(We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26809658.)
The e in many words isn't silent, it's a modifier. Kit and kite are different words. "th", "z", "w", and "v" are all really different sounds. While certain accents (or children) do occasionally conflate them, in basically every case, it's technically incorrect. Zebra, Webra, Vebra, and Thebra are all totally different words to a native English speaker.
I'm absolutely behind the idea of simplified English where spelling and pronunciation match. But that's a lofty goal, as first one would have to canonize English, which is basically impossible at this point. Then they'd have to tackle homonyms, like cot and caught (assuming canonized English has these pronounced the same).
Another easy example is just fixing "island". The <s> was never pronounced. Medieval scribes put it there because they incorrectly guessed that the word was related to Latin "insula".
The real low-hanging fruit is getting the British to give up on those spellings that follow a dead branch of French ;-)
But really, it should be kite because that's what it is :)
For most non-native speakers, the backtracking of silent `e` is more confusing. It does not help in case of `sake` vs `saké` where most people do not add the acute mark and use context for disambiguation.
To pick a particular pronunciation-based spelling of words would therefore be to prefer one region over another. This would at least trigger a monumental North vs. South argument, assuming that the plans survived the inevitable knee-jerk reactions / incredulity of the usual media suspects.
Probably best if we stick to arguing about daylight saving time, or changes to the format of cricket matches.
But then again, those rules are pretty standard (c/g before e/i [the "skinny vowels"]) are almost always soft and they are hard otherwise. If you need a soft "c" sound before an "a" then you just use the letter "s". So maybe it's not even worth the effort.
Um, yes, I can't think of regular words where a "c" changes.
<thinks a bit more>
Place names. Place names - at least in England - can have significant differences between spelling and pronunciation, and the locals will often use or be aware of a local pronunciation that isn't obvious to outsiders. Examples include Bicester ('bister'), Leicester ('lester'), Salisbury ('solsbry'), Tottenham ('totnam') and many others. It's not quite the same effect as with dialects but it certainly complicates spelling reform.
I had a 85 year old (yes) technical writing professor in college who insisted that we do our papers using the "Queen's English" that he learned growing up in Catholic school. He even went so far as to write a damn book outlining his rules for English writing because none of the existing style guides out there matched his view of the language.
You'll never get people like that to adopt any sort of change to the language.
The only power they have is influencing the way kids are taught at school. Everything else changes by social pressure and exposure - most media choose to follow the new convention and people get used to it over time.
The changes are very gradual - the only big one I remember was in 90s - changing how "not" was written with adjectives and adverbs. The rules got much simpler so few people complained.
Romania also had some spelling reform, albeit it was more motivated by a desire to distance itself from a communist past and not cleanup of tech debt.
Oh, and Indonesian is my favorite lingua franca. Super easy to learn for anyone and also simple, phonetic spelling.
I had only ever learned Indo-European languages (ie English, Spanish, French) and a bit of Japanese (also unrelated to Indonesian), but I was able to pick up a useful amount of conversational Indonesian in about 3-4 weeks. Indonesian is an Austronesian language (actually a standardized variant of Malay) and totally unrelated to my mother tongue (American English), yet it was the easiest thing to pick up. Sounding out new words in Indonesian is actually easier than English to me.
Mai vot gos tu som nordik languag like Svedish.
Start by purging English of French influence, starting with words where words of Germanic origin exists with a similar meaning. Simplify German grammar. Undo some consonant shifts. E.g (the German and Dutch I had to check/adjust w/Google translate; no guarantees for accuracy):
Swedish: En dag kan vi alla tala samma språk
Norwegian: En dag kan vi alle snakke samme språk (or "det samme språket")
Danish: En dag kan vi alle tale det samme sprog
German: Eines Tages können wir alle dieselbe Sprache sprechen
Dutch: Op een dag kunnen we allemaal dezelfde taal spreken
English: One day we can all speak the same language
Now consider "speech" as an alternative to "language" in English (alternatively: "tale" is valid but archaic in Norwegian in this context and we have the English cognate "talk"), and undo that D->T consonant shift in German (e.g. compare Tag to Low German "Dag"), and replace "the" (compare det/de/die/das/der etc.).
There are a whole lot of simple spelling and sound changes that'd bring the above languages a lot closer together very easily.
Of course it's easy in theory - in practice I've lived through multiple Norwegian language reforms and know how excruciatingly slow it can be to get people to adapt (e.g. Norway changed the spoken form of numbers above 20 in 1952 from the equivalent of "four and fifty" to "fifty-four"; my parents learned the new forms in primary school, yet I still picked up the old forms from them in the late 70's and still switch back and forth between the old and new forms now)
For example in Czech:
Jan zabil Petra
Jan Petra zabil
Petra Jan zabil
Petra zabil Jan
Zabil Petra Jan
and
Zabil Jan Petra
are all equivalent to the English "John killed Peter." Change Jan to Jana and Petra to Petr and all 6 of those become "Peter killed John." Even more confusing to a foreigner learning it is that Petra and Jana are the feminine forms of those names in the nominative case.
But we all know that it should be Esperanto.
German has significantly fewer irregular verbs than English.
It's ~200 to ~300. (French is double that?)
There's enough to be moderately annoying, but not that bad. Also (in my personal opinion), German irregular verbs tend to be not-as-irregular as English.
z, c (as in "ce", "ci"): use "s" (non european spanish speakers do not distinguish these sounds anyway)
v: always use "b"
c (as in "ca", "co", "cu"), q(u) (as in "que", "quiso"): replaced with "k"
w: why do we have this letter?! use "u"
y (as vowel): use "i" (basically only used as "and" in Spanish)
y (as consonant): stays like it is now (important in some variants where it sounds pretty much as "sh" in English)
ll as in "lluvia": replaced with "y"
h (mute as in "hueso", "humano"): Just remove it (ueso, umano)
ch (as in "chorizo"): replaced with "c"
r, rr: Couldn't yet find a good replacement that's not ambiguous for the soft and vibrant sounds in all the use-cases...
ñ: this stays. it gives the language personality!
I've got not much traction with my friend, though!!!!!
As far as I know, when properly pronounced, the V in Villa doesn't sound the same as the B in Billete.
Sure, sometimes they blend into each other, but not always.
We can remove it and call the entire transition the Convergencia año-ano.
I stand by the Ñ!
https://web.archive.org/web/19991006200917/http://users.ox.a...
Sometimes when I'm in parts of the world where I'm surrounded by other languages I don't speak, I find I'm almost automatically tuning out people speaking them around me. That doesn't happen at all with Dutch.
x can then be used as "sh", as in Portuguese.
This thread finally made me remember to go look it up and it seems like the "ç" used to be a different sound (/dz/). I guess it evolved to the "s" sound we hear today sometime by the 1700s.
I wonder if that means only words older than the 1700s have the cedilha and newer words would just be spelled with an "s"?
"The European Commission has just announced an agreement whereby English will be the official language of the European Union rather than German, which was the other possibility.
As part of the negotiations, the British Government conceded that English spelling had some room for improvement and has accepted a 5- year phase-in plan that would become known as "Euro-English".
In the first year, "s" will replace the soft "c". Sertainly, this will make the sivil servants jump with joy. The hard "c" will be dropped in favour of "k". This should klear up konfusion, and keyboards kan have one less letter.
There will be growing publik enthusiasm in the sekond year when the troublesome "ph" will be replaced with "f". This will make words like fotograf 20% shorter.
In the 3rd year, publik akseptanse of the new spelling kan be expekted to reach the stage where more komplikated changes are possible.
Governments will enkourage the removal of double letters which have always ben a deterent to akurate speling.
Also, al wil agre that the horibl mes of the silent "e" in the languag is disgrasful and it should go away.
By the 4th yer peopl wil be reseptiv to steps such as replasing "th" with "z" and "w" with "v".
During ze fifz yer, ze unesesary "o" kan be dropd from vords kontaining "ou" and after ziz fifz yer, ve vil hav a reil sensi bl riten styl.
Zer vil be no mor trubl or difikultis and evrivun vil find it ezi TU understand ech oza. Ze drem of a united urop vil finali kum tru.
Und efter ze fifz yer, ve vil al be speking German like zey vunted in ze forst plas."