News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Where did the other dollar go, Jeff? by aidenn0 on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @12:07PM (#26970961)
Shortly after that he does acknowledge that collective labor may be more valuable than individual labor.

However we can all agree that Amazon doesn't create $91B of value when it buys something for $91B in cash. The entire supply chain behind creating the thing Amazon buys, plus the raw inputs, creates something of value that Amazon then consumes.

You could maybe argue that in a market without Amazon, the workers may have been paid only, say, $85B, so Amazon has transferred $6B from consumers to workers. Even then, the value of transferring $6B from consumers to workers is unlikely to be $6B.

If I tighten the last bolt on a car that is worth $20k, I have not created anywhere near $20k in value.

Re:Where did the other dollar go, Jeff? by chmod600 on Wednesday April 28, 2021 @02:47PM (#26972688)
I agree that the overall value that amazon is claiming is dubious at best. It's conflating consumer/producer surplus with net profits and conflating both of those with wages.

But the whole point of the article is to debunk these distortions and add clarity. Adding its own confusion and distortions is not a good way to start.