed explanation below.
Since the marginal cost of using extra space on a hard drive you already bought is near zero, this should theoretically drive the farming rewards for Chia so low that it's not economical to buy a hard drive specifically to farm Chia.
In contrast, consider compute. If I try to use extra cpu power on an average computer or server to mine bitcoin, compared to the high end GPUs and ASICs this extra amount of compute I have within my average computer is so small it would barely generate any rewards. Given that using more CPU also causes more power consumption, it also costs more.
So putting this together, due to the existence of specialized/more-performant hardware and the fact that using more CPU/GPU incurs a cost, most of the people buying high end GPUs (or definitely ASICs), are buying it primarily for mining. In contrast, with space, since it's always near free to use storage you already bought, and everyone is on a near-level playing field, the market is only profitable for those with no sunk costs. At least, that's just a theory.
Just a thought, but who knows. We'll see in time.
Viagra was originally developed as chest pain medication. Did it utterly fail, simply because a new use-case was unveiled?
Which begs the question, what is the new use case for Bitcoin? Some say digital gold, but only time will tell.
Everyone mines on GPUs because they are cheaper and casual dual purpose (play games and mine afk)
Aren't ASIC normally limited to a single algo as well?
Heh. I think you just unintentionally used this correctly by assuming there even is a new use case.
That was intentional?
Premined, just like Ethereum and all the other shitcoins.
The latter isn’t necessarily greed, lots of people just don’t have the good fortune to make a comfortable amount of money (as those of us in tech do) so are more susceptible to bubbles.
The people who can imagine and implement a novel new type of cryptocurrency certainly do
I wish it worked! It does feel like something out of a cyberpunk novel. I loved "Crypronomicon." There's nothing punk about Bitcoin anymore, though. IBM, the least punk organization in the history of mankind, wants to sell you a blockchain. The promise of Bitcoin is the idea that individuals, not large financial concerns, have the power. Coinbase just IPO'd for an eye watering amount of money on the premise that people who want to buy and sell Bitcoin are probably going to have to do it through them. What's less punk than an IPO?
Bitcoin is not the only cryptocurrency out there.
Besides, the fact that coinbase just had an IPO doesn't mean they control bitcoin, I don't need them or anyone else to move around cryptocurrencies however I want.
Bitcoin works well in plenty of ways. Bitcoin just doesn't work very well as a currency, but that ship has sailed and it's ok.
I've seen this comic, and the dog is melting in the next panel.
And that is exactly why I dislike it. At least among ones that I encountered cyberpunk is strongly dystopian.
> I don't understand how a forum called Hacker News is so dismissive of an invention that should be right up a hacker's alley
I hope that Chia dies and falls on its face before SSD and HDD will repeat story of GPU.
I like to use this resources for actually useful things, not gambling.
> decentralized
So far BTC-like stuff is centralized, just in a novel toxic way.
Back in the day when we were sitting in dark basements with big Unix beards drinking Jolt cola, we all dreamed of living in a crypto-anarchy, becoming cyborgs with chip implants and fully submerge in the Metaverse. I guess times have changed.
Cryptocurrency, the internet, mobile devices, huge powerful corporations, Anonymous, black hat hackers, hi tech protests like DDoS, electric vehicles, shady IT security companies, Moxie Marlinspike, billionaires going into space...
I know how buggy software is, I would not feel safe with it directly coupled to myself.
> living in a crypto-anarchy
I know how well communism went, I hope that next radical society reengineering will happen sufficiently far away to not impact me.
Which is all that is needed to create a fair bargaining position for the consumers.
It does allow you to have an "account" outside any jurisdiction, and allows you, given good opsec, to transfer huge amounts in transactions not controlled by any state. Like, millions of USD.
Bitcoin is obviously useless to pay for daily goods, like a coffee. But gold would be also impractical for such a case.
Crazy speculators pumping the value of bitcoin may look unreasonable, but again, for those who have millions (and maybe even billions) in bitcoin, they are weirdly... useful.
https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
It does not, at any point in there, say that the benefit is to avoid state control. It talks about how the cost of requiring a third party in transactions discourages microtransactions, for instance (there are other touted benefits as well). But it's not an anarchist manifesto. And all of the benefits of Bitcoin listed in the original paper require it to be a useful medium of exchange. The Bitcoin paper posits that it should be useful for transactions _much smaller_ than a cup of coffee. It isn't. It so obviously isn't that even Bitcoin advocates can admit that.
Okay, so maybe you think that it's okay that Bitcoin doesn't meet its original goals given that it meets these other goals. But the goals you state, the lack of state control and the difficulty of seizure, are... like, Bitcoin does not put you the person outside of the state's law enforcement mechanisms, including the taxation people. Ironically, if Bitcoin was actually useful for small microtransactions, like the paper says it should be, that might actually be useful for avoiding state control. It's not! And nothing about Bitcoins makes them hard to seize if you are within the physical jurisdiction of the state.
Random fun fact: the EU Investment Bank just did a 100 mln bond issuance on Ethereum.
The financial rails of the world will be moving to crypto asset networks, slowly at first, and there is nothing that can stop this shift.
Like, from where I sit, Chia looks like it's trying to solve the unintended consequences of Bitcoin, which is a tacit admission from the Chia people that Bitcoin has those problems. It also looks like Chia has an easily foreseeable set of unintended consequences as well: doing to SSDs what Bitcoin has done to GPUs. It doesn't seem to me like the Chia people are worried about that, and I don't know why.
I understand your argument, but Bitcoin hasn't been mined on GPUs since 2011/2012. Broaden your argument from Bitcoin to "proof of work schemes" more generally, and from GPUs to "profligate (mis)use of resources", and it will land more effectively.
If you are against cryptocurrencies more broadly, inclusive of proof of stake and other more recent approaches that aim to address the resource consumption issue, then that position didn't come across clearly.
Bitcoin started the whole crypto craze, and etherereum wouldn’t exist without bitcoin.
And the eth (and who knows how many other coin) crowd certainly does still mine on gpus.
And is actively on the path to proof of stake.
Is this past the point of basic research?
Cold fusion has been on a path for 50 years.
At least for miners in a PoW system, there’s a pressure for some liquidity by miners selling to cover the mining costs.
[1] Who uses Bitcoin for peer-to-peer payments? And the cryptocurrency ecosystem as it exists right now, far from allowing people to transact without third parties, is driving a cambrian explosion in third parties, because most people are incapable of transacting Bitcoin themselves.