However we can all agree that Amazon doesn't create $91B of value when it buys something for $91B in cash. The entire supply chain behind creating the thing Amazon buys, plus the raw inputs, creates something of value that Amazon then consumes.
You could maybe argue that in a market without Amazon, the workers may have been paid only, say, $85B, so Amazon has transferred $6B from consumers to workers. Even then, the value of transferring $6B from consumers to workers is unlikely to be $6B.
If I tighten the last bolt on a car that is worth $20k, I have not created anywhere near $20k in value.
But the whole point of the article is to debunk these distortions and add clarity. Adding its own confusion and distortions is not a good way to start.
If I pay you $10,000 to eat a pile of horse manure, then you pay me $10,000 to eat a pile of horse manure we have:
Created $20,000 of "value" for the economy and increased GDP $20,000. That's all great for PR!
In reality we both just have s--t eating grins.
In fact, the value is likely to be undercounted by GDP. People are taxed on income, so casual transactions like the orange-for-apple trade are likely to be left out of GDP simply because they are unreported.
Your example is the opposite: over-counting GDP and the participants paying thousands of dollars in taxes.
The shipping industry is useful and using it to ship bricks for some fraudulent scheme doesn’t change that. The value of a physical action isn’t inherent in the action itself, but rather depends on what purpose it serves.
Or the exchange value, ie, how many apples is this iron worth.
Or the labor value, ie, how much labor went into producing this item.
Or the price, ie, how much is this item worth in money.
It seems that in reading this sentence, the author is talking about the labor value of the fruits. The various parties may have different ideas about exchange values, prices, and use values, but the labor value doesn't change because the items have exchanged owners.
In a slightly more complicated model - or the real world - the value of a good or service is informed by things like control and location. Value is not objective, but subjective. Value can be and often is created by moving good from a location where they are values little to a location where they are valued highly.
Does any serious economic philosophy actually believe that foolishness?
So perhaps not in any serious modern economic philosophy, but people definitely arrive at this idea in naive ways.
An outsider, Person C, might say that each of them has given up a fruit (-1), and gained a fruit (+1), so both Person A and Person B end up at 0. This is the point the writer was making.
For someone with allergy to that fruit it's worthless.
Aggregated preferences usually show that specialization (comparative advantage) helps satisfy everyone's preferences more that if everyone would just do their owns things. (Hence trade usually brings prosperity.)
Identifying imbalances in supply and demand and resolving them absolutely crates value, but that's the root of big scary nasty evil capitalism, so we can't be having it.
Not that Bezos' sums make and real sense at all either, but this critique is way off base.
That seems wrong. If I trade, that means I value whatever I get more than what I gave up; and likewise for the counterparty. Isn't that a net positive even though nothing was physically created?