News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by GhostVII on Sunday April 25, 2021 @09:56AM (#26932722)
I don't get the point of all those cross-country routes, isn't air travel both faster and cheaper once you are going long distance? I mean I would love to cross the country by rail for entertainment, but as a common method of travel it doesn't seem to make much sense. It works well in Europe because it is both much denser than the US, and also subsidized.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by slacka on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:17AM (#26932859)
I lived in China for 2 years. Americans have no idea how liberating it is to be able be able to hop on a 200 mph train and arrive at totally different climate in hours. Over lunch, my coworkers would talk about a weekend of drinking tea in mountains in Hunan, visiting Mao' home in Wuhan, or exploring the beaches of Hainan. These are all things we did and were possible because of China's high speed rail system.

I think the biggest factor was the convenience. We'd just show up at the train station and take the next train, usually within an hour. No planning, no booking, just bought our tickets at the station, minutes before our trip. All of this for less than 1/4 the cost of a last minute plane ticket.

Sure we could have flown, and the farthest places may have been faster to fly. But that only if the tickets were available and security lines in china are just as bad as here. There's also the comfort of a train with a meal coach. And, the thrill of watching the land rush by at lightning speeds. America felt so backwards on my return.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by jwcacces on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:59AM (#26933239)
Flying used to be like this. I'm from Long Island and I went to college in the Boston area. I remember you could buy a book of delta shuttle tickets (~$100 / fight, book of 5) and show up and use them whenever you'd like, last minute, with no security hassle or whatever. You could also use the same tickets to go to DC if you wanted. Just stay on the plane for the next leg.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by mncharity on Sunday April 25, 2021 @03:11PM (#26935626)
Nod. Pre-9/11 peak deregulation had $40 flights BOS-NYC. I'd run from Boston subway, to a quick direct shuttle bus, then through the doors, across the small lobby, with staff yelling at me... "Run faster!" they'd shout, mostly with a smile. Down the ramp without stopping, sliding through the closing aircraft door. Flight attendants later walking the rows, collecting two twenties from everyone. Here in a multiply dystopian future... sigh.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by mncharity on Friday April 30, 2021 @04:23PM (#26998804)
A belated caveat: I find myself now uncertain - it might have been three twenties, $60? Wasn't four.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by ghaff on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:08AM (#26933298)
Pre-Acela and the electrification of the line north of New Haven that came with it, the only real reason you'd take the train from Boston to NY (much less points south) was to save money. When I was in school in the Boston area, when I went home to the Philadelphia area, I'd take the train for longer vacations but would fly for 4-day weekends.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by andreimackenzie on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:42AM (#26933581)
Arriving at Penn Station has benefits if you're traveling for business. Hailing a ride to get to an office within 15 minutes beats the long ride to get downtown from one of the NYC airports.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by ghaff on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:27PM (#26933971)
Yeah, none of the NYC airports are particularly convenient. And I'm actually usually in midtown, often on the west side, so I can just walk from Penn to my hotel. (And Penn may actually stop being its dingy self one of these days.)
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by CydeWeys on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:55PM (#26934230)
> (And Penn may actually stop being its dingy self one of these days.)

That's kind of already happened. The Moynihan Train Hall just opened up recently. I checked it out recently and it's quite nice, certainly much nicer than the old Penn Station. The next time you're getting off in NYC, walk towards the back of the train you came in on and then go up to the surface, and you'll be exiting in Moynihan instead of Penn.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by ghaff on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:12PM (#26934399)
I haven't been in NYC for close to a couple years at this point. Some of the renovation work around the LIRR entrances was done but not anything else. I'll definitely check out next time I'm there. The drawings for the continuing renovation look quite nice too.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by crusty on Sunday April 25, 2021 @04:54PM (#26936586)
I kind of wish I wasn't contributing to the topic tangent/hijack, but whatever...

Hawaii's interisland flights probably most closely resemble this air travel experience. Aside from Sunday & Friday fares that have a $30 premium due to work-week commuters, currently current week tickets are $49 and next week and beyond tickets are $39. And if you want to believe that's just a covid effect, there was a $29 special going last year right before covid.

Pair the process with chill, small-ish airports* and the hassle of flying is about as low as it gets for controlled commercial air travel.

Years ago, it used to be the norm to Judy show up 10 or 15 minutes before the flight.

* Obviously Honolulu is an exception, but it does have a separate interisland terminal.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by csense on Sunday April 25, 2021 @06:03PM (#26937147)
Now that we're finally pulling out of Afghanistan and done with the War on Terror, it's time to disband DHS / TSA and put things back to how they used to be.

I think it's kinda weird how very few politicians are talking about this.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by alisonatwork on Sunday April 25, 2021 @02:02PM (#26934919)
If you were living in a place in China where you could just show up and catch a high speed train, you were very lucky!

My experience living in China is that for high speed rail departing from tier one and tier two cities, you would often need to book a ticket a day in advance, or - if you were winging it - be willing to go to somewhere other than your intended destination. And foreigners cannot get their tickets through the machine like people with Chinese ID card can, so that means waiting 30-45 minutes in the line to get your ticket (even if you booked online), before you even go through security, which is another 15-20 minutes. And if you show up at the main concourse 5 minutes before the train leaves, you will be denied access to the platform due to the airport-like boarding procedure. As such, I always had to calculate arriving at the dedicated high speed train station (usually itself 30+ minutes bus or subway ride out of the center of town) with at least an hour to spare.

It is still far less hassle than taking a flight, but it's not comparable to the real spontaneous opportunities of going by bus/coach or slow train (hard seat). With those forms of travel you really can just show up at a nearby station and go wherever, with little to no pre-planning and less stressful security checks. But then it will take hours to go halfway across the province. Of course, for many Chinese, that is the standard mode of travel, because high speed rail is still fairly expensive by comparison.

All that said... Pretty much everything about traveling by rail in China is better than it is in America. But traveling by rail in Europe is the gold standard, I think. Being able to buy tickets from a machine, not show photo ID anywhere (in the Schengen area at least), just step on and step off, that's real freedom of movement.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by cbm-vic-20 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:53AM (#26933670)
One of the (many) problems with Amtrak is that they pretend they're an airline. Booking well in advance is the only way to get a good rate, "walk up" prices are pretty high. I mostly have experience with the Northeast Corridor, and this is the baseline level of service that we need nationwide. I've been on some of the other routes, and the quality of the service on those lines pales in comparison.

That said, the route from NYC to Montreal is really beautiful north of Albany. It just takes about ten hours to get there.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by alkonaut on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:49PM (#26934175)
Rule #1 of travel pricing is you can’t risk charging too little for business travel because they subsidize the price conscious travellers. Leaving on an earlier train because a meeting ends early is exactly the kind of thing business travellers pay good money for. But that’s also indiatinguishable from this kind of random walk in travel that leisure travellers would love to see - so it can’t happen. If you want business travellers to pay 3x for that convenience you can’t give it to everyone for less than that.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by VWWHFSfQ on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:30PM (#26933996)
> It just takes about ten hours to get there.

This is just always going to be the problem. It's ok for some mild entertainment but it's not viable for regular travel. A flight to Montreal is like an hour and probably half the price.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by mjmahone17 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:51PM (#26934188)
It’s a little absurd that a trip of less than 400 miles takes 11 hours on a train. That’s a terrible average speed.

With pretty reasonable high speed rail, that should be no more than a 4 hour trip. At which point it is very competitive with flying in terms of time.

For cost, it looks like a round trip on Amtrak is typically $200, whereas a round trip flight for two weeks from now is around $300.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by bsanr2 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:13PM (#26934414)
Even now it really depends on where your priorities lie. Going from Rhode Island to Maryland or back, I had to arrive at least an hour and a half (more like 2 hours) before takeoff to get through parking and security. That meant leaving the house 2-3 hours before takeoff. Then, a 2-hour flight, and another hour and a half dealing with baggage and transport home. That two-hour flight was more like 6 hours of my day, a majority of it spent in uncomfortable settings (driving, in the security line, in a cramped plane seat). Compare to Amtrak: 30 minutes to the closest station, and I can arrive immediately before boarding; 7 hours on the train, but in fairly spacious seats, with free WiFi, and then 20 minutes home from the station.

I much preferred the relatively relaxed nature of train travel, and it only bit out an extra hour or two of my day. With high speed rail it wouldn't even be a contest.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by mgbmtl on Sunday April 25, 2021 @02:49PM (#26935411)
It's an international flight, so the price is more expensive relative to a flight between two US cities. Usually it's 300 USD to fly compared to 140 USD by rail.

Two things to keep in mind by rail to Montreal: customs add 1h, and in summer, if the rails are too hot, per Canadian regulations, the train cannot go faster than 50km/hour or something ridiculously slow like that, which adds another hour or two. Onboard wifi only works when in the US, and because of the mountains in upstate NY, the signal can be very flaky and slow.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by ghaff on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:48PM (#26934167)
>Booking well in advance is the only way to get a good rate, "walk up" prices are pretty high

In all fairness, that's pretty true in a lot of places. It certainly is in the UK in my experience. I'd actually have said at least the Acela isn't particularly onerous in this regard.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by throwawayboise on Sunday April 25, 2021 @03:51PM (#26936015)
This was true in Denmark last I was there. You could buy an "orange" ticket online, well in advance, for a significant discount, which I used for a planned trip into Copenhagen from Jutland.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by Ericson2314 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @02:25PM (#26935190)
I completely agree with you in the abstract, and would happily never fly cross country again, but I'm worried Amtrak's map is a sign that want to do middling incremental improvements everywhere that don't reach that inflection point.

See https://pedestrianobservations.com/2021/03/20/streaming-high... for a much less exciting map, but one for which u have more confidence Amtrak could actually pull it off.

I rather they do the crazy fun cross country routes after that. America needs to demonstrate it's serious about urbanism before I take any cross country lines crayoning seriously.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by GhostVII on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:45AM (#26933605)
I think that for shorter distances, like LA to SF to Seattle that would be great. But I don't think any of the rail lines in China are comparable to going from Chicago to Seattle - that is a huge distance to build a high speed rail line on, and there is almost nothing in between that people would want to stop at.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by treeman79 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:47PM (#26934159)
California has been trying and failing to build a high speed rail system. So far it’s only good at making a lot of people rich and being worthless.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by alisonatwork on Sunday April 25, 2021 @03:18PM (#26935680)
There are several "trains to nowhere" in China. High speed rail is already active between Lanzhou (Gansu) and Ürümqi (Xinjiang), which is 1500km of pretty empty countryside. They're talking about linking in Lhasa (Tibet) too. I can't imagine any of those routes will be profitable, but perhaps the income from the coastal provinces makes up the difference.

I suspect in China there is more political incentive to connect these far-flung provinces, though, to try to promote national unity. I'm not sure closing the gap between the PNW and "middle America" is considered quite as important by people in DC.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by hanniabu on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:09AM (#26933307)
We wouldn't be getting 200mph trains though
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by jessaustin on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:18AM (#26933383)
It might be instructive to imagine what would have to change about USA to allow 200mph trains. (real ones, not hypothetical BS like Elon's tubes)
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by imtringued on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:48PM (#26934164)
Elon musk promised 155mph for the LA tunnel. In reality you are down to 40mph. Off by 4x. If Elon Musk promises 800mph in the Hyperloop expect to cut off 75% off that so its back to 200mph. Why even bother? It's not like he has any special insight, the only thing he has is the ability to throw money at random projects.

The only things Elon Musk does well are incremental improvements over existing technology, that's not a bad thing but he always throws out bullshit promises that he can do it 10x cheaper or fares only cost one dollar.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by natch on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:47PM (#26934156)
And the fast trains are made even better because of the complementary system of slow trains, which because they have many stops at smaller places along the way, eliminate the need for fast trains to have too-frequent stops.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by yorwba on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:39PM (#26934064)
Hainan is an island and while a tunnel is planned, the current solution is to ship the rail cars across in a ferry, which creates a bottleneck and makes the line not that fast overall. But it's still pretty convenient, especially if you consider that for most people the alternative wouldn't be a plane but a car, which has the same difficulty crossing the strait. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guangdong%E2%80%93Hainan_railw...
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by fireattack on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:09PM (#26934372)
Agreed.

However, I think there is another issue in the US: last mile transit.

Even if the US magically have the rail system similar to China today, using it in cities like Houston etc. that has poor public transit would still be a pain in the ass in practice.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by ghaff on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:30PM (#26934568)
It's another reason (besides density) why the Northeast Corridor works pretty well for rail. The biggest cities (Boston, NYC, Philadelphia, DC) have pretty good transit systems and the train dumps you downtown which will often be where you want to be.

Houston is arguably a particularly bad example. But there are a lot of cities where you pretty much need a car if you want to be at all mobile.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by tzs on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:31AM (#26932988)
I think it may be like an elevator.

About 15 years ago, I had to spend a little over 3 weeks in Beaumont, Texas, for work, leaving Beaumont just before Thanksgiving. I dislike flying and wasn't paying for the trip and had never taken a train, so asked to take Amtrak.

My train trip was from the Tacoma, Washington Amtrak station to the Beaumont station and back, via the Los Angeles, California, station. It's a 3 day trip each way, and so on the return trip I was traveling on Thanksgiving day.

Pretty much every stop that day had a ton of people getting on and a ton of people getting off, often whole families. They were all just taking the train to the town a few stops down the line to get together with family from the neighboring towns for the holiday, and then return the next time a train going the other direction came through (trains came through each way three days a week on that segment).

So yeah, it may not make sense to have a cross-country route if you just consider people who are traveling from one of the route to the other, just like an elevator does not make sense in many buildings when you just consider the volume of passengers traveling between the penthouse and the bottom of a five level underground parking garage.

But just like an elevator between that deep garage and the penthouse is also an elevator between every other pair of floors, a cross-country train route is also a route between every pair of stops between the ends.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by stuaxo on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:43AM (#26933089)
Exactly - just like with roads.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by kolinko on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:23AM (#26933423)
Cross country - perhaps not. But, living in Europe, I see many people chhosing a train for 4-5h over 1-1.5h flight.

For 1,5h flight you end up wasting 3-4h anyway because you need to get to the airport etc, and out of those 3-4h most of the time you can’t do anything productive or relaxing either. With 5h train you can either relax or work and it’s much more productive. Also less co2 produced ofc.

And that’s with “slow” trains going 100mph. With faster trains as in France or Japan even more airplane rides are unnecessary

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:53AM (#26933663)
Did that a couple of years ago to go from Glasgow to London. Almost exactly the journey times you mention. Bought a ticket the same day as I travelled. It wasn't cheap, but was cheaper than same-day flight tickets. No airport stress, and ended up back in the middle of London, not at some ex-urban or suburban airport with another 35-60 minute journey into town.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by dehrmann on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:01PM (#26934298)
I think most of this demand is already covered by the popular Northeast Corridor. It should absolutely be upgraded, but outside of it, I think everything's either too small or too far to effectively compete with air travel.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by ghaff on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:35PM (#26934612)
There definitely are city pairs or maybe triplets here and there. North Carolina was mentioned somewhere upthread. I've actually taken Amtrak from Raleigh to Charlotte. Could just walk to the station from downtown Raleigh. Did need a cab at the other end to get to downtown Charlotte but it was closer than the airport.

I know people take the train between Seattle and Portland. I'm sure there are other examples.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by jcranmer on Sunday April 25, 2021 @03:50PM (#26936000)
There are four main regions that have viable HSR outside of the NEC. These are:

* The CA region (SF/Bay Area/Sacramento/LA/Las Vegas/Phoenix).

* Texas triangle

* France TGV-like lines in the Midwest, centered on Chicago, connecting to Minneapolis (via Milwaukee), St. Louis, Detroit, Cleveland, maybe Indianapolis, Columbus, Cincinnati

* New England/New York outside of the NEC--that is, Toronto-Boston and Montreal-New York with timed transfers at Albany.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by manacit on Sunday April 25, 2021 @04:20PM (#26936289)
I would probably add Vancouver, BC -> Seattle -> Portland to that list, but I think that's probably right. The thing is, if we actually added viable rail to all of those cities mentioned, it would be a huge swath of the country, without needing to build a 200mph train through Wyoming.

Right now there are ~40 flights a day that go from PDX-SEA or SEA-PDX. Those are a waste of airport capacity and carbon emission. Both cities have the transit network to easily get people to the airport from wherever the HSR ends up for people who are using those flights to make connections, and could promote growth in the aggregate area in a way that doesn't exist now.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by myself248 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:27AM (#26932947)
Not everyone optimizes for fast or cheap. Some prioritize comfort, or scenery, or not-being-in-an-airplane for whatever reason.

Some really enjoy getting off at one stop for a while, and getting on the next train and continuing the journey. Or just deciding that this place looks nice, and getting off here. Try that in an airplane...

There's a growing niche of transoceanic travel by container-ship and bulk freighter, too. It's neither cheap nor fast, and that's the point. It's truly unplugged, where the journey is part of the destination.

Throughout the entirety of human history except the last hundred years or so, long distance travel has been a borderline-boring activity. Maybe that's not such a bad thing -- our brains need some downtime to reflect and defrag. We're just starting to appreciate en masse that "monotonous" can be kissing-close to "meditative". Rail is part of that, and as people catch onto that, it's making a comeback.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by peckrob on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:46AM (#26933117)
Frankly, even as poor as our rail infrastructure is, there's still a lot to be said for train travel.

A couple years my wife and I went Birmingham to New Orleans for $150 round trip on Amtrak. Airfare on the same route was $600, and I would have paid $150 in parking alone in downtown New Orleans. Moreover, the time difference between train, driving or flying was not all that different. The train was scheduled at seven hours, about the same as driving time with stops. And air travel would have been about the same once you factor in getting to the airport early, two flights with a layover in Atlanta, and getting from the airport to downtown.

It’s also a whole heck of a lot more pleasant than flying. 50” of seat pitch, width of a first class seat, hot food, alcohol, plenty of room to walk around, interesting people to talk to, no needless security theater, no need to get to the station 30 minutes early, no need to worry about baggage fees or weights.

Before the pandemic hit, we were planning on doing the Empire Builder from Chicago to Portland. For the three of us (me, wife, daughter) in a bedroom was $1100. Expensive, but factoring in transportation, room and food for 2.5 days for 3, it’s not a bad deal. And you get to sit back, watch the scenery, read, nap, etc.

I mean yeah, if I need to travel across the country quickly, an airplane will always win. But airlines have seemingly gone out of their way over the last 20 years to make flying as miserable as possible to squeeze every cent out of customers. If I can afford to take some time and the train is an option, I will always choose the train based solely on it being less miserable than flying has become.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by spc476 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @08:02PM (#26937938)
Six years ago, a friend of mine vacationed in a private rail car with his family. I got to ride in it for three hours [1], and just that trip spoiled me for all further travel.

My friend never did say what it cost him. I suspect it was the price of a low-end car, but given that he had the car for over a week, and it came with dining and sleeping arrangements for 9 people (him, his family, in his laws, the chef and conductor) he doesn't regret it.

[1] http://boston.conman.org/2015/08/05.4

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by loonster on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:18PM (#26938917)
That looks like a lot of fun.

>Typical pricing for a trip is along the lines of a high-end cruise. On average, the all-inclusive costs typically can run between $2,500 and $7,000 or more per car per day. But remember, a rail car may accommodate 6, 8, 10, 20 people or more.

https://www.aaprco.com/travel/where-do-i-start/chartering-a-...

Still looks like a lot of fun, but 20k-56k for 8day trip... I can't do that.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by 7thaccount on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:29PM (#26933990)
Was also researching a sleeper car for a family of 3 before the Pandemic. I've only been on a train once before besides work trips in DC (use the metro a bit), so it's a little out of the blue for me, but perhaps it could be making a comeback
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by jen20 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:49AM (#26933146)
> I don't get the point of all those cross-country routes,

Same. I10 is pointless - no-one drives from Santa Monica to Jacksonville - flying is much faster once you’re going long distance. I mean I would love to cross the country by car for entertainment, but as a common method of travel it doesn’t seem to make much sense.

/sarcasm (for those who need it pointing out...)

Cross country rail lines are just like cross-country interstates: mostly used by people for specific regional connectivity.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by ghaff on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:02AM (#26932754)
And by and large, people don't take trains for Chicago to Seattle type distances in Europe. That's further than the distance from Paris to Moscow.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by apostacy on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:20AM (#26932890)
These long distance routes should be left intact because they are an important anchor for eventually expanding to high speed rail.

China kept their unprofitable rural slow passenger routes into the distant corners of their country, and now they are converting them to high speed routes.

The Beijing-Guangzhou high-speed line is 2,298km long, and used to be 22 hours but now runs in 8[1]

Being able to go from Penn Station in Manhattan to Union Station in Chicago in 8 hours in a comfortable train would be a serious alternative to air travel, and once the track is upgraded, it would probably be cheaper than existing service. And this is completely doable with decades old technology. Other countries have done comparable things with less.

I don't think we should abandon "legacy" routes just because they are not profitable right now. And even if they are never profitable that alone is not a good enough reason to abandon infrastructure.

[1]: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-20842836

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by T-hawk on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:26AM (#26932941)
Note that New York to Chicago by Amtrak is so slow largely because there's no direct route. You either take the Great Lakes route going through Albany, Buffalo, and Cleveland, or the northeast corridor route to Washington DC and then another line to Chicago. The more direct Keystone line through Pennsylvania only goes as far as Harrisburg.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by ghaff on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:36AM (#26933020)
And the other part of the problem is that you're going through a continental divide. Prior to air travel, I assume NY to Chicago was a major route so there may be good reasons for why the routing is as it is.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by calvinmorrison on Sunday April 25, 2021 @02:08PM (#26934988)
100 years ago there were many routes! I hate that the rails have failed, taking a train between Philly, Reading, Allentown, and Scranton makes so much sense!
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by ghaff on Sunday April 25, 2021 @02:43PM (#26935357)
Yes, but the 20th Century Limited flagship of the New York Central Railroad [1] actually did follow the current Lake Shore Limited route. I suspect that there are geographic factors that limit a more direct route.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/20th_Century_Limited

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by apostacy on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:35AM (#26933017)
I think the absolute time and distance is what matters, and it would still substantially benefit from being high speed, even if it is meandering through upstate NY and along the great lakes.

Eventually, a more direct NY - Chicago high speed rail route could be built that is even faster.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by OldHand2018 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:19AM (#26933394)
You’ll notice that there is a Detroit to Toronto line on that map. It’s not an accident. Chicago to Detroit has been running at 110mph for 80+% of the distance for almost 10 years now. The rail tunnel under the Detroit River already exists.

You just need a fast NYC to Buffalo with a little extension on to Hamilton, ON and you’ve got a very direct NYC to Chicago route.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by bbanyc on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:52AM (#26933656)
They'd need to do something about the hour-long stop at the border for CBP and its Canadian equivalent to go through the train checking everyone's passports. Decades ago I ran into it on the now-defunct Chicago-Toronto line and I'm pretty sure it's why they don't run those trains anymore. The New York-Toronto and New York-Montreal trains still do it.

Seattle-Vancouver avoids it by not making any stops between Vancouver and the border, so the immigration checks take place at the station. This might be feasible for Montreal, probably not for Toronto, and a train that runs from Buffalo to Detroit without stopping in Canada at all seems implausible.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by mjmahone17 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:07PM (#26934347)
Could probably set it up to do checks on departure. End up in the wrong country without your passport? Just take the next train back to the last destination in the other country.

Would likely need a special treaty in place so Americans traveling from Chicago to NY can travel through without a passport (just ID). Alternatively if we’re talking diplomatic solutions, the US and Canada could move towards a Schengen-style free transit zone without cross country border checks.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by mattm on Sunday April 25, 2021 @02:42PM (#26935345)
> Could probably set it up to do checks on departure

There's a seaplane from Victoria-Seattle. It's been a few years since I took it but I believe this is what happened. There's a custom agent at each side. I can't remember if there were any checks before departure though. I would imagine they would do some preliminary check because they don't want to be on the hook for taking you back.

Shortest custom wait ever BTW since the plane only holds 10-15 people.

> US and Canada could move towards a Schengen-style free transit zone without cross country border checks

This would be a dream. I'm curious why I've never really heard any proposal about this. As a Canadian (currently living in the US), I think that Canada would be more opposed to this. We always seem to have a fear of the US amalgamating us. I think it'd be politically tricky on both sides though. Even though it was proven to be false, there's still this myth that the 9/11 hijackers entered the US through Canada.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by vinay427 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @05:30PM (#26936873)
> As a Canadian (currently living in the US), I think that Canada would be more opposed to this. We always seem to have a fear of the US amalgamating us.

If it helps, Switzerland joined the Schengen area while maintaining its own customs controls (with reasonably consistent enforcement) and autonomy on immigration policy (outside of temporary tourist travel which is mostly harmonized). Major policy unification isn't necessary, although the minimum feasible level is likely still unprecedented for the US and Canada.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by spc476 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @08:06PM (#26937970)
Prior to 9/11, going between the US and Canada just meant answering a few questions, no passport needed, at least between Detroit and Winsor.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by loonster on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:25PM (#26938955)
Sometime around 2008 that stopped and passports or enhanced licenses were required.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by euroderf on Monday April 26, 2021 @05:59AM (#26940918)
Yup, the USA messed up the longest, bestest border in the world.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by pessimizer on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:15AM (#26932843)
Of course, there is a Paris to Moscow train. The thing about the coast to coast train routes in the US and the Paris to Moscow train is that you're not in any way required to take the entire trip - there are stations along the way.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by ghaff on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:59AM (#26933231)
I guess I picked a bad example in that, to my surprise, there is a direct train for that route--although it still takes about a day and a half. But I could certainly pick a lot of city pairs in Europe that are 1-2K miles apart that would be anything but efficient to travel by rail.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by gsnedders on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:56PM (#26934244)
It is, I believe, the second longest passenger train in Europe. (The longest is a similar Nice–Moscow service.)

But both are weekly services, and even Nice–Moscow (yet alone intermediate stops) has more capacity most days by plane than the once-a-week train.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by CydeWeys on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:15PM (#26934433)
Well, let's hear some. You're probably gonna want to limit yourself to city pairs that have multiple direct daily flights though, as anything less won't have enough demand to merit a direct convenient train route either.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by ghaff on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:42PM (#26934684)
Without making a research project out of it:

- Rome to Athens

- Paris to Barcelona

- Madrid to Stockholm

Much of Europe is a very far way from having a seamless integrated cross-border train system.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by vinay427 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @05:32PM (#26936892)
Paris to Barcelona does actually exist: https://en.oui.sncf/en/train/timetables/paris/barcelona

The next direct train takes 6h39m.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by sofixa on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:01PM (#26934296)
> That's further than the distance from Paris to Moscow.

Which has, in regular times, a weekly service by the Russian railways. And it passes through Belarus, and ends in Russia, countries for which you need visas and aren't necessarily the friendliest. If that service makes sense, Chicago-Seattle certainly could ( as an experience, cheap travel, etc.)

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by Stasis5001 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:16AM (#26932850)
I started looking at the map in the article and realized I had just booked a flight where there was an existing rail line ! So I checked out the Amtrak site, and what's 1h20m by plane is 14h40m by train -- and 8h by car. Maybe by getting a sleeper cabin I could have had an enjoyable trip by train, but as the trip scales things get dramatically worse.

Of course, maybe this is exactly what the future of transportation should look like: more localized travel on modes that can be powered by renewable sources or nuclear.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:58AM (#26933705)
It's a mixed bag, really.

Compare the journey from my small village in New Mexico to Chicago, about 1200 miles. We just happen to have an Amtrak station 5 miles away. The drive time is about 18-20 hours without stops, which is long enough that an overnight stop is going to be likely. The flight time is only about 3 hours, but that requires first driving 40-70 minutes to the airport, spending time waiting in the airport, and then arriving at O'Hare, and then the 50 min metro journey back into the city.

The Southwest Chief, however, arrives here around lunch time, and arrives in Chicago about 24 hours later.

If you were optimizing for minimum travel time, you'd probably fly. If you were optimizing for cost, you'd probably drive. But if you want a nice journey, the train is fantastic and faster than driving if you're going to stop.

So, there are variations on the theme, and sometimes the train wins, sometimes the train loses.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by brandonmenc on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:58PM (#26934259)
> If you were optimizing for minimum travel time, you'd probably fly. If you were optimizing for cost, you'd probably drive. But if you want a nice journey, the train is fantastic and faster than driving if you're going to stop.

Train fans vastly overestimate the number of people who will optimize for "sitting in a train and staring out the window for days".

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by anaerobicover on Sunday April 25, 2021 @02:15PM (#26935067)
> optimize for "sitting in a train and staring out the window for days".

I'm acknowledging that it's not for everyone, but that's not really a fair depiction. I get a lot of work done on a train -- the atmosphere is similar to a coffee shop in some ways. Other people enjoy going to the common car and chatting and playing cards with strangers. Or reading. Or just watching Netflix on their devices, like they'd probably be doing at home anyways. We were also talking about an overnight trip, not "days".

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by spc476 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @08:23PM (#26938074)
I work in Ft. Lauderdale, Florida. The home office is in Seattle, Washington. I've made it clear at work that I'm not about to fly to the Seattle office [1] (not that I've ever needed to, but others in my office have). On a lark, I decided to see what it would cost to travel by train. On the plus side, there is train service between Ft. Lauderdale and Seattle. On the down side, it cost about $2,000 one-way. No way my company would spring for a ticket than costs more than first class air line ticket, but I wouldn't have mined the week travel one-way, as long as there was decent Internet connectivity (so I could continue to work).

[1] I don't have a fear of flying. I don't fly because of the security theater and the "presumed guilty" attitude. Also because of the declining comfort and service because people are prioritize the bottom line. It sucks.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by ghaff on Sunday April 25, 2021 @02:12PM (#26935042)
Especially given that, if it's business travel, I expect a lot of companies aren't that big on you adding a couple days of travel time because you feel like taking the train.

In the case of the parent's scenario, it seems pretty reasonable in that you're really only talking about maybe an additional half day of travel. But that's probably about the upper limit.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by loonster on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:52PM (#26939101)
Grand Rapids to Orlando:

Driving: 18 hours, 1269 miles x $0.56/mile = $710 each way (IRS millage rates as proxy)

Train: 55 hour travel, $209 each way (no refund)

Flying: 2.5 hour flight, $68 each way on a budget flight. Double both time and price for non-budget.

I would love to take a train, its just not practical.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Monday April 26, 2021 @10:46AM (#26943052)
This seems like a demonstration of routing issues, more than anything else. I have no idea how many changes that journey would involve, but there's no way that 55 hours to cover 1269 miles is representative of the time a train (even a clunky Amtrak train) would take to cover that distance. So this would seem to be an argument for increasing routes/services, rather than an argument that the train can't ever work.

OTOH, the flight is hard to compete with in that instance, so I suspect even with a better route, you'd likely still fly between those two places. Others might not, and the new service/route would benefit people making shorter journeys along the way.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by jpindar on Sunday April 25, 2021 @04:51PM (#26936561)
OTOH, how many of us sometimes happily sit in a chair and stare at a screen for days?
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by dreamcompiler on Sunday April 25, 2021 @04:34PM (#26936423)
I love the Lamy-to-Chicago train. I've taken it several times. You get to sleep through Kansas (where there's nothing to see anyway; no offense to Kansans!) and you wake up crossing the Mississippi River. There's 110v power and cell service for most of the trip.

(I always get a sleeper; without that it wouldn't be worthwhile.)

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday April 25, 2021 @05:08PM (#26936711)
Good guess at Lamy! But it could have been Las Vegas or Raton too :)

Are you close by?

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by dreamcompiler on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:09PM (#26938863)
Didn't guess; your bio says Galisteo ;-)

I'm near Golden.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by colinmhayes on Sunday April 25, 2021 @05:57PM (#26937093)
I travel form Chicago to Detroit pretty regularly. The train takes 4.5 hours, driving takes 4, and flying takes 1.5. Flying ends up being the slowest though because you have to spend 1.5 getting too and from the airport plus waiting at the airport. The train costs $25 which is cheaper than driving and I get to get work done. It's by far the best option imo.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by Angostura on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:26PM (#26933958)
If a country is serious about reducing CO2 emissions, it should be serious about moving people from plain to train, if possible. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-49349566
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by ris on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:26AM (#26932939)
> and also subsidized

Name a form of transport that isn't subsidized.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by danans on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:11AM (#26933322)
In many places, walking and biking.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by amanaplanacanal on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:02PM (#26933734)
I don't pay to walk or bike anywhere where I live, it was all built with tax dollars. Where are you that walkers and bikers pay for their infrastructure?
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by lbotos on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:21PM (#26933912)
> Where are you that walkers and bikers pay for their infrastructure?

> Where I live, it was all built with tax dollars.

You answered your own question, and, you paid for it too!

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by amanaplanacanal on Monday April 26, 2021 @09:43AM (#26942404)
Just like subsidized mass transit. Which was my point.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by tinus_hn on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:35PM (#26934034)
Even if there is no government and no infrastructure, you can still walk. We have had men walk on the moon!
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by beowulfey on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:17PM (#26934451)
Well... that was also thanks to the government. Although moreso for the getting there.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by hh3k0 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @11:02AM (#26933251)
> I don't get the point of all those cross-country routes, isn't air travel both faster and cheaper once you are going long distance?

It's also an absolute atrocity in the face of climate change.

And it's long overdue that fact is reflected in the ticket price, imo.

Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by freeone3000 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:08AM (#26932798)
Ideally, people in Minnesota would also want to go to North Dakota. There's ideally some station-to-station ridership, these aren't express routes.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by lacker on Sunday April 25, 2021 @12:54PM (#26934217)
This is a very “political” map. Many of these routes are only in there so that every state is included. (Except South Dakota who complained about being left out!) A lot of parts, like the route from Minnesota west to Washington, only really make sense in that light. If this were closer to being a real proposal for what to build, I think the map would look a lot different. This is more like a symbol to hopefully kick off a discussion.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by beowulfey on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:13PM (#26934403)
This is almost certainly built on existing rail corridors though too. I think priority of upgrades will follow your thinking, but these lines weren’t drawn entirely randomly.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by akg_67 on Sunday April 25, 2021 @10:00AM (#26932743)
Air travel, That’s how you create flyover states.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by meristohm on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:01PM (#26934292)
Noise pollution is a big reason I prefer trains.
Re:Amtrak's 2035 map has people talking about the future of ... by oceanplexian on Sunday April 25, 2021 @01:29PM (#26934555)
The laws of physics are clear that trying to push a vehicle through standard atmosphere is always going to be less efficient than one operating in a low-friction or near-vacuum environment. Scrap inefficient airport security for higher tech solutions, and start building hydrogen-powered supersonic aircraft and high speed rail is toast.