News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Governments Fail by varispeed on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:38PM (#26944580)
The problem is that nobody cares about corruption, or the so-called "lobbying". Big companies get their way at the expense of regular citizens meanwhile police and other agencies are busy enforcing big pharma monopoly on drugs. Most governments run until they are exposed and people are mad enough to march on the streets, or they simply run out of "their" monopoly money. To improve that we need a ruthless agency that will remove corruption from politics once and for all.
Re:Why Governments Fail by jrwoodruff on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:19PM (#26945161)
>a ruthless agency that will remove corruption from politics once and for all.

Used to be called a free press, until we allowed massive mergers creating single companies with control of a massive media market share, and journalism trade unions to be eliminated, leaving journalists no choice but to cover what they're told.

Re:Why Governments Fail by dane-pgp on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:28PM (#26945276)
I think you're missing the other half of the problem, which is that people actively seek out "journalism" that confirms their world view, regardless of whether it is true.

Despite the mergers, there are still news outlets that produce accurate and in depth reporting, and of course it's possible to consume news from multiple opposing sources, but most people either don't care about the news or only care if it gives them a reason to hate the other side.

Re:Why Governments Fail by billytetrud on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:30PM (#26946132)
This is only a problem for hype-based ad funded news. Our news is so bad today because it's ad funded, instead of subscription based. With a subscription, you read a source you trust and that source has an incentive to keep you trusting it by giving you interesting information.

By contrast, ad based news gets most of it's revenue from vitality, shares, and clicks. They create hyperbolic headlines aimed to create an emotional response (usually highly negative) in order to induce people to click in a rage.

Re:Why Governments Fail by pietrrrek on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:37PM (#26947764)
One could argue that subscription based news orgs are incentivesed to provide you news which would ensure that you stay subscribed. For some people these news would have to be factual, but, for IMO most people news which are either not fully factual, or omit some information would be "preferred" as long as they (the news) conform to the opinion of the subscriber.
Re:Why Governments Fail by billytetrud on Monday April 26, 2021 @06:07PM (#26948877)
People have their biases, and people like to be validated. I agree. I just don't believe that people satisfying their biases would have much of a market in primarily subscriber-oriented news. Even todays subscription news is driven by clicks and shares in a misguided effort to compete with free news.
Re:Why Governments Fail by sbacic on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:50PM (#26947946)
There's a funny joke about that.

"Where do rich people hide their wealth in the West?"

"In tax havens."

"And where do they hide it in Eastern Europe?"

"In plain sight".

A free press won't do squat if there is no consequence for the behavior they expose. If neither the public nor the courts punish such behavior having a free press cover it will amount to very little.

Re:Why Governments Fail by varispeed on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @05:33PM (#26961910)
In places where press is licensed, it is not free - because they must report in a certain way to not lose license - it also includes being nice for whomever is currently on top. I've seen here in the UK where Russia Today reported a story that should have collapsed the government, but none of the other main stream media investigated the story until few months later where the party has concocted a plausible explanation why something happened. Between that RT was given a warning that they'll lose license for interference in UK affairs... Madness.
Re:Why Governments Fail by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @05:39PM (#26962001)
The press requires a license in the UK? Foreign press? Really?

(American here, so I don't know. But the idea seems insane to me.)

Re:Why Governments Fail by missedthecue on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:16PM (#26957956)
Media has perhaps the most competing firms of any nationwide industry. I don't understand this take, and I see it a lot. There are probably 20 relatively trustworthy outlets through which you can consume US news.

That is a lot. Look at the competitive landscape in other industries. There are basically 4 tire companies, 4 or 5 home builders, 6 or so mobile handset manufacturers, 4 or 5 US based airlines... You get the picture. And all of those industries are still decently competitive.

Re:Why Governments Fail by naravara on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:54PM (#26944807)
This misses the actual mechanism by which political corruption works. Lobbying is merely any person going in to press their interests with their representatives. Where large, monied interests rig the game is because they run election campaigns and implant narratives in the media.

In other words, the mechanism by which lobbyists get their way is by weaponizing regular citizens into voting in their interests. It's marketing and mass manipulation rather than the "quid pro quo" corruption people imagine it is.

Re:Why Governments Fail by dane-pgp on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:09PM (#26945859)
> weaponizing regular citizens into voting in their interests. It's marketing and mass manipulation

Which means there is a problem even if the money never even touches a politician's / campaign's bank account. It's too easy for a politician to say something like "If elected, I will remove burdensome regulations on airlines" as a dog whistle for "I want the airline industry to buy ads that attack my opponent".

The only obvious ways to prevent that are to somehow prove that the politician coordinated their position with the industry (which seems impossible) or banning companies from ever expressing a political opinion (which apparently some politicians would like to achieve, but only those political opinions that they disagree with).

Fortunately there does exist one slightly less obvious way of preventing this, which doesn't require nullifying all the freedom of speech principles of the First Amendment. What is needed is a law (and probably an enabling Amendment) which limits political advertisements to N dollars per person per year (with N being 1% of the median US income).

Importantly, other forms of political speech and expression wouldn't be restricted. This way the law is targeted at the specific loophole that lobbying exploits, which is that people can be bombarded with a message against their wishes, generating an "illusory truth effect". People can still go out and find information, or march in the street to spread awareness of a political cause, but having more money wouldn't give you a greater ability to get your message in front of people who aren't interested in it.

The idea above is basically the core of CFR28 which is explained more in the relevant Wikipedia article:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campaign_finance_reform_in_the...

Re:Why Governments Fail by fossuser on Monday April 26, 2021 @12:58PM (#26944876)
Yeah - I basically agree with this framing.

I think Lessig's talk is the best summary of this: https://www.ted.com/talks/lawrence_lessig_we_the_people_and_...

Lobbying itself is fine - we want experts with deep domain expertise interacting with law makers. We just don't want them also funding their campaigns.

Re:Why Governments Fail by tacocataco on Monday April 26, 2021 @06:38PM (#26949202)
I must have watched a different ted talk he did on the same subject. I think it was called "the green primary"
Re:Why Governments Fail by billytetrud on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:32PM (#26946153)
I think there is a lot more quid pro quo than you think. Lobbiests are NOT usually just regular people. They're usually paid agents.
Re:Why Governments Fail by imtringued on Monday April 26, 2021 @06:41PM (#26949225)
I think he made a distinction between lobbying which anyone can do and a lobbyist which is a career whose sole goal is to do nothing but lobbying.
Re:Why Governments Fail by naravara on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:26AM (#26955501)
Yes and no. There are lots of public interest lobbying organizations out there as well. For example, I donate to one that's just focused on making cities more bike friendly. I used to work for one focused on improving how the Census counts people. There's a galaxy of nitpicky, nerdy stuff that's supported by very nerdy volunteers and part-time lobbying efforts (and usually a bit of pro-bono work from one of the big lobbying firms).

But even though they outnumber the "big industry" lobbys they just don't have the money, connections, or influence.

Re:Why Governments Fail by User23 on Monday April 26, 2021 @01:27PM (#26945264)
Put more simply, lobbyists are just the bag men. They facilitate payoffs that are laundered through junkets, book deal advances, insider trading opportunities, and who knows what else. The lobbying firms certainly have little or no idea why the proposed bill they are selling was crafted.

It’s a sobering realization that none of our elected legislators are competent to actually write laws. Occasionally you’ll see an example where they’ll have a staff attorney draft something for the purpose of political grandstanding, but that’s a sideshow compared to the amount of legislation written by the people with the real power.

The dynamic of how the sausage is made in DC is why, incidentally, Trump had to go. For all his many many faults, one thing he did right was bring buying legal privilege in the form of laws or federal regulations to a grinding halt.

Re:Why Governments Fail by naravara on Monday April 26, 2021 @02:14PM (#26945919)
> It’s a sobering realization that none of our elected legislators are competent to actually write laws. Occasionally you’ll see an example where they’ll have a staff attorney draft something for the purpose of political grandstanding, but that’s a sideshow compared to the amount of legislation written by the people with the real power.

Even if they wanted to, they couldn't. Their staff offices don't have the payroll budgets to pay a decent analyst a living wage so their offices are staffed by the rich children of donors who can afford to be paid a pittance while living in one of the highest cost-of-living metros in the country. Smart legislative analysts are expensive, but none of them can afford to pay off student loans and raise a family at the payscales available to them. So they end up going into advocacy, big law, or lobbying once they cut their teeth on the Hill.

Re:Why Governments Fail by User23 on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:12PM (#26947451)
That’s more strong evidence that the system really doesn’t work as advertised. If it did then the people that supposedly have the power of the purse and control trillions of dollars in spending might vote themselves enough budget to do their jobs.
Re:Why Governments Fail by naravara on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @09:23AM (#26955469)
They might, but a significant chunk of that body (and of the electorate) is philosophically opposed to the idea of them doing their jobs.

Also fundraising, public communications, and case-work are all bigger determinants of them getting reelected than legislative acumen or policy-making skill so big surprise what kinds of people the job selects for.

Re:Why Governments Fail by User23 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @10:38AM (#26956489)
Why do the people who control an organization that can vote trillions of dollars a year into existence need to fundraise?

Philosophically opposed, whatever that means, is an obvious fig leaf. The system observably can’t actually be functioning as advertised. Whatever the conditions of the actual operationally descriptive system are, they select for people who vote as they’re told in exchange for a minuscule fraction of the loot.

Re:Why Governments Fail by salawat on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:11PM (#26948197)
They certainly voted themselves out of the legislative work of actually understanding technology.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Technology_Assessm...

Re:Why Governments Fail by loki49152 on Monday April 26, 2021 @03:51PM (#26947187)
Lobbying is a form of self-defense against the real corruption - a government that has assigned itself the power to interfere in our day-to-day lives. Most people today take it for granted that "regulations" must exist because they solve some actual problem.

Usually, the "problem" they exist to solve is that some government functionary wants to look like they're "doing something", which is itself a form of corruption. Regulations also commonly serve ideologically-motivated belief that some faction has managed to force on everyone else. Everything else that is "corrupt" about proscriptive regulations follows from the fact that the belief in proscriptive regulations is a corrupt belief (and illegal under the US Constitution as it was actually written).

Re:Why Governments Fail by cung on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:38AM (#26952064)
Like child-labor laws? Public education? Your comment has a point, but it is quite black and white.

Governments are a service that people buy, which we have collectively voted on, agreeing that there are things that a purely corporation driven society would not do.

Re:Why Governments Fail by simonh on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:01PM (#26947302)
Just for clarity, it seems that when you say regulations, you're really talking about laws.
Re:Why Governments Fail by salawat on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:03PM (#26948098)
Specifically of the Administrative form (read: delegated to the executive in their definition by Congress)

These are the types of regulations that can change on a moments notice, and that the American citizen has no knob to turn to influence once the paper to establish the Agency in question is inked.

Executive lawmaking was never supposed to be a thing.

Re:Why Governments Fail by nradov on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:08PM (#26950511)
While I share your concern with the legislative branch handing over its lawmaking authority to the executive branch, the rules really don't change on a moment's notice. There is a defined rule making process which all federal agencies must follow, which includes a significant public comment period. The real problem is that regular people don't have time to monitor notices of proposed rule making or submit comments in the right way. So the process ends up being dominated by lobbyists, special interest groups, and unaccountable bureaucrats who are pushing their own agendas.
Re:Why Governments Fail by HWR_14 on Tuesday April 27, 2021 @12:38AM (#26952063)
> Usually, the "problem" they exist to solve is that some government functionary wants to look like they're "doing something",

I tend to disagree. Most regulations address some problem, and in fact, the rules around changing regulations are strict enough that most of Trump's appointees' attempts to do away with regulations were ultimately reversed by the courts.

Sometimes, the problem no longer applies. But, I don't just want to disagree. So I'll tell you what. Throw 3 or 4 regulations out there you think are insane, and we'll see if I can explain a real problem for at least 1. I'd bet I could with a single regulation chosen at random, but your choices will be anything but random.

> serve ideologically-motivated belief that some faction has managed to force on everyone else

This one is true. Like, I believe murder is wrong and want it to be outlawed. But there are tons of other beliefs - e.g. rich people should a higher percentage of their income - that are ideological as well as pragmatic.

Re:Why Governments Fail by lazide on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:12PM (#26950536)
And what is to stop or check that ruthless agency when it is corrupted?

It is a fundamental attribute of power that it corrupts, and any agency with the power to decide what is corrupt and enforce against other agencies /government bodies their idea of corruption - is pretty much all powerful no?

Re:Why Governments Fail by haecceity on Monday April 26, 2021 @04:00PM (#26947294)
It's not a problem! Maybe it is a problem but China is even more corrupt!! They're gonna fall apart any day now! We don't have to be worry about ourselves look at China!!!